upvote
I think it requires a re-conception of the mechanics of a social network. The goals described in the article don't sound like they would replace the incumbent addiction-driven platforms. I think you're right, the addicts don't want that fixed, and will stay on those platforms.

The topology of addiction- and influencer-based social networks is bizarre, and I think there is plenty of room for alternatives. There are potential users that value quality over quantity; they want, and would probably prefer, far less of a network effect.

reply
It's pretty condescending to label anyone using social networks as addicts, the ones that know how to work them for extracting maximum attention are often using it seldomly and in an automated fashion.

The ones that are addicted are guys in the reply section, youtube, HN, reddit racking up an insane amount of posts and interactions that ultimately can't be momentized or lead to any sort of economic uplift.

reply
>The ones that are addicted are guys in the reply section, youtube, HN, reddit racking up an insane amount of posts and interactions that ultimately can't be momentized or lead to any sort of economic uplift.

Reducing social interaction to its profitability is definitely a different approach than the article is proposing.

reply
More like digital social interactions can't replace human offline ones, profitable or not, it's unhealthy.
reply
I agree, but there's a lot of middle ground. My best experiences with digital social interaction have been in much smaller, more focused communities than today's social media platforms. What stands out to me about those was the accountability: many of the members were not anonymous, but even those that were still managed their reputation and credibility.

I don't see this OSWA ensuring that kind of scenario (more centralized moderation probably won't encourage that soft self-moderation), but there are better patterns that can be recreated.

reply
Wrong. vTaiwan / pol.is are real successes and have barely scratched the surface with what is possible.
reply
> It's a cute attempt at fixing some of the things with social networks but they almost always something that people don't want fixed at all

This reads to me a little bit like saying the person addicted to a drug doesn't want to get off the drug so why even try. These are people that are extrapolating into the future and being worried about what they see. This is an attempt to, as a community, steer us into a more resilient but still enjoyable behavior I would imagine. How can we support them because the alternative could lead to a decline in overall species health and we'd regret having gone down that road too far.

reply
The lower you are on the socio economic ladder, the more likely you are to be perma-online, social network or not, although I guess you can call HN one (I can see that some people are very addicted through the pseudo anonymous text centric format), posting incessantly on forums for nearly two decades, racking up an insane amount of posts, building an online identity that ultimately doesn't result in any sort of audience or economic transformation.

You have confused being online permanently solely as the fault of social networks but the perma-online crowd has existed even before the arrival of mass social networks like Facebook. They've hung out in IRC chats, php forums, mailing lists.

reply
I don't know that this is proof of anything

bsky is a protocol, so the protocol ought to work for both the left and the right. Some people are annoyed with how broken on a technical level x has gotten

Network effects really do matter which is the problem with "Facebook sucks. But Facebook popular, therefore Facebook good". Because nobody wants to move off the bad product because you lose access to everyone else on the bad product

The internet's still relatively young. It takes time to move, and establish

reply
Yes, good. Fuck those people.
reply