upvote
In the UK this was litigated more than two decades ago. A vendor of PlayStation modchips was sued by Sony and lost. He claimed that his purpose was to allow the use of lawful game backups. Sony claimed that backups were unnecessary because they would replace any disk that developed a fault! This was a flat lie. They won the case though.

On the other hand, an Australian court ruled the other way, as did the Italians.

[1]: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/technology/3915179.stm

[2]: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/technology/4315172.stm

reply
UK law is frighteningly inconsistent in this regard, hiding behind the 2001 EU Copyright Directive being shoe-horned badly into their existing legislation (CPDA 1988)

You cite the Messiah case from 2002 involving David Ball being fairly spurious legally. The knife cuts both ways in this regard.

The Mr.Modchips conviction in 2008 was quashed in the Court of Appeal with the ruling that prosecutors failed to prove that playing a pirated game on a modified Xbox or Nintendo console involved copying a "substantial part" of a copyrighted work into the console's memory.

https://www.casemine.com/judgement/uk/5b46f2042c94e0775e7f05...

R v. Gilham (2009) then closed the loophole with an even more controversial interpretation of the "little and often" principle, ruling that even though a console's RAM only holds tiny fragments of a game's graphics and audio at any single millisecond, playing a game continuously creates transient copies that collectively infringe copyright.

Unfortunately they've gone full Nuclear since Brexit, with the last draconian ruling mandating blocks at ISP level for websites distributing RCM loaders and custom firmware tools for the Nintendo Switch. As such it is fairly clear-cut atm that hardware circumvention devices have no valid defense under UK law.

https://www.eurogamer.net/nintendo-wins-uk-high-court-case-t...

I would be quick to contend, however, that this is more a reflection on UK Society and Culture as a whole rather than a bellwether for the appetites regarding consumer protections globally.

reply
Our legal system was once lauded because it is not (directly) corrupt, relatively apolitical (compared to, say, replacing a US Supreme Court Judge) and sometimes logical to the point of hilarity (see my favourite case about poppadoms here – [0])

Unfortunately, when it comes to anything technological, I have no doubt whatsoever that the richer litigant wins. IP law is insanely draconian, exists entirely to mandate rent seeking and is often touted by politicians as "supporting starving artists" and "protecting Britain's great culture and soft power" when, in reality, the artists are starving because of a combination of corporate greed and Arts Council cuts and punishing homebrew serves to, if anything, stifle innovation. Heck, it's almost time to cite the EU's study on piracy in the EU that showed it increased spending on digital media -- “The complementary effect of online streaming is found to be somewhat larger, suggesting a stimulating effect of this activity on the sales of digital music” [1] on an n=16,000 population...

[0] https://www.ft.com/content/3a64f96e-3214-48ba-9da4-76b3fb7ab... [1] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S016762451...

reply
Can't argue with any assertion there. The only thing I'd add is that this is all part of a holistic roadmap for UK Technological use going forward at the explicit expense of consumer rights and privacy.

The likes of Ian Hislop and The Guardian Trust are the last bastion of defense against this stuff even getting coverage in the era of the Super-Injunction.

It's a wholly predictable outcome that the UK will soon start chilling-effects on coverage of other technological consumer advocacy at the expense of MNC profit-lines on the basis of spurious National Security or Child Safety concerns. Indeed, the whole concept and ethos of the Internet to date is slowly being transmogrified into an ersatz-AOL by successive Tory governments.

Hacker culture as a whole is the panacea. As a result, this is their focus.

Edit: Time to get AI to do some topical updates to "Yes, Minister". Same as it ever was.

Edit 2: Since I posted this the UK Government has admitted it issued Apple secret orders under Section 253 of the Investigatory Powers Act 2016, which gives the UK government powers to require technology companies to make changes to their services to facilitate the exercise of investigatory powers. In short, they've backdoored iCloud to malfeasant nation-state actors.

reply
>This was a flat lie

Absolutely.

But so is

> his purpose was to allow the use of lawful game backups.

There can't be a real conversation about this if we're going to pretend one of these is the truth.

reply
I can definitely see it being true, though? Especially nowadays where buying a game is just renting, I actively seek ways to make sure I can keep what I bought. It does not seem far-fetched to me.

Most people I know of who use these devices simply mod games they already paid for. I don't suspect that's the truth you're alluding to.

reply
Sure you could do those things with a mod chip, and I’m sure there is someone doing that, but it’s not like it was a mystery what mod chips were for. There was a whole industry selling pirated games and the same people selling the games would modify your console for a fee.
reply
It's equally not a mystery what a significant amount of needle syringes sold in retail end up being used for. What's your point?

I have and will continue to pay extra to have backups of the games I paid for and own that leaches like nintendo and sony can't control. Legitimate use for this product is a well-established fact that neither those leaches or you get to dismiss.

reply
> What's your point?

I read the argument thus: if something that has a general use in theory but in practice is more often used for nefarious purposes, then that item is to be evaluated as not general purpose but for the specific thing it’s most commonly used for.

It’s quite the slippery slope, in my view.

reply
So in your opinion we should ban needles? What about ski masks? Crow bars? Pawnshops?

No no, I don't think this is going far enough. Let's just ban cash entirely. A good portion of cash is used for the trade of illicit goods and most of it is covered with traces of drugs. Wait! Most of the Internet's traffic was porn until Netflix changed that. Dang it! We missed an opportunity to ban the internet.

Are you really fine with living in a world like that?

reply
Oh I’m in agreement with you, I was just explaining how I understood GP’s thought process
reply
The example in the video is not game backups, its backups of game save files.
reply
Is it a coincidence that backing up your saves is a cloud-based feature that the console vendors charge money for?
reply
"felony contempt of business model"
reply
True but the point of lawyers is never to present a balanced view. That's the judge's job and when it's close to middle he just has to decide one way based on who made the better case. That doesn't make it a truth, it makes it a ruling.
reply
On the other hand now it's 2026, it's true that I need a backup to play my PS2 games due to the failing disc drive.

And Song won't replace the disc. Infact Sony doesn't want you to even use discs citing some of the very same problems that they argued against.

The backup argument has become stronger, Sony's lie has become more obvious.

reply
Really? I never owned a playstation, but multiple Gamecube games disc failed on me. I would have loved to be able to create backups.
reply
The mod chip was capable of making backups, Sony would never replace a scratched disc. Seems like one of them is more true than the other.
reply
The situation wasn't a "conversation" though. It was a court case. The article doesn't mention either of these statements, so we don't have further context. That said, it is disingenuous to dismiss these comments like this.

If Sony's defense was focused around replacing discs and they never did, that just bolsters the legitimate need for a product such as one that can play backups.

reply
[flagged]
reply
> Well this is going to be the big question going forward with all Hardware Manufacturers.

It's an ongoing part of "right to repair". Hardware manufacturers are increasingly looking into ways to extract more money and with the slowdown in performance and increase in hardware costs that means they are looking elsewhere.

These companies are almost certainly thinking of and looking towards planned obsolescence as the mechanism to force their customers to repurchase new hardware barely different from the old hardware. Sony shutting down the PS3 store is going to be the move for others.

End users hacking their hardware and making the software they purchased still usable after the obsolescence period cuts right into those plans.

reply
Does right to repair include language stating private property ownership?

All these subscriptions and lock outs for modification feel more like a lease and less like ownership.

reply
I am a simple person. Once I bought a system, it is mine. I'll do whatever the hell I want with it, including storing it in a box, modding it, putting stickers on it, throwing it in the bin or running whatever software I wish.

Problem is online services, IMHO. A device is not just a device anymore. It is a device + online shop + secure online gaming infrastructure. If you use the device to unlawfully access copyrighted content, and you don't have an army on your payroll, it does not matter if you "agree" with copyright law. With picofly, I can run the homebrew launcher and stream my PC games. I can also download the games and install and run them.

The old tired knife metaphor is apt here: a knife can cut through a tomato, a home invader or that nosy neighbor who keeps overstepping. Where do we draw the line? Intention?

reply
I hold out hope for this being the way in which freedom and copyright protection are legally considered. Because if I can't play with the hardware I bought, to your point, it's not mine. And I think it should be judged in each case by intention, otherwise we've given up too much freedom to business interests merely for the sake of entertainment products.
reply
TTL;DR GitHub too many DMCA. No scrutiny before turn off. Nintendo bad. Take advantage.

TL;DR It’s a broken system, further broken by companies trying to make it cheaper to handle such requests. The end result is a lot of false positives. Lawyers at Nintendo know this, and will try their luck as far as it’ll go. Even when something like this might not actually hold in the court of law (after all it’s unlikely for any indie project to sue back).

You’ve got to understand, the people flipping the switch on and off aren’t students of the law[1].

My guess is the buck was passed to a bunch of incompetent folks. They saw the repo has a low number of stars and doesn’t belong to a company, figured there was a low risk of blowback, and concluded there was no need to escalate to actual competent folks (aka in-house counsel).

They may have had a playbook, but when it comes to moderation, a lot is left to how the individual interprets the rules. The real scrutiny on their end would happen now if enough of us complain about this.

[1] AI music company claims copyright over musician's own recording, gets her YouTube video removed - https://www.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/1xyi3bu/ai_musi...

reply
It kind of blows my mind that we've had a decentralized means of distributing content for 25 years now, yet we still rely on github to host these sorts of repos. I don't know why folks working on projects like this don't host a tgz of their source code as a torrent with every release. Pretty sure the dmca doesn't apply globally.
reply
Because even less people would download it?

Right now whoever cares has a clone of the repo locally and can just push elsewhere. It is decentralized.

reply
That sounds alike something even less people would do.

Though, is there anything like a peer to peer distributed floating global repository? The repo is in the peer to peer network and git uses that as a remote? Could something like that work?

reply
Git does have to use a server at some point.

But there seems to be two main candidates:

https://radicle.network/ which is a true federated git forge, where issues and PRs live inside the repo

https://tangled.org/ which is basically GitHub but built on top of ATProto (so the social features, global repo search and so on works) , so it's interoperable with any ATProto thing, and git hosting is delegated to a "knot" where you can use your own or a public one.

I'll admit I don't know much about radicle but I've heard about it a lot.

Though I personally prefer tangled because they managed to get back the GitHub social features but in a decentralized and interoperable way

reply
DMCA needs large penalties for removing content that does not infringe, awarded to the victim. That would solve things in a hurry.
reply
I agree.
reply
We need to close the roads. All roads. They allow criminals to rob banks and drive off with the stash, using roads.
reply
> We need to close the roads. All roads. They allow criminals to rob banks and drive off with the stash, using roads.

Holland is almost cashless.. What about closing down the internet cause crypto heists occur?

reply
At first they came for the €500 note... I said nothing because I didn't use it...
reply
The DMCA has always been weaponized as "felony contempt against business model".

Its also why for anything that interacts with a system that MIGHT be called a bypass, to host it on Gitflic.ru and tell them all to fuck right off.

reply
I mean part of it is the accountability-hammer that the DMCA has given bad Corporate actors.

140+ Repos are pulled under Safe Harbour justification based on an unchallenged accusation. Github only reinstated youtube-dl after the EFF did some basic due diligence. The Github Developer Defense Fund to help open-source developers respond to unwarranted DMCA Section 1201 claims is a paltry $1 million.

Ryan Daly tried to defend himself in the MIG-Switch case and ended up settling for $2 million. The Yuzu devs ended up settling for $2.4 million.

The 9th Circuit (which github falls under) reversed previous decisions and said any circumvention - even for lawful purposes - is illegal regardless of copyright infringement. This would suggest that the presence of ANY copyrighted code on ANY physical product automatically grants the weaponisation of copyright law to deny aftermarket repair or any other use-cases of actual ownership.

The scarier question then becomes - when will Intel or Broadcom or Nvidia start suing people for unlocking their hardware?

reply
You're defending my own point: going against a multi-billion dollar company legally speaking is a losing endeavor, even if you somehow win.

Hosting the repo either in China or Russia, outside of the US's sphere of DMCA-like laws is the proper play here. Of course, use some random name as well that's only used on those repos.

The law is absolutely wrong, and should NOT be respected.

reply
I'm not arguing, merely expanding the context for people catching up.

You can safely assume you're preaching to the choir on these matters with Hacker News.

Your position, however, doesn't represent an inviolable workaround.

Even if a foreign host ignores a DMCA notice, a copyright owner can still pursue infringement claims directly against a US developer in the US, or pursue it on similar local copyright laws in the host's country.

As explicitly related to this case, 17 U.S.C. § 1201 legislates that it is illegal to manufacture, offer to the public, provide, or otherwise traffic in circumvention tools. Writing the code, maintaining the repository, or uploading it from a computer inside the United States constitutes domestic conduct, giving U.S. courts jurisdiction regardless of where the remote server sits.

reply
> As explicitly related to this case, 17 U.S.C. § 1201 legislates that it is illegal to manufacture, offer to the public, provide, or otherwise traffic in circumvention tools. Writing the code, maintaining the repository, or uploading it from a computer inside the United States constitutes domestic conduct, giving U.S. courts jurisdiction regardless of where the remote server sits.

One day someone will be brave enough and sufficiently monetarily-endowed to fight this on 1st amendment grounds, where it should easily fall... Code is speech and we should all practice our freedom to speak.

reply
I think that trying to deny Section 1201 covers this is almost obstinate.

Does anyone actually think that a mod chip for a DVD player allowing disc dumping would be exempt under the DMCA? DVD circumvention was basically the entire reason we have Section 1201 to begin with! There's also the aspect the statute does not differentiate, in any way, between software methods versus hardware methods for circumventing access controls.

(You may have never read the fine print, but VLC has always had a warning to US users saying their DVD decryption is probably a violation.)

reply
This is just another illustration of how DMCA is legal overreach. Copyright was meant to protect authors from unscrupulous publishers who would steal authors' work on an industrial scale.

Why does this matter? Because it's the state putting muscle behind authors who would otherwise be exploited. It wasn't meant to put muscle behind already aggressively litigious publishers by criminalizing the activity of individuals. DMCA is a perversion of rights. It reaches into the activities of individuals and criminalizes them.

reply