Did we, though? I think much of this boils down to personal preference. I grew up pre-www, so I remember having to go to a store for everything. I remember when it could be a 45 minutes drive depending on the kind of product, not knowing if they'd have what I wanted, not knowing where in the store it was. Sure, we had mail order catalogues, but that was a strictly inferior experience to online.
I've never enjoyed shopping, and have always looked at it as one of the most annoying chores of life. Now I can open up my laptop while sitting on my couch and have an almost limitless variety of products at my fingertips. Sure, it's not perfect. I can't see it before I buy it, and I can't get it right now. But to me, those are minuscule trade offs for what we've gained; I am more than happy to wait a day or two (or even a week) for most purchases if it means I don't have to go into a physical store.
Amazon sucks these days, sure, definitely. It's a flood of ads, promoted crap, and cheap, unaccountable, Chinese brands with alphabet-soup company names. But overall, the idea of ecommerce has been an amazing success, in my eyes.
I loved being able to shop and explore things in person, its a MUCH better experience than whatever the hell Amazon tries to pass off as "shopping". There used to be Fry's electronics where I lived which was amazing, you could always see the latest and greatest, aisles full of hobbies, etc. When they died, it felt like the death of retail.
Once the national chain big box stores started, Circuit City, Best Buy, etc, it became less and less of a "deal" and more of a ripoff compared to online. At Fry's I could get stuff priced pretty close to Newegg for bigger items like CPUs and motherboards. But if you went into Best Buy they want to charge you $60 for a 10ft HDMI cable, or $50 for a 25ft Cat5e cable. It was the massive 5x markup on those items, the ones that would regularly draw me into a store, that killed retail shopping for me in favor of online. If I'm not going in when I need a cable, I'm not going in when I need an appliance - they trained everyone to price compare with online stores by ripping everyone off. This worked for a single generation that had no experience with technology or knowledge of what a fair price is, but it killed every savvy generation after that.
Without ecommerce I'll be running a shitty Asus or whatever consumer laptop they sell in stores.
I'll still have to buy a new headset every six months because they only sell garbage products.
I'll still have to buy a new blender every year because they only sell the low-power ones.
I live in a big city so there is some niche stores were I can go and get actual quality products, but the big stores are all selling the same trash they were selling when I was a kid, and I don't see the point of going there when I can buy quality products on niche websites.
Also how would you even get a catalog for B&H? I'd never even heard of that place until the 2010s. Certainly no one in Texas in the mail order catalog days knew about a kosher (closed on the sabbath!) camera store located in the big apple
Back in the day, you'd buy a computer magazine and find reviews for the computers, and there'd be ads for the computers with a phone number and address. You could request a full catalogue, and get the niche thing ordered.
I think the main reason their ecommerce attempts didn't succeed is they didn't appreciate how important fast shipping was. They treated their website as another front end for mail-order with 4-6 weeks delivery, until it was too late.
https://www.cnbc.com/amp/2019/04/18/sears-sues-eddie-lampert...
Even though it's all just blatant consumerism, I genuinely think kids today lost something cool when they could no longer convince their parents to take them to the mega toy store, filled floor to ceiling with cool stuff.
Even though it was corporate magic, it was still magical to have a place like that. Now it's just all ipads.
These were items that would undoubtedly be behind the locked counters at Walmart, where it would take some time to get a worker to retrieve the items. But at least they would be directly from Walmart's supply chain, with no chance of getting fakes co-mingled in Amazon's warehouse.
Amazon is nowhere as good or special as they used to be.
There will probably come a day where the walmart online shopping is just a blue and yellow version of amazon with few benefits.
If you want same-day delivery you are limited to what is in stock at the nearest local store. And even then, sometimes they will only offer in-store pickup, it may depend on how backed up their delivery is (they use gig workers, at least where I am).
Set your search filters to "sold by walmart" to eliminate the third party stuff.
I feel like all of these threads just get derailed by people not really staying focused on the value proposition offered by each store [0].
When I'm thinking about Walmart, I'm thinking about items that Walmart themselves are selling/fulfilling. I have never found a third party listing on Walmart.com to be compelling. In my estimation they must exist because listing is essentially free for Walmart and the seller [1], people get confused (especially browsing on a tiny screen on mobile), have no idea where they should actually buy a certain type of item, have no idea what things should cost, etc. [2]
So having said that, to me Walmart is actually an outlier in being different among [online] shopping. Most of the type of sundries you'd actually buy at Walmart get delivered quickly from the store (gig work courier?). Or if they won't do that for a certain item, or you don't feel like meeting the "shipping minimum", then you can do a store pickup.
Contrast with say Target where everything gets shipped Fedex (or Ontrac now I think), and basically takes at least two days if not several because it's coming from a further warehouse. I'd say this is in the same logistics bucket as Zoro, Newegg, etc - large shippers that still wholly rely on delivery companies for fulfillment.
[0] the thesis of the original article doesn't match my experience at all, but I also keep an eye on prices for what things should cost, and the idea that you'd just hit buy on some boots because Amazon itself told you they were a good deal is utterly foreign to me. Like yes, fuck their dark patterns. But the real check here is shopping around, or more pertinently, being able to have automated software that shops around.
[1] there is very little exclusiveness to third party listings. the same exact 3P-fulfilled listings are generally on Amazon, eBay, even Zoro / Home Depot / Lowes depending on the type of product.
[2] I'm more than willing to accept someone chiming in and pointing out something compelling they have found from 3P Walmart sellers [3]. Just do it within the framework please! Or point out where my estimated framework is wrong, that's great too! Just don't analyze things as if "Walmart" consists of everything returned from a naive query on walmart.com!
[3] eg I think the return policy might be better (90 days, and you can bring to the store for free?), but prices are also generally a little higher.
Each store (or really each fulfillment method of each store) has types of items of items they're good at. That is my primary key for where I start looking.
Most items that I've found Walmart is good at, are going to be nowhere near a Whole Foods. And for food items specifically where they do manage to overlap, I would expect Whole Foods to be much more expensive for little gain. But YMMV, as food is like the one single thing where I still go to physical stores - I haven't found any online+delivery that provide enough value to justify the various fees they want.
In my experience, for most items that Walmart is going to be good at, Target is likely also going to be good at. Some of them will also be on Amazon at reasonable prices.
Does that mean commingling for "shipped and sold by Amazon" or does each third party seller get its own non comingled are ?
It used to be the case that there would be big bins containing all of a given product in the warehouse, whether they were being sold by a legitimate vendor or a counterfeiter (though I think vendors could pay extra to not commingle). When you bought a commingled product, there was no way to know whether you were getting one actually sent in by the vendor you made the purchase from. You could buy a product from a legitimate seller but get one sent in by a counterfeiter, or vice versa. Now (since they ended commingling) there are separate bins for each vendor selling through Amazon.
I don't remember them previously announcing the end of commingling.
(And note that I'm simplifying over some asterisks on various points)
As of two days ago, I am now able to get "Free overnight delivery" on many items with delivery windows from 3am-5am or 5am-8am. That's pretty awesome.
They're also testing drone delivery nearby.
I'll admit I have a Pittsburgh metric wrench set, but if I could go back in time I would've just bought the Icon set instead. I tend to avoid using them unless I have to.
A lot of their hand tools are getting better. I got the big quinn set to put together a to-go kit with as few skips as possible and they've been very nice to use.
Also one major thing I feel that is missing from all of these discussions every time "Amazon" comes up is that different types of stores have different value propositions. IMO for the bulk of their products, HF's is that you're paying a bit extra (even after sales/coupons/etc game) for more predictable quality compared to hit-or-miss GENSYM brands on Amazon/eBay/AliExpress.
I'll probably end up cancelling my membership at one point in the future because I won't have the need for tools as frequently, but I tend to go at least once every couple of months since I work on my cars and fix stuff around my old house.
In regards to the physical location, I recently purchased a sectional online. The store had a showroom at the mall, so we could test the comfort of the couch and its various add-ons. We ended up going with that store vs comparable online options because we actually understood what we were getting.
The only disappointing part of the process was that there is no incentive to purchase the couch from the physical location. I was looking to get a commission for the store while also maybe scoring a free add-on, but the employee said there was no point because they don’t get commission and they don’t give out add-ons. It’s a bummer because I want to reward the location for its help and keep it running, but it was a worse experience to do so.
But I remember back then it wasn't unusual to see a retail price sticker at $59 the shop, to find the exact same thing on Amazon for $19.90.
We figure staff walking around doing nothing need paid, prime real estate isn't cheap, even when the shop is empty.
When I was growing up you might have a nearby mall with e.g. Babbages or similar, and there were a handful of other stores that might have stuff you wanted (Radio Shack, Service Merchandise, Toys-R-Us actually had computer equipment for a little while; I've never seen a Microcenter or a Fry's), but you were still limited to whatever they had locally. If you wanted something else you ordered it from their catalog and you could pick it up later. The catalog was always bigger than the local stock.
And before all the e-tail stuff, in my hometown, there literally was no place to buy a chassis fan, RAM, thermal paste, CPU, or motherboard. Eventually newegg showed up, thank God, because I was able to upgrade my Dell box with better parts eventually.
I feel like people complaining about how e-tail is inferior must've spent their whole lives in the Bay Area, Chicago, or new York City. Must've been nice not having to spend six hours in the car just to buy a hard drive.
The problem in Sweden where I am is that it's close to impossible to find certain type of items, and Amazon has thousands available for next day delivery. Also things like German products, which are often very good, is easily accessible, while the Swedish stores all carry the exact same inventory more or less.