upvote
The most difficult part about making iron gall ink is crushing the oak apples enough to where you can extract the acids. The “folk science” of iron gall ink is backed up by later scientific analysis. The original rich black color does fade to a beautiful brown, and should only be used on parchment or vellum, as the gallic and tannic acids are not archival on cellulose paper.

Most botanical dyes are, as you have found, not lightfast and will fade quickly. The simplest and most lightfast organic ink simply uses lampblack (fine soot) and gum arabic which is simple to mix, but making it yourself requires collecting and scraping fine soot. I just use Chinese ink sticks.

Stone? Do you mean mineral pigments? By my lights, once you start grinding and mulling mineral pigments and mixing them with gum to write with, you’re working with watercolor paints, not inks, and sourcing mineral rocks and grinding pigments from them rather than getting them pre-ground as I do sounds more tedious than making organic lampblack ink.

reply
> By my lights, once you start grinding and mulling mineral pigments and mixing them with gum to write with, you’re working with watercolor paints, not inks, and sourcing mineral rocks and grinding pigments from them rather than getting them pre-ground as I do sounds more tedious than making organic lampblack ink.

The problem with getting them pre-ground is that for many pigments particle size has a significant effect on the final product. Commercial pigments are great for quality control, less so for “character” and variability which matters a lot if the pigment has interesting optical properties.

That said I collect various historically and technically interesting pigments for mulling my own oil paint, and I have no idea how much that matters for writing ink.

reply
It’s almost silly how simple lamp black is to make, like literally it’s just soot which you can pretty much find everywhere

And yes mineral pigments is what I’m talking about, Finely ground minerals mostly

reply
In my Japanese class every Thursday was calligraphy day. Calligraphy day began with half an hour of grinding solid India ink on the inkstone. I never made the inkstick myself, but Wikipedia makes it sound pretty easy: it's soot and animal glue, and I accidentally make animal glue regularly by cooking meat too long. Chicken, usually.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inkstick

Admittedly, I didn't kill the chickens myself.

reply
If you're into inkmaking from local materials, I recommend "Make Ink: A Forager's Guide to Natural Inkmaking" by Jason Logan. He's fairly relaxed about consistency and longevity and treats it more as an art, but he also operates a side business selling his foraged inks, so at least some are reasonably self-stable.

Lots of great pictures of colorful inks in that book.

He also wrote a version of the book aimed at kids, but it's not as good as "Make Ink" IMHO. Blue copper oxide ink does make a good project for kids who are old enough to understand it's toxic and shouldn't be used with fine pens.

reply
Very cool recommendation I’ll check it out thanks.
reply