upvote
To this point, I think an AutoZone and/or O’Reilly’s episode of Acquired would be incredible. The fact that I can drive down the street and get a random part for a 20 year old car is incredible. Sometimes walking out with it, sometimes from their distribution network.

They’re a Right to Repair aligned business model.

reply
> I see no reason why two different SUVs on 17-inch wheels need completely different brake pads shapes, when both sets have the same surface area, require the same performance profile, etc, but that's what we have now.

Because an SUV that has 17" wheels can weigh two tons or three tons or more. It can do 120 mph maximum speed or it can go to 160 mph or more.

The math changes really fast when it comes to stopping that SUV down based on those two parameters alone. You can see why different calipers, how many, brake disk size, type (ventilated or not), different sized brake pads.

reply
>> I see no reason why two different SUVs on 17-inch wheels need completely different brake pads shapes, when both sets have the same surface area, require the same performance profile, etc, but that's what we have now.

> Because an SUV that has 17" wheels can weigh two tons or three tons or more. It can do 120 mph maximum speed or it can go to 160 mph or more.

Didn't I address this objection in advance with the words "performance profile"?

Right now, 95% of SUVs have the same brake performance requirements: under 4 ton, under 160mph, etc. There is no cost saving in making an entirely different wheel assembly for SUVs that require under 3.99 tons and under 159mph, which is what the current manufacturers are doing.

reply
> Didn't I address this objection in advance with the words "performance profile"?

I did not understood your statement like that.

I don’t know about cost savings, but most likely it is about design decisions regarding how a wheel should look like (brake calipers in front of the wheel, in the back).

reply
> most likely it is about design decisions regarding how a wheel should look like (brake calipers in front of the wheel, in the back).

It's irrelevant in 95% of cars. All of the things I specified are irrelevant in 95% of cars.

reply
Brakes got big and dirverse because "muh handlig" and "muh moose test" (and "muh $500 replacement rim when you hit a curb) drive tire and rim size. Big rims add weight. So they make the brakes lighter by using a bigger diameter rotor and smaller/lighter caliper. The move from traditional spindles and/or press in bearings to bolt on unit bearings hasn't helped either since you're carrying around a few pounds of extra mounting flange.

A big honking cast iron caliper grabbing 12" rotor that mounts from the back of the hub (to reduce the hat diameter letting you have swept area right up to the wheel bolt circle) can really take some heat and the whole thing will package in a 16" rim. But it ain't gonna be light. I get that we're gonna have different "classes" of performance and you won't put that brake assembly on a new land rover even if it has comparable demands to the old van but there is a whole lot of room to consolidate here.

reply
They can like idk, use exact same capiler mounting brackets or mounting screws or pre-cut brake hoses or things like that for vans and trucks, then fit differently sized pads or even the whole calipers each.

That will eliminate like, technically different washers and nuts used for screws to mount the truck calipers that goes this way versus van calipers that comes through this here using slightly longer screws, and that kinds of things add up.

A lot of comment heree seem to be fixated on metal parts, but I think it's more about plastics and wires and electronics. If you could use a common harneess for compacts and sedans and trucks going forward and backward and across... saves a lot of inventory cost.

reply
There already is some commonality within manufacturers. Ever look under the hood or dashboard and notice a connector on the wiring harness that's not connected to anything? That's because they used the same harness as another model that needs that connector. It's cheaper to design, produce, stock, and manage one harness even if there's extra wire and connectors that aren't used on every car. It probably doesn't happen across manufacturers though, but there are SAE standard connector types at least.
reply