upvote
Hank Green taught me that it’s often ethane they flare and it’s one of the reasons recycling plastic is currently uneconomical https://youtu.be/325HdQe4WM4?t=319&si=FEDgBApNlEFdwox_
reply
Besides being currently uneconomical, the process of recycling plastic is way worse for the environment than simply using virgin plastic and throwing it in the landfill. Energy used to recycle, chemicals used and discharged, water used, microplastic leaching and discharges.
reply
Sounds as if plastic should not be used at all, or at least heavily minimised.
reply
The plastic industry spent a lot of money astroturfing “recycling” and then doing ad campaigns to shift blame for littering into individuals and off of the producers of single use materials, right before flooding the world with a tidal wave of plastic.
reply
I've often thought that the company that sells the packaged item should be just as responsible for the packaging as they are for the product. Similarly to Post Offices etc. being responsible for the plastic bags they supply to send packages in (which isn't the case but equally should be).
reply
Long term plastic products are probably OK. It's the packaging where it's pain in the ass.

Where I live in New Zealand soft plastic is not being accepted in recycling bins (plastic bags haven't been available in shops for years now), but our local recycling center does. So now instead of dumping it into rubbish I now have a separate bin for it. It has reduced our rubbish output by like 2 or 3x. Once we off disposable nappies and if centralized composting is implemented (for stuff like bones) - I don't see us producing much rubbish at all. I know of people who are the same, perhaps producing a bag every few months. It's not that hard. Sounds crunchy af, but we didn't have to bend our life around it.

reply
In the end, how much of that separated recycling ends up in the trash anyway?
reply
Nearly all of the plastic, likely.

What I also want to know is, in the US where most cities now do commingled recycling, what percentage of the paper from residential recycling is salvageable, once it's been tossed into containers and then trucks with 10,000 dirty yogurt containers, beer cans, etc. If even one person doesn't dutifully rinse and dry their garbage (oops, 'recycling') it's sure to make most of the paper that's collected a hopeless mess.

If it were up to me, metal and glass should be recycled; plastic is for the landfill. Pretending otherwise doesn't change anything.

reply
Often the case for glass as well. Definitely not the case for aluminum.
reply
Glass is extremely recyclable. Not as much as aluminum (which takes prodigious amounts of electricity to convert from ore to metal) but it's still far fewer steps to melt existing glass than mine silicates and additives.
reply
Glass is nearly infinitely recyclable.

A major obstacle with recycling glass is that the raw materials are very, very cheap (silica sand, mostly), and the places that make glass are often located where they are because there's a source of it nearby.

It often costs more to return used glass than to dig up more more sand and melt that instead.

reply
The actual recycling is straightforward but it's a lot of weight and the sorting is a barrier.
reply
Can crush glass and use to in tarmac to make roads more hardwearing too
reply
exactly what i want in my roads...
reply
Glass and its molecular foundations are in a lot of places you might not expect. Insulation, sand, microchips, obviously in fiberglass, filters, etc. No reason to avoid its industrial applications just because it has a macro-scale amorphous form that can cut you.
reply
AFAIK it ends up in roadbeds way more often than it gets melted down to be recycled into new glass. Seems to work okay.
reply
A lot of it is propane too, left over from cracking stuff down to make polyethylene.

So in theory my 4.6 litre V8 Range Rover is a net-zero-emission vehicle. I'm just burning the gas that would have gone up the flare stack somewhere else, in smaller quantities - a flare stack burns enough gas for me to do 250 miles every ten seconds.

reply
> So in theory my 4.6 litre V8 Range Rover is a net-zero-emission vehicle

1. "Net zero" is a bogus concept generally. Greenhouse gas emissions happen, and they don't get cancelled out by other activities.

2. We should avoid burning hydrocarbon gasses without carefully and efficiently sequestering the resulting CO_2.

3. ... and of course we should use less hydrocarbon gasses generally, methane included, so we don't _get_ quantities of ethane we have nothing to do with.

reply
What's the opportunity cost of doing all that versus the opportunity cost of not doing it? IMHO the second is smaller than the first by a long way.
reply
Not a good theory.
reply
Nope, you don’t get to use that theory for your car because I use it for my plane.
reply
You'd need to pipe it somewhere. Or make it into LNG but my impression is that's crazy expensive so it's nowhere close to plausible.

You need a specific destination for the pipe, and then capex is proportional to the distance, but the revenue for the gas is proportional to volume of gas produce. So there's going to be a cut-off where you don't make enough gas to be worth building a pipeline and flares are more economical.

reply
It's cheaper to flare it in Texas then use it so one doesn't have to pay out to mineral rights owners. Some leases have covenants about what to do with stranded gas.

In Oklahoma we have way less flair gas as chapter 10 of the Oklahoma Register prohibits wasting oil and gas. That and we are a gas state more then oil.

I grew up in oil and gas. And different times over my tech career worked in the field on tech. So much I view it as a computer.

reply

  >It's cheaper to flair it in Texas then use it so one doesn't have to pay out to mineral rights owners.
By selling just oil, do they not have to pay out to the mineral rights owners?

Or is the full explanation more complex? Seems like it must be.

FYI flair vs flare, then vs than

reply
Ha got me on the flare. Just brain dump and didn't read.

They pay the oil royalties but collecting the gas for at least a decade hasn't been worth selling as pipelines are almost always over capacity. Assuming there is a collector on the well pad and pipes.

The Waha Hub prices have hit zero. (Ref -https://www.hartenergy.com/midstream-energy-infrastructure/h...)

It is why Chevron is very willing to build DCs behind the meter.

Permian base has like 200-300TcF of gas reserves about double Oklahoma. This includes unconventional.

Last year's estimate is .101 TcF was flared last year Permian. (From some miners - Gas flaring in the Permian Basin, 2025 https://permianchain.com/data/flaring/permian/)

reply
I know that natural gas distribution pumping stations use natural gas to power themselves. The first problem with will head gas is that it's not refined, so what sort of generator do you put it in, and the second is now the additional potential ignition source on the site is near the ground instead of however many stories high they typically build those.
reply

  >as pipelines are almost always over capacity
Thanks! And the student was enlightened. :)

Basically gases are ~1000x less dense than liquids, and we're paying for energy not volume. Q.E.D.

reply
'Flair' has more _flair_ than 'flare'.
reply
There are a couple of companies that do partnerships to do something with the flares but it's certainly not ubiquitous.

And the question when anyone starts doing a thing is whether they will be able to keep doing it once investors want their money back.

reply
For the right price, I'm sure they would or do collect it
reply
crypto miners now turned inference sellers have been building next to flare gas operations for half a decade

bitcoin causing less emissions than what was already occurring, in those areas

we will probably see a resurgence of this with the new Democrat railroad commissioner in texas, basically the flaring industry was getting indefinite waivers to keep polluting as the agency was captured, but the new administration may be very strict, which means flare gas fields will either need to shut down many operations or accelerate partnerships with miners that want to use that energy

reply
Why would the emissions be less? Whether you're burning the gas in a flare or burning it to produce power, it's still burned, right? Do the power plants burn it more completely, or are they doing carbon capture?

Or do you mean less net emissions, assuming that bitcoin mining would have otherwise been powered by other means?

reply
Presumably it's the latter. The useful work of bitcoin mining now being powered by the otherwise wasted flare. It's kind of great actually. But if it's so easy to generate electricity from these flares, why aren't we doing flare-powered electricity generation all over the place and just pushing net-power back to the grid? Oil derricks must be wired for power, so why aren't we plugging stirling engine generators into the grid and feeding that power back?
reply
I think because the grid connections would be uneconomical. These sites tend to be somewhat remote, and you'd need significant transmission lines to feed back the amount of power generated, which would ultimately be obsolete once the well was dry. (And just using it to power the oil operation itself wouldn't use enough power to be worth it or to use up the flare gas.)

But if you can relatively cheaply set up a large consumer on site, then it makes sense. I wonder if we could do mini data centers like this.

reply
So the math usually breaks down that as expensive as power is for a data center, having equipment idling is even more expensive.

We've had many talks over the decades about people moving server load around from areas of high power cost and/or temperature to areas of low cost and/or temperature based on live tracking, but every time someone has showed me the math that it's not even close to economical.

Then add the extra complication in the US of CAPEX versus OPEX, which I still don't understand why we've made it so complex, as it seems to completely eliminate some business models.

reply
What are the fundamental differences between data center and crypto workloads that makes it work for the latter but not the former? I guess the former would need better network infrastructure, for one thing. But both seem like they should be fairly similar on the CAPEX vs OPEX front, no?

I'm also not sure the associated gas from oil wells is actually that intermittent? I think at least in some cases it can produce power pretty consistently. Just not forever.

reply
There are different kinds of stranded power. A gas flare has, I presume, an expected average rate of production per day and if that is either stable or you provide a reservoir, you can install enough hardware to consume the median output, and then cross your fingers it will be depreciated before the well is exhausted. Not knowing much about wells (mostly only as pertains to GG emissions), I can't say if that's likely or virtually guaranteed, but I think we can deduce it's at least very likely, since it's already being attempted.

Then there's stranded solar and wind, and hydro, where either the grid cannot use the current power, or the transmission lines aren't rated to handle peak power. Those would all idle your equipment quite often, particularly in the case of peak shaving. Or conversely, if there's a power station you want to run as base load and keep running even when demand sags, and so you get a discount based on the cost difference between the producer's other options.

Perhaps some day we will have a thermal battery that is sufficient to vary the power draw of a datacenter by banking or expelling heat on a cost/benefit basis, but the heat pumps are only a fraction of the total power draw, so getting more than a 25% discount on net power draw seems unlikely, and then subtract travel time for maintenance and administration, theft prevention, etc, probably doesn't work out.

reply
Do you want high voltage power lines next to your oil well?
reply
Amortization.

The problem of course comes later when the wasteful industry has proven that the stranded resource can be recovered but has long term contracts with enough locations that newer, better uses for that resource cannot do so.

But then you get into the, "If a tree falls in the forest" problem because would anyone else have actually moved on this if they hadn't?

reply
If only there was a way to turn free energy into money.
reply