upvote
23 atomic bombs of energy? Every day?

I don't have the qualifications to disprove that statement but I'll just go ahead and say I don't buy it.

If that's true, it's more than a visualization issue, it's an education issue. Because yeah I'm sorry I don't even begin to believe that number.

reply
> at a time when, as a world, we are trying to reduce our carbon emissions.

From my perspective, that is not quite the correct way to put it. Because honestly we are not even trying.

---

I find those "Olympic swimming pool type" comparisons very tiring, to be honest. They certainly don’t help my grasp anything. "23 atomic bombs of energy" yeah okay

reply
It sounds really dramatic. Even worse, unlike an olympic swimming pool, nuclear bombs vary drastically in terms of energy output. Like, several orders of magnitude. If they mean 18GW as mentioned later in the article, that's about the energy consumption rate (total, not just electricity) of a city like Houston.
reply
if the prices of domestic and international flights were cheap, people would be flying a lot more, I saw a girl say stop using generative ai because it hurts the environment as a caption on her trip to Iceland, the irony is staggering.
reply
The prices of flights are cheap.
reply
One thing that make absolutely no fucking sense for me is that in places of Europe, for intra country (so good train network and dense population and no so long distance) train is quite more expensive that (subsidized) plane.
reply
its the costs. Trains are heavily subsidised because they have to be.

1. Trains need tracks for the full length of the journey. This is a lot to maintain. Plans just need a runway each end and air in between. 2. They are slower so staff have to be paid for longer hours.

However, for many journeys trains can still work out cheaper because they can take you closer to where you want to go from closer to your starting point, so the cost of the complete journey can be lower.

reply
Trains have to deal with thicker atmosphere (closer to the ground) and have tracks that need maintenance. Planes only need a few square miles of tarmac.
reply
Why just Europe then.
reply
Trains are also more expensive in the US
reply
Why it doesn't. Running trains is simply expensive regardless of country. Swiss have excellent network and its very expensive to use even for locals (I live here and use it for daily commute), for tourists its prohibitive. Other places have often much less quality / reliability / reach and prices are still high.

Cheap train network is a proper pipe dream, not possible. Much better to have fully self driving electric taxi cars (so not that joke with driver constantly needing to be aware if your tesla wants to steer you to standing ambulance / firefighter trucks on highway, I mean no driver setup to push prices to very low levels).

reply
domestic flights in the USA are up 25% year over year and international flight are up 15%, do you have early Anthropic equity?
reply
This doesn’t change your argument but it’s worth pointing out:

> This is not the total energy being consumed by this data centre. It's merely the waste heat it will release to the surrounding environment.

Total energy should in theory equal waste heat. All energy a data center consumes will eventually get converted to heat.

reply
> This is not the total energy being consumed by this data centre. It's merely the waste heat it will release to the surrounding environment.

What would happen to energy it uses other than be released as heat? It has to go somewhere (conservation of energy) and I cannot think of anything other than heat that energy used in a data centre would become.

> about 1.5 petajoules

That is about 2% of total Canadian energy usage. How many more are going to go up? Are they all going tbe powered predominantly by fossil fuels?

reply
> What would happen to energy it uses other than be released as heat?

If only we had some need for heat as a civilisation and could actively combine projects to achieve multiple things at once.

reply
It would still be released as heat.

It could reduce the use of other energy that is used JUST to create heat, so its more efficient - but that only works in some locations, and in most of those only for part of the year.

reply
> This is not the total energy being consumed by this data centre. It's merely the waste heat it will release to the surrounding environment.

Is there a difference? Where else would the energy go?

reply
I imagine there are thousands of optical transceivers, emitting milliwatts each. That adds up to literally dozens of watts!
reply
>The scale of energy that AI data centres use is huge in a way that most people don't have the ability to visualize

While I can't really visualise energy at all, this does make it seem like more than the 0.5% of world electricity consumption that it actually is.

While it is currently cheaper to build renewable energy capacity than most fossil fuels, as far as I can tell, the reason most data centers are not doing so is because they can't, All of the renewable infrastructure being produced is currently being deployed.

The question they should be being asked is when will they be switching to renewables. The height of the plot is not the important thing. It is the area underneath that matters,

reply
0.5% of the world's energy is massive! Every other thing society does - agriculture, shipping containers across the ocean, flying planes - and 1/200th is for AI? The thing we didn't have a couple years ago and we were all fine without?

"When are you going to switch to renewables?" has proven to be a useless question. Companies will say whatever is expedient, and then they'll buy credits or whatever green washing instead of actually reducing consumption. If you let them double their energy consumption by adding renewables they'll just use double.

reply
For starters, 0.5% of the world's electricity, not energy.

Most of the worlds energy use is not electrical.

It is a large amount. I do not deny that, I just want people to consider it in terms that are true. Every person who I have asked how much they think it is based upon the coverage they have encountered has massively overestimated.

A common response is that considering the concern reported in media they estimate data centers use 10-15% of electricity. How can we have an informed conversation about the relative importance of things if people have been misled about the relative scale.

reply
Under the rate of expansion we saw in 2025, data center share of electricity in the US is expected to be around 12% in 2030. So it does not feel particularly misleading

Source: https://eta.lbl.gov/publications/united-states-data-center-e...

reply
On the other hand 2030 projections are for 1.5% of electricity globally.

The US figure is not so much a factor of data center usage but rather the desire to centralise contol within the US where energy providers are more interested in extracting profit from existing infrastructure than building new infrastructure.

Add to that the amount of electricity spent on industrial uses that the US just doesn't do any more. It inflates the US percentage.

That's not a symptom of data centers, The US is trying to put a new engine in a neglected car with a rusted out chassis.

reply
The US has a particular high concentration of data centres.

Those are not just AI ones, and some reduce other energy usage - e.g. if a video conference replaces multiple people travelling to a face to face meeting.

reply
Why not use heat from datacenters to heat homes? Or to produce more electricity? Or to heat greenhouses in winter? Looks like free energy.
reply
But it's not huge. All US data centers consume about 5% of total US electricity. Projected to be 7-12% by 2028. Quoting numbers without context makes them seem much larger than they are.

https://www.energy.gov/articles/doe-releases-new-report-eval...

reply
5% of total US consumption is a huge number though. More then doubling it in 2 years makes it even worse.
reply
They have not broken ground yet on this project, it still has legal hurdles before building starts. The last 10 largest built datacenters don't even add up to this 9GW mega project estimate which wouldn't finish until the mid to late 2030s if it even gets built. U.S. total electricity growth per year seems to be 2-3 percent, if 9GW+ projects become the norm and are built at scale you will see this number skyrocket. Your comment led me to believe this is the norm and 9GW is / has already been built at scale.
reply
> It's merely the waste heat it will release to the surrounding environment

Is it not possible to use some of that for basically free local district/water heating?

reply
Totally possible, but just like a solar+battery setup, it costs more so why would they voluntarily do it?
reply
datacenter builders have been very generous about giving things to the surroundings, and ultimately its another revenue stream
reply
Infomaniak does this with Euria in Geneva, Switzerland.

https://news.infomaniak.com/en/euria-sovereign-ai-assistant/...

reply
They’re _really_ noisy, so usually built far from the kinds of big cities that would benefit from district heating
reply
People keep thinking that the solution is to just keep giving the thinking over to AI, and keep on waiting for it to grow.

Meanwhile codebases get exponentially more bloaty and buggy. The internet gets filled with more and more disinformation. Students get worse and worse.

And the growth everyone is depending on is also so cleary destructive. This is not sustainable and it will not be the solution.

reply
Seems like the DC operators could buy some goodwill if they provided district heating?

Is that feasible at all?

reply
> 23 atomic bombs of energy every day

What yield?

reply
(18GW * 1 day)/23 ~= 67TJ

Little Boy (the type of bomb dropped on Hiroshima) was 63TJ

reply
Where are you getting 18GW from? Last estimate I saw (for 2025) was 14.4 (125TWh continuous)

The IEA is projecting 500TWh (57GW ) by 2030 so it might be consistent with their figures.

reply
From the source of the 23 atomic bombs claim that was linked in beloch's comment - https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/edmonton/wonder-valley-slcn-c...
reply
Ah, now I remember the original headline.

Now it has a bit at the bottom This story and its headline have been updated to provide further context about the preliminary nature of Robert Davies’ assessment and align with our journalistic standards and practices

I was thinking they were talking about current usage. Not guesses of how much something might use.

The only other source I found was https://majorprojects.alberta.ca/details/Wonder-Valley-AI-Da...

Indicating the initial build would be 1.4GW.

I'm not sure how much size matters of individual data centers apart from their contribution to the total. If they sum to the same amount, how much does it matter.

If it's true that you can build something of that size without an environmental impact report then there's something pretty wrong with the laws there.

reply
Probably 50 kilo grams of TNT, affectionately known as "Fart Man".
reply
> 23 atomic bombs of energy every day

Is this supposed to sound very impressive? It genuinely doesn't to me.

I know atomic bombs are scary, but that's because they explode very quickly in a very small space. (Radiation aside which I guess was not the point of the comparison)

If you spread that energy release throughout a whole day and a bigger area, letting the wind slowly take the energy away, then it doesn't sound scary at all.

reply
The amount of sunlight that falls on the data center site is around 18 atomic bombs per day of energy.
reply
Not to mention that the power to the data center comes from somewhere. So whatever amount of fuel, solar, or wind went in to the system is the most that can come out.

Using nuclear bombs as the measuring stick is a cheap rhetorical tactic.

reply
> This is not the total energy being consumed by this data centre. It's merely the waste heat it will release to the surrounding environment.

It is very funny reading people who don't understand physics layering on histrionics to make something sound as bad as possible.

reply
All this to make human thinking redundant. AI will kill off humanity, but not in the way the Rationalists are convinced.

I have a fantasy that keeps me warm on the cold nights of my mind. It's that after building AGI they ask it how to solve global warming. And it replies, "Lol, you're fucked. Why did you sacrifice everything to build me instead of saving yourselves?"

reply
> He said if the Wonder Valley project goes ahead it would release the equivalent of 23 atomic bombs of energy every day, though he noted the comparison has its limits."

Saying this comparison has its limits is an understatement. Energy released by different atomic bombs can vary across different order of magnitudes.

reply
If they centrally located that data center, the heat wouldn't need to be wasted at least six months a year.

Also AI data centers weren't responsible for decades of people burning natural gas to heat their homes without investing in insulation nor the tar sands oil which is really screwing the climate.

reply
People heating their homes is necessary for survival. AI is not.
reply
Heating homes, yes.

Not investing in insulation, no. Especially rentals have lagged behind.

reply
>If they centrally located that data center, the heat wouldn't need to be wasted

Good luck getting that past the NIMBYs

reply
Who are responsible for sprawl (and thus dependence on automobiles and freeways). And the hardest part of siting new solar plants. And why North Seattle has a dearth of affordable grocery stores (... that one might be a little hyperlocal).
reply
Then maybe don't build it when you can't safely power it, not to mention if its even dubious its economically viable or even useful for anything.

We could build The Great Pyramid from TNT byt we don't as its a stupid idea.

reply
> if the Wonder Valley project goes ahead it would release the equivalent of 23 atomic bombs of energy every day

I just cannot understand how anyone would find this comparison useful... oh wait, I see, it's not to educate people, it's to push a false narrative. Now I understand!

> 18 gigawatts

That's a figure we can work with!

reply
oh so this is who that bad propaganda was aimed at.

on the proper hn thread for that misinformation article, i did a quick lookup and the comparable number is a large aluminum plant.

we should turn off Quebec's aluminum industry - its got tons of plants emitting like this datacenter will, and were releasing all that heat in the environment just to ship the aluminum south afterwards.

at least the datacenter will be used by canadians

reply
I would note that this data center is likely unique among Canadian data center projects for being built to be an oil-and-gas consumer. They're presumably doing that with this Alberta data center in particular, because oil-and-gas is the natural resource Alberta happens to have, and it's strictly more economical to burn the extracted gas near where it's produced than to have to send it thousands of miles via pipeline first.

And that economy-of-locality means that if they wanted to build more of these gas-plant data centers, they'd just also build those in Alberta.

Thus, if they're building DCs "across Canada", then I would expect that the data centers being built in the rest of Canada will not be powered with piped-in Alberta oil. A data center built in e.g. British Columbia / Ontario / etc, would presumably use the natural resource common to those provinces, i.e. hydro power.

---

Also, coincidentally, there's something interesting/unique about building data centers in Alberta, that being that it's friggin' cold there. Which means that Albertans spend a lot of grid power (or oil-and-gas directly) to heat their homes each year.

They're already doing waste-heat recovery district heating for data center projects in Finland. Could be done in Alberta too. (Though maybe it'd be better to target some of these DC projects to slightly northern-er parts of Alberta, where it stays cold for more of the year, so that ideally the district heating is a desirable consumable year-round rather than only for 6 months out of the year.)

---

As for carbon emissions, I would point out something less positive and more frustrating. There is a fixed (slowly-growing) production capacity of oil-and-gas producers like Alberta. If all the oil-and-gas that Alberta is pulling out of the ground was already being burnt, then it would have been impractical to build any data centers there, as the data centers "sucking on the straw" wouldn't be able to force the oil derricks to work any harder than they're already working, nor force any oil-sands exploration to happen faster than it's already happening, and so they just wouldn't get enough supply to satisfy their demand.

No, the reason the data centers can be built in Alberta, is that an inelastic production industry like oil-and-gas, when demand for its product goes down, doesn't scale down; but instead, buffers its supply in reserves, while looking for new avenues to demand its supply (potentially at lower cost.)

In other words: numbers like "30 million tonnes of CO2/yr" sound impressive, but what we're actually talking about here is a reallocation of oil-and-gas production. Those barrels of oil had previously been being burned in cars; now that cars aren't using them as much, they're being burned in power plants instead. The net carbon we're releasing from pulling that oil from the earth has neither increased nor decreased.

And, of course, that's a bad thing. We want oil-and-gas production to be elastic; we want our decreases in aggregate end-consumer demand to lead to gradual scale-down of the oil-and-gas extraction industry.

But can you guess who doesn't want that? Oil exporters like Alberta. And, often, their voters. "A gradual scale-down of the oil-and-gas extraction industry" is, to them, a gradual scale-down of their tax revenue and/or livelihoods.

So of course they're going to push back on it / "work around" anything that threatens that by coming up with new sinks for their product.

If we want to "solve" carbon emissions, we really need, first and foremost, to come up with a way to decouple oil-exporter states' tax base + jobs from a dependency on the maintained worldwide aggregate demand for oil-and-gas. Only then will those states stop coming up with new justifications for continuing to pull oil out of the ground.

reply
I said this elsewhere I think the "AI" DCs in Alberta specifically are actually less about "AI" demand and more about partially stranded natural gas assets and natural gas shareholders and stakeholders looking for a way to consume it at point of production.

They're looking to take advantage of the gold rush in AI to do this -- and the Canadian population's current distaste for carbon taxes and environmental restrictions, and the Alberta govt's frankly corrupt pursuit of exponential growth in energy sector emissions.

There's no "rational" world where it makes sense to build AI DCs in Alberta & Sask (which have dirty expensive grids) instead of a place like Quebec or even B.C. which have cheap and cleaner hydroelectric power.

It's being done only because the AB gov't is on the side of the fossil fuel industry above all else. And because Smith got Carney to massacre the carbon tax.

We will all be left holding the bag in 5-10 years. And we will suffer with increasing energy costs in the interim as demand for natural gas spikes. Enbridge shareholders will like it though.

reply
The point of reducing emissions is to increase QoL. But that should not come at the cost of reducing QoL itself. That's just a religious need for degrowth
reply
The point of reducing emissions is to ensure life as we know it can continue to exist on earth. It's to avoid widespread extinctions and famine.
reply
Is there a paper that models this? I hadn't heard about the extinction scenario.

50 million years ago there were 1600 ppm CO2 in the atmosphere. I haven't seen a projection that has reaching near that in the next 100 years. The extreme scenarios are like 1100 by 2100.

The early Cambrian period had 5000-6000 ppm.

reply
> Global extinction outcomes strongly depended on global emissions scenarios (Fig. 1, A and B). At current global temperatures ~1.3°C above the preindustrial average, 1.6% (CI95: 1.2, 1.9%) of species are projected to become extinct (Fig. 1A). Extinction risks are projected to increase to 1.8% (CI95: 1.5, 2.3%) at the 1.5°C threshold advocated by the 2015 Paris Agreement and embodied by Shared Socioeconomic Pathway (SSP) 1-1.9. Beyond this threshold, extinction risks increase to 2.7% (CI95: 2.2, 3.3%) at 2.0°C (SSP 1-2.6). Current international emission abatement commitments (14) would elevate global temperatures to 2.7°C, threatening 1 in 20 species. Beyond this temperature, extinction risks quickly accelerate to 14.9% (CI95: 11.6, 18.8%) at 4.3°C (SSP 3-7.0) and 29.7% (CI95: 23.0, 37.1%) at 5.4°C (SSP 5-8.5).

https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.adp4461

reply
might not be extinction, but people start getting dumb at indoor CO2 > 1000ppm
reply
Source?

OSHA's exposure limit is 5000ppm averaged over 8 hours.

This study found no cognitive impact at 2100.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S036013232...

A larger NIH study found nothing at 4200.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42035679/

For some reason people think its acceptable to spread pseudo-scientific bullshit whenever it supports an anti-climate change agenda. It really isn't needed. The direct harms based on scientific data are enough to justify far more intervention than is currently happening. Spreading misinformation just discredits the movement.

reply
There is no credible climate change scenario that puts "life as we know it can continue to exist on earth" at risk.

"Humankind will drive itself extinct with climate" is fearmongering - completely unsupported by science.

The harms are bounded, and that's a big part of the issue with addressing climate change.

Climate change is severe enough that something should be done about it, but not severe enough to make itself impossible to ignore. Harmful enough that those harms should be prevented, but not harmful enough to justify extreme prevention measures.

reply
I mostly don’t buy the tail risks narrative that if we continue emissions, the whole human civilization is at risk. I guess we can agree to disagree on that.
reply
> The point of reducing emissions is to increase QoL.

This is wrong.

reply
Then what's the point really? You are welcome to go into the jungle and live amongst the animals. I'd rather use AI and live life happy.

We engineers optimize for human life, that's it.

reply
> We engineers optimize for human life, that's it.

Maybe that's the ideal, but every engineer I know is forced to create tools which are designed to die after a certain point in time. Things designed otherwise are either prohibitively expensive, or reducing in numbers or both.

I rarely see improvement in quality of the things I buy when compared to their older siblings. Cost optimization is the name of the game, not optimizing for human life. Otherwise companies should strive for longevity, ergonomics, and reduction of hazard.

When game companies organize conferences on how to monetize by exploiting human psychology and car manufacturers create parts designed to fail after some time, your claim sounds unbelievable.

reply
> We engineers optimize for human life, that's it.

You engineer for maximum return on capital, and any benefit to human life is incidental.

reply
I won't go into the ethics because there's no point given your position, but even if you solely care about humans: the point of reducing emissions is to prevent our QoL from decreasing, which it will for the vast majority of humans (who will then decrease the QoL of the rest, since they don't want to suffer and die).

You will not be able to "use AI and live life happy" if we don't reduce emissions.

reply
QoL is correlated with GDP which can mostly only go up with increasing productivity, like with AI.

Whereas increased emissions also reduces quality of life.

So it is a tradeoff. If any activity increases so much quality of life such that it offsets the reduced QoL due to emissions, we should pursue it.

Unless you believe in human collapse and extinction due to tail risks which I don’t believe.

reply
GDP is just a human-made number. In the real world, our quality of life is determined by things we can’t control, no matter how much money we may have. Like natural disasters.

Really doesn’t matter if our GDP goes up 1 million times if people are dying left and right to natural disasters globally. Reducing energy emissions is vital to preserving our quality of life.

I don’t believe there’s much of a risk of extinction. But that’s such an extreme case. We don’t need extinction for things to suck ass for a lot of people, I don’t know why people think that. Obviously, things will suck way, WAY before extinction.

reply
> QoL is correlated with GDP

To a point, yes, but I don't think QoL has tracked GDP in developed countries for at least 30 years. I mean, my country's GDP has tripled since 2000, but if you erased all technological progress from 2000 from my life, frankly, the effect on my quality of life would be marginal. Sure, I'm addicted to digital crack like everybody else, but life was plenty good back then. It's not like you'd be taking away my fridge or washing machine.

In terms of QoL, solving the housing crisis would have a far larger effect than any amount of data centers, with a smaller carbon footprint. Or cheap groceries. Or free and efficient healthcare for all. It's hard to say increasing productivity is important for QoL reasons while failing the basics.

reply
This sounds great and all, except for the tiny issue that we cannot evaluate the potential QoL benefits of AI or the thresholds for QoL decreases caused by emissions with any kind of precision. So you're gambling with hundreds of millions of human lives (not to mention all the animal lives we're risking), just so you can get your new shiny toy a little earlier.

But I've seen other people explain this to you before, simianwords, and I haven't seen you critically engage with arguments against your position. So I don't think this will lead to much.

reply
They’d say it is tail risk of human collapse.
reply
Yes but the data center hardly runs off the internal combustion engine.

The energy consumption of data centers is irrelevant: our complete failure to deploy the technology we've had for the past 40 years, or the last 5, to produce carbon-free energy is the real issue.

I'm rather tired of using energy consumption as a convenient bludgeon in the OmniCause, by people who have typically steadfastly opposed what we could've been dong this entire time and can be doing now.

Build more datacenters. Permit more solar and wind to power them. The money is flowing so I'm pretty sure we can afford some nuclear plants to backstop the baseload as well. This is all ridiculous: we should've ended carbon fuel dependence for stationary power in the early 2000s.

reply
Several countries whose income depends almost entirely on oil export would like to disagree, and their incredible wealth is highly influential.
reply
deleted
reply