upvote
The problem is education. Humans reacting emotionally instead of logically. Everything else is a symptom of that disease. What good is a healthy democracy full of people agreeing on something that isn't even true?

A populace with critical thinking skills and the ability to regulate their emotions is immune to all the bullshit we jump through hoops placing bandaids on.

reply
Human emotions are a deeply nested and integral part of us as beings. It's impossible to just dismiss them.

But even if I try to consider this scenario for the aake of the argument, the biggest issue I see with it is that it puts incredible individual responsibility on everyone.

E.g. where I live we make cigarettes extra expensive, put explicit pictures of cancer patients on the box and prohibit all tobacco product advertising. We could simply educate people and expect them not to smoke, but we know it doesn't work as well. It puts every single person in a fight against corporations spending millions on psychological research and targeted advertising.

IMO government regulation isn't bullshit and bandaids, it's citizens focusing power in a bigger entity that can then fight a slightly fairer fight against those odds.

reply
The most educated people run and work at companies that extract resources from the poor and kill the weak.

A new way of thinking is required to find peace and kindness.

reply
Just the other day I was recommended to apply for a high frequency trading firm. The pay makes it such a no-brainer regardless of what you think of the ethics. The problem is that society has given these firms so much money.
reply
I'd say maybe they're very educated, but it's jagged / incomplete education that lacks exposure to and practice of things like non-violent communication, finding common ground, empathy, or ethics.

From my perspective, better education would help enormously. As long as you don't use the narrow definition of education that only contains subjects like maths/physics/chemistry.

reply
This!!! how I dream about a world where everyone understands that.
reply
Simply being "educated" is not sufficient. The type of education matters. There are some very dumb brain surgeons and rocket scientists out there who are great at their jobs, and nothing else.
reply
Depends what you mean by education. In the classical sense, they're mongoloids. In the modern sense, they're highly educated.
reply
Education alone will not fix our issues. There are highly educated, highly motivated, smart people who are utter arseholes in life.

Education is important, sure. But what is even more important is basic decency, kindness and willingness to live and let live. I don't need a PhD to feel empathy for a kid in Ukraine caught in the stupid war or for a woman living under the religious fanatics in Afghanistan etc.

There are videos on YouTube of seemingly normal people making fun of the Palestinian misery in Gaza, for example. These people aren't uneducated, no amount of education will make them care. They just don't give a shit.

reply
I was with you until the Gaza example. That one in particular is where education probably _would_ help. People would care, but they've been pushed into a corner ("you're a Nazi unless you believe what I believe" doesn't get great results).
reply
People are mocking the mass extermination of 6 million Muslims because they are Nazis, not because they've been told they are Nazis.

But people have been miseducated about the Nazis. They are made out to be a special kind of evil people that you can't accidentally be. In truth, most of the actual Nazis actually didn't know they were Nazis, they just thought Germany had a Jewish immigration problem that the government was dealing with, etc. because that's what the media (mostly newspapers) told them

reply
Do you think Peter Thiel would be a better or worse human being with less education? Do you think the world would be better if more people had enough basic reading comprehension to understand what inflation is, or how science and vaccinations work, and that their mom's Facebook posts aren't "research"?

Or do you think OP was suggesting that education is the sole issue and that evil people would suddenly cease to exist if they went to college? Do you also argue that laws are dumb because criminals still do crime, or do you understand that sometimes there are just evil people and "nu-uh"ing a suggestion because you thought of one, single, counter-example is non-additive and childish?

reply
> Humans reacting emotionally instead of logically. Everything else is a symptom of that disease

As long as you believe that's a symptom of a disease and not the human condition, you're not forward facing. The triumph of critical thinking over emotions is only a thing in sci-fi.

This is why righteous nerds never win, they don't want to. Deep down they know what they're saying is impossible, but they'd rather be "right" than make a difference.

reply
The only tool that can say has some direct effect on democracy is what Taiwan is doing with .. vTaiwan (i think?) and Pol.is.

NB: From what Wikipedia says, apparently OpenAI and Anthropic also had Pol.is on their radar since they apparently used it to build/study consensus.

reply
Great point, and TBH it made me feel like I should have softened my language a bit. I don't think tools can have no impact, but there needs to be strong social scaffolding around them. IMO it wasn't excellent engineering that led vTaiwan to success, but rather a social movement that understood how to deploy it effectively. The tool can be crude if the political will is strong.
reply
Agreed, it's a human problem and nothing a computer can solve
reply
Like the sibling comment by 'intended' explains, computers can help us:

> talk to people, build a coalition, wield power to make a (positive) material impact in peoples' lives

but allow such to scale in a useful manner, like vTaiwan / pol.is has shown is possible.

reply
"You can't fix social problems with technological solutions"
reply
> Over the last decade I've been left so cold by these attempts to 'fix' democracy via cleverly engineered tools.

Same, the solution to most of our woes (govt inefficacy, social media, partisan politics, corruption) is to talk to each other again IRL. The many outweigh to money.

To this end I now make paper mini zines and give them to people, usually resulting in conversations with strangers.

reply