upvote
Very much agree with you that there is a pattern emerging. I think I agree with your conclusion as well.

There are a couple of things to keep in mind with nsanet though:

- It can handle anywhere between confidential to TS//SCI information

- It is largely (completely?) an off-infra network, meaning that it doesn't run over the same infrastructure that the open internet uses. It uses an entirely(?) discrete backbone. SIPRNET uses similar architecture.

- You cannot easily cross pollinate data from unclassified networks to nsanet. Everything from removable media to EMSEC is considered prohibited without proper channels being informed and paperwork being performed.

- Lastly, we're unaware of the timing of this supposed source. This could have been over the last week or a month ago or <n>. Scant detail is given, so I'm unwilling to believe "lolz nsa pwnd" just yet.

reply
I used to routinely watch people pull thumb drives out of SIPRNET machines and put them into NIPRNET machines and vice-versa.

I would not be surprised if something similar was involved here. It worked with stuxnet, too.

reply
So, that's illegal and against AUP.

Beyond that it's also typically blocked by GPO prohibiting USB, so even if that were the case, the net result would be no real data transfer and a nice email to the DA mailgroup about the workstation and logged in user who triggered the alert.

reply
I remember the cork board outside the dfac with phones and ipods screwed through the screen to the board... all the ones folks plugged into the sipr for one reason or another.
reply
Stuxnet was preloaded thumb drives that were scattered in areas where people plugged them in on accident. Either you don't understand the DTA controls and processes, or the people around you were committing federal offenses and were being tracked.
reply
Stuxnet was not randomly scattered USB drives.

Unspecified computer parts were interdicted by US intelligence while being shipped to Neda Industrial and infected with Stuxnet. Four other external vendors working on the enrichment plant were also compromised, likely by Israeli intelligence physically entering buildings.

Stuxnet then spread across each companies internal networks and onto USB drives that were then carried into the facility and plugged into the air gapped network.

reply
SIPRnet and the other confidential networks are transporting data on regular Internet but use encryption. It’s like a VPN.
reply
Some, there are still a lot that don't share lines and predate the ubiquity of the world wide web.
reply
Some do, not all though.
reply
Well, it is bit beyond a typical VPN. The routers that encrypt/decrypt at either end are special. They only like to talk to each other.

https://gdmissionsystems.com/encryption/taclane-network-encr...

reply
Do you have an estimate of NSA uptime over the last 10 years?
reply
It occurs to me that even if the recent outages are mostly just growing pains from rapid/careless AI adoption, a sufficiently advanced AI cyberattack would be designed to be indistinguishable from normal outages.
reply
> ...a sufficiently advanced AI cyberattack would be designed to be indistinguishable from normal outages.

Aren't these being treated as "normal" outages by the media and powers that be?

reply
They are so far, but I would expect the same kind of public do-not-fear response if this was a coordinated cyber attack and the US is at war with an adversary that has experienced the power and consequence of targeted cyber capabilities. If they didn't pursue their own program in earnest after StuxNet I would be shocked.

We collectively are very much in arm-chair speculation at this point. If this is a coordinated cyber attack the US government right now wouldn't want to demonstrate weakness or fault. Iran would be the obvious culprit... but going full arm-chair on speculation... There was a major and disappointing result in our elections to the current powers that be...

If this was a staged set of attacks carefully done to minimize casualties... I bet it would be enough to declare a state of emergency and get additional executive powers "legitimately". If that was the case I would expect more propaganda and less bury it under the rug if that was going on.

Be careful out there the world is scary. Don't take any of this as fact, this is all personal speculation based on my own observations. Let me stand-up from my armchair and go for a walk...

reply
The US has so many enemies both internal and external it could be basically anyone:

- Epstein/SV network within the US flexing muscles in response to mid term losses

- Iran, obviously

- China, obviously

- Russia, obviously

- CIA attacking other parts of the deep state in some internecine struggle or other

Literally all of those are completely plausible scenarios where the actors are motivated and capable

reply
Absolutely agree. All of those are practical and viable threat actors.

Based on my personal experience and to a certain extent sitting back down in my arm chair. I don't believe this is either China or Russia, they both have priorities that don't immediately involve the US and (as a government) the US is actively supporting both right now in very desirable (to them) ways.

Internal US action and Iran both seem equally likely in my head right now, but this is purely speculation and attribution is the hardest part to actually nail down when a state actor is involved.

This and the continued outages, such as the new Apple services outage, all collectively feel to close together without some evidence of a shared infrastructure causing it or a coordinated attack.

I don't personally believe this is "AI agents hacking the planet". The companies involved (well at least half of the outages I've seen) have enough compliance and protection obligations they are regularly audited against that my Occam's Razor gut feeling tells me that this is either long established persistent and maintained access being detonated one-by-one OR its a focused attack by one or more teams under the same directive taking down significant US focused institutions for attack or reprisal.

reply
> ...this is either long established persistent and maintained access being detonated one-by-one OR its a focused attack by one or more teams under the same directive taking down significant US focused institutions for attack or reprisal.

Have you considered the possibility that this isn't even the detonation/attack? That this is testing and/or a modest demonstration of capability.

If these are attacks, they don't at all feel like they're at the hands of people who have shot their wad.

reply
It doesn't even have to be a state actor. Thanks to technology, even small groups can wreak havoc these days. And it's only going to get worse.
reply
how about israel?
reply
The country that must not be named is always a suspect, but I kind of included it under Epstein/SV - ultimately that network all leads back to one place
reply
I would include in this list all of South America both government actors, disgruntled private citizens who feel they are beyond the reach of US authorities, and paramilitary or drug cartels.
reply
South American actors would align well with the recent surge of DSA socialists
reply
Iatrogenic outages would happen at similar times with overlap, versus convenient-for-narrative day-to-day outages.
reply
It's the fact the outages took the weekend off is kind of what is tingling my spidey sense.
reply
Did the outages take the weekend off, or did the reporters and users of the impacted systems take the weekend off?
reply
The only problem with that bias is it only takes into account the hyper sensitivity and press these events are getting.

While all flights grounded is significant on it's own, and would have got press, even in a world where the fear of AI or foreign interference wasn't so strong, but there's been more than a few substantial local and regional groundings due to software over the past 4-5 years.

Microsoft outage is not new, Teams and Outlook have had more than a handful of outages way before the current doomer craze. While I had to search these for accurate recall, having worked closely with Microsoft for a decade plus, the recent outage is not isolated and to jump to conclusions is short sighted. For example, pre-doomsday summary of Microsoft's noteworthy outages: (1) Azure Outage -Sep 2018 South Central US (San Antonio DC); (2) Recurring multi-day Teams outage that effected users world wide February - April 2020 (3-4 outages in total); (3) December 2021 - Azure Active Directory outage locked people out of Azure and Outlook for several hours. (4) July 2022 - half-day outage for exchange, teams, sharepoint for most users. Same span outlook and exchange were down much like this last event for several hours. (5) Jan & Feb 2023 several outages for globoal Microsoft Outlook and network events.

That's not even all of the events in the last 5-6 years.

Optimizely, NSA network, and FAA mostly would have been under reported and or ignored by the general public.

I'm not saying this time couldn't be different this time, but what is the thesis? AI, foreign actors, incompetence?

"I don't know what, but something is clearly happening" is fear talking not rational thinking. Not all dots require connections. If you had full awareness of all the wild things that go on in one day, the amount of correlation you could draw from that if you're trying to tell a story would be pretty salacious.

But correlation != ____________

reply
Why would the FAA have been ignored by the general public? I feel like a 4+ hour stop on all planes in the US is going to be front page unless there's something bigger going on.

I agree that correlation doesn't imply causation. At the same time, I think an increase in uncommon events over a relatively short period of time does increase the chance that they are correlated.

Does it increase it enough to make it plausible or likely? No clue. But we've seen similar in Europe, and the consensus among intelligence/military analysts seems to be that Russia and Europe are in a non-military conflict of some sort.

It might be just bad luck here, or the start of something similar.

reply
The devil is in answering the question "4 what?"

Because then you have to define the "major" and "short" in "major outages in a short timespan", in such a way that

A. Includes all four of those B. When applied to the past, would actually, meaningfully differ from the status quo (How often can something happen before it's alarming? Once a decade? Twice as often as that? Half as often?) C. Isn't a clear overfit, threading the needle to meet A and B, but is actually robust against perturbations.

You will likely be right that this is a meaningful period, simply from the flights being grounded and the Microsoft outage, both meaningfully unusual events, but it's very easy to make a fairly challenging assessment seem simple if you just arbitrarily choose things to count on your fingers.

reply
Keep an open mind. We are pattern-matching beings.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apophenia

reply
Would we have heard or cared about this one if the others hadn't already happened?

I don't think it's a stretch to say that some number of services go down every day and we don't hear or care about them. Three or four services going down and/or being attacked over a few days is only a pattern if it's actually different from before vs. you're just more aware about them.

reply
US Banks down, United grounded a second time.
reply
Chase had an issue. Other banks' only problem was that they couldn't work with Chase, which makes up a large % of external accounts.
reply
deleted
reply
Heh - from "Goldfinger":

'Mr Bond, they have a saying in Chicago:

"Once is happenstance. Twice is coincidence. The third time it's enemy action."

[From the original Ian Fleming novel]'

reply
Train crash in Prague today: https://news.sky.com/story/prague-train-crash-leaves-46-peop...

After the very deadly crash in Spain a few weeks ago...

reply
AFAICT the Spain crash is due to horrendously irresponsible (non)implementation of train traffic safety systems.

You don't need a spy if the target self-sabotages.

reply
[dead]
reply
Public companies have 4 days to disclose material cybersecurity incidents, per the SEC.

While this rule doesn't apply to the NSA, speculation that recent down time from these U.S. companies being caused by state-sponsored cyber warfare seems unlikely.

reply
Four unrelated things?
reply
Idk why you're being downvoted. Optimizely getting malware doesn't seem connected to Outlook going down last week in any meaningful way.

It's easy to spot patterns when paranoid.

reply
Because we don't know they're unrelated.

If four politicians die on the same day of heart attacks, maybe they're unrelated. Maybe they're chemical assassinations.

Same here.

reply
4 systems going down in the span of 2 weeks for very different reasons is not atypical though. A more apt analogy would be "4 politicians died in the past week in different parts of the planet for different reasons". If headlines focused on those deaths it would also fuel conspiracy theories.

> Because we don't know they're unrelated.

They might be related! But the burden of proof is not on the null case.

reply
Thank you for explaining how the mind of paranoid conspiracy theorist works. For the rest of us it works like this: four unrelated events get treated as unrelated until there is convincing evidence showing otherwise.
reply
Wasn't there a bank outage too? OpenAi must be cooking. The new model is so strong it will mass destruct your ass!
reply
They could just be asking AI to attack different things and find weaknesses as an attack everything goes down things go down 1 by 1 its more like testing. Or more cynical read it could be the plan to hose the american people for all the AI investment scare them into investing in and allowing ai data centers
reply
Who is "they"?
reply
who are* "they"
reply
Modern usage begs to differ.
reply
We're in an interesting time when Hanlon's razor seems to be being tested. "Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity".

AI-accelerated attacks, I think most of the cybersecurity ones are attributable to that exploiting previous incompetences. But the flight grounding and microsoft outages? Looks more like direct incompetence to me

Either way I think the takeaway is that we've been slacking for a long time and now we have something that doesn't need man-hours, caffeine, and obsessive human focus to take advantage of that fact. At least for those of us who have been in the field for a while there's lots of work cleaning up these messes for the foreseeable future but I been on calls with peers of mine in infosec who have definitely been losing valuable sleep and health over it

reply
Hanlon's razor reads more to me like a malicious thought terminating cliche than an actual law via averages that still requires testing. Anyone operating with Hanlon's razor can have their perception of anything easily hacked by simply pretending to be stupid, thus converting an act of malicious intent presumably brought about through some motive into an opaque act that requires no further scrutiny.
reply
Hanlon's razor is a useful tool for your personal human relationships, but it is a bad tool for geopolitics.
reply
burn after reading
reply
It's a snark "law", not a real guidance policy.
reply
Agreed, although in common parlance the cliche has has developed more power than it was intended to possess, purely through habitual use. My main point is to point out that it does have a real chilling-like effect within public discourse. I see it most often in commentary about unfolding events. Inquiry into current events creates an impetus for further explanation from information dealers (governments, reporters, etc.) and when that inquiry happens out in the open, it benefits us in the moment and in the historical record. You only get so much attention from a reader and when the content is akin to eating your vegetables, readers look for excuses to clear their plate.
reply
Interesting perspective. Do you have any better proposals?
reply
At the very least you should take "cui bono" into account, weighted by frequency.
reply
checking which way the errors lean seems like a nice sharpening of the concept, thanks
reply
Embrace the nuance of any given situation. Abandon the idea that there even exists a valid explanation in blaming cause on stupidity. The cliche doesn't convey information, its merely a characterization which gives permission to readers to stop further inquiry and our acceptance of this has been trained through basic mimetics. Find comfort in saying "I'm not sure what the attributable cause is" rather than deferring to a pop-sci over generalization of human nature. After that, its simply an effort of fact finding.
reply
The reverse Hanlon's razor: malice by default, unless proven non-malevolent.
reply
What do you mean by "better proposals"?

Of what?

reply
They have a really good point about strategic negligence and it's just the first I've ever heard of that angle
reply
Who is they?

What are you talking about?

The question I asked you is a specific one and it has a specific answer.

reply
Well, how about: "never attribute something that benefited your enemies to just a pure chance"?
reply
deleted
reply
At what point does widespread incompetence become malicious? AKA malicious incompetence
reply
It seems we're in a 2-for-1 situation nowadays: "Hanlon's Cut-Throat"?
reply
Im more in the camp of just avoiding simple repeatable explanations for diverse, complicated, and nuanced events.
reply
I would say the incompetence side also includes decades of 'get er done' attitude towards software design. We've been chasing fashionable frameworks and abstractions that may support velocity for developers, but not deep contemplation of the ramifications of design/architecture. The reward/risk balance was never in favor of slowing down to design secure software, it is in favor of meeting the complex and changing requirements of business as quickly as possible. Tech debt just got more expensive because 'poke it until it breaks' was always an option, but now we can ask an LLM and it can work tirelessly in the same problem space. Time for everyone to grind fundamental CS concepts, and aim to reduce complexity. On the bright side an LLM can help with that as well, just remember to append "make no mistakes" to the end of every prompt!
reply
Yeah you said it better than I did.
reply
Although I don't know the answer, and have not done the work to analyze this situation properly, in cases like this I find it helpful to try to focus primarily on the overall epistemological framework rather than only the matter at hand (since it is easy to get lost in all the uncertainty, lack of knowledge, and presence of disinformation); an especially useful and simple tool here is Bayesian inference.

For instance, I have heard that Iranians have developed rather sophisticated cyber-warfare capabilities. I don't know if that is true, and if true, I don't know how likely it would be that they would have reached capabilities to cause the observed outages. But even if you assume that the probability (or rather degree of belief) is quite small but still realistic, say between 0.1 and 10 percents, than considering the current situation it might be absolutely rational to see it likely that they are behind these outages. The full analysis requires estimation of the probability that this is all just a coincidence, and of other major "non-coincidental" branches. But one can do this at various levels of precision and explicitly observe how the output depends on the priors and the estimated probabilities (and therefore, on the assumptions).

reply
As always: how does Bayes' Theorem and assigning arbitrary percentages shed any light on this topic? If you took any mention of Bayesian inference out of your comment, would it lack any content or insight? I have encountered the concept for years and it just seems to make explicit what everyone already does implicitly. Not that there's no value to that, but I think it's very rare that it's worth invoking.
reply
It is hard to give an answer to a comment like yours since I have no idea at what level are we discussing the topic.

First of all, I have not said that just assigning arbitrary probabilities sheds much light on the matter. Rather, what I alluded to, is that even rough estimates might often shed a lot of light on the topic. The Bayesian formulation helps to separate the problem into relevant parts, make the relative importance and interdependence of various factors that enter the reasoning clearer, and makes the assumptions more explicit. But in my post I have not really explained anything; I have just pointed to a tool somebody interested might use to critically assess similar issues. So yes, if you took it away, the post would lack an important part of its message, namely a pointer to a framework that the OP (or anyone interested) might find useful. However, I do not plan to give a treatise on Bayesian analysis in a HN post.

As for the other angles of your post: 1. Yes, the usage of the framework absolutely can shed light on many matters of this kind. What is your background? How much experience do you have with statistics or inference in general? There are many good sources where you can learn about these methods. A somewhat controversial one, but freely accessible, is E.T. Jaynes' Probability Theory, which actually directly addresses some aspects of what I spoke about. 2."it just seems to make explicit what everyone already does implicitly" People apply very bad judgement to matters like these all the time, this forum included. And even if people all used those things implicitly (which often they don't) it would still be worthwhile since it allows one to inspect the argument and find flaws or observe what are the dependencies on various assumptions.

reply
Apple's services are down as well.
reply
What kind of CLASSIFIED network is this one, that when it goes down we hear about it on CNN?
reply
I assume most trusted news networks would have some staff that are cleared so they can read a bit more detailed news, then help frame the messages that go out to the masses.
reply
They have intelligence mouthpiece contacts whom they quote uncritically, because they have no other option. That becomes the new truth through Citogenesis.
reply
That's a silly assumption.

News professionals would never be granted "need to know", and therefore would never be granted any level of secure access at all.

reply
The size and scale of something like SIPR, JWICS mean they're interacted with by tens of thousands of people at facilities worldwide on a daily basis as part of their regular relatively mundane work. It would be hard not to notice.
reply
Classified ads aren’t a secret as well.
reply
The existence and status of the network are not classified, just some of the data on it, I'm guessing.
reply
The kind that you need clearance and polygraph to get on.
reply
Here is a question for your next polygraph test: "Are you the source who told CNN about our internal IT stuff?"
reply
The pattern is that a bunch of software kind of sucks
reply
Yes, you don't know. And neither do I.

What I however know is that somehow the human brain likes pattern matching. We look into the sky and see patterns made by the clouds. We see some random cloud formation, match it against 100000 patterns and say "This is a car". We look at ink blots on a paper, match it and say "This is a knife" (Rorschach test).

Nothing of this is true ... it's just that we matched a pattern. And that he hold something plausible.

But ... thinking something is plausible is far from being it true. To draw an actual conclusion, we need a rigorous thinking process. Based on logic, not assumption. With facts, not assumptions.

If I would have to describe the current times (e.g. the last 15 times) then it would be the sudden lack of all this virtues in people engaging with other people. We seem to be certainly back in the old times, where rumors are hold to be true ("This red haired lady with a dark cat is certainly a witch. Burn her!"). And, worse, often people base actions on this hearsay, so we are also a bit back in the Lynch justice mindset.

> I don't know what, but something is clearly happening.

And I know, something IS happening. That's an inherent truism. Example: You, dear reader, are breathing. Breathing is "something". It is happening. Clearly even. I mean, if we start to write extremely vague, then another human matching pattern can see anything in it. We shouldn't talk in horoscope language and we shouldn't assume that horoscope language contains anything of value.

reply
Thank you, Godel/Rorschach/Magritte. But your truism is not useful.
reply
I am just surprised this is not happening all the time, after piling on layers upon layers of software and merely looking for a checkbox to check and someone else to blame (and pay). Even the vertically integrated tech companies that used to be in control of the whole stack are having their Outlook moments now, everyone else is worse off.
reply
Everyone had to jump off VMware because the price got jacked up, and the people who were forced to rebuild the systems in a hurry weren't the ones who architected them. I'll bet there is a big learning curve for these systems that were slowly optimized over time, but now people are switching to Openshift and whatnot where those optimizations and Lessons Learned are mostly thrown out.

AI cyberattacks, foreign interference, and Ghost in the Shell type stuff sounds cooler though.

reply
You forgot about the Chase bank incident yesterday. Supposedly it was a software glitch. So that makes 5.
reply
Timed to peak with GTA 6 release and Anthropic IPO.
reply
DOGED
reply
PRISM update is being rolled out.

It's a big change so hiccups are expected.

reply
The deadline for Genesis Mission [0], the US gov project to integrate its systems as well as private systems into a centralized AI platform to deliver its first report is at the end of November.

I saw some speculation here [1] that it might be the root cause.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genesis_Mission

[1] https://substack.com/@thedreydossier/note/c-389611426

reply
Add 5, apple services down
reply
In the early days of the Russian invasion of Ukraine, Russia faced a big problem: it had hardly any of the tanks it paid for. Why? Corruption. Basically it worked like this: a general would get money from the Kremlin to design and build new tanks. They'd build a few but for whatever reason they'd be found wanting. So a new contract was written up. But what happened to the money? It got pocketed by the generals, the contractor and a bunch of other people in between.

That's basically what's happening to the US right now. It is corruption from the Oval Office all the way down. Pardons are being openly sold. The news was manipulated ("a ceasefire is imminent") to profit off the oil markets. Stock trades on insider information abound. All of this is an inevitable consequence from a Supreme Court who manufactured out of thin air substantial criminal immunity for the president. This built on other decisions where this Court in particular just could not see corruption (eg Snyder v. United States [1]).

In the private sector literally nobody is ever punished for cost-cutting on systems to the point that they break. In fact, they're rewarded for it. It's entshittification from the CEOs all the way down.

We'll probably find as more of these incidents happen that AI code was written and reviewed by another AI, never tested and deployed to production. Foreign actors will be blamed, Congress will be blamed, etc. As an aside, the DoT is asking for $50 billion after the FAA outage (the worst in 25 years). Then Representative Mullin voted against $25 billion for the FAA in the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act in 2021 [2].

Now the administration wants to sell this narrative that they've been hacked. No, they're just corrupt and everything sucks as an inevitable result. Everything is shit. Nobody is hacking us.

I honestly don't know how we get out of this but we need a hard reset of some sort. One such hard reset was the French Revolution. There are an awful lot of people who need to spend the rest of their lives in jail, penniless.

[1]: https://us.transparency.org/news/supreme-court-undercuts-fed...

[2]: https://heritageaction.com/scorecard/members/M001190/117

reply
the pattern is more and more poorly trained people are effing around with running "AI" agents on their massive, fragile codebases

none of these systems are even vaguely similar

reply
"Mr. Bond, they have a saying in Chicago: Once is happenstance. Twice is coincidence. The third time it's enemy action."
reply
[dead]
reply
Pretense for Iran ground operation
reply
Iran's strong hits against our military, which were barely reported, could easily have been the excuse of they wanted to go that route.

They don't. This administration thought they could Venezuela Iran from the air.

reply
Yes, there are no legitimate actions in the world. Everything which seems to happen is actually just a pretense so we can justify our actions.

Even more importantly, when these pretextual actions occur, everyone interprets them the same way and agrees that the secretly-planned action is now the one we must take.

reply
Do they even need a pretense these days?

It has come to my attention that the political elites and the Epstein class simply do as they please with virtually no consequences.

reply
Would you say the Democrats winning a lot of seats in the midterms is as least some consequence?
reply
The Democrat politicians are part of the Epstein class.
reply
Some. Certainly the Schumers and Jeffries.

But not the AOCs and Bernies. They have no counterparts in the completely corrupt and immoral GOP.

reply
[dead]
reply