Businesses must be competitive. If they all use the same AI model, then they’ve lost all competitive advantage by using it. The only advantage left is the inputs that go into the AI model. Who supplies those?
Since you’re asking for examples, let’s talk about marketing. You cannot fully automate this. It’s a zero sum game. It’s like if all business owners decided to pick a really good marketer named Steve. Steve could probably come up with some bangers for a few clients, but once every business is asking Steve for marketing, it all looks the same.
High end fashion brands like Gucci, Prada, Louis Vuitton, are perfect examples of this. Why would I buy such an expensive bag from them? AI is never going to be the reason because fashion is not rational, even if it’s the one constructing the bag
In the next 3-5 years, sure, but that's not the long term vision I see. I think it's more likely we'll see the Anthropics/OAI/Google/Meta/XAIs of the world stop selling tokens. Instead they are the ones offering wider ranges of SaaS products, starting quant trading operations, taking over media (even more than today), developing new pharmaceuticals, etc. GPT 12 or Gemini Francium can and will tighten the RL loop by improving robotics, and have billions of dollars to offer armies of humans to fill the gaps where needed, until it no longer needs humans.
> let’s talk about marketing. You cannot fully automate this
Marketing is one of the most easily automatable jobs there is. AI is already capable of designing commercials, making cold calls, buying ads. Sure, they suck right now and are weird, but in 20-30 years when all of society has been so permeated with AI, AI will be more capable and also people will be way more accepting of AI.
I even find contradicting claims within software companies: that agents will boost productivity 10x, so they don't need to hire so many people. But if it made people 10x as productive, the maths say they could hire 10x the people to become 100x as productive! Shouldn't they do this and do circles around their competition?
(a counter argument is the productivity claims mean it's multiplied in general but not exactly per head... But I don't see many nuanced arguments, just "accept or leave").
This isn't going to happen. You're in the middle of a hype cycle.
1) Your claim is false. At least at my company, we are still doing the "intern to full-time hire after graduation if we like you" pipeline that we've always been doing. Does my one anecdote defeat your zero anecdotes? I don't know.
2) The companies are caught up in the hype. They're trying to find out what it's good at and what it's not. As reality comes back online and prices go up, they'll find reasons to hire humans again.
3) Money is no longer free (ZIRP is over) so there is less experimenting and less hiring and less mobility between employers, meaning fewer openings completely independently of the AI stuff.
There's many explanations that don't require falling for the AI hype cycle.
Predictions about the medium term future on HN are ridiculous. 95% of them are mindless drek, 4% are weak claims, and 1% have anything close to reality baked in and might be reasonable.
Younger generation had an edge previously because they could absorb how to use new tools, machines etc compared to someone older.
That's not the case here anymore.
Older people don't have any problem using AI. It's just AI don't need that many people. I don't think you can blindly apply what happened in the past to this case.
AI is no different, it's just people are swallowing the hype and getting hysterical. Certain things will be made more economical via AI which will create new opportunities which will in turn create other opportunities and new work.
The idea that AI will put everyone out of work is asinine.
For some reason, people in this thread keep making this statement without providing any reason why they believe it
So higher today than in 2015?
https://www.newyorkfed.org/research/college-labor-market?utm...
Doesn’t select to back your claims up in America
If you don’t think using AI is a skill, then you haven’t used it enough
If people didn't get fired, like they weren't with introduction of regular IT, then... the whole narrative will have to change.
Everything requires some amount of skill, but if you think using AI requires some great skill, like a degree, then you're using it wrong.
More to the point different people will have different levels of productivity using AI, but that has more to do with their existing or different skills. For instance more experienced developers tend to be more productive with AI (but not always).
If you think it is a skill, then you haven't used it enough.
FWIW, I use it plenty, and you're talking to a group of highly technical people who have probably also used it plenty.
Saying its painful but things will be fine, comes across very... Farquaad.
Like what are you insinuating this even means? Painful as in people starving to death painful or just painful as in no family vacations for a few years or a blend of both?
Are you saying that we just have to accept that as it is and nothing can be done about it?
Most people, especially with kids, don't share this attitude to keep things polite.
Not for a generation or two, there weren't. Unless you have an example, I'm not buying this argument.
In a fully mechanized/automated world, we won't work. It will make no sense to work. Im this scenario we have a wealth distribution problem. How do you decide who gets how much of what? Capitalism as we know it relies on cost of labour to distribute wealth.
Now, will AI be doing this? I don't think so. So I agree with you, it's going to increase productivity of a lot of jobs, but it will also create jobs. But we don't really know.
Your entire argument rests of this statement. Why wouldn't it make sense to work? How would one company differentiate its products from another if they're all using the same AI?
Let's take a contrived example. Let's say automation can produce yachts for all of us at affordable prices someday. We're just going to all own yachts then. What will be the reason for one person to choose one yacht over another? Branding, marketing, positioning, patents, regulations, etc. Who does that work? Humans. Because ultimately you're selling to humans in a human-controlled world, not machines.
Why are humans needed for that?
Patents, regulations are decided by humans because we’re ruled by humans
What I'm saying isn't anything new. It was a hot topic during abd after imdustrial revolution. Even Karl Marx joined the discussion and wrote about it. The key thing is, what is money and what determines the prices. If there's abundance, the problems you talked about start to occur and market cannot price the goods. This is, to some, abundance communism.
I suppose, at that point, the key inputs to a company become creativity and ambition (rather than, say, overall effort). Humans are still better at those than AI.
Humans would still direct branding/marketing/positioning while we control the overall creativity and ambition of a project/company.
If the only intent is to make money, then I suppose you could build machines that tweak the creativity & ambition in different ways to create different products & services, in which case you can argue no humans need to be in the loop.
But there is no pure capitalism and the government also redistributes wealth.
In an extreme(-ly unlikely) case of everything being automated the government would just redistribute the generated wealth to the populace (assuming a democracy). Apparently the end state of capitalism is socialism.
This is usually where people insist that the corporate overlords will take over and enslave everyone.
The thing that these sentences miss are the time spans.
It took more than 80 years for the British workers to recover salary and occupation wise from the first industrial revolution.
It took 70 years for European economies (deep into the 1950s) to recover from machines entering agricultural fields. In the meantime tens of millions emigrated to the americas because there were simply no jobs.
And previous revolutions only arrived in specific sectors (industries or fields). Now workers are being attacked in every single sector at the same time.
Do you have several life times till the job markets correct? I don't.
Yes they do. Constantly.
If AI is coming for all our jobs why are more progressive politicians not screaming for a standard 4 day workweek?
In fact, we should be on a 3 day workweek by now.
Why are "they" only speaking about people having normal 5 day week jobs, or being completely replaced by AI - no middle ground? Surely this is the time to transition to working fewer days? Fucking bizarre.
I choose to work only 4 days (for less pay obviously) and consume less (until automation makes more things cheaper), but it looks I'm alone with that choice.
Also remember that to Ford, "good american" usually also meant things like "not jewish".
The reason Ford increased wages was because he had to retain labor. The work was hard and mind numbing and awful, so turnover was massive, so he raised wages to get workers to stay and actually benefit from them learning on the job. An assembly line actually works fairly poorly with green labor.
Ford raised wages because the system didn't work well with bottom tier labor. You couldn't treat your employees as super replaceable.
This of course has largely been forgotten by everyone to instead be replaced with stupid myths about his legacy.