upvote
> “I don’t want any of this.”

Obviously you're entitled with this opinion, but others are entitled with their opinions too. For example, they might want to:

> talk about pricing, profitability, and capability

"I don't want any of this" doesn't really add much to the discussion. I can copy & paste "I don't want any of this" to any HN submission, be it a Nintendo switch emulator, the 1001th javascript framework or yet another Lean-verified math proof of an open math problem.

reply
Nintendo switch/JS Framework/etc don't pose a threat to so many things as AI does. I'm not saying that there aren't upsides to AI but I'm also wondering why are we in this frenzy and rush while totally ignoring absolutely all the downsides..
reply
Thank you for posting this, I share the sentiment and I have been feeling the same way for a while. I had not put words onto it. I understand the urge to talk technical details. I also don't enjoy the lack of critical distance that is required to have educated discussions. Right now, it feels like we are talking about margins while brushing past the broader human cost.
reply
What are you going to do about it? Ban LLMs? Ban new development?

Humanity's strength has always been adaptation. Most people realize that the world they are going into ahead is in for a bumpy, very unclear ride with a shitload of pivots. You don't have a say in of you don't like it or not, people are just trying to keep up and adapt so they don't fall and literally lose their jobs and survival possibility.

reply
Similar approach as with casinos, ethanol, asbestos, tobacco, prostitution, drugs, slavery, labour law abuse, and others. They are not banned, but regulated, because they are proven to have negative impact, often visible only in long run. So there is a middle ground between doing nothing and banning everything. The problem is that politicians are 10+ years behind, and super reactive on problems. Lobbying/corruption also must take its toil. We went through this for example during boom of ad tracking, and the problem was addressed despite a lot of squealing from big techs and the ad industry.
reply
How are you going to regulate intelligence?

When have you gone "too far" with statistics?

Its inherently a different, geopolitical problem than a private health one

reply
We regulate guns, so we can regulate intelligence, because it can be as deadly as gunpowder.

Practically it means people can go to jail if they don't comply with regulations.

reply
You're not answering the questions, how do you define what is too much with intelligence and statistics?

How do you ensure that everyone follows this measure of "too much"? Mass surveillance?

Tobacco, guns and nuclear weapons are not used by the average person to make decisions on which route to take to work

reply
We regulate guns by ensuring that the governments have the biggest guns. Do you want this to happen to intelligence?
reply
Should we unban the development of nuclear weapons then? Somehow I don't think that humanity's strength was adaptation in that regard. We banned a dangerous technology and were better off for it.
reply
1960: ~20,000 nuclear warheads around the world

1967~1970: The Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons was signed into force

1980: ~54,000 nuclear warheads around the world

That was how we "banned" nuclear weapons. When you hear "ban A" you should automatically translate it to "ensure that only a few most powerful entities can have A" in your head.

reply
We didn't ban nuclear weapons, we capitalized on them being extremely difficult to build.

AI doesn't afford us that same luxury of nuclear weapon deterrence.

Bans do don't shit to stop interest parties.

reply
I don't think nuclear weapons were banned out of moral enlightenment... They just have 0 ROI for the private sector, there is no market for them. And they are bulky, difficult to make, and require a bunch of stuff like centrifuges, it's a much simpler task to agree upon. If you instantly got 2bn$ for every detonated nuke, I think the world would look different.

It's different with code and LLMs because there is actually a market for this. It's more like you are trying to ban excel spreadsheets or something. They are already out, a shitload of people use them, and you get outcompeted by countries/companies that don't ban them.

reply
Algorithmic news feeds are all directly competing with Google, Meta, TikTok, X, Reddit, etc. for eyeball time and serving content from publishers who are competing with them for eyeball time (legacy news and print media especially). They'll sell you a lifetime of doom and gloom if you let them

I literally don't see what there is to be upset about with technology like this? This seems like a great new tool for making movies, videogames, training environments for both humans and robots. Imagine a game like Dwarf Fortress or No Man's Sky where the environment is actually realistic. That sounds fun! World models, splats, and AR are going to be what make amazing next generation media possible.

> You can also bring Gemini models into the session as you explore

You can literally implement conversational NPCs or (if not now, soon) embed software/UIs in virtual worlds!

reply
I think HN is actually open to philosophical discussions and tech "negativity" too (if you allow me to call it that).
reply
Agreed. I feel like humanity has not yet figured out how to effectively avoid using (or developing!) harmful technologies. We are quickly reaching the point where the question isn't "can we", but "should we". This applies to a lot more than AI, too.
reply
Not sure if that helps you in any way, but my reaction to all these news is "Does it run on my computer? No? Okay, it doesn't exist".

That helped with a lot of tech trends before AI existed and continues to work quite well.

reply
What do you see as potentially devastating negative consequences of technology like this?
reply
"If I can spoof the nuclear detection system, I can get all the aggressive trigger happy humans to eliminate themselves"
reply
what?
reply
deleted
reply
What are the potentially devastating negative consequences of people being able to create digital worlds?
reply
Escapism to a world so satisfying that reality cannot even hope to compare, and you never want to leave it.
reply
Would that really be so bad?
reply
That is arguably for each individual to decide. It's a massive social experiment, we don't know if that type of escapism is good for society, but... At the moment, if someone wants that and they can afford it, that's their call.

As far as if it's good or bad, my gut feeling is that most forms of escapism become bad quite quickly, and this stands to get very bad, but I don't have evidence to prove that.

Also, I think that generally speaking we should be engaged with reality, but... There are outlying cases where I can understand why people would crave escape, and I wouldn't deny them that. I would want it too. It's complicated.

reply
Having tried it a little, yes.
reply
Ok I understand why World of Warcraft is bad, but what about Genie?
reply
Yes, what are the negative consequences of being able to fake anything? I can only think of several bookshelves of speculative sci fi, and a number of movies, exploring this.
reply
You don't want it, millions don't want it or like it, and yet, it continues. It's a dead-end conversation. I'm not thrilled about it, but it's reality. The cat is not going back in the bag.
reply
> millions don't want it or like it

yup, but 2 billion people use it. As you said, the cat is not going back in the bag. I can't think of any disruptive technology that has ever, effectively, been put back in the bag.

reply
There have been some restraints on many biotech topics, eg. human cloning. Development didn't stop or stall on those areas, but slowed a bit and there were ethical discussions, and are continuing in a not fully wild west style. There is a bit of wild west resurgence recently, but I believe bioethics are still working better than software ethics.

Software would need strong ethical and regulatory guidance, eg. adtech, the whole digital-panopticon surveillance economy, FOMO practices on digital marketplaces (though this is adtech), the addiction inducing psychological tricks in user interfaces, dynamic pricing, and recently AI also. These all are net negative things for society in their current forms despite providing local maxima, and the systems and services which use these could still be useful, ethical, profitable things.

reply
> > millions don't want it or like it

> yup, but 2 billion people use it.

Worth noting that there is, of course, also some overlap between the people who use it and the people who aren't thrilled about it.

For most software developer jobs it is practically malpractice to not use LLMs at this point, but you can both recognize that and also be unhappy with the way their existence has changed the nature of the job and the culture around it.

I use LLMs all the time for work and get undeniable practical benefits out of using them, but have also been in a low-level existential crisis for the better part of a year now because of how they are changing things.

If I could magically wish them out of existence, I would. And before anyone brings it up, that's a very different situation than me just deciding not to use them unilaterally in a world where everyone else is.

But, yeah, I'm not a sorcerer and the cat is not going back in the bag, so this is the reality I have to live in.

reply
deleted
reply
This isn't the same place it was 10 years ago it's been Ship of Theseus'd from a place for hackers to a place for nontechnical managers, spammers, growth marketers, etc. This is appropriate content for them.
reply
> potentially devastating negative consequences of technology like this

Could you say a few words on this?

reply
> little discussion about how the potentially devastating negative consequences of technology like this

You can complain about the sky being blue. What will that accomplish?

reply
deleted
reply
deleted
reply
When I was first starting out all the real programmers were up in arms about Visual Basic allowing idiots to code without understanding what was going on.

This is just another layer of abstraction, as hard as people try to cast it as something more. A powerful lever, but still humans pulling that lever.

The Unabomber's primary point was that every time leverage increases, it takes power and freedom from folks at the bottom. But I think he underestimated how much unhappiness came with plagues and dysentery...

reply
> he underestimated how much unhappiness came with plagues and dysentery...

we just got out of a pandemic which didn't kill as much as the black death but probably caused depression / mental health issues in a large part of the population.

we die less, suffer more because of tech

reply
Suffer more compared to what exactly?

I feel like too many people have near 0 historical perspective. I'm sitting in my house, with hot water and artificial light. I can have my lunch cooked for me and delivered to me with ingredients from around the world and eat it while being entertained by a world class entertainer on a screen in front of me.

Things that maybe only the top 0.01% could do 150 years ago.

It is still an option to go live in the woods somewhere and live where cutting your hand on a rock might be a death sentence.

reply
all that while social media has degraded human interactions, a concerning amount of people can't eat without doom scrolling / watching a tv show / listening to a podcast.

we're not hungry / cold but are more alone than ever.

something something.. homeless crisis.

tech provides comfort, I can argue that maximizing human comfort does not make for a better society and a more meaningful life. I say this while being spoiled all my life with creature comforts you suggest as good but recently I'm starting to doubt the goodness. Nonetheless, put me on a farm and I'd be useless, I'm not proud of this but I believe if I grew up on a farm I'd be much happier and more fulfilled than the 20 years I've spent in front of a screen.

reply
That’s great but some of us don’t want to regress back technologically lol.
reply
You can have modern medicine / agriculture tech / automotive without FAANG.

Are you saying life is better for most people because FAANG exists?

reply
Then everyone in the industry should demonstrate what new plagues they're solving with the new leverage, probably. Cancer would be a good one to start with.
reply
if it would be easy, it would’ve been solved

otoh, no private enterprise can afford to find the cure for cancer

reply
Yeah, cool, so maybe we can redirect the trillions of dollars spent on enshittifying web apps towards solving cancer.
reply
> When I was first starting out all the real programmers were up in arms about Visual Basic allowing idiots to code without understanding what was going on.

Lol. What a dumb analogy. Understandable, given the choice of defending not understanding what's going on.

reply
deleted
reply
”Potentially devastating negative consequences of technology like this” has been said about everything from television to the internet, not sure how that attitude would be any more hacker coded
reply
> A lot of talk about pricing, profitability, and capability,

OH NO!

Not on my venture capital backed discussion board for tech startups!

Is it really a surprise?

reply
(Shrug) We already have one Reddit. We don't need two.
reply
Which is crazy, because reddit also used to be free from this kind of fearmongering and general hissing about The Consequences:tm:
reply
1. There's a million discussions like this here.

2. Other people want things. The measuring stick of whether a product is useful isn't just whether you'd use it. When I don't want something I mostly just don't click.

reply
What negative consequences? Everyone out of a job? Human thoughts and feelings aren’t “sacred”? Who cares. Bring on the future. Get excited for it. I want robots to do everything. Can’t wait for physical LLMs to do to the physical world what LLMs did to the online one.
reply
> I want robots to do everything

Sure, then your existence is not necessary anymore.

reply
Your existence was/is never "necessary", it's up to you to find and tend a path you find fulfilling.
reply
deleted
reply
deleted
reply
And what will you do? And why would the robots or whomever controls them think you're worth keeping around?
reply
Who cares, I’ll take the future when it comes. If everyone is out of a job we’ll figure out a way, or we won’t. Either way, I am pumped for this.

Can you imagine a future where you can have a group of 50 robots and you can say clear this land and build a hospital here and they just do it. We can see that in our lifetime if we don’t mess it up.

reply
> Can you imagine a future where you can have a group of 50 robots and you can say clear this land and build a hospital here and they just do it.

I can imagine that.

I can also imagine that you won't be seen at that hospital unless you are very wealthy. The hospital you are imagining is far more likely to be built next to Peter Thiel's or Elon Musk's bunker than it is in a regular community.

In the really real world (in the United States, anyway) for the past 16 years we've been, on net, significantly reducing the number of hospitals we have, not expanding or maintaining them, largely as a result of increasingly pulling healthcare access away from those who aren't wealthy.

Having hospital-building robots isn't going to change the socioeconomics of this in a positive direction. It is almost certainly going to get much worse as more and more people are seen as economically unvaluable and wealth concentration gets even more lopsided than it already is.

reply
> or we won’t. Either way, I am pumped for this.

I'm an optimist that we'll figure our way out, but I don't think it makes sense to be "pumped" for the "we won't" if that happens.

reply
deleted
reply
Not a student of history I see
reply
And that’s somehow different from today - are you necessary now? Someone decided to keep you around for now, to do something for them, that you won’t be needed to do tomorrow? I don’t think that’s how it works or will work.
reply
[dead]
reply
Welcome to HN, where everyone is running 69 agents 24/7 babysitting each other, when they wake up they look up 34 startups these agents created (all with fancy landing pages and full SaaS microservice infrastructures deployed on serverless) and they decide the next steps from their bed, talking to Claude on their phone.

While most of the world uses AI not even knowing it is AI, because they type stuff into Google search and it spits out the answer, just like it always did (right?).

HN bubble is real. And it's fun :)

reply
[flagged]
reply
actually youre wrong, ive already decided you are part of the problem
reply
What value does recognizing something as potentially harmful have other than posturing on discussion boards?
reply
being a dismissive asshole is being part of the solution?
reply