upvote
+1. I was waiting to buy this, but it doesn't really have anything I want over my existing apple tv (which I really like). I was going to add one for a second television, but its just too expensive. I will stick with the Roku there (which I really don't love, at this point, its slow and has lots of ads).
reply
HDR support on Apple TV is fairly hit or miss depending on the player you are using.

HDR10+ is supported in some players (infuse) but not others (plex) and will fallback to HDR10. Profile 7 DV files do not play properly on Apple TV period even though it will display the DV logo (though frankly very few devices can do this). Profile 5 and 8 DV files will play properly depending on the player and the content mapping level in the content (2.9 is well supported but 4.0 causes HDR10 fallback or black screens in some cases). Apple TV also doesn't support HD audio passthrough great.

reply
And now that the Nvidia Shield Pro is the same price, it makes the Apple TV an even tougher sell.
reply
Does it? The Nvidia Shield Pro is 7+ years old at this point. I'd maybe agree if they released a new one, but that seems unlikely.
reply
Yes. It does.

The Shield Pro is still the best all-around set-top box streaming device. It was always a bargain at $199 for the overpowered hardware it had under the hood, but after the hardware refresh and size reduction, it was a no-brainer. It was the only box that had a gigabit Ethernet port, which Apple finally put in their new device.

Nvidia will never release another device like it again, because the Shield and Shield Pro were meant as a foothold against Sony, Nintendo, and Microsoft consoles. Now that Nvidia can make bajillions selling GPUs for AI, they won't even bother with a new Shield device, or if they do, it will be only marginally better than the current Shield Pro and will land with a total thud.

They're completely uninterested in gaming nowadays and that was their bread and butter until 2022/2023 or so when datacenter revenue finally eclipsed gaming. Now that AI revenue dwarfs everything else, there's no chance we'll see a kickass STB that makes others run in fear. Those days are over.

reply
> which Apple finally put in their new device

Not to take away from what you're saying, but I have a 2022 Apple TV 4K with a gigabit ethernet port.

You just had to buy the higher storage model, weirdly.

Model MN893X/A

reply
I thought nvidia stopped supporting or producing shields many years ago
reply
They're still getting the bare minimum of maintenance software updates. It's 2019-era tech that's long overdue a refresh.
reply
I've used Steam Link to play games from my Steam library on the Apple TV using a video game controller and it worked surprisingly well. You still might want the Playstation (or Switch or XBox). Just depends on what games you want to play.
reply
Moonlight works really well on the ATV4K too. I stream 4K@60FPS with HDR and surround sound from my PC using the Apollo fork of Sunshine (creates a virtual display since I normally game at 1440p on my attached monitor).
reply
I'm quite "technical" so to speak yet trying to properly set up HDR in Sunshine was rough.
reply
I think this is one of the things that the Apollo fork[1] makes way easier. I'm not sure that I had to do anything Apollo config wise* . I just went through the Windows HDR calibration tool the first time to tune it for my TV and it was good after.

*I do have a once-per-run Moonlight glitch that may even be because I'm on an older version. The first connection just doesn't pick up on the HDR immediately. I just have to reconnect once and it's good after that.

[1]: https://github.com/ClassicOldSong/Apollo ("Built-in Virtual Display with HDR support that matches the resolution/framerate config of your client automatically")

reply
They just updated the moonlight client which I’m sure you’re on should be more reliable and I highly recommend https://github.com/Nonary/Vibepollo fork of Apollo
reply
I found the input latency to be much worse than the PC connected to the same TV, for whatever reason.

I thought I surely was imagining it, so I revisited it 6 months or a year later, and, yes, the input latency from the controller is substantially worse on the Apple TV.

reply
Does your TV (not the Apple TV) have a "game" mode picture mode in its settings?

I had unacceptable input lag when streaming to my Apple TV 4k, but switching the TV it into "game" mode fixes it entirely. I just need to swap it over to game mode when I hop into Steam Link or Moonlight.

reply
It has a powerful CPU/GPU because those chips are what they have on hand and they can control the whole stack. It's likely cheaper for them to just shove their overpowered chips into things that don't need them than setup manufacturing for a net new lower power chip.

Their Studio Displays have an A19 in them too (A19 Pro for the XDR)

reply
A lot of people complaining about the lack of 120fps, but I've no idea who that's even for? Games?

> used playstation

Unfortunately PS5 prices have shot up due to everything else.

reply
I’m been wondering that same thing while developing tvOS app and testing across hardware. What does this new model offer the last 3 didn’t??

Eg Pixel Brite works great on all versions of AppleTV including FEL playback on 1st gen

The only thing I haven’t been able to do with the older models is upscaling content at the same fidelity levels. But the results are very subtle either way and not all that compelling IMO.

[0] https://pixelbrite.site

reply
reply
List is the same as the incumbent model :-( I was hoping for a lossless Atmos TrueHD pass through support.
reply
Right! I just remembered why I was still on my Nvidia Shield Pro, Apple TV 4K doesn't have the lossless pass through.

That's crazy

reply
It has lossless output i.e. PCM. It does not have the license needed to pass through proprietary Dolby formats other than DD/DD+
reply
Used PS5 prices are spiking with the GTA6 coming out and the chip shortage. They are $550 for the base and $1400 for pro right now, so still nearly double the apple tv (but of course, you can play GTA6)
reply
My lad went and bought a PS5 six months ago in preparation for GTA6 because he could see the prices of them were rising by the month.
reply