upvote
Well, the argument has been that it's a kind of vaguely cosmological or conceptual abuse of children, through the normalisation of sexualised depictions of children and so forth. In the production of such material, children suffer as a class.

The problem is, this viewpoint is infinitely flexible, infinitely elastic and can do a lot of gymnastics. I'm not sure it's compatible with the very concrete and procedural orientation of Anglo-American jurisprudence, particularly.

reply
I agree, there needs to be a concrete legal framework around this.

One closely related example was the punishment introduced for (legal-age) deepfake porn for which legislation already exists - this could be handled as a special (more severe) case of that more appropriately.

reply
>The real question, whether indulging sexual desire for children is wrong even when no child is touched

Only if you think right/wrong sex is a function of consent and harm. Which is a very modern idea. And also cant condemn incest between consenting adults.

I see your perspective. It's a very coherent path to normalized ai generated child porn.

reply
I ask you to not reword my statements to make your arguments easier to win and argue for/against the points that actually were made.

The law already recognizes nuance. Calling for the death of someone is still a serious crime, but an entirely different ballpark to actual murder.

Saying that you need to persecute these people as a full-on child predators or not at all is not consistent with how basically all of existing laws work.

reply
Im not rewording your statements to make it easier to argue with.

Which parts of my comment do you feel I mischaracterized you? Are you saying you think there may still be something wrong with child porn even when the subject doesn’t exist?

The law is already clear on computer generated child porn. Been explicitly illegal since 2003 if we are talking about the US. And shouldn’t it be?

reply
People forget that less than 300 years ago people were r**ing children like it was normal. I'd argue that it survived up until half a millenia ago considering the fact that large groups (namely epstein) still exist and are surviving to this day.
reply
Hell, wasn't CP basically legal* as recently as the 70s?

* in the sense that there was not many laws against it specifically; as I understand it the imagery may have been considered illegal under broader obscenity statutes

On the issue of Epstein, that probably would warrant more nuance. I would be willing to bet that many people still today draw a very significant distinction between the teenagers Epstein preferred and, for example, prepubescent children.

reply
Statutory rape didn't exist until 1996, so yah you're right.
reply
Heh, occasionally I get reminded that I grew up when many things we understand to be truth today were not in fact recognized as such then. Starting to feel old. I don't remember that the 80s were really that bad. Different time for sure.
reply
> I don't remember that the 80s were really that bad.

They weren't, people's brains have just rotted. They've started to call people who are attracted to 17 year olds pedophiles (rather than calling most people saying that they're not attracted to 17 year olds liars who you shouldn't be alone with), fighting for the right of 18 year olds to be prostitutes, and meanwhile you can get sued to sharing copyrighted videos of 18 year olds being paid $1200 to do triple-anal penetration by one of the people who was doing the penetration and also owns the copyright.

It's not a new moral framework, it's a bunch of slogans and a bunch of legal contradictions. And somehow, things become more legal and more moral when they're filmed or done in the name of commerce.

In the 80s, or to be more accurate pre-9/11, you were expected to be able to make a coherent argument about things that you believed. After 9/11, coherent arguments became a sign of privilege and possible foreign propaganda.

The kids born after 9/11 just didn't have a chance. We raised them to say the words, and told them if they interrogated the words that they would be expelled from school, fired, and socially shunned. We had eroded workers' rights (and worker's consciousnesses) so completely by then that firing anybody for anything was trivial. We had eroded free speech so much that any reaction to anything you had said or done was not only fair but actually good, and maybe obligatory.

Now, AI is helping (and being allowed to help) enforce this strategic, authoritarian confusion. I'm sure that will end well.

Facebook: it started off censoring nipples, and ended up censoring anti-wingsuit posts and wishes that people would die. Then it branched out into surveillance devices and nuclear reactors. Are you happy about how power develops in this new world, and how it starts with the centralized control of "truth"?

/rant

reply
You might be my spirit animal. Definitely winning the Internet today, at least.
reply
> draw a very significant distinction between the teenagers Epstein preferred

That is an entirely different line of discussion, and please, please, please do not go there, as it's unlikely you'll find support for these opinions

reply
It's actually a great place to go. The idea that people who are attracted to 17 year olds are pedophiles is a corrosive idea. The idea that the reason pedophiles should be punished because they don't love the children is a corrosive idea. They're victories of mindless sloganeering over morality.

The reason that we have an age of consent is to protect people under the age of majority from being used as commodities by adults - to give them a little time before wiser, more powerful people start using them and trading them. It's the same reason why we have laws against child labor.

We don't have an age of consent because it's disgusting to be attracted to 17 year olds, and we don't have legal ages when children are allowed to work because they wouldn't be good workers before then. We do it because children should not be commodities until they've had enough training in this world to be able to defend and represent themselves to some extent. You should be working in a child's interest, they should not be working in yours.

Epstein exploited the girls that were over 18, who were the vast majority, too. They were marginal girls from broken homes who needed money. Making the odd cases when he was connected to 17 year olds the defining characteristic of what happened distorts and trivializes everything. It reminds me how #MeToo ultimately trivialized what Weinstein did by lumping it in with any sort of unwanted sexual advance. I've heard from more than one person that Weinstein went to jail for sexual harrassment. No, he was a serial rapist.

reply
As Judith Levine learned back in her day when she tried to publish "Harmful to Minors", this is an area where nuance goes to die. You're either for "paedophilia" (as defined by whoever's standing in front of you after having considered the matter for a few milliseconds), or against.
reply
IMO there's far more harm being done by 'think of the children' laws than pedophelia has ever done. We've reached the point where people don't give a f*ck about children.
reply
It's difficult to weigh those things, and I'm not an empirical researcher in this area. My gut sense, though, is that genuine paedophilia is quite rare, while the harms of thought policing and censorship are all too vivid and acutely present in the every day.
reply