(exitpath-ruddy.vercel.app)
1. Challenging to get running properly.
2. User experience often leaves much to be desired.
It quickly became clear I was better off spending time and energy on problems directly tied to revenue, not managing operational infrastructure from the ground up.
With AI, you can fix any UX issues that bother you with relative low cost.
I've noticed that the transparent/ease of use of scheduling Microsoft Teams/Outlook Meetings in general doesn't translate well to people doing it by hand in Google's ecosystem. If you're creating a Google Meet, that's fine but I notice that people tend to create Zoom meetings and put the meeting URL in the wrong spot, or, the join information isn't something you can easily copy to your clipboard if you want to join manually, or have multiple versions of a meeting software installed.
Even if you somehow manage to train your employees to use strong passwords and password managers, if someone stops working at a company it is a lot to manage deleting user accounts in all the systems one is using.
Microsoft Entra is basically the reasons people still use other Microsoft products. (Same story for Google just much smaller market share.)
Unfortunately, I'm not in any community that actively uses Zulip so haven't had much real experience.
The model of having threads within channels provides great organizational help. But also, these days, if you want to have a "general chat" in a channel that isn't in a thread, you can optionally do that. (I'd recommend not jumping to that just because you're coming from Slack/Discord and not accustomed to threads; give yourself some time to try them. But it can be useful for a subset of channels; some people like it or casual/social channels, for instance. I personally like threads for those too, though.)
Also, the integration and API are easy, and bots and similar are easy to write. You can also arrange to have emails turn into posts on a channel.
Despite what the site says, you don't have to self-host. The software is Open Source, and you absolutely can if you want to. But you can also use the hosted version, either free or paid, and save yourself the trouble, knowing that you can always move to self-hosted later.
I use the app on mobile, but just use the web version on desktop, in a pinned tab.
(Disclaimer: I'm on the board of the Zulip Foundation.)
Overall it's a nice experience and I like how communication is more asynchronous like forums and not as noisy as something like Slack. The UI could be a bit more polished, but it's good enough.
OP: I'd be curious about your personal stack? A bit of your story / motivation here would be interesting, too!
I'm seeing some things pop up where open-source tools are more paradigm-breaking, e.g.
- Ink and Switch's Patchwork[1] is a very malleable[2] piece of software
- Imbue's Studio[3] looks pretty accessible and fun from a user perspective
My theory of change: make open-source more powerful than the closed alternatives, e.g. a single connected database that powers tasks, messages and projects.
-> Connected context wins in the age of agents! Repo here: https://github.com/withnative/native
[1] Very cool demo at Local-First Conf 26: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4UxGijnuXEs
[2] As you'd expect given their Malleable Software essay https://www.inkandswitch.com/essay/malleable-software/
[3] https://imbue.com/product/studio -- I think technically not OSI-approved (BSL or FSL, off the top of my head), but imo still a great thing to check out. Studio is also a bit more 'use your data from within SaaS apps' rather than get out of them, however Imbue also has `datalib` as an export tool: https://github.com/imbue-ai/datalib
I share this sentiment hugely. I found watching the demo so delightful -- a similar feeling to watching a great magician's performance. (It was both the actual demoed tech and also the excellent job their team did in the choreography of it all.)
> it's research-grade and the entire security story is basically non-existent right now; there's no permission management at all. So it's still early days, let's see if it will ever be production-ready.
Yes, I do see this as a challenge as well -- and, to be honest, I think there are adoption challenges for things which have that level of paradigm-shift. Patchwork is probably most fun and thrilling for people who have this creative and playful spirit / muscle for their tools, and I think most people can get to that point of having that spirit... but I also think that the vast majority of people are not yet there. What to you and me might seem incredibly exciting and full of possibilities is perhaps bewildering and confusing to mainstream users.
(But maybe it's enough for a tool to have a passionate niche, and/or maybe that pushes into the mainstream eventually!)
AI helps rather than hurts here too. Exactly why isn’t irc good enough to be your slack? If it really wasn’t before then the distance between actual and desired state is more narrow than ever before. Consequences for Hail corporate are clear, the off ramp is clear, let’s get to it.
Fit: Workable 3/5 Getting data in: Trivial 1/5 Running it: Nothing to host 1/5
All those ratings should follow a LOW=BAD and HIGH=GOOD system. Otherwise it's hard to parse whether any given option is good or not.
Perhaps something that would've been noticed if it wasn't generated entirely by AI.
Just have a look at the venn diagram for the different M365 Enterprise/Business and Office 365 options.
Microsoft 365 Enterprise: https://m365maps.com/files/Microsoft-365-Enterprise-Venn.htm Microsoft 365 Business: https://m365maps.com/files/Microsoft-365-Business-All.htm Office 365: https://m365maps.com/files/Office-365-Enterprise-All.htm
This is the complete opposite of my experience. I set it up a couple of years ago, I have the Android app and the Linux app, several colleagues have the Windows app. The file sync seems to work at least as well as Google Drive or Onedrive.
What problems have you had?
AKA "This is made for how I do things, not how everyone else does things."
I was an early adopter after having used mIRC nearly everyday and found it to be a comfortable place
I’m not really sure what better async-sync range communication tool exists especially because it keeps workplaces entirely separate.
Mattermost is “we have slack at home” and while serviceable way less capable.
Discord is one app with many subgroups, which commingles work and play into one app way too much for my personal tastes.