upvote
Why not? Whenever you need to enumerate arbitrary many cases you can make it arbitrary long.

Few people would consider it a beautiful proof though.

reply
I like the idea that the universe isn’t necessarily beautiful and orderly, because my life has seldom been orderly. “Imagine a spherical cow” is fine? But there are no spherical cows.

The assumption that the universe is orderly, has beautiful laws, and doesn’t have potentially one-off events or rules is a religion.

I have had this thought experiment for decades. “Imagine that once every 1.2 million years a grand piano spawns approximately four miles from the city center of modern day Phoenix. That’s just the rule. That’s a law of the universe.” There would be no way to measure this because if it happens to happen during our time it would just be a weird event that nobody could explain and we would have to wait another 1.2m years to see it again. Ain’t nobody got time for that? So all of our explanations for this would be wrong and would never be able to explain this or predict the long term future of the universe because hypothetically our universe would be dominated by the mass of these grand pianos eventually. Maybe beings then could piece together what had happened then? But likely not. They’d be just as baffled as we are.

Parsimony makes sense to us, because we’re simple creatures that live in finite time with finite senses. There’s no reason that nature should favor simplicity over complexity other than our own biases.

reply
> There’s no reason that nature should favor simplicity over complexity other than our own biases.

No reason? Isn't the fruitfulness of this so far itself a very good reason? We've taken this approach and successfully explained and predicted so much of the universe already. How is that not a reason to keep going?

reply
Now did I say we shouldn’t keep going?

I’m just saying that the universe is under no constraints to be understandable to humans, and our human limits might impose limitations on what we can model.

reply
You called it a religion, and the main thrust of the response was that the fruitfulness thus far was a reason to not consider it a religion, but rather a rational course of action. It seems you got hung up on the phrase “keep going”.
reply
I don’t necessarily agree with you, bur I really enjoyed reading that.
reply
Well, I appreciate it. In your defense, I'm not sure that I entirely agree with this take either? But I think it's important to consider that we may not be clever enough to tackle all problems.

Like, my dog is pretty clever, she's a good dog too! She can roll-over and shake, and after much work I can get her to "stay" for a limited period of time. She's a good dog.

She's not smart enough to do calculus I don't think, and even if maybe she is physically smart enough to do calculus there's no way I could communicate the concepts to her. So... what's like that for us humans? What's like that for our experience of the universe? Like, I can look at a spreadsheet, and do some math on various columns in a dataset. I can do the SVD here or there.

But... I cannot really intuitively understand something in... say, 30 dimensions. The best I can really do when I feel really clever and think really hard, is maybe 4 or 5 if I'm being generous as to what I consider a "dimension." If I do something like say, "ok, picture a cube, and then visualize the heat on the cube as a color scheme, there's a burner below the cube." That's "kind of" like visualizing 4-d, and maybe I can add some roughness to cube too, to add another dimension to the data.

But that's the best I can do and the temperature is not even a spatial dimension . Meanwhile, it's not uncommon for like 10 dimensions to be useful in a dataset for prediction of some value - maybe even more. So, what are we not smart enough to understand? What are we simply too dumb to truly get? What will we never be able to understand unaugmented? And maybe parsimony and the "unusual effectiveness of mathematics" or whatever is that? But maybe... math isn't unusually effective, maybe the universe is substantially more complex than we can even comprehend? And our simple first order approximations are useful, but miss massive amounts of the underlying geometry/structure/system that makes up reality?

I guess, that's kind of the Donald Hoffman take on it right? This is the interface, but our interface kind of sucks.

reply
reply
Man, I wish my dog could take the derivative of a polynomial! All mine can do is count one treat or two treats!
reply
This is roughly the position of Charles Fort in the late 1800’s when he started collecting reports and compiled them into his "Book of the Damned", suggesting that there’s lots of your pianos happening - rains of frogs, teleportation, clairvoyance, etc - and scientists discount them as valid evidence because they would ruin nice clean simple theories. i.e. scientists pick and choose the evidence that lets them conclude a simple theory.

This gave rise to the term 'Forteana' for unexplained happenings, and The Fortean Times magazine. I think this stuff likely felt more plausible in the 1880’s before much understanding of electric fields making hair stand on end, drafts and flickering oil lamps being common, before atomic theory and the electromagnetic spectrum and radioactivity and thermodynamics when there were still a lot of big unexplained things around, before tape recorders, point-n-shoot cameras, then smartphones, were invented.

The ubiquity of smartphones on Earth selling at a billion a year and still no convincing recordings of Bigfoot, ghosts, UFOs, force fields, teleportation, is evidence indicating absence despite the saying “absence of evidence is not evidence of absence”. If you aren’t warm, that is some evidence that there’s no fire. If we had a lot of independent witnesses and videos of your piano appearing we would still lean towards it being a magic trick, hoax, CGI, because we have agreed that you can’t create energy and can’t teleport therefore it didn’t happen as it appears.

I haven't read Carl Sagan's Demon Haunted World but I think it's a counter position, look at all the nonsense humans have believed over history and still do believe today, and about the only way we can divine the real from the nonsense is repeatable tests - "science as a candle in the dark".

reply
But then Occams's Razor is no longer a guiding principle, which is fine, because the Universe has no obligation to be simple.

Also, claiming a teapot orbits does not put the burden of proof on the claimant, because, again the idea that the one making an extraordinary claim MUST offer extraordinary evidence is just that, what we think is a nice approach to take. Truth does not care who has the burden of proof.

That's why miracles are not to be brushed off; maybe you just never saw one. Maybe they only occur under some weird circumstance the vast majority of people do not experience. Not say there is material proof of them, but mostly the objection to them is based on politics and adherence to the religion of "we have the universe all figure out" We could be living in a simulation, and "miracles" are a bypass of the simulated reality.

reply
Hey, I'm a fan of Occam, but.... I recognize that maybe, kind of sort of... what if we're at the limits of what can be described by Occam? Or similarly, what if like, we can make crappy models that are parsimonious and accurate models that are not. What if the universe is parsimonious when you don't look very close and extremely chaotic and weird and inconsistent when you do? That would surely track much of my lived experience?

But who knows? I'm surprised most days that there's something rather than nothing, that I exist at all (it's quite strange to be anything at all), and that math and computers work. I'm quite glad they do? But yeah, things seem pretty damn miraculous to me most days.

reply
There are many things I don't know, but this much I do know: There aren't any teapots orbiting the sun deep in interplanetary space.

How do I know? Very simply. There's overwhelming evidence against the idea and no evidence for it.

reply
You don’t know that. You believe it - and to be fair, I believe it too - but you don’t know it.

The parsimonious answer feels good to us, and I think mostly it bears fruit - but there’s no guarantee that parsimony is the only way to model things accurately

reply
This gets into what the word know even means. Nothing's guaranteed. I know it as much as one can know anything.
reply
It takes thousands of hours of study for a human to get to the point of understanding what the RH says and means. It isn’t hard to imagine that there are mathematical truths that require far more than this to understand them.

Pretty much every major result in mathematics - assuming ZFC as the background theory - requires thousands and thousands of pages to formally prove from the axioms of set theory.

reply
An infinite number of math proofs really need more than 15M to write out. Could that include some easy-to-state ones that we care a lot about? Yeah probably.
reply
What do you think the upper limit on the size of a math proof is?
reply
Not sure why you got downvoted but this is actually quite deep. I guess it depends on the mass of the universe. Since our universe is approximately a black hole, its mass determines its area and the number of bits it can store on the surface through the holographic principle. If the universe is not infinite there is a physical limit to math.
reply
A finite universe does not imply a finite limit to the size of proofs of true statements.

There are proofs that might not be capable of being written down in the material universe, even if we assume a plank volume per symbol. They would exist nevertheless.

reply
I guess the upper bound is the the amount of information in the universe. That seems to be about 10^80 bits.

https://www.sciencealert.com/physicists-quantified-the-amoun...

reply
tbh i was the student in undergrad maths classes using induction to prove trivialities bc nobody handed me a “book of axioms” and my intro to writing proofs was using Coq. let’s cut some slack to our autistic LLMs — I am sure in six months we will know how confident we are in this proof; no need to rush.
reply
Do you NEED 15M lines? No, it's almost certain this proof can and will be reduced, but the goal of an initial proof of a theorem like this isn't conciseness, it's to actually... prove the theorem.

Fermat's Last Theorem was initially proven in Lean in September and that proof required 13M lines, it has since been reduced to 2M lines and it will likely be reduced even further. Anthropic claims they can reduce it down to less than half a million lines by doing similar techniques to what software developers do... find common and reusable snippets and factor them out instead of repeatedly proving similar sub-theorems over and over again. There are also opportunities to replace lengthy sequences of explicit reasoning with automated tactics, reuse existing mathematical libraries including the Lean standard library, and reformulate arguments at a higher level of abstraction.

reply