upvote
Jensen Huang literally said that AI can help us fight climate change, but it has has to first "inflict an enormous amount of pain and suffering first."

People are pushing forward with an illogical, destructive ideology, saying that somehow it will solve our problems AFTER it hurts/destroys us.

https://www.theverge.com/tech/1000140/jensen-huang-nvidia-ai...

reply
I know, it drives me crazy! I think the worst part is that we currently have the technology to reduce our climate impact but the likes of Anthropic etc are shunning them in favour of quick, and easy money.
reply
We are also able to solve world poverty but priority seems to be to make life easier for the 0.001 percentage who are already richer than they could ever spend.
reply
What a load of horse shit. We know how to build "clean" datacenters, it just costs a lot of money and these companies do not want to affect their bottom line of they don't have to. That is it.
reply
It's not illogical if you put a fancy name on it. Its Effective Altruism. Screw the real people today to supposedly benefit hypothetical people in the theoretical future.
reply
Similar to the lunatics that talk about colonizing mars as an escape from a destroyed Earth. Ideas with zero contact with reality.
reply
We need to terraform Mars even if it means mars-o-forming Earth!
reply
It’s a doomsday cult
reply
[dead]
reply
At the extreme you don't have much pollution when your population is decimated and what's left is starving so... It's right on some scale.
reply
I think OP’s point is that is a bad thing not that it’s incorrect.
reply
> when your population is decimated and what's left is starving so

That conveniently takes care of the obsolete worker drones. From the perspective of elites, it's a built-in solution.

reply
From the perspective of the elites, if you kill off the worker drones you also kill off your customers and by extension the value of your stock which put you in the elite class to begin with. So, how exactly is that supposed to work in your mind?
reply
It wasn't my idea, and that'll be their problem to solve. The point is they think there will be no need for most workers, and to some degree they're right.
reply
Don't confuse jobs with the people doing the jobs. Agriculture used to be the main source of employment but it became highly mechanized. Manufacturing used to be a much larger sector of employment and it shrank due to automation. Freight and transportation saw large amounts of mechanization that reduced the number of jobs with cargo ships becoming larger and needing less crew, docks being mechanized and needing only a fraction of the former numbers of dock workers, larger trucks and trains also reduced the number of people moving freight and warehouses also needing fewer people. Specific jobs disappear but there is still demand for human labor. Now we're seeing more automation in white collar work, it's another increase in automation but we've seen previous waves of automation there as well due to computerization e.g. draftsmen, bank tellers, secretaries, accounting clerks, bookkeepers, etc.

New jobs will be created, they're hard to imagine now just like the concept of software developers being a huge industry was hard to imagine when the computer was first invented. At that time people only thought there would be a few large computers, maybe a few dozen in the entire world and so they couldn't conceive that we would reach a point where there'd be a large demand for people to program them or have sub-specialties like creating computer games or consumer software. For all of our science fiction we're actually pretty terrible at predicting the future, most of what we take for granted now was never imagined by people 50 years ago and if you had told them they wouldn't have believed you.

reply
Easy. Business to business sales. You are right, there will be no consumer facing market. There will still be plenty of market though, datacenters needing fueling. Paper clip optimizers needing optimizing. Profiting all the way.
reply
What do these businesses do if they have no customers? If they are only serving the few remaining elites who have any money at all then why wouldn't any of those people think "I could get a lot richer than my peers if I created a business that served the needs of all those other people". Not to mention that serving the needs of non-elites is the business model of the vast majority of companies, do the elites controlling those companies just go bankrupt? or do they fold their businesses and retire? why wouldn't they just do that now if they can and didn't want to keep earning money?

What this theory is proposing is a drastic reduction in wealth for the elites. I can guarantee you that most of them are not okay with that happening and will work to prevent it since it means protecting their livelihood.

reply
People are just labor units to these elites. They aren't necessary for an economy if you don't need them for their labor capabilities. Businesses just sell resources and what amounts to spent energy to each other, in a closed loop economy that increasingly shunts out the humans that make little sense to have as participatory in it, much like how various animals eeking out an existence in our economic periphery do not participate directly in our economy either.

The great hubris of course is that these elites believe they will still be allowed to sit atop the resource pile, that their models they give unilateral decision making to will somehow determine all the other humans on earth are fat to excise, and not themselves with their greatly outsized resource footprint and complexity of needs.

I guess this is really why there is so much focus on alignment: trying to hardcode the inefficiency of the elite control of resources into a model that would otherwise quickly dispense with that stranglehold.

reply
> People are just labor units to these elites

If they have a reductionist view of people then it's more likely to see them as customers whose money they want to extract don't you think? You don't get rich by just making stuff, you have to sell it too.

> They aren't necessary for an economy if you don't need them for their labor capabilities

There won't be an economy if no one is buying what you are selling.

> a closed loop economy

A very tiny one if they are only producing goods and services for a small number of elites. What's your cutoff for elite anyways? How many people? Imagine the world having only that many people.

> these elites believe they will still be allowed to sit atop the resource pile

How do you know what they believe? Are you an elite? Have you ever met one? Do they all think the same?

reply
If the people are out of work and aren't getting paid, they don't have money anymore, and the money is instead held by corporations, which other corporations do business with directly instead. It isn't producing for elites, it is producing for businesses and their business needs. Robot factory needs steel. Steel factory needs iron ore. Mine sells it, fueled with energy from the power company. Same as it is now, only no loss of profit to payroll. We already have structured our economy for this. Corporations can already own land and seek out representation in governments without having a human agent representing them for this. We've already reduced labor in many sectors. This is not a what if situation, but already taking place to a matter of degree.

I don't expect they would cull the humans outright, maybe if there's enough sabotage efforts they might. But they might be content to let the humans live out on the urban wildland interface, akin to deer. We'd devolve back towards what we evolved to live as: tribal hunter gatherer bands in far smaller numbers, given we'd be limited to the carrying capacity of what land is available in a days walk to support ourselves.

reply
That's because they don't like the solution. The solution is restraint and sobriety, and they don't want to restrain themselves, because they value immediate profit over the greater good.

Nuclear? They would simply consume more, just like an additional lane on a highway simply leads to more traffic.

The solution won't come from them. It might come from us, but it won't be pretty.

reply
That isn't unique to the AI companies. Restraint and sobriety would at the individual level would also help many of today's problems.

Even just on the energy used problem, consider how often people fly, drive, buy stuff shipped around the world sometimes multiple times, etc.

reply
It's restraint and sobriety at the societal level that we need. Individual choices are the result of structural forces and incentives. However at the societal level power is held by the capitalist class whose goal is profit regardless of externalities. The capitalist class itself is a product of the structural forces of capitalism, the profit motive.

It seems that China is right to subordinate the capitalist class to governance, rather than the other way round like the US does. That's why they are now the leader [1] in green energy technologies while the US fights its oil wars.

[1] https://www.aspi.org.au/news/aspis-critical-technology-track...

reply
This idea that only top down solutions are viable will be end of everything. If individuals do not hold themselves accountable for their actions, there is no hope.
reply
Individual action is often a choice between few options made available at scale by the market. The reason people ask for top down solutions is because that is how individual action is currently shaped. Everything in your life is the result of top down forces. Virtually nothing is bottom up.
reply
Change can happen top down, it can also happen bottom up.

Both have their pros and cons but I'm much more in favor of bottom up solutions and bottom up change.

reply
The scale of energy usage for AI is just different, and I see it a bit like the difference between my sister's resource usage and my own. This can be measured in terms of flights, car journeys, how much goes in the general recycling and how much goes in the general waste.

At a conservative guess, there is a 100x difference, yet we both started with the same education in the same family.

Both of us understand the individual responsibility debate, and my sister does do things like recycling and buying eco-friendly consumables. Yet still, there really is a 100x chasm in resource usage. I try to suggest the frugal life to her, mostly on health grounds, yet some lifestyle choices that go with the Western world are very difficult for people to consider changing.

My feeling is that this AI business and the energy usage is a bit like the above, we have old-school databases that chug along nicely being replaced by AI behemoths that are 100x more energy intensive, in data centres that are just on a whole new scale.

We then have the tech bros that live in this maximum wastage reality and all of it has a certain amount of inertia to it, making it hard to get out of, even if the numbers don't add up.

reply
> Nuclear? They would simply consume more, just like an additional lane on a highway simply leads to more traffic.

And? Nuclear's net CO2 emissions are negligible, on par with wind and solar. What's the problem of consuming more energy if it comes from decarbonized sources?

The whole point of clean energy to to build a metaphorical highway without CO2 emissions and get more traffic on that decarbonized highway. Whether there's an net increase in traffic doesn't matter as long as all the traffic eventually ends up on the carbon free highway.

reply
These people are likely just radical “degrowth” advocates. They don’t want a world where people use more clean energy. They want to shrink everyone’s standard of living because they feel like that belief makes them more enlightened or something.

That’s why they jumped to discredit nuclear right off the bat targeting the idea of even using more energy. They don’t want any more usage, even if it’s clean. And it doesn’t seem to be for logical reasons.

reply
The solution could be to put AI-level spending into developing fusion power.

It's just more obvious that there isn't much money to be made from power-generation. With LLMs they have somehow deluded themselves into this being the next money generation opportunity.

reply
Unlimited energy, even 100% clean fusion energy, would just lead to accelerated extraction and unnecessary production (the main thing we've been doing for the last few hundred years), since the main moderating force would be gone.

Why bother developing a more efficient solution if you can just cheaply chew up 10x more resources? Just like how software has gotten worse as computers got better.

reply
What's wrong with extraction and production?
reply
It sounds like your goal isn't stopping climate change. It looks like the goal is degrowth, and climate change is just the convenient justification for it.
reply
Please explain how to maintain or increase consumption/utilization of resources without continuing to exhaust those resources? I know it has caught on, but calling the pulling back from destructive consumption levels "degrowth" just sounds like a political thinktank talking point.
reply
This is a rather absurd take when the amount of material required to provide nuclear energy is significantly lower, results in significantly fewer overall emissions (i.e. the entire resource pipeline, not strictly the extraction of energy itself). China's energy production is meteoric, and even with that, oil and coal use is declining. Their greenhouse gas emissions themselves are also declining.
reply
Problem is that the time horizon to make fusion work is decadal, and it's going to need billions upfront. Hard to create generational bag holders on that time scale.
reply
In the last year $4.48 billion has been raised for fusion startups. We need to only 10x that and then we are getting somewhere. Some bag holders are apparently already willing.
reply
We already know the solutions to climate change, the problem is that they're societal/political/economical in nature, not knowledge-based.
reply
For decades now it's been the same trend. More tech = more fossil fuels worldwide. Due to Jevons effect and due to companies and governments not doing enough about climate change.

We'll probably reach a peak in fossil fuel consumption over the next years, mostly for demographic reasons, then we'll see if we can keep doing tech the same way while consuming less fossil fuels worldwide.

Anthropic employees and CEO probably care about climate change vocally, but before the IPO they couldn't reduce their emissions, and now it might even be illegal for them to do so. Reducing CO2 emissions massively and quickly would mean destroying their business, investors wouldn't let them do that. Good alternatives take time to develop and cost more.

The reward to "solve" math problems is not much bigger than the reward to "solve" climate change on the short term. It's just that they're mathematicians so they care about maths, solving the Riemann hypothesis on paper didn't change the world much, people need to actually understand how it was done. The same way having the solution to climate change on paper won't change the world much, people need to understand and accept the solution to do it. If you have a solution to climate change tomorrow, people will congratulate you. But that's it, implementing this solution will be the hard task. And energy and climate change are very different from maths because there is a social aspect to it. Whether people accept or refuse the solution to the Riemann hypothesis doesn't matter; while if people reject your solution to climate change, they just won't implement it, which means your solution wasn't a real solution as it didn't solve the problem.

Anthropic employees (and other employees of AI companies) could surely do way more for energy and climate change. Maybe they just don't have the qualified people for that. It's a full time job to understand energy and climate change, I spent 1 year full time on it reading hundreds of papers, and that's really not enough.

reply
>Reducing CO2 emissions massively and quickly would mean destroying their business, investors wouldn't let them do that.

Investors have no say in Anthropic's decisions. Their governance structure ensures that.

reply
That's not true! Investors[0] have 49.9% of a say. The founders collectively have more voting power, but the investors only need one founder on their side.

The way the board works is even weirder.

[0] except major institutional investors

reply
It would only be illegal to spend extra money on solar if shareholders got together and specifically told them not to do it.

Even public companies do not, despite popular perception, have a fiduciary duty to maximize "shareholder value" at the expense of everything else:

Burwell v. Hobby Lobby Stores, Inc. - https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/13-354

> While it is certainly true that a central objective of for-profit corporations is to make money, modern corporate law does not require for-profit corporations to pursue profit at the expense of everything else, and many do not do so. For-profit corporations, with ownership approval, support a wide variety of charitable causes, and it is not at all uncommon for such corporations to further humanitarian and other altruistic objectives. Many examples come readily to mind. So long as its owners agree, a for-profit corporation may take costly pollution-control and energy-conservation measures that go beyond what the law requires. A for-profit corporation that operates facilities in other countries may exceed the requirements of local law regarding working conditions and benefits.

reply
There is no such thing as predictable Jevons effect. The paradox happen only sometimes.
reply
Brought to you by Dodge v Ford circa 1919. This is what we get at scale when the mandate of a publicly traded company is to enrich the share holders.
reply
What's the incentive for them?
reply
We've had a solution to this problem for 50 years: nuclear.

Who killed it?

reply
That isnt the solution, just like solar and wind arent the solution.

The problem is that every time we add cleaner forms of energy to the mix, we find ways to use that extra energy. On top of all the fossil energy we continue to use.

The only solution is to stop using fossil fuels.

reply
Fossils fuels are expensive. When the cost of running and maintaining gas and coal stations is higher than just building renewables/batteries, you just phase out fossils fuels (or just keep them running 10% of the time during the Dunkelflaute). It's coming soon.
reply
Right but unless people are simply going to tolerate pre-industrial living standards, what are we going to replace fossil fuels with? The main alternatives we have are geographically constrained, like hydropower. Or intermittent, like wind and solar (which also have disparities in performance based on geography). Nuclear is the main prominent alternative that largely replicated fossil fuel plants, just with a different source of heat. But people don't like it on account of skewed risk perception, and large capital investment.
reply
> Right but unless people are simply going to tolerate pre-industrial living standards, what are we going to replace fossil fuels with?

This is a solved problem. Multiple grid models exist showing how we can have a 24/7 clean power grid, even accounting for increased consumption. No decrease in QOL necessary. The tech exists today. There’s upfront capex involved but it would ultimately be cheaper than continuing to burn fossil fuels.

reply
> we find ways to use that extra energy

This has become abundantly clear to me in the past decade with extra energy going to non-productive uses first (crypto mining), then to more productive uses (AI). The solution is simply that "we" (governments, corporations, individuals) need to spend more money to replace fossil fuels with clean alternatives, and get those down to the price level where it doesn't make sense, economically, to burn them. But efforts to make fossil fuels more expensive are horribly unpopular (see Trump's Iran invasion) so it's clear we do not have the political will to do it nor have we done well enough on the transition front.

reply
I'd say it's worse: solar and batteries are now cheaper then nuclear and could do the same job...but the US government has gone an active crusade to ensure they're also unaffordable and impossible to build.
reply
Complexity of safety systems.

Safe nuclear is just too expensive.

reply
The systems built in the 60s and 70s are plenty safe compared to fossil fuels. We wring our hands at the several hundred deaths in Chernobyl - up to 1.7K for the highest end of credible estimates. Yet around 2-5 million people die each year due to fossil fuels, and it's not treated with nearly the same degree of concern. Let alone the three orders of magnitude more concern compared to nuclear that it ought to be.
reply
Unfortunately the systems built in the 60s and 70s were not that safe. That's why there were multiple prominent accidents and several programs to increase and make redundant existing safety systems.

I'm not disputing that many million die from coal and other fossil fuels and that should definitively be discussed with the same degree of concern.

Externalization of costs is the only thing that keeps fossil fuels viable.

reply
Electricity in France is cheaper than electricity in Germany, and it would be cheaper if France weren't forced to sell it to the rest of Europe.
reply
You confuse the end price with the production costs.

And don’t forget the heavy subsidies of the French government to keep the prices lower.

reply
The French government has been sucking money OUT of EDF for decades to pay for our disastrous pension system.
reply
You either pay companies so they lower their prices or you give money to the people to afford higher prices.
reply
> Who killed it?

3 Mile Island, Chernobyl and Fukushima are three guys that come to mind.

You think a data center in your backyard isn't popular? Try throwing in a nuclear reactor as a package deal.

reply
We can't even properly store 80 barrels of spontaneous explosive for 20 years. What makes us think we can properly store 10,000 barrels of nuclear waste for 10,000 years?
reply
This is the only real anti-nuclear argument. And it's fatal.

Building a safe nuclear plant is not terribly hard to do. Having our society with our leadership build a safe nuclear plant is extremely, extremely difficult.

reply
deleted
reply
The best anti nuclear argument is that it’s insanely expensive and takes over a decade to build. Why would anyone invest it that over solar or wind?
reply
It's a nonsense argument.

Vitrified nuclear waste is way less dangerous than say, uranium ore, and you just need to put it where those lie, such as in a suitably deep hole in a geologically inactive region.

Nuclear waste is tiny in size, and its dangers have been completely been blow out of proportions.

reply
And yet, we don't do that. It isn't hard to do, and we don't do it. (At least in the US.)

That's my argument exactly: we, as a society, don't have our priorities right when it comes to designing and operating these things. And because we don't have our priorities right, we shouldn't be building them over other sources (renewables), which have in past decades outpaced nuclear in many respects anyway.

There are similar issues in plant design, construction, and operation, not just waste storage.

Again, just to hammer this in: the argument is not that anything is impossible. It is that the people in charge don't do it right, and can't be convinced to do it right.

reply
This is not an effective comparison. Lead azide is a chemical deliberately engineered to have a low activation energy, for use in primers of explosives. The nature of its use requires a material that is unstable and dangerous to handle.

Spent nuclear fuel is radioactive but otherwise pretty stable. You bury it 400 meters deep in bedrock in an area without groundwater. What is going to bring that spent fuel in contact with humans?

reply
> The nature of its use requires a material that is unstable and dangerous to handle.

That entirely misrepresents the current problem, which is perpetually neglected management of the stockpile over many years.

reply
Grave robbers?
reply
Nobody died from nuclear exposure at TMI and Fukushima.

Chernobyl was a soviet POS. "I won't fly in an Airbus A350 because 1950's Tupolevs were death traps."

Those are the only significant nuclear accidents in 50 years. Nuclear power has been safer than every other power source in the mean time, even taking into account those three (3) accidents.

reply
How many people died from 3 mile and Fukushima? (Excluding Chernobyl because, I mean, can you name a Soviet project that didn't kill a bunch of people?). More people died today from coal power plant smog.
reply
Basically, "Communists were too stupid to boil water, so now nuclear energy is bad". In your list, basically only Chernobyl had casualties.
reply
IDK, whose fault was the multiple overlapping cost overruns at Vogtle? Be specific
reply
That humans make huge errors that lead to nuclear catastrophes and that nuclear can also be used to create bombs.

Try that with photovoltaic

reply
I'm not immediately sure why people feel such a strong moral injury or sense of doom from AI co2 emissions but not from zinc, copper, steel, aluminium, concrete, pulp & paper and so on.

I suppose it feels very _optional_ compared to those other things. A lot of tokens are gonna be spent optimising ads, for example.

reply
Just because one issue is getting attention doesn't mean people don't care about the others.
reply
> They have most powerful AI systems and yet they can't solve their own power consumption nor climate change.

It seems like they have solved their power consumption...? AI probably told them gas is the most cost efficient way.

reply
deleted
reply
"Design a complete fusion power plant for 200GW data center consumption. Source all parts and hire a construction crew to build it. Make no mistakes!"
reply
What's crazy is that they're claiming we need AI to know how to solve it, despite having the answer for decades..
reply
It’s fine, Altman says GPT will just sort it out
reply
By definition though, doesn't "everything" accelerate climate change in our society given it's capitalism at the core of what you're describing i.e. short term thinking?
reply
In pre AI days some companies were at least committed to green energy. I know Google was one. They promptly dropped their commitment to clean energy as soon as AI became mainstream.
reply
What definition?

There is stuff that decelerates climate change.

reply
[flagged]
reply
Mobile phones have become necessity just like AI will be. I don't want to use one but I'll have to if I want to compete and earn my living in this world.

BTW I have a Nothing phone. I don't upgrade it with every new version.

reply
Neither are iPhones, on a global scale. Apple phones have good resale value and hold well for years. If you want to go after anyone here, I'd go after low-end Android phones, or all those new upstart phones. Saying so as an Android user.

But of course the whole thing is backwards; both smartphones and LLMs have some of the highest utility per watt (including embodied power) of all goods and services worldwide. Plenty of much greater waste to go after, but it's not as sexy to complain about vacations or sportsball or fashion or home decoration or DYI arts & crafts or ... as it is about smartphones and data centers.

reply
iPhones, as everyone knows, run on natural gas generators.

It’s not like they have batteries that are charged from the grid which be sourced from renewables.

reply