upvote
Would you have been equally de-motivated if a human would have solved it? If no, why? because if it was a human you would have though "the fields is being pushed forward by humans, and I am one myself, so maybe I'll also manage to push it forward"? If that's the reason, would have you been equally de-motivated if it was solved by a human that demonstrated intellectual abilities far superior to yours since birth, hinting at a genetic advantage you don't have? (genuine questions)
reply
> If that's the reason

It's NOT the reason. I simply don't see why people would even think that. If a human had solved it, I would have liked it because it's part of a nice community of people solving things by themselves, showing off their passions. I like that community feel.

If human beings do things, I enjoy them even if have no hope of doing them, because in totality it creates a community. One highly exceptional person does not change that. An entire army of machines is soulless and does change that.

reply
> I like that community feel.

Then was math the right thing to go into? Perhaps local governance. Or volunteering at the local community center?

Mathematics is for finding truths. How does it matter how the truths are discovered.

reply
Are you a mathemetician?

Like philosophy or computer science, mathematics is historically about discovering elegance hidden in abstract forms. It's an aesthetic art with some occassional practical applications.

These recent AI Lean proofs are anything but elegant. They're simply functional, which is fine for where practical impact is what matters, but for many practicing mathemeticians, that was an aside, not the point.

Inasmuch the modern era is characterized by the brutal boring commodification, they represent mathematics finally succumbing as well.

reply
> discovering elegance hidden in abstract forms.

That's highly subjective. An equalatorial⁰ triangle for example is just a triangle with all sides equal, whether drawn by a human or machine, with a pen on paper or with a mouse in a paint application. I'm in both computer science and philosophy, and I can't really think of anything "elegant" about either. The former is primarily about empirical research for advancing computation, and the latter primarily seeking truth through rational thought (for me). It's a lot of fun, but... shrugs

⁰ Totally forgot the word as I haven't encountered/thought it since high school.

reply
If that is your view then the problem is still "open", you can still find an elegant version
reply
Mathematics used to be about a community of mathematicians. It wasn't solely based on finding truths. It operated in practice as a community. Now that is falling apart. Before AI came along, it was very different than now. That's of course when I decided to get a PhD. I've actually been in that world and it was a pretty nice community. Not now.
reply
> Mathematics used to be about a community of mathematicians

Politely, that's your view. Community is of course part of every occupation, but it's not the reason for the occupation. For something as pure as math, it's simply the discovery of truth that's the core.

I urge you to take some time for reflection. These are trying times, but your feelings are targeting the wrong thing, in my opinion.

reply
I've taken a lot of time for reflection. This is not a knee-jerk reaction. I've read books and studied the opinions and ideas of philosophers over time. This believe is core for me and I disagree with you completely.
reply
yeah dude just let me volunteer at the local community center to pay my bills. that will give me the same feeling as discovering previously unknown facts about the universe. Some of us actually want to accomplish things.
reply
Ok, thank you. Just to clarify even more, is more important to you the "community" aspect or the "human" one? E.g. if math was mainly driven by alone geniuses, Perelman-like, proving theorems by their own in isolation, would it be equally disappointing?
reply
I think they are somewhat connected, in practice. But to answer your question directly: I think it's also unhealthy if math would just be a collection of hundreds of geniuses working in isolation, never talking to each other.

I wouldn't say __equally__ disappointing because I don't think your scenario can ever reach the level of LLM use, but it would also be disappointing. The loss of community is key but the addition of using unsustainable machines to do so adds insult to injury.

reply
"Concordantly, while your first question may be the most pertinent, you may or may not realize it is also the most irrelevant."

- The Architect

reply
Haha, I didn't even realize that what I said was similar to that scene. Rather chilling and freaky...gives me goosebumps!
reply
That would be true if math had no utility.
reply
I think you're succumbing to a vast simplification or false dichotomy. Math does have utility but the most advanced math hardly does, which is the same thing that motivates mathematicians to get degrees and participate. Don't fool yourself into thinking that modern math research does anything much except motivate mathematicians to do the other parts of the job much less fun like teaching.
reply
I think the history of math shows that things that were only of theoretical interest ended up having utility. Lobachevsky and Bolyai's work, for instance. In other cases, math developed for a single problem has had utility far beyond what it was developed for. Complex numbers are an example. That math was advanced for its time.
reply
If you examine history also, you'll see that the proportion of results that end up being useful are also diminishing. I seriously doubt modern math will be useful compared to ancient stuff like complex numbers.
reply
That could be the case. It would be kind of sad though.
reply
Dude your worth as a mathematician isn’t less because of this

This frees you up to go find and solve problems we would have never even bothered with before because it may have seemed ridiculous

I say this exact same thing to the engineers on my extended team - you’re still relevant and you can do even more ambitious things now

reply
I don't care about being "relevant" or even having a career. I care about a community of people doing things on a human level. That's what matters to me. I don't care about being a great mathematician or a great artist, just about participating in a community of other people who do things on a human level, at a human speed. That's it.

I don't care about career or ambition. I'd rather just have a corner of the world to myself to create artistic things to share with others, and stay out of the way.

You mistake my motivation completely. The human community for me IS the end goal. Not proving things. Not results. Results for me are just the fuel to keep the community going.

reply
Yet if that's the case there's a multitude of communities out there that one can become part of. No need to lament the math community that was, as communities also have life spans, and at any given time there will always be a set doing things at the human level.
reply
How is it not part of a community if you’re in a community with others who just so happen to also use ai?

The tortured artist bit is a bit much here

If you want to feel disenfranchised over this that’s fine, but community is still very much here

reply
deleted
reply
> I don't care. Equally important as the solution is the human effort towards the problem

Then you should care a little at least

reply
[flagged]
reply
Haha. Unfortunately for you, I'm not depressed. I've already left academic math. In fact, I'm spirited to fight against AI because of this.
reply
Unsure why that's unfortunate for me, but it sounds ominous!
reply