Although I guess for current AI workloads, it could be viable, since the additional latency of sending your (small, text only) prompt around the world for processing is little compared to the time taken to process (whereas for other stuff being close to users matters more)
You could build batteries, charge the batteries during the day, run the DCs off it at night.
SunCable / AAPowerLink is likely going to be connected to the Darwin grid, which is currently not connected to the main East Australian grid; but building a connection to the main Australian grid would be a lot cheaper than undersea HVDC to Singapore. Once that happens, there would also be the potential to use pumped hydro (including Snowy 2.0) for storage.
Given this year’s events [0], even Sahara seems more likely.
But you’d still have to build it out from ≈scratch, including cooling, internet connection infrastructure, and maintenance, so I’m not sure what the time horizon on amortization would look like, even with the cheap solar power.
[0] https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/amazon-cloud-unit-...
Obviously security is a concern which limits the number of locations, but there’s still plenty of places with stability, security, land, and the lack of taxation and tarrifs that the US puts on energy.
Globally, places like Australia and India should be more competitive for solar than the Sahara, although both Australia and India have a lot of dirty power generation to replace as well.
I find the concept of agrivoltaics really exciting for climates such as found in Spain.
https://www.google.com/search?q=agrovoltaics+in+spain+resear...
*runs*
But then of course that's another front-page submission with its own long thread of commenters feeling smart for calling it stupid, despite recently becoming a worked out plan and addressing exactly the (subset of reasonable) things people are complaining about here. In fact, we had those a week or two ago.
I swear the tech space turned into thought-space NIMBYs. "I don't understand any of it, but something about it pattern-matches to something I don't like, therefore it's stupid and people behind it are evil". In this thread, and in every other thread recently, too.
To deploy 1 GW of capacity, apparently 100 Starship launches would be needed.
On earth, 23 GW are currently under construction, 100-132 GW is already active, and about 100 GW should be added by 2030.
SpaceX's CFO supposedly cited 2029 as the timeline for multiple GW of compute in operation in space. Musk's vision seems to be launching 100GW/year or 1 million ton of satellites.
This would require 10k launches of Starship per year under ideal conditions, or 5k if Starship Block 4 can double the payload capacity to 200t as planned. This would mean 14 launches per day.
It does sound like a lot. Starbase Louisiana, at a $100B buildout, is planned to have 12 launch pads that could handle 30 launches per day.
Obviously there's much more needed than some launch pads. Anyway, that's the numbers and projections I found.
It might shrink to 3x-10x when considering secondary atmospheric effects, such as on reentry, if they don't use 'graveyard orbits' instead.
From a capacity perspective, if SpaceX remains successful in scaling up their Starship rocket, it seems putting AI compute into space could at least realistically happen at significant scale.
Should SpaceX solve the problem of requiring fossil fuels to launch (doable) and the burning things on re-entry (harder) I don't oppose solar data centers. But without those, it's just externalizing the environmental cost to future generations.
Instead we should be setting up in space infrastructure to enable manufacturing and most importantly space resource use.
Then we can build anything more cheaply at a much bigger scale.
Doing space compute clusters right now is like trying to do regular trans-atlantic airline service with biplanes with floats. While that was possible and done to a degree, it all only took off with more advanced airplanes and supporting infrastructure.
Same might be the case with space. Building infrastructure to enable cheaper infrastructure to enable massively cheaper operations is usually the right approach on paper, but also usually near impossible to fund directly. What happens instead, is attempts at doing something directly, which predictably fail but prove the viability of the idea and justify marginal investment in the infrastructure; couple rounds of that, and in a roundabout way, we eventually arrive where we could've arrived 10x cheaper if the economy could fund long-term plans. Alas.
This is pretty bad-faith. What is the point of your comment? You’re sowing hate and attacking a nondescript group, for what? What does that achieve apart from being hateful?
Yours is one of the few usernames I recognise on HN. I remember seeing some comment from yours (I think it involved Star Trek) which I found interesting at the time and somehow the username stuck with me. Since then, every time I bump into your comments they have gotten more hateful and generally worse and more tribalistic takes.
It genuinely saddens me. Especially as you have in your bio “I'm constantly looking for opportunities to do something actually useful for humanity”, but your words reveal the opposite.
I’m not going to be specific about past posts because frankly I no longer remember their content, only the disappointment I felt. But I can take this one as an example. In addition to every thing I mentioned, I find it a pretty bad take to claim that adding more shit to orbit improves humanity. We need less crap up there, not more. I also find it nonsensical to defend (if we can call it that; you just attacked detractors with no explanation) something that is purely theoretical (which it objectively is; it doesn’t exist yet).
Anyone who has paid attention in the last decades will see all the unkept promises. You can see them in this very submission. Blockchain and AI were full of proponents making the argument that “all this energy consumption is good, actually, because it’ll increase investment in renewables”, but obviously what we’ve seen is an even bigger spend on fossil fuels which are exacerbating the problem. Believing the next promise from proven liars who make everything worse every time is not a smart strategy.
Anyway, I’m not entirely sure why I felt I should write to you specifically. I guess I once saw the possibility of something better and am hopeful that being respectfully called out might help you to reflect. Those of us capable of introspection (which I believe includes you) sometimes need a little nudge to get back on track to the person we want to be. I know that’s true for me. Sometimes I help others, other times they help me. I hope this helps you.
I know there are smart people on HN, and I don't believe most of what (person that shouldn't be named) says. But I agree with OP, the amount of hate anytime the topic comes up is frustrating. And the arm-chair aerospace engineers are are the most annoying group.
Of course, comments and downvotes like yours were very much expected. On HN I’ve come to anticipate lack of nuance and the belief any disagreement or criticism is hateful and looking for a fight.
I can only try to counteract that one post at a time, though I can’t say I’m feeling hopeful that the bother is worth it.
1) Musk retches up another one of his Hyperloop-style dumb-ass ideas whilst patting himself vigorously on the back
2) His companies grovel hilariously to backfill the reasoning for why this is a Good and Smart idea, actually, while actual experts put on a wtf face (“worked out plan” goes here)
<this is where billions come in handy, by the way, since you can just make people work on whatever stupid shit you want without getting any buy-in from the sane>
3) The technorati follow the their glorious thought leader off his cliff
That is simply not workable, and the suggestion needs to die because it sucks motivation from solutions that can work in a year or two.
You can look France, Canada, USA. For example Civaux 1: they started to build it in 1988 and in 1999 it was producing electricity: https://world-nuclear.org/nuclear-reactor-database/details/C...
I plotted how fast nuclear reactors have been built in the world based on this page. It starts at 5 years, peaks at 7 years, and ~90% of reactors are built in <15 years. The last reactors built in western countries (which took a long time to be built) don't represent the average situation. It's taking the worst scenario, which is very pessimistic (why?).
Of course you can include what you want in "from project start", maybe you're reffering to when a politician says "we should build it" rather than when the construction began. In many western countries projects for future reactors have already started (UK, France etc.). A large country won't build 20 reactors in 7 years starting tomorrow, but if it starts building all reactors simultaneously it can build 50 reactors in <30 years.
Maybe what you're also saying is western countries take too long between the decision to build a reactor, and actually building it. I agree with you that we should remove a lot of steps and discussions to accelerate these projects.
France did build out a lot of them over a short period of time. This worked because they standardized the entire thing. They then steamrolled all local objection in order to build them quickly.
So at that point, the design was done, they had factories set up to build the parts and full backing of the national government allowing them to push this through.
So yes, the Nth reactor like that might be built in under 5 years because the design was already done and they built many. This is just not where we are today
Short term plan is much faster and cheaper. Therefore it’s a much better plan.
China add an entire US grid worth (1,281GW) of renewables every 3 to 5.3 years. Why wouldn’t the US do the same and have the problem well in hand in 5 - 10 years rather than waiting 20+ for a single nuke?