upvote
This comment needs to be made more frequently. Nobody acknowledges the consumerist risks in AI job destruction. Henry Ford famously recognised he needed his workers to afford the cars he made.
reply
It’s off topic, and it also makes no sense. Why wouldn’t there be jobs? All the past times new automation arrived, there were still jobs. The jobs simply change. Why? Because we don’t stop wanting to buy things as automation makes things cheaper. We just buy more
reply
People make this argument all the time without being able to give specific examples of what jobs will remain. I'm not talking about what jobs will remain in 3-5 years when we are all still interfacing with AIs in similar ways we are today, I'm talking about for our kids in 20-30 years when AI can run billion dollar businesses totally autonomously with robotics.
reply
> People make this argument all the time without being able to give specific examples of what jobs will remain. I'm not talking about what jobs will remain in 3-5 years when we are all still interfacing with AIs in similar ways we are today, I'm talking about for our kids in 20-30 years when AI can run billion dollar businesses totally autonomously with robotics.

Businesses must be competitive. If they all use the same AI model, then they’ve lost all competitive advantage by using it. The only advantage left is the inputs that go into the AI model. Who supplies those?

Since you’re asking for examples, let’s talk about marketing. You cannot fully automate this. It’s a zero sum game. It’s like if all business owners decided to pick a really good marketer named Steve. Steve could probably come up with some bangers for a few clients, but once every business is asking Steve for marketing, it all looks the same.

High end fashion brands like Gucci, Prada, Louis Vuitton, are perfect examples of this. Why would I buy such an expensive bag from them? AI is never going to be the reason because fashion is not rational, even if it’s the one constructing the bag

reply
> If they all use the same AI model, then they’ve lost all competitive advantage by using it.

In the next 3-5 years, sure, but that's not the long term vision I see. I think it's more likely we'll see the Anthropics/OAI/Google/Meta/XAIs of the world stop selling tokens. Instead they are the ones offering wider ranges of SaaS products, starting quant trading operations, taking over media (even more than today), developing new pharmaceuticals, etc. GPT 12 or Gemini Francium can and will tighten the RL loop by improving robotics, and have billions of dollars to offer armies of humans to fill the gaps where needed, until it no longer needs humans.

> let’s talk about marketing. You cannot fully automate this

Marketing is one of the most easily automatable jobs there is. AI is already capable of designing commercials, making cold calls, buying ads. Sure, they suck right now and are weird, but in 20-30 years when all of society has been so permeated with AI, AI will be more capable and also people will be way more accepting of AI.

reply
Fully agree: it's not a law of the universe that automated jobs are guaranteed to have a replacement.

I even find contradicting claims within software companies: that agents will boost productivity 10x, so they don't need to hire so many people. But if it made people 10x as productive, the maths say they could hire 10x the people to become 100x as productive! Shouldn't they do this and do circles around their competition?

(a counter argument is the productivity claims mean it's multiplied in general but not exactly per head... But I don't see many nuanced arguments, just "accept or leave").

reply
> I'm talking about for our kids in 20-30 years when AI can run billion dollar businesses totally autonomously with robotics.

This isn't going to happen. You're in the middle of a hype cycle.

reply
Then why are young graduates not getting hired anymore?
reply
It's tough to respond to an unsourced claim with anything meaningful. Here are some possible answers to your question that don't jump all the way to the conclusion that AI will end the concept of employment:

1) Your claim is false. At least at my company, we are still doing the "intern to full-time hire after graduation if we like you" pipeline that we've always been doing. Does my one anecdote defeat your zero anecdotes? I don't know.

2) The companies are caught up in the hype. They're trying to find out what it's good at and what it's not. As reality comes back online and prices go up, they'll find reasons to hire humans again.

3) Money is no longer free (ZIRP is over) so there is less experimenting and less hiring and less mobility between employers, meaning fewer openings completely independently of the AI stuff.

There's many explanations that don't require falling for the AI hype cycle.

reply
The Riemann Hypothesis was just proven yesterday by AI and people still say this is a “hype cycle”
reply
Yeah. We're still figuring out what it's good at and what it's not good at. It seems to be decent at things with concrete correctness claims, like math & basic programming, but it still needs lots of assistance even in those fields, and it's actually quite bad at maintaining large projects. It is absolutely miserable at fields with less concrete correctness, like writing, or creating attractive art & media. It's also very expensive. Once they stop giving it away for free and start actually charging money for it, I suspect reality will settle in and we'll see it used where it's actually appropriate, and abandoned where it's actually not very good and/or too expensive. It's a cool tech, we can do things with it that we couldn't do before, but it's not magic and it's not going to end the economy.
reply
In 20-30 years those NFTs will finally be worth millions too and we'll all be prosperous and trading monkey jpegs, right?

Predictions about the medium term future on HN are ridiculous. 95% of them are mindless drek, 4% are weak claims, and 1% have anything close to reality baked in and might be reasonable.

reply
It was obvious to everyone during the NFT craze that they were worth zero; this is much closer to the creation of the Internet or railroads. I hope I’m wrong about the long term trajectory of AI, but so far, there hasn’t been any sign of it slowing down or concrete areas where we are certain it will never out perform humans at a single task.
reply
In the past it actually took a generation or two until new jobs appeared and many people’s life were destroyed by automation.
reply
Actually way more, it took 80 years in the first industrial revolution and 70 years + mass exodus to the americas when machinery appeared in agricultural fields.
reply
Yes, it will be painful, but there will be jobs. I predict the younger generation will likely be better suited to adopt to this new world, because it will be easiest for them to start from scratch at a new paradigm, and less for them to lose by doing so
reply
I doubt it.

Younger generation had an edge previously because they could absorb how to use new tools, machines etc compared to someone older.

That's not the case here anymore.

Older people don't have any problem using AI. It's just AI don't need that many people. I don't think you can blindly apply what happened in the past to this case.

reply
Technology has been putting people out of work for centuries, and the economy and job market adjusted over time.

AI is no different, it's just people are swallowing the hype and getting hysterical. Certain things will be made more economical via AI which will create new opportunities which will in turn create other opportunities and new work.

The idea that AI will put everyone out of work is asinine.

reply
> It's just AI don't need that many people.

For some reason, people in this thread keep making this statement without providing any reason why they believe it

reply
Just look at the hiring stats for new grads. And compare it with pre ai era.
reply
reply
I am speaking from what I see in the industry. Junior developers age rarely getting hired. I don't know about these statistics. I think you can always cherry pick the data point.
reply
That’s actually been my point the whole time. The jobs change. New grads aren’t graduating with skills needed for the new world

If you don’t think using AI is a skill, then you haven’t used it enough

reply
AI use in programming is most definitely not a skill. Any average developer can be productive with AI given just a few weeks.
reply
What about factory employees and whats considered blue collar work now? How do they integrate AI and find future jobs?
reply
The big assumption is that AI makes money and people gets fired. They both have to be true for the AI industrial revolution narrative to become a reality.

If people didn't get fired, like they weren't with introduction of regular IT, then... the whole narrative will have to change.

reply
> If you don’t think using AI is a skill, then you haven’t used it enough

Everything requires some amount of skill, but if you think using AI requires some great skill, like a degree, then you're using it wrong.

More to the point different people will have different levels of productivity using AI, but that has more to do with their existing or different skills. For instance more experienced developers tend to be more productive with AI (but not always).

reply
> If you don’t think using AI is a skill, then you haven’t used it enough

If you think it is a skill, then you haven't used it enough.

FWIW, I use it plenty, and you're talking to a group of highly technical people who have probably also used it plenty.

reply
They're software engineers or adjacent.
reply
By painful, do you mean another Great Depression? Because a lot of societies just straight up did not survive that. Some nations are still trying to find their feet after that.

Saying its painful but things will be fine, comes across very... Farquaad.

reply
"Yes, it will be painful"

Like what are you insinuating this even means? Painful as in people starving to death painful or just painful as in no family vacations for a few years or a blend of both?

Are you saying that we just have to accept that as it is and nothing can be done about it?

reply
Clearly opinion of somebody unconcerned about existential crysis, maybe you milked those faang bonuses and are set for life or at least think so. When society crumbles around you full of desperate folks it won't matter much though, there is no fence high enough you can build around yourself.

Most people, especially with kids, don't share this attitude to keep things polite.

reply
> All the past times new automation arrived, there were still jobs.

Not for a generation or two, there weren't. Unless you have an example, I'm not buying this argument.

reply
This isn't fully correct, and the second part is focusing on cobsumption rather than the reason of employment: production.

In a fully mechanized/automated world, we won't work. It will make no sense to work. Im this scenario we have a wealth distribution problem. How do you decide who gets how much of what? Capitalism as we know it relies on cost of labour to distribute wealth.

Now, will AI be doing this? I don't think so. So I agree with you, it's going to increase productivity of a lot of jobs, but it will also create jobs. But we don't really know.

reply
> In a fully mechanized/automated world, we won't work. It will make no sense to work.

Your entire argument rests of this statement. Why wouldn't it make sense to work? How would one company differentiate its products from another if they're all using the same AI?

Let's take a contrived example. Let's say automation can produce yachts for all of us at affordable prices someday. We're just going to all own yachts then. What will be the reason for one person to choose one yacht over another? Branding, marketing, positioning, patents, regulations, etc. Who does that work? Humans. Because ultimately you're selling to humans in a human-controlled world, not machines.

reply
> Branding, marketing, positioning, patents, regulations, etc. Who does that work?

Why are humans needed for that?

reply
Marketing, branding, positioning are part of a zero sum game, so cannot be automated with the same AI model, otherwise you lose differentiation

Patents, regulations are decided by humans because we’re ruled by humans

reply
If you invest into/found a company to pay for the robots and tokens, you'll probably want to give it a specific direction instead of a random one. But yes, all the rest can probably be automated.
reply
Why do we assume humans will do the work? What's the inherent reason for this?

What I'm saying isn't anything new. It was a hot topic during abd after imdustrial revolution. Even Karl Marx joined the discussion and wrote about it. The key thing is, what is money and what determines the prices. If there's abundance, the problems you talked about start to occur and market cannot price the goods. This is, to some, abundance communism.

reply
>Why do we assume humans will do the work?

I suppose, at that point, the key inputs to a company become creativity and ambition (rather than, say, overall effort). Humans are still better at those than AI.

Humans would still direct branding/marketing/positioning while we control the overall creativity and ambition of a project/company.

If the only intent is to make money, then I suppose you could build machines that tweak the creativity & ambition in different ways to create different products & services, in which case you can argue no humans need to be in the loop.

reply
> Capitalism as we know it relies on cost of labour to distribute wealth.

But there is no pure capitalism and the government also redistributes wealth.

In an extreme(-ly unlikely) case of everything being automated the government would just redistribute the generated wealth to the populace (assuming a democracy). Apparently the end state of capitalism is socialism.

This is usually where people insist that the corporate overlords will take over and enslave everyone.

reply
> All the past times new automation arrived, there were still jobs.

The thing that these sentences miss are the time spans.

It took more than 80 years for the British workers to recover salary and occupation wise from the first industrial revolution.

It took 70 years for European economies (deep into the 1950s) to recover from machines entering agricultural fields. In the meantime tens of millions emigrated to the americas because there were simply no jobs.

And previous revolutions only arrived in specific sectors (industries or fields). Now workers are being attacked in every single sector at the same time.

Do you have several life times till the job markets correct? I don't.

reply
I feel like that’s such a echo chamber perspective though. You need consumers with some income to consume products made by some other consumers for an income so they can consume. Like I’m not even saying you’re wrong, it’s absolutely true that this system is built on those assumptions and it will likely collapse if those assumptions are breaking, and a sudden collapse is not desirable, but I don’t think this system should remain the way it is either.
reply
It really doesn't, not everything needs to be made about AI.
reply
> Nobody acknowledges

Yes they do. Constantly.

reply
And needed his workers to have enough leisure time to enjoy said cars. Hence the "generous" 2 day weekend us plebs have all been afforded.

If AI is coming for all our jobs why are more progressive politicians not screaming for a standard 4 day workweek?

In fact, we should be on a 3 day workweek by now.

Why are "they" only speaking about people having normal 5 day week jobs, or being completely replaced by AI - no middle ground? Surely this is the time to transition to working fewer days? Fucking bizarre.

reply
Maybe because people want to work less but then want the same pay, and then decide against it.

I choose to work only 4 days (for less pay obviously) and consume less (until automation makes more things cheaper), but it looks I'm alone with that choice.

reply
You seem to be forgetting the part where Ford's better working conditions were contingent on you accepting his "moral framework" policed by the company "Sociology Division", which would do things like visit your home to make sure you were a good american.

Also remember that to Ford, "good american" usually also meant things like "not jewish".

The reason Ford increased wages was because he had to retain labor. The work was hard and mind numbing and awful, so turnover was massive, so he raised wages to get workers to stay and actually benefit from them learning on the job. An assembly line actually works fairly poorly with green labor.

Ford raised wages because the system didn't work well with bottom tier labor. You couldn't treat your employees as super replaceable.

This of course has largely been forgotten by everyone to instead be replaced with stupid myths about his legacy.

reply
If full automation does come, you will buy the car for 1000$. Also, we are a long way from full automation, basically we need the next generation of AI, or even further than that. We will be all dead by then.
reply
deleted
reply
> We will be all dead by then.

Of old age or something else?

reply
Old age :)
reply
By AI. Probably. At least 10%. Sorry, couldn't resist..
reply
The economy will just increasingly supply the people who do have incomes, which are the owners of capital.
reply
Human wants are infinite and not all of them can be handled by machines, so I'm not that worried about jobs. For one thing, we can come back to the older mode of education, where, instead of teaching children in schools en masse as we do now, each child had a private tutor. This would increase the need for teachers (tutors) by a factor of 30x, an create tens of millions of jobs in the US alone.
reply
I wager that from a certain age, kids would learn more from a personal ai tutor than from the current form of schooling, at a fraction of the cost. (this only does not happen because we're all forced to go to public schools and pay for public schools, at least in Germany) Most people wouldn't want to pay for mediocre human teachers.
reply
We can, but what points towards anyone wanting to do that? We can already do that if we want, but we don't. We focus on cost cutting and optimizing everything. If only some technology could provide a personalized tutoring experience to our kids.
reply
Today it’s too expensive.
reply
And human labour cost changes because of complete automation? Maybe.

My point was basically that I only see us going the exact opposite direction of using more human labour. I don't see how that changes with more automation, I'm probably too pessimistic.

reply
As more goods get produced with heavy automation, they get cheaper, and we can afford more non-essential goods and services. For example, a century ago people spent amost of their income on food and shelter, whereas today it's only 35% (in the US). That's why today we get such professions as pet groomers, psychotherapists or landscapers, which either didn't exist a century ago or were the purview of only the top 1% - today many people can afford it, thanks to automation making our food very cheap.
reply
Yea that makes sense. Interesting to see how this plays out.
reply
Doesn't matter because we'll all have robot self driving cars. I mean, we won't all "have" them because we will be renting them and thus totally reliant on Alphabet or Tesla in order to move through the world. Never mind that tens of millions of people worldwide drive for a living who will be out of work, nor will any one have jobs to afford the Waymo/Cybercab service.
reply
Did jobs disappear forever after we invented the plow?
reply
This is not a good comparison. World has been growing the population and improving quality of life. This created thousands of new job categories. Current situation must be assessed on how many new jobs can be created. Will they last 15-25 years?

I like to imagine a new form of wealth distribution needed to ensure happy life for everyone- healthcare can become cheaper with AI for example. Could we fund healthcare for all?

reply
The U.K. has healthcare for all and it costs about the same per citizen that the US spends on Medicare just to cover a small number of people.
reply
Medicare covers 70.7 million people, just slightly more than the population of the UK.
reply
[dead]
reply
The plow only affected one industry. AI will affect every industry.
reply
I get your point that it was more localized than what AI offers, but the invention of the plow changed a lot more than one industry.

imagine the increased demand in animal husbandry, tool and die making, metalworking, woodworking, logistics and transportation, storage & food processing itself.

The secondary effects of any big jump like that rarely touch one portion of life.

reply
If there hadn't been an industrial revolution to soak up displaced farm labour things would have been pretty torrid when mechanisation hit Ag. thing is.. this time round there's a huge risk of displacement to automation and not many jobs the other side. Risk, not certaint.y
reply
The displacement of farm labour things is what created the Industrial Revolution.
reply
What displaced farm labour?
reply
Many jobs have disappeared forever because of technical advancements. I'm not sure what point you're trying to make.
reply
I think you just made it for me. Some jobs disappeared but jobs in general are here to stay.
reply
Anthropic employees said AI will kill everyone.
reply
At most a few employees, out of thousands, said that. Why would you attach any importance to what a couple of doomsayers said?
reply
Good point! Can you show me the correct postion to put my fingers back in my ears. Is there an optimal way?
reply
The plow very much did make some jobs obsolete. As did the power loom, and the washing machine, and the automobile, and many combinations of machinery in manufacturing and processing industries.

The objective and effect of the plow (and practically every tool humanity has ever made) was to improve the efficiency and efficacy of a single task. The objective of the AI hyperscalers is to create a tool that is capable of doing any arbitrary work. They want to abolish human effort as the last possible economic problem to solve - similarly to how cryptobros proselytized about the monetization of everything forever, hyperscalers are sticking their tech everywhere they possibly can to try and find places where it extracts money.

The argument this time around is stronger as the fundamentals are simpler and more practical and not a pipe dream. Cryptobros argued that you could "own" anything, as long as you and every other person alive agreed to jump through the stupidest hoops ever concieved and were fine with not actually owning things in any conventional sense and also you connect everything in the world to the internet because its Really Important™ that proof you bought a pack of gum is duplicated on millions of computers simultaneously. There are endless critiques of Web3 and crypto, but they all generally boil down to infeasibilty. The AI argument lacks this issue; real tangible work is being done profitably right now by machines. The uses of these machines can potentially be cheaper than paying a person to do this work. The work done may be done faster or better or cheaper (or some set of these) than if a human does it. Economic players recognize its potential value and are frothing at the mouth at the idea of never having to pay a person to do any work ever again. Employers don't want to pay people because people are generally their highest cost, and eliminating them for a cheaper alternative is their goal, and an economic inevitability.

reply
deleted
reply
BlackRock is thinking of solutions to this...
reply
Technology always increases total jobs. The coming orbital economy will see so much work to be done. People will be managers and leaders.
reply
[dead]
reply