There's a fix incoming here[1].
> Homebrew ships its own CA bundle
Outside of an enterprise environment, I never thought about having multiple "golden sources" of CA certs on a single host. (I have no experience working outside of classic enterprise environments, so please do not read my surprise as immediate dismissal of this idea!) For those unaware, in enterprise environments, it is very common to use a common CA cert pack from Oracle/Mozilla/Google/Microsoft/Amazon/Apple, but add 2-5 CA certs from your own company that act as trust roots.
I did some Googling on this matter. It looks like the "Big Four" of CA cert packs are: Mozilla, Microsoft, Apple, and Google. (I guess there is one or two in China also, be leave that alone for the moment.) What happens if they are in disagreement? This is a complex problem! If anyone is involved in this process, I would like to learn more.
Not easily, because it's closer to a convergence of smaller engineering decisions into an emergent choice to ship a CA bundle.
But the short version: lots of tools ship their own CA bundle. This is not ideal for distributors like Homebrew, because people expect one CA root program for the entire distribution. As a result, Homebrew tries (and sometimes fails) to apply a consistent root program across its tools. Apple's own roots are not inherently best suited for all Homebrew users, so we end up shipping a composite of their roots and the Mozila root program.
> What happens if they are in disagreement?
They are in disagreement, all the time! Root program operators are totally free to manage their trust roots as they please. The only forcing function is a desire to honor users' connections; differences in root programs end up getting papered over somewhat by cross-signing between different CAs.
Edit 2: This is being fixed now[1]. Everything below is stale.
I couldn't reproduce this:
% which git
/opt/homebrew/bin/git
% git ls-remote https://git-emudhra.we-have-a-problem.com/check.git
fatal: unable to access 'https://git-emudhra.we-have-a-problem.com/check.git/': SSL certificate problem: unable to get local issuer certificate
$ git ls-remote https://git-emudhra.we-have-a-problem.com/check.git && which git
2975b9930644b321e18ecae09e29c15b955e6103 HEAD
2975b9930644b321e18ecae09e29c15b955e6103 refs/heads/main
/opt/homebrew/bin/git
Wow, that was fast!
I would've preferred a doc or a code repo link as a source. Otherwise, this just reads like a brag. A decent one, to be fair :)
(Sorry if you thought it was a brag, it’s just supposed to be context so that everybody is on the same page about the reason for a comment.)