I cannot disagree with this point more strongly.
If anything in the parent comment constitutes flamebait, it's the dismissive opening:
> School shootings aren't a concern.
But soberly offering data on topics people are emotional about is not flamebait, it's simply discourse.
(Not that it matters, but my wife is an elementary school teacher and we have children in school, so this is as about as sensitive a topic as it gets for me.)
I'd wager you could walk into any PTA meeting in the country and start reading off the hazards from the material safety data sheet for dihydrogen monoxide and get the majority of parents to sign off on a ban.
I agree people are horrible at evaluating risk. They're even worse when they're evaluating risk involving dangers they do not understand. The problem is compounded even further when it involves their babies. And yes, it doesn't matter if their baby is 17 years old, it's still their baby in their heart & eyes.
But stats + "these policies will harm your children" and "they will not reduce the risk of an already improbable event" is the correct choice.
And I would note that my comment was not offered at a town hall, but on a technical forum.
I wish more elected officials at least attempted the former, but populism seems to work. As hard as it is, I'm more bullish on educating the electorate than getting elected officials to act against their incentives.
>And I would note that my comment was not offered at a town hall, but on a technical forum.
Yeah I think most people here are agreeing with you and we're just arguing about how things work vs how we wish they worked. Governance would look very different if HN was representative of the electorate, but it's not.
It would be equally awful, just in a slightly different way. :)
So as effective as campaigning to Gen Z, who statistically do not turnout to polls as much.
Or if a minor commits a murder with a weapon, the parent gets punished.
Or maybe we take a look at why people are shooting up schools.
Or maybe we do all three because we have a lot of people in government and we can check more than one thing at a time.
Arguing this point on the basis of something less likely than being hit by lightning smells of bad faith and exploiting tragedy for political ends.
Maybe gun access should be restricted but it is not on this basis. We are well into the point of "diminishing policy returns" with an event whose incidence is well below 0.1/100k, and ranks in deadliness far below other much more manageable risks.
There is a strong case to make that the intersection of juvenile phone usage, social media, and sedentary lifestyles is far more deadly than gun usage, and that discussion not politically hamstrung by such petty things as "the constitution".
Because I noticed that the school lunch kitchen door was propped open before lunch hour, and that the soup pots were just inside the door and anyone could just drop rat poison in there and it would be mayhem.
Guns are a convenient tool of violence but I experienced that already on the regular, and there are so many ways to hurt people even if you’re not the strongest person there.
1) Most kids (especially those who'd do this) aren't that smart and all encompassing
2) the kinds of kids doing school shootings are not ones who'd take long term malicious joy out of slowly killing their student body. They have specific targets in mind and want to see their anguish now (collateral is just that)
3) there's the social media influence of it all. In some ways a school shooter wants to eventually be identified and glorified. Getting away with murder on the down low would not satisfy that need.
4) A school body is in more direct control of a safety concern like an open door than checking the content of every student's bag.
It's always out of "an abundance of caution" of course, but no person responsible, in case an incident does happen, is going to go up there and recite these statistics.
There is a reasons that doctors do not casually suggest tests for e.g. all sorts of cancers when those tests carry false positives: false alarms can, in aggregate, be worse than the event they aim do detect.
The mentality that "bad thing could happen" --> "we must act" is deeply embedded in our culture, but is incredibly harmful. Sometimes the best course is to make an informed decision to accept the risk, because all available alternatives are worse.
Statistical presentations like that which do not quantify the actual harm ("how many were injured / killed") and instead focus on the emotional aspect ("how much did a scary thing happen") are not worth discussion; they're intended to mislead or frame the discussion in dishonest ways.
* How often does the thing happen
* What are the harms / costs of the thing
* What are the available responses, what risk reduction do they represent, and what burden / cost do they incur
That’s some normalisation of deviance you got going on there.
There should be zero school shootings.
However, being able to contact your kid directly because they’re carrying a phone isn’t going to render them any less shot.
I propose government mandated safety rails with hazard-yellow paint on all roofs and personal taxpayer-supported lightning rods.
More seriously and on-topic, depression and anti-social behavior are far bigger risks to teens and phone usage makes that risk far worse without meaningfully affecting shootings. Can we get rid of phones?
Diminishing urgency is not the charge this puts upon gun control activists. One should really be asking why people fail to prioritize addressing the greater child killers. I don't think it's necessarily because this one is more addressable. Activists who make this their main concern primarily seem to want large scale firearm seizure. Even in an authoritarian's dream America where the Constitution is a wax tablet for carving and molding we would struggle to take peoples' guns. I hope I am not extrapolating too much.
...is due to a toxic media culture that latches onto particular issues more over their political exploitability than for their actual impact on threats to life / liberty.
If media / politicians truly cared about kids they'd have instead spent their energy over the last decade campaigning against
- Food policies that encourage junk food even (especially) among lower income families
- School policies that allow or encourage technology despite the near zero evidence for benefit and numerous studies showing harm
- School permissiveness towards (or approval of) phone use and social media despite mountains of evidence for harm
One can say that we should reduce the shootings to zero, but it would be folly to let that prevent tackling far larger, more tractable issues that are not politically divisive as "gun control" is. I can already anticipate the angry responses over the recognition that it is a divisive issue; surely that itself is demonstrative of the folly?
And number of deaths is not the whole story. Entire generations of children are coping with school shootings. From in-school drills to metal detectors. We are in a position of having to teach all kids about avoiding being murdered. That comes with a cost. Both in dollars and emotional impact that will shape the rest of their lives.
So yeah. 21. But those 21 have a huge impact.
It’s no surprise the same people who want to take education apart are the same people that want to do nothing about school shootings which make schools danger zones.
So why do we have to do that now, and did not have to do that in 1980? IIRC, in 1980, you could buy guns at K-Mart (the Walmart of the day).
I posit that this is at its core a media problem: it creates the fear and basically advertises murder to maladjusted kids. You'd probably have a lot less of them if they got very little coverage when they did happen.
Should we try to mitigate school shootings, et. al.? Yeah. Are people fixing the issues? no. They point to guns. Yes, guns are used, but the problem is mental health. No one gives an eff about your family. Everyone cares about what effects themselves.
It's starts at home. Kids become isolated, parents are busy working and do notice or care or are able to intervene, faculty don't have the means or care to address issues at school (bullying, etc). It's not the gun's fault. It's the layers of failures up to that point.
Anyway, people should be more afraid of inattentive drivers, walking alongside roads at night, etc.
I'm also one of the parents that doesn't feel any need to be able to text/call them at any time of the day. I'm raising them to be able to handle themselves and contact me through means available to them if they need to.
Modern parenting gets a lot wrong in my opinion.
Someone worries about school shootings and they do things around it. But not everyone needs to nor even should worry about them, as it becomes counterproductive.
I'm a millennial and it happened when I was in high school. But yeah, there was maybe only one incident with a gun at my high school before then (not a shooting, kid just had a starter pistol in his backpack) and I don't recall ever thinking of a school shooting until Columbine happened.
I'd be more concerned about my kid not learning anything because of constant phone/social media access.
Phones are entirely about not shutting the fuck up.
Shutting up when someone is shooting at you would take actual scary practice. Which I do not think is happening.
If you know where the shooter is, that would better inform the decision to run, hide, or fight.
That said, general chaos and delays in information dissemination mean that location information is likely stale and not very useful.
Not to mention, knowing the danger is near makes many children panic, which makes them a bigger target, not a smaller one.
This is anxiety, not based on any knowledge we as a culture possess about threat management and stress in dangerous situations.
Something like:
a) Shooter is in Building 1, Room 23. Exit towards the fields. (Around here, room numbers are on large print signs visible through the windows, so it's plausible that outside observers could see the shooter and know the room number)
b) Shooter is in your building, barricade doors and hide.
c) police moving in, stay down until they escort you out.
A and B assume the sender knows the location of the recipient and the shooter and understands the school layout.
Could be very useful, if accurate and timely. I don't expect it to be possible (or reasonable) to be accurate or timely though. Even if this was a reasonable expectation, phones off and/or in bags during a normal day and taken out and turned on only for special occasions would be sufficient.
Also, how have we identified the shooter and his accomplices so that we aren’t sending them the identical information? And how do I know the locations of every student so I tell YOU to exit toward the field but not the person on the other side of the shooter toward the field?
None of you guys are thinking, just reacting. Reacting gets you killed. I hope to God this isn’t in your job descriptions. Because this is all hopes and prayers not serviceable crisis management behavior.
Building number? In this economy? If someone asked me which room my class was in, but the end of the semester I had to think really really hard about that. It was the third door from the exit, the left door at the top of the stairs, the last door before the bathrooms. In the weird little hallway near my locker from last year. And wtf knows where room 23 even is, unless you’re in room 21?
And when both parents and your step mom are offering conflicting information from what the phone is telling you?
I mean, I expect teenagers to be able to follow simple instructions, if they're trying to communicate, but that's only really worth considering if you can determine and deliver the instructions. "It's safe(r) to leave, exit towards X" or "barricade yourself and hide" are simple instructions, but broadcasting exit directions can't work and broadcasting to barricade is probably not ideal. You can probably broadcast that police have entered the scene and to stay where you are because that would apply to everyone.
>And when both parents and your step mom are offering conflicting information from what the phone is telling you?
Yes, that's an issue --- accurate and timely communications is required and not easy or reasonable to expect. But if you're going to leave based on remote messaging, you probably need to do so quickly since the information will go stale quickly, so when someone tells you to go, you should go right away... and focus on leaving rather than checking your phone as you go. OTOH, your parents should only send you directions if they have high confidence that their information is accurate and timely --- it would be hard to have that much confidence.
100% agree that a crisis situation without practice is going to be a disaster. Tbh, it will anyway. Cell phone or no. The only school kids with practice reacting to violence live in the inner city.
This is fewer than "deaths in a hot car" (1/2), "familial homicide" (1/10), and "deaths from traffic" (1/50). Cancer, suicide, and (inferential from various studies) obesity all outrank it.
As I recall from the last time I dug this up, this is fewer deaths than "people falling off of their roof" and lower than the annualized rate of fatal lightning strikes (2006-2025).
Strange then that none of those drive policy, and we instead focus on a thing that is astonishingly unlikely to occur.
I don't think I recall any major policy platforms on these, school shootings has seemed to drive the bus and (forgive the cynicism) it seems to have been precisely because it dovetails directly into the political wedge issue of gun control. That is, its divisiveness-- that it can't result in meaningful change-- seems to be why it draws so much attention, to the detriment of fixing more solvable, lower-hanging fruit.
Allowing ourselves to distracted in this manner specifically prevents us from "doing two things at once".
https://www.transportation.gov/grants/SS4A https://www.transportation.gov/NRSS https://www.nhtsa.gov/pathways-to-safer-streets
Traffic isn't sexy, so we don't get talking heads yammering on about it. But, the works is being done.
So, yes, we can in fact do two things at once.
- Easier to trace causation for
- Politically undivisive to mitigate
- Dramatically more impactful
... than trying to tackle gun deaths.
Most people here are surely technical. Imagine you have a stack of CVSS 9+ vulnerabilities with lateral movement capability in exposed services where the patch risk is low.
Now imagine some redteamer pops up saying "Hey, your internal, airgapped AC monitoring IOT devices have CVSS 3.0, patching it is incredibly manual and it has a high chance to disrupt office-wide cooling-- I think you should prioritize fixing it".
I think most people here would immediately see the absurdity of it. Focus on the big, easy wins before tackling the stuff with a harder-to-justify risk matrix. We can do two things at once, and when you pick you don't make one of your two the unlikely, hard, low-return thing.
It's bonkers to me as well, and I would argue that the view espoused here-- "darn the facts, I'm emoting over tragedy"-- is the literal cause.
Doctors regard false positives that lead to unnecessary life changes as a harm that requires consideration when evaluating interventions. Why is it so crazy to take the same approach to society at large? As we discuss teenage depression and suicide, should we not evaluate whether an (ineffective) culture of fear over an incredibly unlikely event is more harmful than helpful?
Perhaps society would do well without guns.
Then consider that the threat we are discussing is, compared to many other threats to children, very low risk.
Finally, consider whether it might be better to instead spend our efforts on other threats (traffic? obesity? juvenile phone usage? familial homicide?) that are simultaneously higher risk, easier to mitigate, and less politically divisive.
A reasonable conclusion is that our resources are far better spent reducing other risks, than tilting at intractable windmills. Sometimes risk reduction gets exponentially harder and more expensive as you approach zero and it becomes more ideological than practical to pursue that unattainable zero.
Again
Have we met? You don't know what you are talking about
I welcome any corrections.... Just putting out facts does not make it so.
Are you asking for links to the search results that it took ~10 minutes to gather?- Quantify how "bad" the event is
- Determine how frequent it is
Those two facts underlie all cost-benefit analysis of a policy response. Do we apply some societal cost? Curtail freedoms? Accept the risk? How can you begin to weigh the alternatives, if you don't know where this thing sits on "list of bad things X how frequent they are"?
It's silly that you take one metric and dismiss it as a non-issue when it's actually a huge force shaping our culture and society. It's like saying terrorism is a non-issue because it kills less people than falling out of bed. Basically we should only care about car accidents and heart disease.
There are hundreds of physical injuries in 2023....distress
There are over a thousand traffic deaths. There are a dozen other mortality risks for kids that are easier to tackle and less politically fraught.If I'm doing a cost benefit analysis I'm going to focus on the biggest risks (mortality, not distress) and on where the biggest gains are going to be made.
The simple fact is, politicians and the media use school shootings because they are flashy, emotional, and can be used to drive narratives around political wedge issues. They are useful, in other words. But that is not the basis on which responsible risk management is performed, and I'd expect rather more savvy in this regard from a technical forum.
- Spend finite resources where they will have more, rather than less, impact
- Diminishing returns can mean that reducing the prevalence of an outcome from 1% to 0.01% is less expensive than reducing it from 0.01% to 0.005%
- That an outcome is tragic does not intrinsically mean "something must be done". Sometimes all possible "somethings" carry costs that outweigh the benefit
In this context, the "something" that is proposed is "bringing phones into school" which has demonstrably
- not reduced shooting incidence
- Nor reduced its harm
- increased antisocial behavior and depression
- Reduced school performance outcomes
So "moving on" would have been better than what happened in this case, yes.
Source: https://everytownresearch.org/maps/gunfire-on-school-grounds...
Speaking very roughly, a random person is more likely to be hospitalized due to covid than to be even at a school while a gun is fired there.
CDC estimates that this week alone there will be 5100 covid hospitalizations, while Everytown (cited below by robby_w_g) tallied 107 incidents of gunfire at school for the entire year-to-date.
https://www.cdc.gov/cfa-modeling-and-forecasting/covid19-dat...
School kids aren’t ’a random person’, they are rather a quite specific demographic.
Update your comparison to ’school kids hospitalised due to covid’, then we can talk.
There were 3x more kids dying in car accidents in 2025 than all school shootings combined since we started recording them.
I do treat this as an engineering problem for what it's worth: If I want to maximize the chance that my kids survive, I do need to attend to the most likely ways that they're going to die.
Kids don't need to have their phones on them during class "for safety". On the way to and from school, sure, but once they're at school, stow the phones somewhere.
Have you seen a scary or dramatic movie in the last twenty years?
I guarantee you have kids today getting pinged in math class because they left a wet towel on the floor. That’s not conducive to learning.
[1] https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/canada-school-cellphones-ban-...
What are they planning to do? Call their kid, who is hiding, and let the shooter hear where the kid is?
People lie on the internet, and sometimes even lie to themselves. I can almost guarantee that most of them just have some other motive.
It doesn’t trigger your tells if you believe your own bullshit.
Not true. Old millenials were in high school at that exact time. And there's that weird Xennial group from 1977-1983. Too young for proper X'er, and almost too old for 'millenial culture'.
Meanwhile, six friends of mine actually did die before graduating. One from a cat dander allergy, one from shooting himself, one smothered in her sleep by her mom's boyfriend, and three from getting hit by cars. Three separate stop lights were also added to streets in my city because of kids getting killed in front of elementary schools, but those were not mine and I didn't know them.
Hell, a kid was murdered at my dad's birthday party where he first met my mom, and it was uneventful enough that she didn't even know until he told the story two Christmases ago. Police didn't even investigate.
I know it's distasteful to downplay people's fears and I don't want to illegitimize anything. If you're scared, you're scared. But the world is not more dangerous now than in the 70s through 90s. Even beyond the more direct dangers, a good quarter of the kids I knew had started smoking by 4th grade. My best friend from high school died of alcohol poisoning, though that was after high school. I lost count of how many caught chlamydia or gonorrhea at some point. Kids today apparently don't drink or have sex and barely drive, so that alone probably makes them safer than ever.
As far as I can tell, it's not the actual probability of harm making anyone scared. It's the sheer overwhelming awareness of threat. Whereas I grew up seeing those news reports about gang crossfire once a week, you're getting it every time you open your phone. You probably have cameras mounted on your frontdoor sending you alerts every time a stranger walks past the house. Neighborhood groups sending group texts or private chats warning you about package thieves or scary looking homeless people.
Again, I get it. The entire time I served in the Army, the probability of dying on the Texas highways back home was higher than dying in combat. Two guys from my unit were killed in combat across two 15-month tours. Nine died in vehicular accidents outside Fort Hood. One drowned in a lake off-post. But I drove all the time, swam in that same lake, and was never scared like I was scared of mortar fire and IEDs. Some events are just scarier than others, for whatever reason. Our evaluations of threat are not rational. But public policy should be. It is abundantly obvious that more harm is done by kids having phones in school than is prevented by being able to contact them during active shooter events.