upvote

points

by mark_l_watson12 hours ago |
comments
upvoteby ActorNightly11 hours ago|
[-]
Honest question - why are you so stuck on Macs for local inference?

A 4 GPU linux box with 3090s, which are $1500 a piece right now, will blow this thing out of the water. Even 2x3090 rig will run most of the good local models like Gemma4:31b at 100+ tok/sec

The VRAM of the GPUs are MUCH faster than the unified ram within Apple Silicon. The only difference is the initial model load, which takes longer from disk to VRAM due to PCIE limitations, but once the model is loaded, GPUs can prefill and and generate tokens way faster than any Apple Silicon.

So is your desire to upgrade to mac because you just aren't aware of how to set up a GPU rig, or is it something else?

reply
upvoteby nomel8 hours ago|
parent|
next
[-]
That's 6 YEARS of their cloud inference!

And, you have to include power. Where I am, the power for a rig with 2x 3090, running for four hours a day, would be around $70/month!

It's kinda like datacenter only exist to optimize compute cost through oversubscription of hardware/time share, cheaper business energy rates, and bulk discounts, compared to self hosting. ;)

reply
upvoteby mft_9 hours ago|
parent|
prev|
next
[-]
AIUI you can only connect two 3090s at a time with NV link? So you’d only have 48GB of fast combined memory? That’s not tremendously interesting as you’re still limited to the smaller models which, while impressive in their own right, are still IMO too limited to use as your only model.
reply
upvoteby Zagitta4 hours ago|
parent|
[-]
There are kernel patches to enable P2P communication via PCIE on 3090 which is almost as fast as NVLink for vllm
reply
upvoteby TruthSHIFT10 hours ago|
parent|
prev|
next
[-]
Upgrading RAM is still probably cheaper than spending $6000 on a linux box. You're correct that inference will be much faster on the Linux box. But, the mac's unified memory can load larger models. And as OP mentions, it's still hard to beat cloud pricing at home.
reply
upvoteby mark_l_watson10 hours ago|
parent|
prev|
next
[-]
Yes, GPUs are much better for dense models. On Macs, MOE models run better, so I agree Macs are more limited and expensive. I have a Linux laptop with a 10GB 1080 GPU, dated, but I should add even more system RAM and try that.
reply
upvoteby 11 hours ago|
parent|
prev|
next
[-]
deleted
reply
upvoteby theshrike7910 hours ago|
parent|
prev|
[-]
A Mac mini running an LLM is quiet

A PC with similar capabilities is going to sound like a jet taking off.

reply
upvoteby manmal9 hours ago|
parent|
next
[-]
A Mac Mini is easy to match by a PC in terms of inference, and the PC will win without getting noisy.
reply
upvoteby lowbloodsugar9 hours ago|
parent|
prev|
[-]
>A PC with similar capabilities is going to sound like a jet taking off.

Not at all. Airflow with big fans is quiet. What I do hear is coil-whine. In fact my PC is quieter than my Macbook when both are running top speed. But one has 4000 AI TOPS.

reply