upvote
If you take that approach,all you can do is accelerate the race to the bottom. You are not increasing you're personal odds of success.
reply
I'm surprised lying is such a strong recommendation here. If we all one-up our resumes by lying we've all just made the entire process of selection futile. I'm not against rounding up dates or stretching responsibilities within the realm of things you didn't do but could have, if they match the job description... but there should be self-imposed limits. Problem is people will always go past those when desperate enough (or they will end up like OP and I, years of "principled unemployment")

Even just using LinkedIn Premium's "cater your resume to this job" feature creates automated lies. I unfortunately don't think there's a way out as there will never be agreement amongst ourselves to be honest and ethical when you're facing such life-altering situations.

reply
So, suppose you participate in the competition where taking steroids is the plausible option.

And you do not really want to do it, since you realize it will have consequences for your health. And you're right, it probably will.

The problem is - its very unlikely for you to win without it. And having a sufficiently large pool, and we have it now, there will be A LOT of people using steroids.

They will simply outcompete you. So, you may like it, dislike it - this is your opinion. And you may be even right that this will have consequences. I'm not syaing anyone is wrong.

But the fact is that you will very likely to lose for people who opt for steroids. Not necessarily, but very likely.

reply
This analogy breaks down because most people winning - eg being recruited into software jobs - are not lying. I think most candidates probably are, but most candidates are not hired.
reply
Extend the analogy: those people have great genetics and we’re talking about only the ugly weaklings that can’t compete.
reply
People are going to keep encouraged to lie and embellishment because we already see all the people at the top and near top get their by embellishment and who they know.

There are limits to how much you should lie, but fake it to till you make it is proven to work again and again.

reply
Embellishment is not the same as lying. Reputation is not the same as nepotism. Of course these things are not black and white, but if you start off saying that lying is how you play the game, then you're already fucked because it shows you don't understand the game that particular brand of social climber is playing. If you try to cargo cult that behavior you will lose. Don't wrestle with pigs, as the saying goes.

The reality is that competence is a better path to success, including at the highest level, but it's harder, and it's not sufficient without demonstrating your impact and building relationships along the way. This doesn't mean giving up your values, but it does mean acknowledging that others perceptions of you is ultimately necessary, and it's not wrong to invest specifically in that perception above your mechanical work.

And the last thing I'll say is that you've got to find a way to avoid negative psychological loops and blanket judgments of the world. Ultimately if you are not bringing a constructive mindset why would someone pay you? If you're hung up on how others are getting ahead with embellishment and nepotism (or any other professional injustice you've experienced) then you're just wasting energy and mental juice on things that are completely outside your control, and can only serve to hurt your chances of success.

reply
The only way out would be for conditions to be less desperate, I think unfortunately. If the market was a sellers market for labor and people could hop easily there would be less competition for each slot, less pressure to lie, and companies might be filtering less like this.

But it's kind of beyond our personal behavior. It's how much the overall economy is growing or shrinking and how much human labor is needed and stuff like that.

reply
I agree with your first sentence but not with the second. Yes, you contribute minutely to accelerating the race to the bottom. But you definitely increase your odds of success even if just marginally.

Your odds of success are 0 if every HR filter fails you for seeing that gap. Your odds of success are non-0 if you can actually pass that artificial hurdle and have a chance to show your skills.

As a matter of principle, doing this is not the most moral thing. But if the alternative is your family starving it’s a price worth paying. It’s clear OP tried it the other way for a couple of years with no success, time to change something.

reply
> But you definitely increase your odds of success even if just marginally.

I think that is true in that you may minutely increase your odds of passing a stage in an HR pipeline, but it places you on a path to long-term failure.

The opportunity cost here is immense. Right now we have a world of opportunity, where people with the right skills, domain knowledge, and insight can have outsized effects and earn a lot of money. Following the race to the bottom only worsens you're personal outlook, like farriers competing on hoof trimming in 1926.

reply
Not really, everybody lies. Massively, about everything. Notice how the measured height for young males is cca ~175cm (and actually falling) yet self-reported height is 185-190cm. Or how female weight is on average ~75-85kg yet self reported at 50ishkg? And these are obvious, clearly visible stats for the most part, yet people directly lie about them (feel free to look up true heights of most celebs, they're all cleanly 10-15cm shorter than claimed).

References: https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/series/sr_03/sr03-046-508.pdf

~99.9% of most peoples CVs are entirely fiction.

reply
I suspect people who lie on CVs are like people dependent on alcohol, who're often shocked when they learn how little the average person actually drinks.
reply
> The opportunity cost here is immense

This is disconnected from the reality OP’s facing. There is no opportunity cost when there is no opportunity. 2 years on the bench and staring down the barrel of being penniless is proof of that. Hard to sit on a high horse on an empty stomach.

You write a nice story about the ideal situation of people with skills making money hand over fist, that this man is obviously not living in, and has by now years of trying and failing to capitalize on that mythical “opportunity”. Everybody has a plan until they’re punched in the mouth.

The opportunity cost is a small price to pay now for some peace of mind and financial safety for the family.

You could be a trillionaire and instead you chose to pay the opportunity cost for doing whatever you do now.

reply
> This is disconnected from the reality OP’s facing.

I think we're just at different stages of grief. The software market has changed, irreversibly, but many remain in denial. They think language skills and framework experience are necessary and they can earn a living based on that.

That's denial.

They're angry at the broken hiring system. Looking for ways to game it. Maybe giving up.

Eventually we come to accept that the skillset that supported our lifestyles is very quickly becoming a commodity and the remaining positions are being filled from an ever-increasing global supply. CV tricks, white lies and massaging the truth can only get you momentarily ahead in a losing position.

Unless you can become a top tier .1% frontier researcher, the only option to maintain the conditions you are accustomed to is to pivot, to become knowledgable and eventually an expert in a domain and to become somebody that other like to work with in that domain.

> The opportunity cost is a small price to pay now for some peace of mind and financial safety for the family.

There is no more peace of mind or financial safety available as a software developer unless you can accrue enough to become independently wealthy. There's no job, no role that's immune.

reply
As I said above, I agree with you in principle. But when you’re at the end of the rope you need to be pragmatic and holding on to the principle when everyone else is not doing is putting you in a losing position against them. Who knows what the future brings, embellishing his CV at this point is just a means to buy more runway until he puts other things in place.

If OP didn’t mention that he burned through all his savings and is in a bad situation I wouldn’t have suggested anything.

Think of it this way, if your clean green electricity gets cut in winter, it doesn’t look like it’s coming back soon, and your fingers are already turning purple, do you fire up that crappy old polluting coal stove, or do you freeze with your principles intact?

> CV tricks, white lies and massaging the truth can only get you momentarily ahead in a losing position.

You keep saying this but provided nothing to support it. And you can’t because you can’t possibly have this kind of data beyond anecdata. Also if almost everyone else is already doing it since forever, does it mean that they’re all in a losing position? To me it looks like OP is already in a losing position, I really doubt a decent job will somehow put him in a worse position “long term”.

> There is no more peace of mind or financial safety available as a software developer unless you can accrue enough to become independently wealthy

That’s exactly the job OP tries to get, but at least any decent dev job, from a position of having no savings and no prospects. If you thought waiting at home is better than having a job you’d quit yours, burn all your savings, and live day to day musing about opportunity costs you’d rather not pay.

You’re taking your line of thinking very far without any basis or argument to support it. You’re correct that the principled approach is to be fully transparent, but the rest is conjecture to support something reality shows every day to be otherwise.

reply
> CV tricks, white lies and massaging the truth can only get you momentarily ahead in a losing position.

Interesting take. I don't understand why that would be the case, and you aren't supporting your position at all beyond just stating it, but interesting nonetheless. Especially because earlier you said:

>> because almost everyone is doing this kind of embellishment

Too keep consistency with what you said earlier, you're claiming that everyone is putting themselves in a losing position. I'll go for a second past the ridiculousness of saying everyone is somehow in a losing position. It's obviously working for most people so it's probably exactly what the poster needs right now.

They need a life raft my friend. They are drowning and need to do something to say afloat. And you're here not only offering no actionable advice, you're preaching for a ridiculously rigid position they can't afford to take, with no trace of an argument why that would even be the correct stance, while struggling to maintain consistency between the ideas in your own comments.

I can't give the poster any concrete advice. But in the words of 2Pac, "it's on us to do what we gotta do to survive". Or if you want something more high brow, you are permitted in time of great danger to walk with the devil until you have crossed the bridge. The poster looks like they're in danger and in need of some help now, not looking to swindle to become a billionaire.

Please stop acting all high and mighty, making someone who's already down feel even worse for putting a white lie on the CV just to get to the interview, so they can get the chance to prove their value.

reply
It should no longer be about getting to that point. Build something with AI and point to and talk about the experience in the interview. AI 'makes it easy', so go and do it and then show it.

But then that gets too real. It's easier to stick to what we know.

reply
I'm responsible to make hiring decisions for developers in our company (150 FTE). HR pre-filters. Anything that ends up with me and smells even a little bit like AI-driven bullshit is gone.

It's so much junk, I don't care at all whether you just did it to "get past HR", I just don't have the time to deal with it so I will mark your application as "Pass, and reject this person for other roles in the future".

reply
There is definitely a conflict between ‘HR filters only allow through resumes that are AI tuned and read like LinkedIn influencer buzzword checklists’ and hiring managers hate the smell of AI on a resume’.

Warm introductions are probably the only way round this.

reply
In many cases, it's by design. Corporate hiring policies give compliance cover for hiring the warm lead they always wanted.
reply
Yes, fully agree. And even if HR isn't just doing the bare minimum, they have very little understanding of the topics so they can't easily dismiss things as obvious nonsense.

The manager needs to make sure the HR part works. With one recent role where I received mostly obviously fake CVs, I found they had updated the role description to be very buzzwordy. After I rewrote it to be much more "this is what we do and how we do it and this is what we expect from this role" I got fewer but much better candidates.

reply
“and reject this person for other roles in the future”

Is blacklisting candidates legal? Still a shitty thing to do.

reply
If someone isn't honest during the interviews, isn't there a petty big risk they'll continue like that also after getting hired?

(Not saying the applicants are being immoral or anything like that, but can't agree with calling the recruiters shitty)

reply
Recruiters are already shitty when they ask for 10+ years of experience on technology that hasn't been out for 5 or are clearly shopping for reasons to claim the domestic market can't support what they need.

Dishonesty will bred dishonesty.

reply
When will you be firing the entire HR department for using AI-driven filters?
reply
The AI-driven filters are vital. The absolute deluge of resumes you get the moment you post a job can be staggering and completely impractical to actually sift through. And HR departments felt this way before AI enabled entirely autonomous mass resume submission.

And I agree with the person you're replying to, I'm hiring a human not an AI meat proxy. I won't explicitly blacklist them, though the rejection reason will stick with them if they apply for other positions.

reply