upvote
> I never felt that context size was any issue at all in codex.

I'm guessing you just started using codex, it suffered greatly from "model context size exceeded" errors early on, where compaction couldn't even recover from it, these errors just stopped happening maybe some month(s) ago.

Nowadays it's a lot better though and I've don't get stuck in those anymore. Although I don't like the idea that they don't surface what goes into the "concise summary" afterwards, make it really hard to know if it actually got everything important or not.

In general, codex seems to be moving into the way of hiding as much from the user as possible, and it wouldn't surprise me if they eventually start encrypting the entire session logs just like they did with agent>sub-agent prompts recently. Sad though as it's easily the best harness+model combo available today out of the ones I've tried.

reply
That has nothing to do with context window or the models at all; it's the compute capacity.

Pretty much every single AI firm had the same issue when the new model came out, it's the result of everyone jumping onboard and consuming all available compute capacity to break it for days.

Claude had the same issues when they released their newer models.

reply
> That has nothing to do with context window or the models at all; it's the compute capacity.

Quite literally a harness feature/bug though, that it's unable to compact when reaching the max context (which seemingly both codex and Claude Code struggled with in the beginning), not something that will happen at every model release forever.

Hasn't happen for at least the two last model releases in Codex, not sure why you'd imply that.

reply
Claude also had issues with this kind of thing for months early on, too, where it simply couldn't compact its own emissions.

But definitely earlier GPT models suffered greatly as context got large, and the compaction itself in Codex was really crappy. That changed around January.

reply
For me, Codex regularly forgets to complete its last task when compaction occurs, especially when the last message I sent was right before compaction.
reply
It seems odd to me that Codex doesn't carry the plan file through context compaction? Claude does this, it re-reads it in full from disk
reply
I’ve noticed it having weird message dropping and replay in general, but the compaction boundary has been pretty solid.
reply
Most problems should be divide-and-conquerable into chunks that 300 vs 400k context is basically never an issue. A coding agent isn't an infinite chat.
reply