upvote
>(Aaron Schwarts was surveilled for years by the FBI for downloading scientific articles that he legally had access to, when an AI company steals them nobody bats an eye).

Funny you mention Swartz. He was entirely on board with "information wants to be free". He explicitly condoned piracy in pretty much every form. Also there's many ongoing legal problems for these AI companies that address all this. Anthropic is already on the hook to pay 1.5 billion for pirated books alone.

But this is going to be the issue of our time. If we make it past this point in history (I'm skeptical) I have a feeling that the "stealing" of information in such a way will seem comical to future generations. We'll gape in awe at how everyone was in a rabid race to hoard THEIR information to get pieces of paper and that we basically destroyed the only planet we have to live on in service of having more of an imaginary "value" (whatever value means on a dead planet).

But I guess I'm of the opinion humanity is ultimately doomed because of our greed. We've been warned and are watching in real time as climate change does exactly what we were told it was going to do decades ago and our answer to it is to put out even more emissions (drill baby drill!). IF AI can cause a technological boom that can maybe fix some of that damage perhaps all the "theft" was worth it? If not oh well the theft probably won't matter for much longer. And yes I know AI is causing even more emissions, but compared to the overall problem that's built up over 200+ years it's basically negligible.

In regards to mass surveillance that was happening well before AI. We all have phones in our pocket that track what we do at all times. You haven't been able to buy a car that doesn't track you for a long while now. Unless you're using cash you purchase things with tracking devices. We ask all of our questions to Google, an international behavioral tracking company. Does AI make that worse? Yep. And people are finally paying attention and getting Flock the hell out of their cities. Hopefully that will go far and people like Facebook, Google, etc. will finally be prosecuted for their decades of crimes against humanity (doubt).

You can say all the things you just said about AI about the internet as well. I can go to anna's archive and steal all the books I want. I can get any movie, piece of software, whatever else that I please. It enabled all the crimes you mentioned and much more. The difference with AI is that it might just be the most important thing since the invention of fire.

reply
If AI data center production continues at pace, you really think that those emissions are going to continue being negligible? Of course it's negligible when you compare a few years to 200 years of industrial revolution.

When you steal a movie from archive.is and watch it what is the result? You stole .00012c from copyrightholders? Are you stopping them from making new movies or taking new revenue streams or setting up your own theatre to profit? no.

When an AI companies steals decades of information, uses it to produce copies, and sells those copies, it is monumentally different.

Aaron Schwartz was supremely aware of class issues in this country, and did not believe meritocracy was real. I sincerely doubt that he would be in support of the upper classes stealing the wealth of information from the lower, and using it to make themselves even more tremendously wealthy while skirting the law. The point of my illustration is that this is a class issue, corporations are viewed as ultra-persons capable of skirting the law all the way to profitability to serve their masters. Meanwhile we are all little peasants that get to watch it happen, but if one of us tries to do the same we will see the inside of a prison cell.

reply