upvote
It's increasingly looking like AI companies have invented electric motors. Incredibly valuable technology that will be in everything. But nobody ever built a moat around electric motors. At least as to LLMs, AI is a competitive, efficient market where the basic interface is the most plug-and-play, standardized thing imaginable: a text stream. Literally anything that can produce a 9600 bps serial TTY stream is basically interchangeable with Claude, GPT, etc.
reply
The essay "AI will not make you rich" by Jerry Neumann makes a similar point, but uses containers (the shipping kind) as an analogy.

It's well argued and the arguments are worth considering.

https://colossus.com/article/ai-will-not-make-you-rich/

reply
In the long term, sure. But in the short term, it seems like it will make a few people very rich.
reply
Electric motors have few dimensions compared to models.

I think a more apt analogy might be cars. In each segment you have room for more than one company. The prices are roughly the same, so is the quality, but there can be no car that satisfies everyone. There are different „feels” to them.

reply
Neither analogy really works, because of how easily you can switch between models, and there being no "purchase" cost. No one is switching between five different cars a day...,
reply
Probably too dated but I would say ISPs. In the dial up days a trivial payment gave you access to a literal miracle. And the was enough differences in price and performance it really mattered who you chose. But the right choice varied over time, initially changing was easy, but they got good at locking in and suppressing competition; then overnight didn't matter at all.
reply
ISPs in the US still have a physical moat today around their wires. Most places have one, maybe two viable options for high speed internet.
reply
OP said “in the dial up days”. Back then all you needed was a phone line and a number to dial.
reply
I think AI models will end up like Linux VPSes: a standard commodity available from dozens of providers at a variety of price points.
reply
Maybe not five a day, but those https://www.flexcar.com/ people are inundating me with ads on how I can change my car every month (or something; I have no idea how it actuality works).

The analogy is still off even with Flex Car, but not as far.

reply
You’re right the fewer dimensions makes the analogy imperfect.

But this is more about the electric motor market than the electric motor itself maybe.

A transformative technology that I think the foundation labs expected would be a bit easier to build a moat around or hold competitive advantage.

reply
Sure, you can have differentiated products, but it looks like the moat is small. We can expect monopolistic competition. And monopolistic competition predicts normal profit in the long run.

There can be excess profit for awhile but it seems like there's not a sufficient barrier to entry to prevent an eventual race to the bottom.

reply
Not another car analogy please ...
reply
The teletypewriter truly was the greatest invention in human history.
reply
I just finished "The Victorian Internet". The author made a similar observation that the internet might have looked less impressive to someone teleported from the late 19th vs. the mid 20th century.

Because it would basically appear to be a completely predictable development from the continuous incremental improvements made to the telegraph, which had already eliminated the operator and evolved into mechanical proto-computers.

Alexander Graham Bell stumbled on his discovery while working on harmonic telegraphy (at the time the latest hype cycle in new telegraph tech). Inventors were scrambling to find every possible way to further automate and expand telegraph use cases, so if the telephone hadn't been invented, might have led to increasingly complex mechanical computers linked by the telegraph network.

But instead, the telephone dominated the zeitgeist and text interchange suddenly looked like a soon-to-be obsolete stepping stone towards the telephone.

reply
Victorian England had mail delivery to their house a few times a day. So your could send a dinner invite across town and get a response in time to set a place setting for them.
reply
If you're willing to pay for it there are plenty of courier services able to do this today depending on your locale.

I'm still partial to people having pneumatic tubes running their documents across town for them.

reply
Nah; social engineering via shared language wins

Reinforcement of oral and written traditions helped get people to sit still rather than hunt and gather in loose clusters

That said we also went off the deep end with the allegory and lost sight this is generally about species survival not personal acquisition of stuff; rarely has it gone well when the majority are holding the bag in deference to the few.

Feels like due to modern logistics a regular cadence is possible between nomadic (both in terms of bodily agency and free thought) and dogmatic tribal custom/long term nesting.

Dump the Gregorian calendar, rely on physical metrics to track seasons, and live far more async routines yet stick to share desire to keep logistics flowing

Anyway off topic; climbed down this rabbit hole with others recently and coincidentally saw your comment

reply
Compare electric motors to search engines or operating systems, and your analogy will not work for comparisons to Google and Microsoft/Apple respectively. Computing development costs are fairly different from a max triple digit $ BoM predictable hardware assembly in the form of an electric motor.
reply
That may have been true if one or 2 AI companies maintained an effective monopoly on models and it took other players 10+ years to catch up.

Google maintained an effective monopoly on decent search results for most of its existence. The closest second competitor (who isn’t just licensing their results) was bing, and you could still see a “bing vs google” screenshots of how laughably bad bing was up until 2020.

Similar problem with OS market. No one other than Microsoft and Apple (then later Google) had a lead measured in decades not months.

reply
The relevant difference is barriers to competition. Operating systems have compatibility as a major barrier to competition. Search has network effects--more users = more information for making search results more accurate. LLM models have no such barriers.
reply
> LLM models have no such barriers.

compute and amount of training data built on top of XXX B investments is very strong barrier.

reply
For frontier LLMs? Sure. A almost prehistoric datapoint by now: Training costs for GPT-2 levels of "intelligence" fell by 600x over 7 years, as measured by Karpathy in Jan 2026, source https://x.com/karpathy/status/2017703360393318587

If we can extrapolate from that (I don't know if we can), good enough models might be achievable with much less than XXX B investments.

reply
I don't think we can extrapolate evolved complexity. I think frontier labs have many thousands researchers crafting and testing various post-training tuning datasets with impact on end quality, which was not the case in gpt-2 time.
reply
>LLM models have no such barriers.

I think it's much more like cloud, where sure, there aren't any single barriers to buying some servers, putting K8s on it, having an account management/billing system...but in practice the expertise in aggregate to run a profitable one is quite rare.

reply
deleted
reply
I don't know about that. The comparison may make more sense than it seems at first. The whole "war of the currents" was about electric motors at the end of the day, at both the generation and consumption endpoints.

You had a couple of 900-pound gorillas -- Edison (the proto-General Electric, merged by the same JP Morgan whose name is still on the bank) and Westinghouse -- playing the part of OpenAI and Anthropic. Both very valuable long-term players throughout the whole twentieth century.

And both with patent moats a mile wide and deep. We haven't seen that side of things yet, but we will.

reply
Given the progress we have seen in local AI as well this year its quite possible that the bulk of programming needs might soon be entirely met by models that run in a 16GB consumer card as well. They are already remarkably capable of implementing specs and working on PHD level problems at a fraction of the size and cost.
reply
We aren’t going to stop at PhD level work and say “that’s good enough”. If a PhD can run on a consumer laptop, it’s going to look dumb compared to what’s available in a datacenter, and won’t be capable of whatever superhuman work would be the norm in that scenario
reply
PhD levels? Idk, at least in physics and comp sci, before Fable, I wouldn’t call models capable of doing PhD level work.
reply
The models do seem capable of reaching graduate levels. But its very spiky, and typically requires using subagents correctly. Single agent will not usually do it.
reply
I have the same sentiment - while I enjoy using Opus 5.5 and Anthropic models, local AI has seen significant strides. Especially with models like Qwen 4 in the horizon, I could see regular users able to run capable models on 16GB GPUs in the next 1-2 years or even sooner.
reply
This is a viewpoint I've consistently heard and while it's a small sample, I wonder if many folks are silently (or not so silently) thinking it. What is Claude's real moat?
reply
Claude the model has no moat.

Claude the product has a moat.

People build up skills, memories, dashboards, and now documents and wikis in it. It’s getting increasingly sticky in enterprise. They know the model has no moat; now they are using the model to capture corporate workflows that become more difficult to swap out.

reply
It’s pretty easy to tell codex to import and adapt all your Claude skills and memories and vice versa, so I’m not sure how much of a moat all that is until they start making it inaccessible to you.
reply
>I’m not sure how much of a moat all that is

The way I see it is that AI usage is starting to go the way of automobile favoritism. Does it really matter whether someone gets a Ford F-150, a Chevrolet Silverado, or a Dodge Ram? Not really, they're all trucks that can be had in a variety of colors, cab sizes, bed sizes, and engine choices, but you'll find that people can become fanboys of one brand or another for whatever reason, and they generally don't switch unless they experience some colossal failure. I think the same thing is going to happen with AI providers, the favoritism itself is the moat.

reply
I would say its almost like Apple vs Android. Yes, Android could make a phone that could do exactly the same thing. But Apple became "the standard" (at least in America).

Claude is currently doing this -- it is so ubiquitous in corporations that people are building full Claude workflows and harnesses.

Maybe it will be easy to transfer all that to a different LLM, but I think it's also possible that they could end up with a similar Walled Garden as Apple without having a far superior product, per se

reply
Yeah they seem to be chasing a classic integrations and sticky-identity playbook. But it is weird this time because the product itself can trivially recreate or bypass the moat. Phones did not happily and actively unravel their makers’ competitive differentiation when asked to do so by their users.
reply
[flagged]
reply
I think many recognized a while back that their safety and doomerism was (at least partially) a way of trying to create one by baiting governments into regulations they could shape to crystallize their position alongside OpenAI and FAANG.
reply
This is why they are all racing to get app features out to capture people into their moat. In particular, ChatGPT sites and Anthropic Artefacts are both huge traps for businesses that will create a long sticky tail of large subscriptions.

Models have no moat, so they are reverting to the tried and tested enterprise SaaS playbook.

reply
Agreed. What do you think is the path for app developers?

Do we all integrate with chatGPT/Anthropic via MCP and basically become providers of context and data?

Or do we have our own app interface, like SaaS always has had, but with intelligence tightly coupled for the use cases the app is designed for?

reply
But why not buy the initial wave then ditch when (or if) things start to go south?

Because even if that'll happen one day, time is still on their side at least on the mid-term?

reply
> But why not buy the initial wave then ditch when (or if) things start to go south?

Buy the hype, sell when it crashes? Is that what you're suggesting?

reply
Cut him some slack, he used up all his tokens on Fable 5.2 Max.
reply
deleted
reply
And a new Gemini model dropped since your comment lol

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50552424

reply
Sounds like this model release, right before the IPO, had its intended effect.
reply
I bet they release some new models on the day of the IPO
reply
>I was on the fence on jumping into the Anthropic IPO

never do that

reply
Being on the fence seems perfectly safe to me.
reply
much safer to be on the safe side of the fence with nowhere to fall.
reply
deleted
reply