upvote
You may be surprised at how terrible cattle grazing land (at least in western North America) is for food production.
reply
It's not just the cattle grazing land, it's the land necessary to produce the feed as well.

In the Netherlands at least the cattle is tacking up a large part of what would otherwise be perfectly fine framland. Though most of the soy used to feed them is produced outside of the EU I think.

reply
The majority of the feed comes from marginal land too, just a step above pasture.

At a microeconomic level it just rarely makes sense for someone to grow animal feed when products that humans want to eat are more valuable (in yield per acre). An acre of strawberries can sell for 10-100x more than an acre of corn for example.

(I’m vastly oversimplifying since markets, mechanization, crop rotation, and local infrastructure make a huge difference too, but that’s the gist)

There’s another wrinkle: A lot of feed comes from waste coproducts like distillers grain used for ethanol or soybean meal that is the leftover from soybean oil production.

reply
well the solution to this is simple: vet and mark all foods properly

raw material coming from 'maybe chem-friendly' area/country/etc? mark as so.

coming from organic? mark as so.

if some food 'contains raw material that may have used certain pesticides' -- mark as so.

reply
Organic food actually consumes more land and water per unit of food than conventional. That’s in part why it’s more expensive. Organic food is hardly a suitable solution for the “keep everyone fed with limited and shrinking amount of fertile land and water” problem.

Organic and sustainable are two different things.

reply
Organic can be more sustainable with technology. There are now laser weeders that use vision-AI to identify and target weeds with lasers. This can replace herbicides, although it doesn't take care of fungal or insect problems; at least the amount of chemicals needed is reduced so far, and maybe future technologies will be able to eliminate chemical treatment of crops.
reply
Not to disagree with you, but the phrasing is wrong I think. "Organic" food - or more like "conventionally grown" takes certain amount of space and time which you can cut by using pesticides and other chemicals that end up being not so great for us.
reply
deleted
reply
if what you say about organic stuff is true...

...well that's what will appear on the price tag?

reply
This is an ignorant and foolish assertion. Most often the land that is used for ranching and grazing is being used for ranching and graze specifically because it can't support other crops, thats historically always been the case.

The following link discusses the issue at length

https://acoup.blog/2019/07/12/collections-the-lonely-city-pa...

reply
You can't fight human nature. Humans like ungulate meat. They also like big cars and comfortable climate-controlled environments. We can debate the extent to which these are necessities--and eco-nazis frequently do--but the demand for those things will persist regardless. And governments that fail to supply those things cheaply will inevitably feel the heat.
reply