upvote
Green energy activists tend to present moral arguments which are easily dismissed on economic grounds. Even if the US were 100% green energy, it makes no meaningful difference since the rest of the world still generates most of the pollution. That fact is both inconvenient and inescapable—it has been very counterproductive for green activists to dance around it by citing unrelated data as a rhetorical device to change the frame.

This new wave of green activists have learned to simply make economic argument instead. To their surprise "it's cheaper and it's clean" sells a lot better than 'non-green energy is h!tler and we're cheaper." I also think markets needed time to get comfortable with green energy.

reply
> Even if the US were 100% green energy, it makes no meaningful difference since the rest of the world still generates most of the pollution.

For a rough calculation, if the US had emitted no CO2 this millenium, then if all else were equal that would be more than 100 gigatonnes less CO2; meaning we'd be closer to 420ppm than the current 432ppm.

(There are feedback loops like oceans and plants that would absorb less CO2 at lower concentrations which I don't know how to account for.)

Mass of CO2 and ppm: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_dioxide_in_the_atmosphe...

reply