upvote
How much energy are we talking about here? 300MW...? An absolute drop in the bucket compared to pretty much anything. Colossus 1 consumes about 7,165 gasoline cars continuously driving at 60 MPH. Since elon has deployed hundreds of thousands of electric cars, i would say he's net even. Especially if you count the amount of battery power and solar they've deployed worldwide. Lastly, they are actively working to solve the energy crisis by putting datacenters in space.
reply
> Since elon has deployed hundreds of thousands of electric cars, i would say he's net even. Especially if you count the amount of battery power and solar they've deployed worldwide.

If you're going to do that for just "is Musk net good", you kinda also have to count how many will likely die from DOGE, worldwide.

> Lastly, they are actively working to solve the energy crisis by putting datacenters in space.

It's trivially obvious that space data centres won't do that.

While PV in a heliocentric orbit can get you a roughly 6x boost from capacity factor (depending on exactly where on the ground you put them), it also gets you a roughly 6x shorter lifespan for the actual panels.

reply
Can you point to a specific contract he canceled that killed people?
reply
> 300MW

300 MW×24 hours=7,200 MWh a day at full capacity

A city of 100,000 people might use roughly 2,000–4,000 MWh of electricity per day,

Drop in the bucket?

> Lastly, they are actively working to solve the energy crisis by putting datacenters in space.

This is PR and you think they will just turn off their earthly AI Data centers when this happens?

reply
As Kant puts it: "Act only according to that maxim whereby you can at the same time will that it should become a universal law."

I don't want to live in a world where everyone computes their own energy need, decide it is an "absolute drop in the bucket" and chooses the absolute worst option to satisfy said need.

reply
Whether a component of energy usage is relatively small or big is an objectively decidable number, not a subjective conclusion. You can look and see that data centers account for under 2% of CO2 output.
reply
While true, I read the parent comment as "and chooses the absolute worst option to satisfy said need" should not be a thing justified in such a manner, rather than if the thing is or isn't a "drop in the bucket".

Industrialised nations have known for my whole life that fossil fuels are bad and we should use other sources instead. And yet, despite the massive ongoing exponential growth in renewables and that PV in particular is the cheapest new power source to install, these data centres have been made in a country which has a massive tariff on the cheapest PV.

Even if you argue about the need to combine PV with other power sources, it's objectively terrible that not even bothering with PV is the state of affairs today.

reply
Firemen save people routinely. I'm sure we can let firemen off for a couple murders here and there since the total saved lives is still positive.
reply
Similarly, adtech and fintech employees are really going to have to get out there and do something good.
reply
> Alphabet has made so many

Didn't they walk away from their renewable goals the moment that AI took off and then deleted previous pledges from the corporate website?

reply
This is just part of the RSI-endgame, isn't it? Basically Anthropic started because they thought this is a winner-take-all singularity moment. They know it can end humanity, and are worried others will take shortcuts to get there. But in the process they take as many shortcuts that they decide are ok to take, which forces others to also take shortcuts. But they tell themselves that their shortcuts are ok because the they are the chosen ones, and the other companies also tell themselves the same story. Then we all die because some of the shortcuts actually led to doom and it turned out none of the humans were gods.
reply
Unfortunately, as long-termists, they are happy to do short-term harm in pursuit of what they believe is a long-term good. It would be nice if they were regulated back onto a more sensible path, but not holding my breath.

Edit: Long-termists are fragile delicate flowers apparently. Didn't think this one would get the downvotes, but have at it. My biases about you guys aren't just going to confirm themselves.

reply
It would be even nicer if we directed our attention to the actual problem: power monopolies posting steadily increasing profits for the last decades.

This isn't just an anthropic problem, and they're an insignificant, just stupid to even talk about it, rounding error to our energy usage. Especially when you include ICE engines as energy sources, and the many multiples grid capacity required to convert everything to electric.

This is a pebble in the ocean that has a strange and disproportionate, probably lobby based, amount of attention directed to it, in the news cycle and social media.

reply
that just sounds like giving someone a pass, and at this point willingly because I haven't heard anything from dario about making the world a better place other than fear-mongering
reply
That's what the parent comment says. Anthropic believes they have the pass. And that's not a good thing and also that's why having laws matters.
reply
yes that's exactly what they're doing here, and that's why serious regulation is needed to force them to act like normies. the longtermism is delusional
reply
They’re not called Misanthropic for nothing!
reply
imagine the reactions of the people working at these companies if someone plopped 50 gas turbines in their backyard.
reply