upvote
As someone who has seen many caregivers of elder family – both family members serving as caregivers, and hired caregivers – as well as a caregiver to my spouse with a lifelong physical disability, Gates is so wrong for this. Caregiver burnout and fatigue is a thing. And sometimes it can be exactly these human circumstances that something is missed, or someone is injured – if we had caregiver robots that could serve at peak human caregiver capacity at all times, we should do everything in our power to make them as affordable and accessible as possible.
reply
There are two different things I need from a caregiver.

First is a slave taking care of "things" that I can't - I use slave in the sense nobody would ask anyone they cared about more than a slave to wipe their butt for them. There are a lot of people who cannot wipe themselves (or operate a bidet), and I want a machine to do that task.

Second is a social help. Machines can do that somewhat, but only partially. I think that real humans still remain the best here, but machines still can help - in the same way that having a cat can help but isn't the same as a human.

reply
Plus, personally. When I’m old, if AI and robotics is really good I might truly prefer being taken cared of by a robot that takes gentle care of my crippled body while carrying stimulating conversations and remembering everything I’ve said.

Compared to the, sadly too common, current hellscape of some underpaid and over worked person who comes by and does the bare minimum (if that) in a rush before hurrying off to their next client.

reply
> Plus, personally. When I’m old, if AI and robotics is really good I might truly prefer being taken cared of by a robot that takes gentle care of my crippled body while carrying stimulating conversations and remembering everything I’ve said.

This thought is likely to be revolting to many people, but most of them are going to compare it to a reality that may not exist: They want infinite human caregivers with infinite patience and infinite money to pay those caregivers, but sadly all of those things are finite.

AI and automation are often second-best solutions to some idealized version of reality, but when the idealized version isn’t attainable pragmatic people start accepting the second-best solution. There are a lot of unpragmatic people who will get very angry at the second-best solution for existing, though.

reply
>There are a lot of unpragmatic people who will get very angry at the second-best solution for existing, though.

Part of the reason why so many governments have banned single room occupancy housing (the other part is a selfish desire to not allow “those types” to live nearby).

reply
What are "those types"???
reply
People who can only afford SROs.
reply
Especially as the ratio of elderly to young working age people continues to increase.
reply
I don't find the thought revolting, but I do find it concerning

A society that is willing to leave the care of people in the "hands" of machines seems so uncaring to the point of not caring for people at all. I'm fully expecting that the sort of society that will leave human care up to automation would just as easily run people through furnaces instead. After all, no one cares enough to look after them so why keep them around at all?

> when the idealized version isn’t attainable pragmatic people start accepting the second-best solution. There are a lot of unpragmatic people who will get very angry at the second-best solution for existing, though

If you wanna talk about unpragmatic versus pragmatic, it's clear what the actual pragmatic choice is, isn't it?

reply
The actual pragmatic choice is to do what humans have done for tens or hundreds of thousands of years, and it's that children take care of their parents in old age, rather than insist on some underclass of strangers do it. Whether that stranger is human or machine is kind of irrelevant.
reply
Society has evolved (people don't have enough kids) and people'a life choices too (kids don't want taking care of their parents to be a main purpose in life and parents don't want their kids to want that).

Btw, those who could afford it have always outsourced this. The blessings of the upper class over millenia.

reply
It's unfortunate that it's fashionable these days to not have children and people just assume that someone else's children will look after them when they're old. Now who's looking after those people's parents?! "Looking after" is quite broad - all the way from changing adult diapers to road maintenance.
reply
I don't want my kids changing my adult diapers if I have any choice in the matter. Better a robot or another human I pay.
reply
> The actual pragmatic choice is to do what humans have done for tens or hundreds of thousands of years, and it's that children take care of their parents in old age

This is true in some cultures

In other cultures it was expected that the elderly, infirm, sickly, or crippled would go walk into the woods so they were no longer a burden for the younger generations. Many cultures used to kill children that were born "wrong" too.

I'm just saying it's entirely possible the value of human life is currently going down, not up. I find that very troubling

reply
Maybe we are not taking about the same kind of care: physical vs psychological.

I don't think that many people will have a problem with a robot cleaning wounds, changing bandages, preparing meals because you can't, etc... if it does a good job. Care here is just making sure your wound heals properly. A nurse can also provide psychological care in a way machines can't, but does it have to go together with treating a wound? Some people don't need psychological care, they just need a new bandage, others have a body that needs no intervention but may need psychological care.

reply
I think a lot of people will have big problems with that. What happens when someone with dementia has a wound that needs to be cleaned but they don't have the faculties to consent. Does the robot hold them down and violate their autonomy, or does it phone home and wait for intervention while the person hurts themselves (intentionally or not)?
reply
That's kind of my point. Dementia is a mental disease and that is likely to require human care. A wound only needs a bandage change, a technical operation that is hard for robots. A nurse can do both, but it doesn't mean every patient needs both. Most patients in need of a bandage change have the ability to consent and don't need human care if a robotic bandage changer can do the job well enough. For those who don't, bring the nurse, and because nurses won't have to deal with patients who can use the robot, they can spend more time caring for those who can't.
reply
I feel it is extreme to jump from "people have more things to do than being 24/7 caretakers for multiple adults" (a natural consequence of an aging and shrinking population) to claiming that this means that they would rather put people in furnaces instead.

There's such a massive gap of things in between that are far more sane and likely where things would end up if such robotics actually pan out.

reply
there's a huge difference between caring about people (good) and caring for people (a necessary task but there is nothing virtuous in the task itself, and a lot of it is tedious and unpleasant work that if it could be automated without loss of patient comfort should be)
reply
Perhaps separate the emotional care like having a chat from the physical care like putting them on the toilet and changing their clothes. I think plenty of old people will be happy with a gentle robot doing the physical stuff if they can still hang out with their family.
reply
Yeah I want a Megan fox doll to look after me. Anyone who is saying otherwise hasn’t actually seen their relative in a care home. Fuck that. They just leave them to rot in their own piss and shit. I’d take a robot in a heartbeat.
reply
Absolutely take two steps into a nursing home and your world view will change in an instant. If robots can be used to help give older folks a better life nothing should stand in the way of that.
reply
I did while saying goodbye to my great grandmother. It resembled a psych ward with no rules, with an old lady clinging to the railing screaming into oblivion.
reply
When I was a kid our church used to do events for people at the local nursing homes, it had a pretty broad affect on me as a kid, both seeing how bad things could be but also seeing how a little outreach made the people in that situation happier.
reply
This greatly differs from one location to the next. One of my aunts ended up in a care home and I am very sure that those people both meant well and took fantastic care of her. They even came to the funeral.
reply
Oversimplifiying, it depends on how much you can affor to pay for the service. A low ratio of patients per caregiver is expensive.
reply
The real issue is who controls the technology

For example, you are talking about gentle robots. But who ensures the robot offers gentle care?

Then you contrast it with underpaid and overworked person. Is the system that underpays and overwork human workers the same that will ensure the robots will be gentle?

If we are talking about changing the system (and we should be talking about this): who will do it?

reply
This is a highly implausible dichotomy. If the time and money aren't there to care for you personally, then they aren't there to keep your robot in good working order, either.
reply
Not true. Most people would rather be mechanics looking after robots than in elder care.
reply
I'm not sure if you know how much decent care homes cost? My uncles is running I think over £2k per week. My aunt who needed home nursing was £5k per week. It'll probably be possible to maintain robots for less than that.

And even with that money there's a shortage of Brits willing to wipe old folks arses so they bring in foreign labour to do it.

reply
If my life gets to the point where the only thing willing to have a stimulating conversation with me is a bot, please give me the option for M.A.I.D. instead.
reply
In Japan they have been working on the caregiver robot concept for a while, I haven’t seen anything mature yet.
reply
But the solution to that issue is obviously not more technology. It's requesting society to do what it's supposed to do: taking care of its people, and put the required means into care giving.

It would even be more efficient! Imagine if a 10000th of the money put in AI would go to caregiving? And it wouldn't even be a bubble that risks bursting, eating the pension you'd need to pay for that robot, and it would be at least somewhat useful!

You'll likely need human contact.

reply
Even in societies where social care is relatively well-funded, instances of neglect, abuse and substandard care are rife. This is not a problem that can be solved by throwing more money at human carers.

Providing full-time care for seniors is incredibly demanding, both physically and mentally. There is a limited pool of people with the requisite mindset and aptitude to do it well. Better renumeration, while certainly deserved by those people, won't automatically increase the size of this pool, it may simply attract more ill-suited people to the profession.

And even with the most compassionate and skilled carers, needing to rely on other human beings for your physical needs results in a loss of dignity and independence. It also creates a power imbalance that will always make abuse or neglect a possibility.

Done right, automated care offers the possibility to provide high-quality physical care that is more convenient, private and dignified for the recipient than needing everything to be done by a human. It also allows for that pool of skilled human carers to focus on higher-value support without being spending the majority of the time addressing basic physical needs.

reply
>Imagine if a 10000th of the money put in AI would go to caregiving?

How much do you think we spend on both currently? Total global AI spending was estimated to be about $1.5 trillion by Gartner in 2025. The US alone spends $1 trillion on Medicare, and the home care industry by itself in the US is roughly $300B. And those figures don’t capture the millions of hours family members spend caring for relatives. Globally, spending on care is almost certainly larger than spending on the AI buildout (though perhaps not in some regions like China, which notoriously provides little support for the elderly).

reply
It's obvious you dont understand ai spending or end of life care.
reply
[dead]
reply
I disagree with Bill Gates. If future androids can take care of people in their old age, they absolutely should. I'm hoping this will be the case. I was a caregiver for my grandfather. It can be very stressful. If androids can take care of my future aging family members, that will allow me and younger family members to keep them in our places of residence rather than having to move them to an assisted living facility or nursing home. That is great. There is also the bonus that humans won't have to wipe 100-year-old butts and change diapers.
reply
Yeah, in his essay Gates referred to and thanked the group of caregivers who were looking after his dying father. They almost certainly indeed did do an incredible job and got paid accordingly. It's also nothing like the level of care an average person in a care home will experience.

When robots become reasonably competent, caregiving should be near the top of the list for the type of jobs they should be used for, both for ethical and economic reasons.

reply
What do you think, if anything, should be human reserved then?
reply
Commenting on HN
reply
I would guess care giving is near the very top of the list of jobs that will be difficult to fully automate.

Complex and varied physical skills, understanding and managing human emotions, and broad medical knowledge.

reply
Caregivers used to hang your hand to count heartbeat not so long ago, now they use a device. This is automation and heartbeat check isn’t reserved to human anymore.

Anything labeled with fully, always, everywhere… is very hard to perform. Meanwhile small steps are a where the tastier fruits hangs.

reply
I hope you get to live in the world you strive for, while I get to live in the world I'm building.

No takesies-backsies!

reply
I think taking this "Uh oh, I wouldn't do that if I were you" approach is not a positive way to discuss things.
reply
> But deciding which things won’t be subject to AI hinges on personal preferences, class interests, and even market pressures.

A lot of parallels to the debate on tariffs and free trade: People really don’t like when something new disrupts the work they do. They do like when it disrupts other companies’ (and therefore, other people’s) work and makes the things they need cheaper.

reply
Sadly, if we reserve caregiving to humans, and robots are much cheaper, we might be creating a situation where only the wealthy can afford care outside the family. That pushes the burden of care onto the poor and middle class, as it is right now. Wouldn't we prefer to democratize the spending of quality time with our loved ones and leave the mechanics of care to the robots?
reply
Human reserved jobs for care means if you can afford a human you get no care.
reply
But obviously we have frameworks for collective decisionmaking about which preferences we want to valorize. We often disempower people who have contrary preferences but the weighing of tradeoffs is also integrated into the decisionamking process. Like this is just how governance works isn't it?
reply
currently caregiver is a really complicated and difficult to automate series of things with a lot of randomization and individualization thrown in that is paid very little, it is not worth automating even if it could be, and thus Bill Gates really thinks it should reserved for humans.
reply
>If only it were that simple to define what a job

There's a group of people whose job is precisely to define this both in abstract and in practice, and many do this full time: Judges, labor attorneys, legislators.

>and which jobs are “worthy” or not of being reserved to humans.

That would be legislators, although to be fair they act as proxies for citizens, so it would be literally up to all of us to define that.

Definitely not dreamy, it's down to earth legislative action.

I'd be a bit less dreamy and ask you directly, do you think automated caregiving should be allowed? Because there's a very concrete proposal that you glossed over in order to criticize the abstract argument. Point blank, should machines take care of the elderly? Much simpler discussion.

reply
Actually I don’t see the actual consumers agreeing.

Not even sex is off limits, there will be sexbots. There will be robot boyfriends and bodyguards. Caregivers for sure.

In fact, I can see a lot of parents simply leaving their kids with robots, to be raised by robot nannies — who will have a ton of patience and will have seen millions of cases and know exactly how to handle and motivate your kid better than you and your kid combined.

If the data will show that robots get better outcomes than human parents at raising kids, what do you think a lot of people will do?

reply
The reason this seems like a complex debate topic is the underlying premise requires massive cognitive dissonance and doublespeak to elide the inherent fractal stupidity.

1.) The basis of the world economy is labor. Assuming we take AI industry claims about potential impact of the technology seriously AI threatens this arrangement without offering anything new to replace it. Letting a handful of extra-national businesses threaten the world economy is stupid.

2.) AI improves through access to high quality training data. Using AI internally funnels your company's institutional knowledge, proprietary data, and processes into the training pipeline for the AI tools you use. You are now paying to improve the tools your competitors use and building an existential threat to your business by setting the stage for your AI provider of choice to vertically integrate into your industry segment once sufficient training has been achieved.

3. Letting extra-national organizations operate the computer security equivalent of WMD with no oversight is a ludicrous national security threat.

4. On a warming planet with aging power distribution infrastructure and significant and growing local and regional water availability issues, massive increases to either power or water use is deeply unethical if not outright negligent. Doing both simultaneously solely to profit a handful of investors beggars belief.

5. The financials are fucking unhinged. If investment figures are to be believed the AI industry would have to capture 100% of the economic output of France, or if you prefer Ireland, Belgium, Sweden, Austria, Norway, and Denmark combined. Annually. Just to break even.

reply
> Bill Gates, Chair of the Gates Foundation, made the case for “human reserved jobs”, such as caregivers, that should never be taken by machines

It's also funny that the jobs he's reserving for us involve changing diapers and housekeeping for the elderly, and aren't the jobs people actually want to do - these definitely must go to machines.

Can we reserve mathematics and software engineering jobs for machines and have robots mop the floors instead? I can't think of a way in which that would make the world worse.

reply
What an interesting thing to be on the mind of an older man recently estranged from his family.
reply
Clearly Gates hasn't seen the classic "Roujin-Z" anime.
reply
The road to hell is paved with good intentions and government regulation (mostly the latter).
reply
Can I have Baumol's Cost Disease for $200,000,000,000, Alex?
reply
Obviously it depends on personal preference, class interests and market pressures. However that's true of every single fucking political decision, and we have an imperfect means of coming to those kinds of decisions, called democracy.
reply
This is why we have laws and democratic governments, so people can weigh in on the very important questions you raise.

It’s not perfect, but still better than anything else we’ve tried.

reply
Bill Gates is a terrible person, and no one should give any credence to what he has to say.
reply
[dead]
reply
[flagged]
reply
[dead]
reply