upvote
How come copy-on-write is not easier with SMR? Each SMR zone a.k.a. shingle or flash erase block is effectively a tiny tape drive. It is basically append only.

Shouldn't this be especially useful with ZFS doing copy-on-write with linked lists as a reversed heap?

reply
+1 SMR drives are really great if you pack your data into large enough groups so that you occupy exacly N SMR zones, and allocate your files to specific SMR zones that you then only rewrite atomically. The sibling comment is on point - it's pretty similar to how to work effectively with SSDs.

The drive doesn't have enough information to do this itself, we need SMR aware filesystems.

reply
What we need is host-based SMR. SMR-aware filesystems exist (e.g. Zoned XFS, btrfs' zone mode, f2fs' zone mode).
reply
There are very good deals currently on eBay for 14TB HM-SR drives! I just got quite a few - should be interesting to see how the current zone aware filesystems perform. XFS with an optane metadata device? Could be pretty okay!
reply
Handling SMRs well probably would require a custom replacement for SPA (block layer) component in ZFS, talking directly with DMU (object storage).

Could also expose the drives as SCSI object storage devices

reply