upvote
The problem is we have a lot of Chinese political posts everywhere all the time. The "The Chinese are FIIIIINNEEE guys" posts are omnipresent. The fearmongering is there too, but its kind of easy to see how flimsy both are whenever economics comes up.

The base story from China is just until people understand what overcapacity is, all everyone else can do is protect themselves economically. Ideally you find a way to work with China, but there's a certain point where you just can't - it's their "manufacture everything" worldview and poverty at home, or degrees of gatekeeping.

China appears to believe it's OK for them to be everyone's manufacturer and views Japan's bubble popping as a mistake by the Japanese. What that actually is, is economic under capacity elsewhere while China continues to absorb both investment and capital. Japan can help with their margins this way a little bit, but while investment in China is sky high, companies aren't failing because of policy, etc., no one can compete cleanly with China.

When you hear things like deindustrialization of the West being a good thing, you sort of see what the end-game is. For the non-industrial countries its fine for them to think that, but it really is one of those "if this is what you get, why would any country invest in any other" mindset. And that makes everyone much poorer. And for industrial countries - BMW/Toyota/GM, etc., etc., going out of business would be a massive social drain/flashpoint.

reply