upvote
I'm picturing a giant tent with a lot of slack in the walls and negative air pressure applied with filtered vacuum systems before and after the detonation.

I imagine building a sufficiently large tent to not just get destroyed by the explosion would be an engineering marvel that we don't have time for.

reply
It’s an explosive. It will produce its own pressure and pop the metaphorical balloon you confine it with.

And any “real” confinement would just make it more explosive when it fails.

reply
I was thinking about if you arranged huge pipes leading from the edge of a large circle round the area, with huge fans sucking the air from the centre of the area through filters. Then as long as the plume gets sucked back before it leaves the circle, it still goes through the filter. But as well as the massive engineering task, it relies on the plume not rising very high.
reply
Maybe, rather than a structure to hold the tent fabric far enough away from the blast that it doesn't get vaporized, we should make a giant pile of soap bubbles. The dampening effect these have on explosions is discussed here: https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/877732
reply
It's the equivalent of about 3000-4000 pounds of TNT, or 1.3-1.8 tons of TNT. And like TNT lead azide is a high explosive, so you get very intense shock waves

I would expect piling as much concrete, soil and water around it as you can without disturbing it is useful, but containing it completely would be difficult

reply
What about water? Can we instead build a sufficient perimeter and fill it with water to a depth that it’s effectively entombs it during the detonation? We can then drain the water and remove the debris?
reply
This is a very bad idea. Water would not be contained is the worst possible thing to contaminate.
reply
It’s insoluble in water, and water facilitates the formation of HN3 gas which is about as deadly as cyanide gas.
reply
What if we used water that is already contaminated?
reply
Then you get even more contaminated water seeping into the local ground supply. The problem with this idea is the existence of contaminated water, not the specific source of contamination.
reply
So spraying it as a fine dust all over cropland for fifty miles is better?
reply
Then letting it seep into the water table, where it will be taken up into those plants and will be harder to remediate? Yes, it is.
reply
What will happen to that dust when it rains?
reply
The article said the plan is to have water spraying on top to contain the dust when they detonate
reply
The disaster already happened.

The proposition is what is the best bad scenario.

There’s a former military depot a couple towns over where they dump drums of dioxin in the ground. Remediation for that entails operating a series of chillers that’s creating a wall of ice underground, and they’re then gonna be pumping water in and out of the most impacted areas for the next 25 years.

reply
What happens in 26 years? Does the stuff neutralise somehow?
reply
The solution to pollution is dilution.
reply
By why is that the solution after 25 years, and not now?
reply
Because continuing a process for 25 years has a much larger total effect than only running it for a few months.
reply
Rinse and repeat for 25 years. Presumably the ppm will be so low after 25 years, it's no longer harmful.
reply
No such thing, but presumably what that actually means is that the harm will be spread out into a slightly elevated background harm level.
reply
That's not a whole lot actually. The story seems like a nothingburger? Eventually it'll be detonated and...that's it, forgotten because nothing else came from it.
reply
I think they are wanting to avoid creating a plume of lead, in case there would be ways
reply
It's basically already buried. I wonder how long it would take to double the mass of the cover, and how likely that would be to trigger a detonation (lots of vibration with heavy machinery).
reply
I also wonder about building up instead of down. Basically, I think you would pick a sufficiently wide area around the whole facility and then entomb the whole inner facility in a shit-ton of concrete and then detonate it. But, doing that would be very expensive and time-consuming. I kinda get the feeling that they want to blow this up partially because they actually have no idea when it's going to blow up on its own, and they want to say that it was controlled.
reply
> want to say that it was controlled

Not just "say". By choosing when it goes off, you can be picking favorable weather conditions, misting, and warning people downwind (to the extent there is any wind) to stay away or indoors.

reply
All the necessary heavy machinery and vibrations could set it off and kill the people working to entomb it.

And then you get a plume of lead in the air at a random time of day, with random wind conditions, temperature inversions, etc.

This is the kind of stuff where, if you look at it funny, it goes off.

reply
They are on a timer. Lead azide destabilizes further in cold temperatures.
reply
Containing explosions can lead to more damage in the short term/local area due to more debris being flung about.
reply
Because unless you're planning on having ants bury it one sand grain at a time, the vibrations of the machinery used or even the settling of the material you are burying it under would likely be enough to detonate the lead azide crystals.
reply
The article says that it may go boom while you try to dump stuff on it. Uncontrolled boom at random weather seems to be bad.
reply
Wait a few more years and get some drone dozers in there on good days. Maybe plant lots of trees and wait. Create a big pond over it. Seems like we didn’t put a lot of effort into this.
reply
We may not have years. Nobody knows when this is gonna go, but something's gonna cause it to happen eventually as the crystals keep degrading.
reply
> Seems like we didn’t put a lot of effort into this.

We didn’t. This was run for profit and mitigation costs money.

reply
You can buy remote control heavy equipment today.
reply
deleted
reply
Some are worried it might self detonate from temperature changes this winter.
reply
I nominate you to bury it.
reply
Burial is a long process that requires heavy equipment and moving the explosive, all of which risks detonation while there is a crew on site doing the burial. Too dangerous.
reply
I also felt like that question wasn't answered.

But I wouldn't want to be the person operating the heavy machinery required to bring in tons of dirt and concrete and to spread it around. I don't know for sure, but I imagine the vibrations involved wouldn't be good for safety - and even if it's fine, you still are working on top of a time bomb.

reply
How do you bury something in concrete that you can’t shock even a little bit?
reply
By slowly pumping concrete on top of the structures it's already in...
reply
What if the expert chemists have already thought of literally everything us armchair spectators could possibly conceive of?
reply
I'd have a lot more faith in that if the armies approach wasn't to simply not tell the vast majority of the people who are going to be affected until the last second. And if their approach wasn't "do approximately nothing".

This reads a lot more like the people in charge are looking for the cheap and easy way out.

reply
This wasn’t the army’s creation. A private company cooked this up.
reply
The initial situation is not entirely the army's creation. The past 9 months of lack of communication and lack of action are entirely the army's responsibility - they've been handling it since then.

It's a shitty situation they found - that doesn't make their handling appropriate.

reply
Could be because, the minute they tell everyone, a bazillion armchair spectators will come out of the woodwork to demand answers to why it can't be done this or that other way and find a hundred ways to gum up the works in the courts for months or years when the appropriate experts had already correctly decided that this was the least-bad possible way and every hour of additional delay creates more risk of an even worse situation.

For an excellent example of this, see this very HN thread, which is chock-full of people doing exactly that (though minus the court cases), when the whole thread is a link to a short and clear article written by an expert in the field and world-class communicator that explains exactly why this is the best way to do it.

reply
I'd imagine you'd have to do it via remote control and be prepared for the eventuality that it goes boom early. That still seems worth it.
reply
Time is the problem. If we do a controlled technician now, we know exactly when it happens and so we can ensure that the weather conditions are the best possible.

If you try and encase this in something, the vibrations are going to happen over the months of building. If we could encase it within 10 minutes, no problem, we choose the day and either it goes from vibration; or it's encased and we're fine. The problem is, building a structure like this would take months, and at any time during construction, you risk that the wrong vibration happens the whole thing goes, possibly, on the worst possible day.

reply