upvote
I left with more questions than anything else after reading this piece. Maybe that's just the nature of the event, no one knows what will happen.
reply
Browse some of his "things I will not work with" articles, to get a flavor or for sheer entertainment. I think he's set the standard for all others to follow in science blogging. But I think he does assume a little bit of conversance in chemistry.
reply
[flagged]
reply
You can't be serious. Typos have nothing to do with whether something is explained well. In both the cited cases, the intent of the sentence is obvious to anyone with even a passable understanding of the English language.
reply
An editor would catch such things. But I guess that's just not valuable enough to the business, idk.
reply
Seems hyperbolic. In fact it's the people with only a passable understanding of English who are the ones most likely to be confused by a typo. They're the ones we should be trying to help.

You say the meaning/intent is obvious. Know what else is obvious? Typos. One reads one's own work, spots the typo, and fixes it. What's so hard? Typos don't deserve to be defended and protected the way HN defends and protects them. A typo means someone couldn't even be arsed to read once through what they wrote. So why should I?

reply
> In fact it's the people with only a passable understanding of English who are the ones most likely to be confused by a typo.

I think you're speculating from a bit of a patronizing perspective. In my experience, the people most likely to be "confused" by a typo like these are people who enjoy being obnoxious about archaic grammatical rules and wield their pedantry for clout.

To be clear, I understand that some typos are genuinely problematic because they actually change the meaning of the sentence. But none in this article were of such a nature.

> Typos don't deserve to be defended and protected the way HN defends and protects them.

My "defense" of the typos is rooted in the parent comment's remark, which I found unhelpful and condescending without purpose. It's one thing for someone to point out typos for the author to fix; it's another to respond to someone praising the article with a claim that the content of the article is fully invalidated by the remnants of a few wayward keypresses that had little to no impact on the actual message.

As in all matters of communication, context is critical. But perhaps, like the parent commenter, you find it more worth your time to remove relevant context and rail against a straw man than to actually engage thoughtfully with the ongoing discussion. I don't think that's a very positive way to participate in a community.

reply
Parent comment has been flagged to death, so I can't see it. There are thoughtful and helpful (i.e. "good") ways of bringing it up, and not-so-good ones. Maybe this was a case of the latter. One thing though that should be obvious to all parties and not need saying is that a grammar/spelling/usage complaint is precisely not the act of engaging with the content of the text. It's a separate point. I would even say a lesser point, agreeing with what you hint at. But making it off-limits unfortunately enshrines poor workmanship as unassailable. Nonetheless, HN thinks the lesser point is boring and distracting, well fair enough, but then can we also get rid of all the comments speculating and complaining about what was or wasn't AI-written? That's just as "meta" as the English stuff.
reply
Typos in this age can also be a human attempting to convince the reader they didn't post AI slop, or it can also be AI attempting to seem more human.

(To me, the silent downvotes indicate some people want to hoard this little trick for themselves)

reply
I did not down vote you, but I can understand those who did.

Your default is to assume bad-faith. "Obviously, no human would bother to put out writing into the world. It must be a trick, where they instructed the LLM to deliberately insert errors so as to throw me off the track. Not today, clanker!"

The man has been posting for decades. Sharing his expertise in a humorous and relatable way that makes it approachable to those with only a modicum of chemistry knowledge.

reply
> Your default is to assume bad-faith.

Inaccurate. I merely listed other possibilities besides what had been suggested. Any of them are possible, and all have happened before.

reply
Feel free to ignore him.

I feel my world is easier to understand, because I don’t.

He’s also quite funny.

reply