upvote
This. This is why everyone who wants to fingerprint and collect tons of data on end users pushes them hard on installing an app. The amount of valuable data is 10x what’s available in the browser
reply
And it is not just the fingerprinting, it is also that a good number of people will install an ad/tracker blocker in their browser, but almost nobody knows or cares about the multiple trackers that most apps have.

To make it worse, Apple's naming undermines consciousness about this issue, since they have an option to block cross-app/site tracking (which IIRC blocks access to the advertising identifier), but called it "Allow Apps to Request to Track". A lot of people seem to hold the belief that disabling this option blocks all in-app trackers. It just blocks one way to correlate, but as this app shows, there are other ways to correlate (as well as correlating server-side using IP addresses, etc.).

On this topic, I somehow missed that Apple added a generic URL filtering API to macOS/iOS 26, which extends Safari filtering to the whole OS (well, as long as apps are using Apple's APIs). It's not perfect, but a nice addition to DNS-based blocking:

https://adguard.com/en/blog/apple-url-filter-system-wide-fil...

The author of Wipr added support to Wipr 2 as an extra in-app purchase:

https://kaylees.site/wipr2-whats-new.html#filtr

Aside from technical methods to address this, all this in-app tracking must be a violation of the GDPR, no? I can't imagine this all falls under legitimate interest.

reply
deleted
reply
> all this in-app tracking must be a violation of the GDPR, no?

Probably, but we're gonna have to wait for the courts to weigh in for a definitive answer.

Same with the very popular pay-or-accept-tracking model. An Austrian court found it illegal, but we'll probably have to wait for a case to make it all the way to the ECJ.

reply
Cut your selection of apps and find/build privacy respecting alternatives for the remainder. Im trying to do this. Music is now locally hosted, Youtube is sorta kinda coming along. I've been working on reversing some of my more basic iOS apps to extract the data/endpoints they use and write my own apps. Fable really helped with this and Opus just does not cut the mustard. I hope it comes back. :/
reply
The intended “protection” is the ToS, which requires apps to disclose what they are tracking and whether they perform cross-premise tracking.
reply
Ah, that’s funny. Too bad those privacy nutrition labels are only honor system.

They give that one completely up to businesses, then, to devs. They also thought they should let an app maker prohibit screen recording, which might promote development since it protects revenue of e.g. subtitling apps as one example. But end result is you even end up with a black screen when recording the iPhone Mirroring app from a Mac.

Apple owes us a better balance here. iCloud Private Relay for all apps (why only Safari?! and Mail and HTTP) as a start, and plugging some of the privacy holes Loupe exposes. They don’t want us abusing free trials I suppose.

reply
Often it's not the app itself doing tracking or cross-premise tracking, but data is passed to installed third party SDKs that do.
reply
These days many things don't work on browser. Even reddit is very difficult as we get constant nagging.
reply
That’s usually a warning the service is malware that wants you to install an app for deeper tracking.
reply
LinkedIn is the worst offender imo. I am not gonna list every shitty thing they do that goes away the moment you switch to desktop mode but the worst one is that they keep showing you the same feed for weeks if you're on mobile web.
reply
reply
.EU? I'd be scared to publish something like that under EU jurisdiction. I could be fined for full actual damages to Microsoft's reputation and I might even be jailed for defamation.
reply
Brave blocks those switch to app notices by default.
reply
old.reddit.com
reply
For now but you know they’re coming for that ass.
reply
It used to be widely thought they were keeping it around because the most important users who actually posted the content preferred it. But they drove all those people away in 2023 by blocking apps except for their spyware one, and everything is posted by LLMs now anyway.
reply