upvote
I used to have your viewpoint, but then I worked in a large ineffective organization. You really do want someone who is a tyrant, and who can motivate people to move quickly.

In my case, leadership encouraged a lot of toxic empathy. We didn’t make hard decisions and didn’t move fast enough. We ultimately laid off a few thousand people.

I believe in the full utilitarian calculus it’s better to have a few people get verbal lashings than have many people lose their livelihood.

A common rebuttal is that maybe you don’t need to abuse people, or cause them to be afraid. But if this is the case I haven’t seen it work in practice. People in big organizations need to be scared for their jobs to burn the midnight oil, change course, or take risk. The alternative is that the organization stagnates and dies.

reply
> I believe in the full utilitarian calculus it’s better to have a few people get verbal lashings than have many people lose their livelihood.

But this is a false dilemma. You can have both civilized discussion instead of verbal abuse and have people keep their jobs. It's just as simple as "You risk losing your job if..." rather than "I'll rip your arms off..." etc.

I worked with both these kinds of PHBs and in general the latter had worse staff as the talent preferred to work in more civilized environment. (But these were engineers, maybe middle management doesn't care.)

reply
>People in big organizations need to be scared for their jobs to burn the midnight oil, change course, or take risk. The alternative is that the organization stagnates and dies.

Your claim is a false dichotomy. An organisation that relies on emotional manipulation and implicit threats to keep the gears turning is a deeply dysfunctional company. The common retort is Apple and Steve Jobs but this is a case of survivorship bias more than anything else.

reply
I used to have your viewpoint, but then I worked in a large ineffective organization into which came a tyrant, who could motivate people to move quickly.

And, guess what, then it was a large ineffective organization with made worse by waves of incoherent fear-motivated action rippling down the org chart as the people with the most direct contact with the tyrant moved rapidly to sooth his most recent rage directed at them and/or prevent the next.

Abuse doesn't solve structural problem, and the quick defensive reactions it motivates don't diagnose and find and implement resolutions for complex problems spanning multiple domains within a large organization, instead it exacerbates the trends of internal competition, fiefdom building, and acting in narrow immediate local self-interest that make large organizations inefficient.

reply
Whatabout toxic empathy is absurd attempt to deflect from ... straight toxicity and verbal abuse.
reply
Disagree.

Justin Trudeau - the Prime Minister of Canada made his adult female (and very progressive) Cabinet Members cry because they used he word 'crazy' to describe something odd.

He belittled them because they shouldn't be so 'offensive' to people with mental disabilities.

Now this is a form of 'toxic leadership' - and by the way a form of 'Woke Toxicity' - doubly degrading because the whole point would be nominally empathetic to people, but instead, he became toxic.

It's perfectly reasonable for some people to use the term 'crazy' and you don't get to destroy people because of some ridiculously high minded supposed 'social principle'.

If the word 'crazy' is offensive - then everything is offensive - and that is how toxic PC culture comes to the fore - by ignoring context.

1) dressing someone down because they are no up to a standard is perfectly legitimate - in context.

2) 'language' itself is contextual. Calling someone an 'idiot' is nominally wrong, but if anyone that I knew at work said 'oh my god you idiot, you pushed and broke he build' - that would be only technically inappropriate because I would not care. If it were done in a degrading, bullying manner - no, I would not tolerate that, but my boss - who is a good and competent person, saying that in colloquial terms ... I wouldn't care.

I don't care if people swear or use creative metaphors.

Some people are offended by use of any gendered language.

3) Humiliation is contextual. In some cultures any public disrespect is very troubling aka 'face saving culture'. In others, complete opposite.

The 'frankness' of Fins, Dutch, German would be considered toxic by some.

4) Proportionality. It's possible that some of he things hat Steve Jobs did was wrong - it doesn't mean we fire him over it. People have a lot of variation, they are going to 'cross lines'. Crossing lines itself has to be put in context. Jobs famously allowed people to 'push back on him' - and that is probably the truest test.

If Jensens was holding people up and calling them 'losers' in front of everyone aka "Ok, Amanda failed her objectives, she is the loser of the week this week - Amanda, explain to everyone why you are such a loser and how you're going to make up for it?" <- this might be considered 'tough leadership' by some - but that's just plain toxic an unnecessary.

Alternatively - Jensen highlighting 'The bottom 10% of sales performers' aka "At the bottom we have John, Chen, Suzie and Ricardo. Again Ricardo - this is two weeks in a row - this is not good ..." <- that's a bit questionable, but it's not toxic and frankly it's totally in bounds, and the kind of thing where you 'choose to work there or not'.

reply
Isn't it mostly bad when the attribution falls to the person ("you're crazy" or "you idiot") and less so, even tolerable, when the attribution falls to the action ("that's a crazy thing to do" or "that's idiotic")?

Or is this concern about where the attribution lands "toxic PC" in your view?

reply
There's a subtle difference between the use of term as you have indicated, but in this case it was a woman using the term 'crazy' in reference to something not calling someone 'crazy'.

It's a very clear cut example of Toxic PC culture and also a 'double example' of him being 'actually abusive' in the pursuit of ostensibly cultural empathy.

I do not think his belittling in that way is justifiable as 'locker room talk' - however the use of the term 'crazy' is colloquially acceptable language aka 'locker room talk'.

reply
What did he call crazy?
reply
Trudeau did not call anyone crazy - he chastised people for using the term.

He would yell at and belittle his staff - female Cabinet Members, who were by the way ultra-progressive empathetic 'woke' types for arbitrary use of what he deemed 'inappropriate and offensive language'.

This is the 'double example': someone doing something actually 'toxic' but doing it in the name of hyper high minded PC culture, aka use of an 'insensitive term' , in this case the word 'crazy'.

As in: 'Wow, that's really crazy!'

You wouldn't put the term 'crazy' in a Public Communication - but you can say that in private language, obviously.

But the PC police can come on hard for any deemed offence.

It's very plausible - especially in government - that someone takes up the Public Sector Union and HR because 'someone somewhere used he word crazy'.

This is PC toxicity and it's real.

It does not justify calling people ugly names etc - obviously. But 'context matters'.

reply
So Trudeau said "don't call things crazy, because it's inappropriate" and the "PC woke police" responded to that with "omg! Trudeau said 'crazy', that's inappropriate!"? Sorry, this explanation doesn't add up.
reply
> What context exactly?

The context that favors one's own favorite narcissist, sociopath, etc.

reply
Because so many have carried the water for Elon Musk and Zuckerberg? I'm not defending it, but the double standard is obvious here.

By all means, take us to a timeline where none of this is acceptable, anyone, Bueller?

The downvotes have unanimously concluded that the hypocrisy will continue until morale improves.

reply
You're assuming an "acceptable" binary that just doesn't exist. Musk and Zuckerberg have structured their companies in such a way that they can't be removed from the top; Nvidia is structured differently than that, so its executives are subject to different standards.

Which is fine! Different companies should be free to organize themselves as they see fit. It's only scary to the gaggle of VCs and tech execs because they believe that it's unconscionable to have a powerful board of directors; in their view, anyone who founds a company and makes it really big is morally entitled to lead it for however long they'd like.

reply
Funny, I got downvoted for pointing out exactly your assertion in another thread. But I agree with you so I guess we both need to be downvoted to demonstrate the error of our ways. I don't make the rules, I just note them.
reply
deleted
reply
> I'm not defending it

Are you sure?

reply
So this is your way of saying what's wrong for Jensen Huang is OK for Musk and Zuckerberg? Jensen yells at people who disappoint him whilst following the letter of trade laws while Musk fires those who disagree with him on the spot and cuts off Starlink to Ukraine, and Zuck lives in his own deluded timeline, happy to meddle in the politics of other nations to deliver shareholder value.

What did I miss?

reply