upvote
> Bonkers to me that we ever allowed this.

I don't understand when it become allowed honestly. Like when I was at school, phones were never allowed. If a teacher saw one they'd confiscate it and your parents would have to come and collect it.

That was before the absolute worst addictive dark patterns etc. Which means that someone looked at the world after that point and said "yeah actually, phones are ok now" which baffles me

reply
Parents insisted that they needed to be in contact with their kids. Not being able to text the kids was a safety issue and strong inconvenience.
reply
I always found it interesting that these are framed as "safety issues" even though they can't really impact the safety parameters. Being able to contact a child doesn't impact their safety, it just means you know sooner if there is an issue. It would be more accurately described as an "anxiety issue".
reply
The term "safety" (also cf. "violence") has become extremely abused in the modern discourse. From what I can tell, the modal reason to "feel unsafe" nowadays is hearing an opinion the complainant deems unacceptable to hold, or the physical presence of a person the complainant associates with such thought (assuming that said person belongs to a group that is socially acceptable to target).
reply
Same goes for abuse, assault, violence, and trauma. They've all been perverted way beyond their normal meanings.
reply
We also seem to be living in a time for unencumbered abuse though. The narrative you present also makes it more difficult for actual victims to speak out loud though; it is easy for people with narcissistic traits to employ the narrative to guilt trip their targets to thinking they are delusional, prolonging traumatic situations using gaslighting.

We need language that can accommodate both human vulnerability and human disagreement without confusing the two. Otherwise, we end up with two equally damaging outcomes. Ordinary disagreement becomes pathologised, while genuine abuse becomes harder to identify and articulate.

reply
The misuse of those words is insulting to those who have experienced actual trauma, violence, etc. and dilutes the conversation around real suffering and oppression.
reply
How is the potential for abuse more common or less encumbered now than any time in the past?
reply
[dead]
reply
This is definitely the case. We've conflated physical safety with emotional and mental safety, and while I think it's okay to use the word safety to describe all three, they're radically different things. Physical safety is paramount, and because of this, people want to use the phrase "safety" as sort of a thought-terminating cliché to get people to change their behavior.
reply
People do this with all powerful words. They see how effective a word or a label can be in shutting down conversation, changing behavior, etc. And they say, "If only I could use that term in situation X, too, in order to get what I want." And so they expand the definition of word. And expand it, and expand it, until it applies to basically everything. Which is extremely frustrating in the interim, because it's an abuse of the word. But the word gradually loses its power as a result. Which is relieving because the abuse ends, but also frustrating because it was (in its original form) quite useful.

You see this with a lot of the -ism and -phobic words. For example, by 2020, it was common to hear even the most liberal of people saying things like, "Everyone is racist." Whereas 20 years before that, to successfully brand someone a racist could have ended their career.

reply
One of these I always find most revealing, perhaps because it’s slightly less political than other examples, is homeless.

When an ordinary person here’s the word homeless he immediately thinks of a person sleeping on the street. But the government / activist term is far far broader. It’s intended to tie larger issues of affordability into the very publicly salient issue of people living on the street.

reply
Ok, now try to say this publicly without loosing your job and/or being acid-attacked by some activist.
reply
A lot of those "opinions the complainant deems unacceptable to hold" are things that actually are unsafe, like believing that the complainant deserves to be the recipient of violence. If someone tells you they believe you should receive violence, and you feel unsafe, that is not some sort of anxiety issue, that is a rational reaction.
reply
> like believing that the complainant deserves to be the recipient of violence.

As far as I can tell, the overwhelming majority of complaints made on this basis are simply completely invalid, claiming a "belief" that is not even remotely supported by evidence. There is, if anything, far stronger evidence of such "beliefs" among those successfully weaponizing the "I feel unsafe" claims.

reply
Not really. If someone says “when the revolution comes people like you are going to be the first ones up against the wall” it satisfies your condition that the person is telling you that you should receive violence. But unless you believe “the revolution” is imminent and this person is going to play a leading role, there’s not much reason to feel unsafe. Uncomfortable perhaps, but not unsafe.
reply
You should feel unsafe around that person. They are telling you they want to see you dead.
reply
Well, maybe if we did something to prevent the kids from being shot, the parents wouldn’t think that was so important.
reply
It's a price they're willing (for us) to pay
reply
See also fearing the predictable consequences of their own actions.
reply
Many safety issues are actually anxiety issues.

IMO school shootings are unfortunately part of this equation. If the school can’t protect your children then you’re going to feel more anxious and want direct contact with them.

reply
The irony is that the real world social isolation and online dark socialization from constant phone use seems to have been a factor in a lot of recent school shootings.

The sort of detachment from reality and radicalization across distance you see in the Tumbler Ridge text messages is way less likely to happen if kids’ time is filled up with physical human connection.

reply
> The irony is that the real world social isolation and online dark socialization from constant phone use seems to have been a factor in a lot of recent school shootings.

It's the opposite actually. Kids that are depressed drift into social media. Usually starts in the none other than family.

reply
I don't get the connection; Columbine predated most kids having cellphones, and after that we had a steady stream of shootings during the early to mid 00s when cell phone ownership among kids became common, but nonetheless phone bans were the default norm and strictly enforced during this period.

It seems that it was only when cellphones became smartphones that parents started sperging out about the bans.

reply
I think it started when the parents themselves got addicted to smartphones, and thus to the expectation of constant communication.
reply
I think social media also significantly increased anxiety levels of parents.
reply
I recall kids lining up at the school office to check in on their parents on 9/11. It wouldn't have made any material difference to the emergency if those kids had cell phones instead.
reply
I think Sandy Hook, which happened in 2012, caused the reaction of "my kids need this in order to tell me they're safe."
reply
This is Horror Movie 101 though. You start beeping your child’s phone while they’re being stalked and they’re the first to die. This is more anxiety by the parents. Thinking information is control. It is not. Many kids have trouble following strange directions from parents in the first place, and that is a legitimate anxiety parents have even with a hand on their child. Which is also Horror Movie 102.

If I see a bear or an active shooter and tell my child to shut the fuck up, will they shut the fuck up or argue with me about being mean or bossy?

reply
The US has Amber, etc, Alert. I wonder if anyone's asked the GSM consortium for a new type of cell tower alert broadcast that would put phones in the area on silent, to prevent them beeping and be homing beacons for bullets.

What would be a good color for this alert? (although Amber Alert's name comes from a kidnapped child named Amber).

This comment written with a lot of tongue-in-cheek.

reply
infrared alert.
reply
TBF the problem relative to when I was a kid is that there used to be pretty widespread pay phones. Now they are very rare.
reply
When there is school shooter, it's much safer to call police/parent from your own phone then going to Dean office and looking for a phone.
reply
It was never a safety issue. We survived generations without it.
reply
Unfortunately, parents now are very worried about school shootings. That just wasn't a concern until the last two or three generations (the Columbine shooting happened when millennials were in grade school).
reply
That doesn't explain it though. Millennials were allowed to have phones with us, they just had to be kept silent and out of sight at all times during the school day. They were already available to us in case of a real emergency, there was no need to relax the rules to account for school shootings.
reply
[flagged]
reply
I understand what you're saying, but I can also understand why those replying are upset by it. The HN guidelines ask us to avoid flamebait, and this kind of comment – taking a topic that carries a deep emotional charge for people - and reframing it simply as a matter of data and statistics, qualifies as flamebait. I can understand you didn't mean to upset people. But I'm posting this as a reminder to everyone to try to avoid this style of commenting on touchy topics. We're all humans here and our emotions about topics like this are valid, especially when harm to children is involved.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

reply
> [..] taking a topic that carries a deep emotional charge for people - and reframing it simply as a matter of data and statistics, qualifies as flamebait.

I cannot disagree with this point more strongly.

If anything in the parent comment constitutes flamebait, it's the dismissive opening:

> School shootings aren't a concern.

But soberly offering data on topics people are emotional about is not flamebait, it's simply discourse.

(Not that it matters, but my wife is an elementary school teacher and we have children in school, so this is as about as sensitive a topic as it gets for me.)

reply
Parent's aren't worried about school shootings because they're mathematically a concern, parents are worried because they're emotionally terrifying. People are bad at evaluating risk, and you can't solve that problem by just pointing at some numbers.
reply
> People are bad at evaluating risk, and you can't solve that problem by just pointing at some numbers.

I'd wager you could walk into any PTA meeting in the country and start reading off the hazards from the material safety data sheet for dihydrogen monoxide and get the majority of parents to sign off on a ban.

I agree people are horrible at evaluating risk. They're even worse when they're evaluating risk involving dangers they do not understand. The problem is compounded even further when it involves their babies. And yes, it doesn't matter if their baby is 17 years old, it's still their baby in their heart & eyes.

reply
Part of this is a sign of the times. I am not one to view the past through rose-tinted glasses, but pop psychology and what not have normalized coddling and indulgence. As someone once said, it's not the strong who are dangerous, but the weak.
reply
This only further reinforces the argument that lack of access to phones is not a safety concern.
reply
Policy decisions should definitely be based on statistics and not feelings though, and "pointing at some numbers" is a great way to structure a disagreement about policy.
reply
School boards are elected, and highest turnout for those is going to be among parents. If a majority of parents have a concern then the school board has to listen if they want to keep their position.
reply
You're talking about the difference between effective leadership and pandering, yes.

But stats + "these policies will harm your children" and "they will not reduce the risk of an already improbable event" is the correct choice.

And I would note that my comment was not offered at a town hall, but on a technical forum.

reply
You're absolutely right, but imagine being the school board member who wants to be reelected. You either have to convince a bunch of concerned parents to reason about something they didn't reason their way into, or you have to disregard the parents' wishes and know you'll lose your seat.

I wish more elected officials at least attempted the former, but populism seems to work. As hard as it is, I'm more bullish on educating the electorate than getting elected officials to act against their incentives.

>And I would note that my comment was not offered at a town hall, but on a technical forum.

Yeah I think most people here are agreeing with you and we're just arguing about how things work vs how we wish they worked. Governance would look very different if HN was representative of the electorate, but it's not.

reply
> Governance would look very different if HN was representative of the electorate, but it's not.

It would be equally awful, just in a slightly different way. :)

reply
Benevolent dictatorship under @dang is the solution to the world's problems.
reply
This view-- gotta get reelected-- encapsulates the sorry state of the GOP and democratic party establishment today, and perhaps explains why they're perpetually surprised when actual principled candidates win.
reply
actual principled candidates are maybe 50/50, even in an environment like this. So many people will still bet on a coin flip if it means they can keep doing what they are used to.
reply
>And I would note that my comment was not offered at a town hall, but on a technical forum.

So as effective as campaigning to Gen Z, who statistically do not turnout to polls as much.

reply
This simply makes statistics a new vector through which opinions are relayed. It is incredibly easy to tweak statistics, questions etc in a way to bias the result towards what you want. This is a major issue in the social sciences for instance
reply
Sometimes feelings turn into statistics (eg anxiety, depression, etc). You can't always just tell people to walk it off. Sometimes you can, but sometimes it absolutely has to be handled (gun control).
reply
But you can tell people to seek help. Being neurotic is treatable.
reply
help? In this economy? People can barely afford groceries, let alone mental health proffessionals.
reply
Goddamnit.
reply
Of course, but if that were always the case, there wouldn't be so many guns out there for this to be an issue in the first place ;-)
reply
[flagged]
reply
Arguing in bad faith is fun! But you are right: We should allow an entire generation of kids to suffer from phone-induced brainrot so that their parents don't have to worry about school shootings.
reply
Or… maybe we do something about access to guns?

Or if a minor commits a murder with a weapon, the parent gets punished.

Or maybe we take a look at why people are shooting up schools.

Or maybe we do all three because we have a lot of people in government and we can check more than one thing at a time.

reply
> Or… maybe we do something about access to guns?

Arguing this point on the basis of something less likely than being hit by lightning smells of bad faith and exploiting tragedy for political ends.

Maybe gun access should be restricted but it is not on this basis. We are well into the point of "diminishing policy returns" with an event whose incidence is well below 0.1/100k, and ranks in deadliness far below other much more manageable risks.

There is a strong case to make that the intersection of juvenile phone usage, social media, and sedentary lifestyles is far more deadly than gun usage, and that discussion not politically hamstrung by such petty things as "the constitution".

reply
I was a teacher’s pet level good kid and I stopped worrying about school shooting in the eighth grade. Why?

Because I noticed that the school lunch kitchen door was propped open before lunch hour, and that the soup pots were just inside the door and anyone could just drop rat poison in there and it would be mayhem.

Guns are a convenient tool of violence but I experienced that already on the regular, and there are so many ways to hurt people even if you’re not the strongest person there.

reply
Sure. Thing is

1) Most kids (especially those who'd do this) aren't that smart and all encompassing

2) the kinds of kids doing school shootings are not ones who'd take long term malicious joy out of slowly killing their student body. They have specific targets in mind and want to see their anguish now (collateral is just that)

3) there's the social media influence of it all. In some ways a school shooter wants to eventually be identified and glorified. Getting away with murder on the down low would not satisfy that need.

4) A school body is in more direct control of a safety concern like an open door than checking the content of every student's bag.

reply
In addition to the other comment pointing out this is an emotional issue, it doesn't help that on average, at least 3 - 5 times a year our local schools go into lockdown because of some reported threat or another. Every time it happens, WhatsApp groups light up with parents feverishly checking in and reporting the latest updates. These schools forbid phones during class, but that doesn't stop parents from trying to text their kids.

It's always out of "an abundance of caution" of course, but no person responsible, in case an incident does happen, is going to go up there and recite these statistics.

reply
> at least 3 - 5 times a year our local schools go into lockdown because of some reported threat or another

There is a reasons that doctors do not casually suggest tests for e.g. all sorts of cancers when those tests carry false positives: false alarms can, in aggregate, be worse than the event they aim do detect.

The mentality that "bad thing could happen" --> "we must act" is deeply embedded in our culture, but is incredibly harmful. Sometimes the best course is to make an informed decision to accept the risk, because all available alternatives are worse.

reply
reply
I'm struggling to derive an actual point or refutation of my comment, from the provided link.

Statistical presentations like that which do not quantify the actual harm ("how many were injured / killed") and instead focus on the emotional aspect ("how much did a scary thing happen") are not worth discussion; they're intended to mislead or frame the discussion in dishonest ways.

* How often does the thing happen

* What are the harms / costs of the thing

* What are the available responses, what risk reduction do they represent, and what burden / cost do they incur

reply
It's not just deaths, all kids stuck in the school during the lockdown are affected significantly
reply
People are afraid of whatever they are told to be afraid of in the media. It's not about numbers and probabilities.
reply
> School shootings aren't a concern. Just picking a random year from google-- there were 21 school shooting deaths in 2023.

That’s some normalisation of deviance you got going on there.

There should be zero school shootings.

However, being able to contact your kid directly because they’re carrying a phone isn’t going to render them any less shot.

reply
There should be zero school bullying too, and as often as not the perpetrators of school shootings have not been having an okay time at school.
reply
We should have zero deaths from falling off roofs, or getting struck by lightning, yet those happen more than school shootings.

I propose government mandated safety rails with hazard-yellow paint on all roofs and personal taxpayer-supported lightning rods.

More seriously and on-topic, depression and anti-social behavior are far bigger risks to teens and phone usage makes that risk far worse without meaningfully affecting shootings. Can we get rid of phones?

reply
[flagged]
reply
How is this inhumane? Because it calls attention to the scourge of vehicular child killing? The bloodbath on the highway? Can you not admit there's something curious in the way people selectively care about things regardless of their importance or solveability?
reply
That number should be 0. As a parent of a child in a country that doesn't have issues with school shootings, the fact that kids are taught how to protect themselves during a school shooting from a very young age, aren't allowed to wear light-up shoes to not be seen too easily by a shooter, some states even argue that teachers should carry. This is very concerning to me. Enough that I would not choose to move to the US for fear of the safety of my kids. Arguing that kids die from other causes too diminishes the urgency of the situation, which I understand is your point, but you might want to reconsider.
reply
<Edit>I agree it should be zero!, and....</Edit>

Diminishing urgency is not the charge this puts upon gun control activists. One should really be asking why people fail to prioritize addressing the greater child killers. I don't think it's necessarily because this one is more addressable. Activists who make this their main concern primarily seem to want large scale firearm seizure. Even in an authoritarian's dream America where the Constitution is a wax tablet for carving and molding we would struggle to take peoples' guns. I hope I am not extrapolating too much.

reply
> the fact that kids are taught how to protect themselves during a school shooting from a very young age...

...is due to a toxic media culture that latches onto particular issues more over their political exploitability than for their actual impact on threats to life / liberty.

If media / politicians truly cared about kids they'd have instead spent their energy over the last decade campaigning against

- Food policies that encourage junk food even (especially) among lower income families

- School policies that allow or encourage technology despite the near zero evidence for benefit and numerous studies showing harm

- School permissiveness towards (or approval of) phone use and social media despite mountains of evidence for harm

One can say that we should reduce the shootings to zero, but it would be folly to let that prevent tackling far larger, more tractable issues that are not politically divisive as "gun control" is. I can already anticipate the angry responses over the recognition that it is a divisive issue; surely that itself is demonstrative of the folly?

reply
You’re way more likely to get hit by a car crossing the street.
reply
[flagged]
reply
Because it ignores a completely solvable problem.

And number of deaths is not the whole story. Entire generations of children are coping with school shootings. From in-school drills to metal detectors. We are in a position of having to teach all kids about avoiding being murdered. That comes with a cost. Both in dollars and emotional impact that will shape the rest of their lives.

So yeah. 21. But those 21 have a huge impact.

It’s no surprise the same people who want to take education apart are the same people that want to do nothing about school shootings which make schools danger zones.

reply
> And number of deaths is not the whole story. Entire generations of children are coping with school shootings. From in-school drills to metal detectors. We are in a position of having to teach all kids about avoiding being murdered. That comes with a cost. Both in dollars and emotional impact that will shape the rest of their lives.

So why do we have to do that now, and did not have to do that in 1980? IIRC, in 1980, you could buy guns at K-Mart (the Walmart of the day).

I posit that this is at its core a media problem: it creates the fear and basically advertises murder to maladjusted kids. You'd probably have a lot less of them if they got very little coverage when they did happen.

reply
You don't have to go as far as 1980. You could buy guns and ammo at Walmart well into the 00s.
reply
I agree 100% with OP and I am a parent of two young kids in school. I'm a logical person and while it is hard to suppress emotional responses to hearing about trafficking, school shootings, etc, it's important to think logically about the risk.

Should we try to mitigate school shootings, et. al.? Yeah. Are people fixing the issues? no. They point to guns. Yes, guns are used, but the problem is mental health. No one gives an eff about your family. Everyone cares about what effects themselves.

It's starts at home. Kids become isolated, parents are busy working and do notice or care or are able to intervene, faculty don't have the means or care to address issues at school (bullying, etc). It's not the gun's fault. It's the layers of failures up to that point.

Anyway, people should be more afraid of inattentive drivers, walking alongside roads at night, etc.

reply
One wonders how many of the parents who've insisted their kids need phones because of school shootings are perfectly happy to drive them back and forth while frequently staring at their own phone and in traffic plagued with people doing the same thing.
reply
deleted
reply
[flagged]
reply
Yes, in fact, my kids go to school not too far from a school where a major shooting happened (i.e. you'd recognize the name of the school if I mentioned it), and I just never worry about school shootings at all. Heck, they're at school right now.

I'm also one of the parents that doesn't feel any need to be able to text/call them at any time of the day. I'm raising them to be able to handle themselves and contact me through means available to them if they need to.

Modern parenting gets a lot wrong in my opinion.

reply
Modern society is plagued with misplaced worry. I blame democracy.

Someone worries about school shootings and they do things around it. But not everyone needs to nor even should worry about them, as it becomes counterproductive.

reply
deleted
reply
Is my answer in any way relevant? Or is it just an attempt to shift the discussion to an emotional one or build an ad hominem?
reply
[flagged]
reply
[flagged]
reply
I understand why the comment was upsetting and I've replied to the commenter. But comments like this are clearly against the guidelines, no matter who or what you're replying to. Please don't reply to a bad comment with another bad one. It's what generates flamewars, and that's exactly what we're trying to avoid here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
reply
> the Columbine shooting happened when millennials were in grade school

I'm a millennial and it happened when I was in high school. But yeah, there was maybe only one incident with a gun at my high school before then (not a shooting, kid just had a starter pistol in his backpack) and I don't recall ever thinking of a school shooting until Columbine happened.

reply
Parents seem worried about kids too here in the UK where we don't have school shootings. I think everyone is just so used to a world where we have constant contact with anyone at all times.
reply
I can't find any school shootings stopped by high schoolers with phones. Or any kids who survived one because they had a phone. School shooter drills consist of 'get in a classroom, lock the door', phones don't really change that.

I'd be more concerned about my kid not learning anything because of constant phone/social media access.

reply
Get in classroom, lock the door, and shut the fuck up.

Phones are entirely about not shutting the fuck up.

reply
They are quiet when they play on their phones.

Shutting up when someone is shooting at you would take actual scary practice. Which I do not think is happening.

reply
What is the proposed mechanism where the phone helps during the active shooter event
reply
In theory, phones could be used during such an event to disseminate the location of the shooter.

If you know where the shooter is, that would better inform the decision to run, hide, or fight.

That said, general chaos and delays in information dissemination mean that location information is likely stale and not very useful.

reply
I had a very early aptitude for spatial reasoning and I can’t imagine how in a text message you would explain to me let alone normal children exactly where they should go and where the shooter is relative to you. You’d literally have to make an app for that and make everyone download it and I cannot begin to express how entirely fucked up that idea is.

Not to mention, knowing the danger is near makes many children panic, which makes them a bigger target, not a smaller one.

This is anxiety, not based on any knowledge we as a culture possess about threat management and stress in dangerous situations.

reply
> I had a very early aptitude for spatial reasoning and I can’t imagine how in a text message you would explain to me let alone normal children exactly where they should go and where the shooter is relative to you.

Something like:

a) Shooter is in Building 1, Room 23. Exit towards the fields. (Around here, room numbers are on large print signs visible through the windows, so it's plausible that outside observers could see the shooter and know the room number)

b) Shooter is in your building, barricade doors and hide.

c) police moving in, stay down until they escort you out.

A and B assume the sender knows the location of the recipient and the shooter and understands the school layout.

Could be very useful, if accurate and timely. I don't expect it to be possible (or reasonable) to be accurate or timely though. Even if this was a reasonable expectation, phones off and/or in bags during a normal day and taken out and turned on only for special occasions would be sufficient.

reply
You’ve conveniently ignored the more important issue of more panic being deadly not helpful. These are kids. Not action movie main characters.

Also, how have we identified the shooter and his accomplices so that we aren’t sending them the identical information? And how do I know the locations of every student so I tell YOU to exit toward the field but not the person on the other side of the shooter toward the field?

None of you guys are thinking, just reacting. Reacting gets you killed. I hope to God this isn’t in your job descriptions. Because this is all hopes and prayers not serviceable crisis management behavior.

Building number? In this economy? If someone asked me which room my class was in, but the end of the semester I had to think really really hard about that. It was the third door from the exit, the left door at the top of the stairs, the last door before the bathrooms. In the weird little hallway near my locker from last year. And wtf knows where room 23 even is, unless you’re in room 21?

And when both parents and your step mom are offering conflicting information from what the phone is telling you?

reply
> You’ve conveniently ignored the more important issue of more panic being deadly not helpful. These are kids. Not action movie main characters.

I mean, I expect teenagers to be able to follow simple instructions, if they're trying to communicate, but that's only really worth considering if you can determine and deliver the instructions. "It's safe(r) to leave, exit towards X" or "barricade yourself and hide" are simple instructions, but broadcasting exit directions can't work and broadcasting to barricade is probably not ideal. You can probably broadcast that police have entered the scene and to stay where you are because that would apply to everyone.

>And when both parents and your step mom are offering conflicting information from what the phone is telling you?

Yes, that's an issue --- accurate and timely communications is required and not easy or reasonable to expect. But if you're going to leave based on remote messaging, you probably need to do so quickly since the information will go stale quickly, so when someone tells you to go, you should go right away... and focus on leaving rather than checking your phone as you go. OTOH, your parents should only send you directions if they have high confidence that their information is accurate and timely --- it would be hard to have that much confidence.

reply
I do feel like this is goalpost-moving. The request was for an explanation of how a cell phone could help, and that’s what the GP gives.

100% agree that a crisis situation without practice is going to be a disaster. Tbh, it will anyway. Cell phone or no. The only school kids with practice reacting to violence live in the inner city.

reply
deleted
reply
How will a phone save my child’s life in a school shooting?
reply
It is my perception that school shootings are less frequent after covid. Is that true ?
reply
Nope, 2023 was a record year for the number of school shootings. And the overall trend line continues to go up, with increased lethality per shooting as well.
reply
There were 21 people killed in 2023 from school shootings.

This is fewer than "deaths in a hot car" (1/2), "familial homicide" (1/10), and "deaths from traffic" (1/50). Cancer, suicide, and (inferential from various studies) obesity all outrank it.

As I recall from the last time I dug this up, this is fewer deaths than "people falling off of their roof" and lower than the annualized rate of fatal lightning strikes (2006-2025).

Strange then that none of those drive policy, and we instead focus on a thing that is astonishingly unlikely to occur.

reply
We can do two things at once.
reply
We're meaningfully tackling technology use in schools, which is linked to all manner of harms? Or traffic deaths among children?

I don't think I recall any major policy platforms on these, school shootings has seemed to drive the bus and (forgive the cynicism) it seems to have been precisely because it dovetails directly into the political wedge issue of gun control. That is, its divisiveness-- that it can't result in meaningful change-- seems to be why it draws so much attention, to the detriment of fixing more solvable, lower-hanging fruit.

Allowing ourselves to distracted in this manner specifically prevents us from "doing two things at once".

reply
There have been several national initiatives to reign in traffic deaths in the post-COVID era.

https://www.transportation.gov/grants/SS4A https://www.transportation.gov/NRSS https://www.nhtsa.gov/pathways-to-safer-streets

Traffic isn't sexy, so we don't get talking heads yammering on about it. But, the works is being done.

So, yes, we can in fact do two things at once.

reply
The few annual datapoints I have seen since COVID (2022,2023,2024) show zero movement there, so this (traffic deaths) remains a risk that is simultaneously

- Easier to trace causation for

- Politically undivisive to mitigate

- Dramatically more impactful

... than trying to tackle gun deaths.

Most people here are surely technical. Imagine you have a stack of CVSS 9+ vulnerabilities with lateral movement capability in exposed services where the patch risk is low.

Now imagine some redteamer pops up saying "Hey, your internal, airgapped AC monitoring IOT devices have CVSS 3.0, patching it is incredibly manual and it has a high chance to disrupt office-wide cooling-- I think you should prioritize fixing it".

I think most people here would immediately see the absurdity of it. Focus on the big, easy wins before tackling the stuff with a harder-to-justify risk matrix. We can do two things at once, and when you pick you don't make one of your two the unlikely, hard, low-return thing.

reply
[flagged]
reply
[flagged]
reply
> The fact that "shooter drills" are standard practice in US schools is absolutely bonkers to any sane person outside the US.

It's bonkers to me as well, and I would argue that the view espoused here-- "darn the facts, I'm emoting over tragedy"-- is the literal cause.

Doctors regard false positives that lead to unnecessary life changes as a harm that requires consideration when evaluating interventions. Why is it so crazy to take the same approach to society at large? As we discuss teenage depression and suicide, should we not evaluate whether an (ineffective) culture of fear over an incredibly unlikely event is more harmful than helpful?

reply
So we should just get over it? If so how?

Perhaps society would do well without guns.

reply
Consider that "banning guns" requires an amendment and is politically untenable; and even if it was done, would not actually reduce fatal school violence to zero.

Then consider that the threat we are discussing is, compared to many other threats to children, very low risk.

Finally, consider whether it might be better to instead spend our efforts on other threats (traffic? obesity? juvenile phone usage? familial homicide?) that are simultaneously higher risk, easier to mitigate, and less politically divisive.

A reasonable conclusion is that our resources are far better spent reducing other risks, than tilting at intractable windmills. Sometimes risk reduction gets exponentially harder and more expensive as you approach zero and it becomes more ideological than practical to pursue that unattainable zero.

reply
+100 - sorry, my emotions got on more than my brain, but it really hurts when someone blurts out this as a "fact".
reply

    Again
Have we met?

    You don't know what you are talking about
I welcome any corrections....

    Just putting out facts does not make it so.
Are you asking for links to the search results that it took ~10 minutes to gather?
reply
Just stop talking about "school shootings" as another statistical tidbit. PLEASE!
reply
If someone is going to raise some bad outcome as a reason for policy change, the first two steps are

- Quantify how "bad" the event is

- Determine how frequent it is

Those two facts underlie all cost-benefit analysis of a policy response. Do we apply some societal cost? Curtail freedoms? Accept the risk? How can you begin to weigh the alternatives, if you don't know where this thing sits on "list of bad things X how frequent they are"?

reply
Why are you only counting deaths? There are hundreds of physical injuries in 2023, and tens of thousands of students in 2023 who went to a school where a shooting of some sort occurred, subjected to distress and trauma of varying levels.

It's silly that you take one metric and dismiss it as a non-issue when it's actually a huge force shaping our culture and society. It's like saying terrorism is a non-issue because it kills less people than falling out of bed. Basically we should only care about car accidents and heart disease.

reply

    There are hundreds of physical injuries in 2023....distress
There are over a thousand traffic deaths. There are a dozen other mortality risks for kids that are easier to tackle and less politically fraught.

If I'm doing a cost benefit analysis I'm going to focus on the biggest risks (mortality, not distress) and on where the biggest gains are going to be made.

The simple fact is, politicians and the media use school shootings because they are flashy, emotional, and can be used to drive narratives around political wedge issues. They are useful, in other words. But that is not the basis on which responsible risk management is performed, and I'd expect rather more savvy in this regard from a technical forum.

reply
So it’s unlikely to happen, move on?
reply
Some principals

- Spend finite resources where they will have more, rather than less, impact

- Diminishing returns can mean that reducing the prevalence of an outcome from 1% to 0.01% is less expensive than reducing it from 0.01% to 0.005%

- That an outcome is tragic does not intrinsically mean "something must be done". Sometimes all possible "somethings" carry costs that outweigh the benefit

In this context, the "something" that is proposed is "bringing phones into school" which has demonstrably

- not reduced shooting incidence

- Nor reduced its harm

- increased antisocial behavior and depression

- Reduced school performance outcomes

So "moving on" would have been better than what happened in this case, yes.

reply
You skipped "thought and prayers", but yes, that seems to be what a large slice of the country wants.
reply
And you skipped right past the actual argument in order to tear down the straw man.
reply
The argument does boil down to ‘move on’, and when you’re talking about shooting kids that is not going to sit well with everyone.
reply
Across the US, there has been a massive increase in gunfire at schools, starting 2021. Often, the rate is at least 1 shooting per school day.

Source: https://everytownresearch.org/maps/gunfire-on-school-grounds...

reply
This seems to be true. Depending on how you define each.

Speaking very roughly, a random person is more likely to be hospitalized due to covid than to be even at a school while a gun is fired there.

CDC estimates that this week alone there will be 5100 covid hospitalizations, while Everytown (cited below by robby_w_g) tallied 107 incidents of gunfire at school for the entire year-to-date.

https://www.cdc.gov/cfa-modeling-and-forecasting/covid19-dat...

reply
That disingenuous.

School kids aren’t ’a random person’, they are rather a quite specific demographic.

Update your comparison to ’school kids hospitalised due to covid’, then we can talk.

reply
I have kids. They're just not gonna die in a school shooting. They're gonna die in a car accident. That's what I'm worried about.

There were 3x more kids dying in car accidents in 2025 than all school shootings combined since we started recording them.

I do treat this as an engineering problem for what it's worth: If I want to maximize the chance that my kids survive, I do need to attend to the most likely ways that they're going to die.

reply
They aren’t all “school” shootings but firearms are the #1 cause of death in children in the US.
reply
That's all fine and true (except about my being disingenuous). If you ask me, gun to my head (whoops), is a schoolkid more likely to be at a school shooting than in the hospital with covid, I think the answer is obvious. That wasn't the question though, by my reading.
reply
That doesn’t explain it in most parts of the world where school shootings aren’t a thing parents would list on their top 20 things they worry about though.
reply
As if texting your mom while a shooter is running loose in the building would change anything. Come on, let's be serious, parents cannot help in that situation.

Kids don't need to have their phones on them during class "for safety". On the way to and from school, sure, but once they're at school, stow the phones somewhere.

reply
i think it’s more about helping the parents know their kid is still alive so they don’t go insane but i agree phones should be restricted in schools
reply
Yeah don’t hide in a dark room, get your phone out and message me constantly. Also have the ringer on unless you’re being hunted. Then remember to turn it off.

Have you seen a scary or dramatic movie in the last twenty years?

reply
I don’t think it’s a good idea just motivating the reasoning
reply
I don't see this as a legitimate concern because their child can simply have a phone and not use it unless needed. In the unlikely circumstance that a school shooting occurs while their phone is confiscated another room, I'm sure they can borrow a phone from a classmate.
reply
Teachers know how batshit their worst parents are. The sort of entitled idiots whose notion of “need” isn’t even most people’s definition of “want”. And since their children are their property, what mommy needs, little Timmy needs.

I guarantee you have kids today getting pinged in math class because they left a wet towel on the floor. That’s not conducive to learning.

reply
deleted
reply
Canada has almost no school shootings but also went down the "cellphones in glass" sinkhole[1].

[1] https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/canada-school-cellphones-ban-...

reply
I suspect they're lying. They probably didn't want the stress of their moody teen whinging about the phone ban.

What are they planning to do? Call their kid, who is hiding, and let the shooter hear where the kid is?

People lie on the internet, and sometimes even lie to themselves. I can almost guarantee that most of them just have some other motive.

reply
Given the people I’ve met and the people they’ve met, most people are lying to themselves before they lie to other people about themselves. The exceptions are sociopaths.

It doesn’t trigger your tells if you believe your own bullshit.

reply
> (the Columbine shooting happened when millennials were in grade school).

Not true. Old millenials were in high school at that exact time. And there's that weird Xennial group from 1977-1983. Too young for proper X'er, and almost too old for 'millenial culture'.

reply
The kids are statistically much more likely to kill themselves. Mental health should take a priority.
reply
Some school shootings are elaborate suicides, after all.
reply
This has been litigated to death already, but oh well. School shootings definitely happened before Columbine. I was already out of school by the time that happened and my middle school was shot at twice in drive-bys. No parents were ever notified as far as I'm aware, because no one was hit. I have no idea how many if any students ever actually got shot in my district, but we were banned from wearing red, blue, or Raider's jerseys because of fear over crips and bloods. The local LA news sure made it seem like every single weekend some 8 year-old girl was getting caught in crossfire while waiting in line at the ice cream truck.

Meanwhile, six friends of mine actually did die before graduating. One from a cat dander allergy, one from shooting himself, one smothered in her sleep by her mom's boyfriend, and three from getting hit by cars. Three separate stop lights were also added to streets in my city because of kids getting killed in front of elementary schools, but those were not mine and I didn't know them.

Hell, a kid was murdered at my dad's birthday party where he first met my mom, and it was uneventful enough that she didn't even know until he told the story two Christmases ago. Police didn't even investigate.

I know it's distasteful to downplay people's fears and I don't want to illegitimize anything. If you're scared, you're scared. But the world is not more dangerous now than in the 70s through 90s. Even beyond the more direct dangers, a good quarter of the kids I knew had started smoking by 4th grade. My best friend from high school died of alcohol poisoning, though that was after high school. I lost count of how many caught chlamydia or gonorrhea at some point. Kids today apparently don't drink or have sex and barely drive, so that alone probably makes them safer than ever.

As far as I can tell, it's not the actual probability of harm making anyone scared. It's the sheer overwhelming awareness of threat. Whereas I grew up seeing those news reports about gang crossfire once a week, you're getting it every time you open your phone. You probably have cameras mounted on your frontdoor sending you alerts every time a stranger walks past the house. Neighborhood groups sending group texts or private chats warning you about package thieves or scary looking homeless people.

Again, I get it. The entire time I served in the Army, the probability of dying on the Texas highways back home was higher than dying in combat. Two guys from my unit were killed in combat across two 15-month tours. Nine died in vehicular accidents outside Fort Hood. One drowned in a lake off-post. But I drove all the time, swam in that same lake, and was never scared like I was scared of mortar fire and IEDs. Some events are just scarier than others, for whatever reason. Our evaluations of threat are not rational. But public policy should be. It is abundantly obvious that more harm is done by kids having phones in school than is prevented by being able to contact them during active shooter events.

reply
[dead]
reply
We survived those generations by having land lines that people could find anywhere they went. That doesn’t exist anymore.
reply
I don’t recall there ever being a landline phone in any of the class rooms in my 12 years at school.
reply
deleted
reply
There was a landline phone in every single one of my classrooms. Did you grow up in the 1930s?
reply
Australia is probably slightly different culture wise since, but I can say certainly in regard to the non urbanised capital and satellite towns, in Queensland most schools wouldn't have seen the need to install phone lines to much more than essential areas. If someone wanted to contact, it was a phone point, and from there people did the rest to let that person know they had a message. Also up to the 90s where the cable laid and tech available to rural areas where I grew up limited the amount of available phone numbers. It was about that point tech arrived that could split lines - a pair could then generally run about 6 lines comfortably - and local phone numbers in my state started to add two more digits to their phone number. Sadly phone reliability soon got much worse, but much came down to newfangled ideas for weatherproofing joints and junctions (a sealing gel in particular) that didn't pan out well.

I should note that much of rural Australia up my neck of the woods (Cent North Queensland) may have had communication lines to small townships but surrounding properties didn't until the late 60's - 70's - so there is barely more than a generation that one could say if they were in trouble the next house probably had a landline.

reply
There was a phone system in my junior high but as far as we were aware that was an interoffice system. Which hardly ever got used. If your parents or sibling had an emergency they sent someone from the office to get you rather than calling.

Hell I was sent to the office to get detention forms for my entire class rather than her calling the office, and in that moment I realized why the entire class hated her guts.

reply
Hmm...there was an intercom system and pay phones in the 80s/90s at the schools I went to.
reply
By far, most of those generations didn't have phones at all. I mean, my grandfather (born 1925) didn't have a landline at his parents' place...
reply
Sure, but I didn't live in those generations, and no way I would want to live in a place where I couldn't call 911 in a medical emergency.

All I'm saying is that this idea that kids don't need phones is mostly coming from people who grew up thinking that cell phones were a luxury item that you didn't need, and are so old and crusty to not have realized how much the world has changed since that happened. Taking cell phones away from kids would still not be the same thing as how they grew up, and would be in fact objectively worse.

reply
Most parents rather think about free time they win than safety.

Internet connected smartphone without control ain’t exactly creating more future proof security for these kids.

reply
For a lot of parents it absolutely was. Active shooter drills have been a normal thing for this generation.
reply
That’s still not a safety issue. Letting the kid text mom at lunch break is not going to have any impact on what happens in a school shooting
reply
Parents wanted their kids to have phones in school to treat their (the parents') anxiety. It doesn't do anything to stop a shooter or any other problem, but you can blast off a bunch of texts to your kid if you're worried about them.

It's a shame that so many parents basically traded their kids' social development for relief from some temporary bad feelings.

reply
It's not just school shooters. Bullying, theft and random violence are at their all time high and much more common than shooters.
reply
I don't doubt you, but do you have stats? I was in school before cell phones and I was bullied at various points, had my bike and skateboard stolen, friends had their stereos stolen (is that even still a thing?), there were random fights at school or the field across the street all the time. I was even in a few.

I can believe that bully is up mainly because of social media, but is everything else also really at all time highs?

reply
I don’t dwell on shooting statistics because that is also unhealthy, but at one point there was a good chance that shooters were the victims of bullying. If you go back the “peacemaker” was marketed as a solution to the stronger preying on the weak. I have a gun so it doesn’t matter how big your muscles or your stick are.

Shooters are getting revenge, and it’s not on the girl who wears rainbow overalls and is uncomfortably fond of puns.

I wonder if that has held over the last generation or if it’s more random violence now.

reply
I was trying to broaden the discussion because the savagery and sadism present in schools are a huge general problem, not limited to shooters. If you factor in teen suicides, which have been rising to horrifying levels, the death toll of bullying/assaults is probably much higher than shooters for whom drills are performed and who dominate the discussion.

To your point, I guess I'm suspicious of studies on school shooter motives anyway because of the gap between self-reported and real reasons. I can imagine many shooters playing the victim card, but I can also imagine others trying to hide their "weakness" of being an outcast/bullying victim.

reply
We have a really hard time showing up for anybody's struggles that aren't immediately visible. People with chronic illnesses talk about it all the time but it's also mental health and especially in schools (where visible problems make you a target of bad things)

So we try to fix five bullet holes instead of hundreds of thousands of kids living in quiet desperation.

reply
Unfortunately, I there are too many indiscriminate shooters to fully correlate that shooter's are only getting revenge. Ultimately, it is a mental health problem, as well as a gun access problem.
reply
Whether or not it's just in their head, the fact that the chance of your child being shot to death is high enough that the school runs practice drills is so disturbing that some parents need an extra security blanket.
reply
The same change in accepting phones also happened outside the USA, where your children being shot during school generally isn't a concern.
reply
I was never worried about my school being shot up in the early 1990's, that's the difference
reply
You also didn't have a smartphone in the early 1990s...
reply
Every developed nation outside the US has smartphones and little to no school shootings.
reply
And the 24 hour news cycle hadn’t rotted our brains yet. CNN was something old people watched.
reply
Yes but we didn't used to have one school shooting every day.
reply
We still don’t, bro
reply
There's been more school shooting than school days every year between 2021 and 2024.

https://k12ssdb.org/all-shootings

reply
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survivorship_bias

Humans used to survive without any type of technology at all, just a fire in a cave with a pointy stick. Doesn't mean people want to do that.

reply
people survived generations without seatbelts too.
reply
plenty of things were absolutely safety issues that most people survived without
reply
Survivorship bias.
reply
Being able to record evidence of abuse by other kids and adults is a benefit of smartphones.

Probably better administered as security cameras that can only be accessed by an auditable third party.

reply
Being able to cyber bully kids by uploading their embarrassing moments is a far more likely outcome of recording another student.
reply
Despite the fact parents could always contact the school as they did for us growing up
reply
That is neurotic behavior. We really need to be careful about throwing “need” around where health and public safety are concerned.
reply
deleted
reply
I think that, when used well, the ability to communicate was more about giving kids extra freedom than about increasing safety. I was not born before the wide availability of landline phones, so I don’t have a direct comparison. But it was pretty great to be able to easily call home and say something like “hey, is it okay if I go out with some friends and come back later than usual?” or “there’s an activity I’d like to do that will make me miss the bus - can you pick me up?”.

In the pay phone era, the use of phones at school was asymmetrical: kids could call parents, but parents mostly could not call kids.

reply
I grew up in the early 90s, pagers were common among doctors and drug dealers, but cell phones were largely a novelty (and those that did exists were the size of shoe boxes, so usually mounted in a car's center console).

If mom or dad needed to contact me, they called the office. If it was urgent, the office dispatched somebody to come get me out of class. This happened to me approximately never, but on odd occasion it did happen to somebody.

And as noted, if I needed to contact mom or dad, I used the pay phone. If it was just "come and get me from sport practice", I didn't even feed in a quarter, I just called collect and they didn't bother accepting.

Parents are a bit insane today. Growing up (pre-teens through teens), I could disappear for the better part of a day and it was no big deal. I'd ride my bike into the city (20 miles each way). I'd go skiing with friends and be gone until well after dark.

Similarly, when my son was a similar age, he's skateboard all around town. He had a cell phone for part of that period, but we pretty much never texted him and he was even less likely to text us. Kids need to stretch their wings.

reply
Before the phone era, you wouldn't have to make those calls, because your parents didn't care what you were up to. You could even stay over with friends for a few days without telling your parents and it wouldn't have mattered a whole lot.

Then, of course, the media was full of scary murderers during the late 1960s and 1970s and things changed. Laws also changed to get parents on the hook.

reply
Without any sort of phone, I might have been less inclined to do an unplanned activity that would keep me at school after the school bus left, because getting home by public transit was obnoxiously slow, it was too far to credibly walk, a safe bike route basically didn’t exist, and none of my friends were old enough to have a car. But I was lucky that my parents’ commutes were such that one of them could come and get me after work if I managed to arrange it. Which I sometimes did by using the aforementioned pay phone to call their office.

I don’t know about any relevant laws, but this was a big city, well after the 1970s. I semi-regularly walked myself a mile or so after elementary school to a parent’s office and no one batted an eye, but this may have been partially a result of the fact that the route was quite safe and largely car-free. Hmm, maybe the problem with kids’ freedom these days has as much to do with busy roads dividing up the world as with fear of school shootings.

I think that public transit in the particular area where my middle school was would have been, if anything, worse in the pre-phone era.

reply
As a young kid we had to ask the office to make a call. When we were older we had a student (landline) phone for outgoing calls that we didn’t have to ask to use.

Parents called the office and left messages directly or had the kids call back.

reply
Did we? I don’t recall it ever being something that we pushed as an issue or a concern, or an agenda item of the PTA or various parent groups I was a member of. Semi-anecdotal I’ll admit.

I’m a parent to 2 kids that are in NYC public school system, one just left for college. There were persistent calls to block phones very early on.

reply
The increase and decrease in phones have the same cause. I think it is argued about safety but it is more about control.

When you hear people complaining about their kids being antisocial by using their phones, their kids actually are socialising.

The problem is when parents gave their kids the option of who to socialise with, they chose people other than their parents.

The harmful parts of phones come from the abundance of things trying to monitize their use. That is something that permeates society. It should be addressed across the board.

In a nutshell I think phones are bad because just about every product is bad now. Phones ara just a subset of everything.

Phones are targeted because of parents wanting to restrict the autonomy of their kids.

Then, as they grow up, we wonder why they feel so powerless in society.

reply
>When you hear people complaining about their kids being antisocial by using their phones, their kids actually are socialising.

Sometimes they're socializing online, but very often they're just scrolling through short form video or some other algorithmic feed of content created by strangers.

reply
Which is odd because growing up in the 90's our parents would simply drive to the school, instruct the principal something terrible has happened and needed to be dismissed. Otherwise, you found out when you got home from school.

I have no idea where this constant need to be in contact with your kids came from. Because even in the dawning of the technological brave new world, we didn't need that level of attachment to our parents and vice versa.

reply
Parents and students live with the threat of school sh*tings
reply
They live with the anxiety of school shootings, which while tragic (and to which our complete lack of response is utterly unacceptable) are extraordinarily rare. Your child is more likely to be killed by overheating in a car than to be shot at school.

People are bad at risk assessment, news at 11.

reply
This "contact for safety" argument has been mostly solved by the new alerting systems schools use now, which will text parents the moment there's a real safety issue.
reply
I am still absolutely perplexed and bamboozled by the actual real fact that there are parents texting their children at school, during classes, to check how they are doing on a daily basis.
reply
School shootings. That's the safety issue parents are imagining.
reply
I've gone through a version of this as a parent. One afternoon, I received a phone call from my son as he and his class were fleeing into the woods behind his school due to shots fired on the campus. As I drove the 30 minutes to an area near his school (not to the school, I didn't want to be in the way or in danger) and was passed by a constant stream of police vehicles, the only thing keeping me sane was the occasional message from my son. He and dozens of schoolmates made it to a neighborhood near the school where people that were home took them in, fed them, and helped them feel safe.

As it turned out, the actual issue was a hoax call about a student with a gun and an accidental gun misfire by an investigating police officer leading to a "shots fired" emergency.

All that said, I still think phones in school is a net negative for the kids. It's a massive distraction.

reply
Our school district has had a number of similar “false alarms” in the last few years. Usually about once season.

Students will notice something concerning (an unidentified object in someone’s backpack, a threatening comment online by a peer, a rumor, etc) and text their parents instead of reporting it to an adult at the school who could investigate.

The parents (not knowing what else to do since they are not in the school) call police, tell other parents, post on social media. Leading to a wave of parents calling the front office and rushing to pick up their kids from class early.

reply
That's a comfort thing rather than a safety thing. In a version of that story where he didn't have a phone, the eventual outcome would have been the same.

The actual safety argument is really thin. You'd need a situation where the adults are out of contact, the kids are in a position to use their phones, they aren't in a position to use a wall phone or find a friendly adult, and somehow that communication is critical to their survival. I'm not sure this ever happens, even rarely.

reply
>accidental gun misfire by an investigating police officer leading to a "shots fired" emergency

Cops are jokes, man. They should be required to have a 4-year degree and pass military style firearms training, not whatever gobbledygook is happening at the academies.

reply
You can have whatever education level you want for your local cops. You just have to be willing to pay for it, as a taxpayer.
reply
Reading comments like this is pretty wild when living in a country with compulsory multi-year training for new police officers.
reply
Parents want to text their kids during the school day in places where this is not a concern. You only need a few sufficiently needy or neurotic parents to get the schools to relax policies (which is also why legislation to ban phones helps even if schools ‘should’ all have bans anyway: they get to say that their hands are forced if parents complain)
reply
Especially in a case of school shooting, parents shouldn't be calling their kids.
reply
They are expecting their kids to text them so they can call the police.
reply
The last thing emergency services need during a calamity is a horde of random people calling them about the thing theyre already aware of.

I got emergency response training from my university when I was on the board of an association and one of the big things they told us was, call the university emergency number rather than 112 because we (the university) are in more direct contact with emergency services, have well thought out calamity plans, a better overview of things like open buildings and where people are, cameras, etc.

reply
Which is frankly bonkers on its own. Kids should know to call 911 first if they believe they are in a life threatening situation. Relaying information back through a parent who’s not on location is not ideal
reply
Wow, there really are a lot of goddamned stupid parents
reply
Yeah, like imagine your kid is hiding from the shooter, and their phone buzzes or rings because you called to check on them.
reply
deleted
reply
deleted
reply
This line got brought up constantly at a local school board meeting when a phone policy was being drafted (And is brought up by parents to admin when their children are reprimanded for phone use)

It appears to be either:

A. An excuse to get their kid out of trouble for scrolling TikTok & Reels during class

B. A weak attempt to provide a socially-justifiable reason for the parent’s general anxiety (constantly texting their kid, watching their precise location, using Life360 to see their messages with peers and fine-grained activity)

C. A futile effort to exercise control over a hypothetical situation where the parent is stripped of control. What are you going to do if you get a text saying “there’s a shooter in the school”? Call the police? The faculty all have phones and are doing the same. Text them back saying “okay I love you”?

reply
C. In Uvalde parents got their kids out of the school while the police stood around and did nothing. But yes, being able to say "I love you" means something.
reply
A horrible failure by police to do their job. The police also actively restrained and handcuffed parents who were trying to get in to the school.

Taking a broader look at the situation, kids being rescued in heroic efforts by parents when police are actively not doing their job or making a situation worse, the solution to this is probably not unregulated phone access for children during school hours.

reply
We really don't hate the media enough. An extremely rare occurrence that gets boosted whenever one occurs has convinced every parent in America it's happening everywhere, constantly, and thus we need to compromise the education of every student in the school to work around it.

Might as well leave your kid home at that point, iPad in hand. Even less ""risk"" when they were never going to learn anything at school anyway if they are allowed access to devices.

reply
Not an American, but have family living there. In two separate occasions, my nephews were in a lockdown because of a potential shooter in the area. The problem is, the hoaxes, bomb threats and etc. do not contribute to the statistics, but they make everything much worse.

I'm very sorry to say this, but I have no idea how you guys live like that.

reply
> I'm very sorry to say this, but I have no idea how you guys live like that.

Unrelated to the topic, but keep this in mind when you see or read any news coming out of the U.S. There is no war on U.S. soil, so it's not a literal war zone, but the population has been living in a similar state of heightened arousal perpetually since Sept. 11, 2001. Everyone's brain has been paralyzed with fight-or-flight since then. Constant state of being afraid and on edge, fed and amplified by the media and the politicians (who are all victims of it as well, to some degree). You can't make rational decisions when in constant panic. It becomes a feedback loop of panic and overreaction, over-correction, and irrational actions causing more fear and paranoia- some justified, some not. I truly believe this explains a lot of what has happened to the country in the last decades.

reply
lol what the ACTUAL fuck are you talking about
reply
That's a great description of the first few years after 9/11. But now, bollocks. Sure, there are always-online people that are like this, but not your average Joe on the street, at least where I live.
reply
deleted
reply
Extremely rare? Not in the US. There's about 250-350 school shootings a year in the US. More than 1 a day
reply
Yes, it is extremely rare. As a comparison, the US has about 40,000 deaths from car crashes per year. About 110 deaths per day. Your kid's risk of dying on the drive to school is 10,000% higher than from being shot during the day.

Also, the school shooting statistics grossly misrepresent the real risk for the average family, because distribution is extremely biased towards violence that happens in a tiny number of high schools with high crime, drug and gang problems.

Few things are as emotionally overwhelming as the idea of your child being killed, so people react based on how strongly they feel about the issue, not by rationally assessing the real risk. A Columbine-style random mass shooter is like being afraid of a shark attack at the beach - it strikes terror into people, but it's not factually in the top hundred or thousand things you should rationally be worried about.

reply
Everyone rushing to the comments to try and justify the the data is fascinating. People claiming that it's not as bad as car deaths, and that it's all gang violence, and that people didn't actually die so it doesn't count.

It seems people are extremely desperate to talk their way around the US having a problem. Here in the UK we had 1 school shooting ever, and that's not trying to justify our way around the data by claiming that gang violence doesn't count. That's just one shooting

reply
The UK has significantly fewer people than the US, so fewer shootings is expected even if all other factors are the same. Trying to contextualize the data is a good thing, even if you try to frame it negatively.
reply
The data on school shootings is very inconsistent. In most of the sources, a shooting between gangs that happens on a weekend at 2am that happens to be in school grounds is reported as a school shooting. So is any other murder between anyone on campus including staff, etc, even if they're not "mass" or "random" killings. Even suicide is often counted in these lists.

The closest analog we have for "person goes into a school while it's in session to kill people at random" is the FBI's list of "active shooter" incidents, and only some of those are counted as "Mass killings", and the data there says we've has as little as 3 (in 2024) and as many as 15 (in 2023) per year in the past 5 years: https://usafacts.org/articles/what-is-considered-a-mass-shoo...

And that 3-15 number is all mass killings, not just in schools (I don't know how many of those were in schools, but we could stipulate maybe 1 in 3?)

So, the 250-350 number is a couple of orders of magnitude higher than the type of school shootings parents are actually worried about when it comes to needing to text them during the day.

reply
I spent an hour or so analyzing these data a little while after we had kids, to see if school shootings were something I should spend any effort or money trying to hedge against, or any brain-space worrying about, whatsoever.

The TL;DR is "no, not at all, it's not a close call".

Even with extremely generous assumptions (and no attempt at all to adjust for differences in distributions of incidents, geographically) I landed on a pretty small, though very much not zero (this was years ago, but IIRC ~2.5%) chance a given child of mine would even be on on campus for the most generous definition of a "school shooting", which can include negligent discharge anywhere on school property, any kind of murder or suicide (the murders are almost always targeted at one person, often against an adult, like jilted-lover or angry-spouse stuff, or targeted gang/drug-trade related violence, plus this can include incidents that involve nobody attached to the school but happen on e.g. a street corner that's school property), and loads of other stuff that aren't "person with gun starts randomly murdering anyone they see in a school", at any time, for their entire k-12 education.

Since the kinds of shootings people think of when they hear "school shooting" are a teensy, tiny sliver of all "school shootings", the odds of being present for that (again, over 13 entire years) would fall into the "vanishingly small" category.

And that's present-during, which I judged as the broadest reasonable category for "suffered significant harm". Actually shot in a school mass shooting, over an entire 13-year school career? Such low odds it may as well be 0%, for the purposes of individual risk assessment.

On the one hand, it's shameful these (the kind of mass, or attempted-mass, indiscriminate shootings people mean when they say "school shooting") happen with the frequency they do, in the US. On the other hand, they're nonetheless rare enough that they're not, on an individual level, really worth worrying about at all.

Policy-wise, the only shift performing this analysis made for me is that I'm now definitely opposed to active shooter drills in schools. I think they're doing quite a bit more net-harm than good.

(Part of why the numbers work out the way they do is that there are an absolute shitload of k-12 schools in the US; it's a big, high-population place. A quick search [I've forgotten the numbers from my original analysis] turns up ~100,000 public k-12 schools, and another 33,000 or so private schools, though IIRC I ignored the existence of private schools for my analysis, as I wasn't sure whether some of the stats I'd turned up included them or not, which was one of the ways I erred on the side of caution)

reply
In 2025 there were 18 incidents where someone was injured with a firearm on school grounds and 6 of those happened during school hours. In total three students were murdered across two separate school shootings.
reply
> Extremely rare? Not in the US. There's about 250-350 school shootings a year in the US. More than 1 a day

Where are you getting this data. I think that's way off. [0] Says 268 since 2018, where a school shooting is any shooting on school property, whether during school hours or not.

[0]: https://www.edweek.org/leadership/school-shootings-this-year...

reply
deleted
reply
People often imagine school shootings as school mass schooting, despite these are a tiny fraction of school schootings.
reply
From a view outside of the US, any shooting is bad. Whether it was mass or a single incident, even if no-one was killed. Any school shooting should not be brushed off
reply
If ‘school shooting’ statistics are anything like other gun violence statistics, the vast majority of those are inner city gang activity in the vague vicinity of a public school, not Columbine copycats.
reply
Pretty sure 350 < 365, decidedly less than 1 per day
reply
School day
reply
deleted
reply
I'd call this "true, but qualified." The last few years have had 250+ school shootings a year in the USA

https://k12ssdb.org/

However, it is clear that 1). this was a historical peak that has declined and 2). an artifact of COVID era. I work in data science, and one thing I think most data scientists know about the COVID era was that there were a lot of behavioral discontinuities in that time, and they are not representative of life outside of COVID era. Everything seems to be reverting back to the mean, which if we are talking school shootings, thats gonna be closer to 100-150 a year.

Far too high, but also far lower than the number you cite. If we are going to make policy or discuss it, best to do so on the basis of honest data.

reply
>There's about 250-350 school shootings a year in the US. More than 1 a day

There's almost 1000 civil aviation accidents per year in the US, so 3x more than school shootings, yet most people don't go on a plane thinking this is something that will surely happen to them every time they board.

So yeah, the way media handles accidents has a huge impact on how gen-pop perceives threats.

Remember, the point of the media is to ragebait and fearmonger you to drive views and engagement, not to educate you. For education, you'll have to read books and papers.

reply
250-300 school shootings a year still seems crazy. By comparison, in the UK we have had 1 in total (not per year).
reply
>250-300 school shootings a year still seems crazy.

When you factor in US guns/capita, easy access to firearms over there compared to anywhere else in the world, prevalence of mental illnesses, drug use, bullying, average crime rates in the area etc, it's not actually that much. Plus if you start to deep dive, highest chances of shootings tend to be clustered into a few hotspot areas, that if you avoid, then chances of school shooting drop to zero.

For Americans it might also seem crazy that people in the UK have 800–1,200+ times[1] the chance of getting stabbed than US children getting shot, and at how many people in UK get arrested for online speech that would be protected under the first amendment in the US, so it's never apples to apples comparisons between countries, as everything differs.

  [1]
  US school shooting rates: 0.07–0.1 per 100,000 people
  UK knife stabbing rates: 80–90 per 100,000 people
reply
Well if you're comparing knife homicide rates then the US still has the UK beat at 0.46 per 100k for the US and 0.28 PER 100K for the UK.

The "stabbing" rate you gave has the right figure, but is not correct. That's for all knife crimes which includes threats without stabbing. There's no public statistics for what percentage actually include stabbing, but estimates have it at about 75% threats without injury.

Then that's difficult to compare to the US because the US doesn't differentiate because it includes all knife crimes under aggravated assault

reply
> That's for all knife crimes which includes threats without stabbing

It also includes merely possessing a knife with blade length over 2.5 inches in public, with no crime otherwise committed.

reply
> For Americans it might also seem crazy how many people in UK get arrested for online speech

I mean, I would agree that this a problem! Still, I'd rather be arrested (most of these people are never actually charged with anything) than my children be shot.

reply
>most of these people are never actually charged with anything

Because as they say, "The Process Is the Punishment".

>I'd rather be arrested

I'd rather not, since it's something that can be avoided, by not having a government that treats 1984 as a model. But you can't really control if someone one day decides to stab or shoot you the same way you can't control if you get hit by lightning or by a drunk driver.

>than my children be shot

Most american school children will never be shot regardless of what they do. But the chance of speech arrest in the UK depends on what you say to who.

reply
Please listen to yourself. "1 school shooting per day isn't that much, really". Is this what the excuses have come to?

I don't believe there are 1200 school stabbings per day in the UK, either. That sounds made up.

reply
It seems the concept of 'per capita' is beyond your intellectual capacities
reply
deleted
reply
People do text their loved ones to let them know they have landed
reply
The planes most people fly on are extremely safe. You're safer on one of those than you are in your own shower. The average number of airliner crashes per year in the US over the past decade is 0.1. The figure you quoted includes small planes, which are orders of magnitude more dangerous, especially small planes operated by hobby pilots. As a hobby pilot myself, I'd say that if you get in a plane like that without at least making sure your life insurance is paid up, you're fooling yourself. And most people do think small planes are kind of dangerous (and rightfully so).

Bad example aside, this is certainly a real phenomenon. It's not about ragebait or fearmongering. Those certainly don't help, but even news that deliberately avoids those and only tries to inform will suffer from it. News is, by definition, unusual. The more unusual it is, the more news it is. A fatal car crash might get a one-sentence mention in the local media. A business jet crash makes national headlines. A fatal airliner crash makes international headlines for months. That can easily form an upside-down impression of their frequency if folks aren't thinking about how news works.

reply
Quick search reports that just commercial airline incidents are responsible for 857 deaths since 2000 while school shooting deaths total 220. So the point stands especially if you tried to account for more hours spent in school than on a commercial airliner. Per hour your airliner is probably orders of magnitude more likely to crash and kill you than a student is likely to die in a shooting.
reply
Yeah, there's still a contrast there, I just had to correct that outrageously bad number about planes. 1,000 crashes per year in the kind of planes ordinary people actually fly in would make aviation the leading cause of accidental death, and put it in the top 10 of all causes of death.

I still don't think it's a very good example, at least not in the direction it was meant to apply. Flying is one of the least risky activities there is. Despite this, a substantial portion of the population is scared of flying. It's another example of people being irrationally scared due to disproportionate reporting, not the opposite as was presented.

reply
Extremely rare?

please, the US propaganda is strong here. That is the only country in the world where guns are so normalised that parents are legitimately worried about a random person shooting their kids in a school. Wikpiedia has multiple pages of school shootings in the US, so many that they have been grouped by decade. Five people were killed just a month back. In 2025, 71 school shootings happened. That is absolutely insane.

Seriously, take a good, long, hard, look at your usage of the term "extremely rare".

reply
You're more likely to die being driven to school than you are in a school shooting. Of those 71 - how many were targeted gang on gang violence?

With over 100,000 schools - school shootings, as common as they are when compared to other countries, still classify as an "extremely rare event".

To compare it against other common concerns. You should be more worried about your child drowning than them going through a school shooting and more worried about them choking on their school lunch every day than them dying in a school shooting.

That parents worry about it and whether parents should be worrying about it are two different things.

reply
which country has "active shooter drills" in schools as part of "normal" life?

Could you please explain why these exist in only one country?

It is truly amazing the levels of mental gymnastics and excuses that people in the US make instead of admitting that guns are a problem.

reply
The continued argument of "Safety paranoia makes parents concerned about a non-issue" is not that America is crazy for having active shooter drills.

It's that the event is so rare that we shouldn't have active shooter drills for the same reason we don't have tornado drills in California schools.

reply
The point in question is whether allowing children to have phones in schools is a vital need so that they can communicate with their parents during shootings, not whether guns are a problem in the U.S. I would say definitely no to the former and definitely yes to the latter.
reply
France. France has shooting drills now. Fins have been forbidden by the nazis in 1941, but we didn't do a good job recently at it. So kids are taught how to react to terrorist attacks, because it's a useful skill to learn in school, they decided.
reply
I've been looking for international data for a long time. I've come up short on a good, citation-quality source. Can you share?

Are you certain that America is the only one? Are we considering all countries, or are we talking about a subset?

reply
deleted
reply
The USA is big, but 415 deaths in 405 shootings in 2026 is not exactly "rare" to justify kids having a phone. I don't totally disagree with your though. It's the same kind of slippery slope that leads to everyone having a massive truck to protect themselves.
reply
You appear to be looking at this data [0], which is for all "mass shootings" not school shootings in particular.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_mass_shootings_in_the_...

reply
And much like having a massive truck, having a phone might make you feel better but it does little to nothing to actually make you safer.
reply
> An extremely rare occurrence

The US has anything around 250-350 shootings a year (I wonder where the spike during covid comes from?!) [1]. The entirety of Europe including the European parts of Russia and Turkey struggles to reach 10 incidents a year [2], with quite a few of them being barely relevant (accidental discharge, mafia drive-by gone bad). Europe is about the same size as the US and has about double the population, so the risk per person and year to experience a shooting is orders of magnitude more large than in the US.

On top of that, gun violence and accidents are the top killer for children and young adolescents in the US [3].

You don't have a problem with the media, you have a problem with guns. And with "you" I mean "Americans as a whole", because Switzerland and Czechia (the countries with the most permissive firearms regulations and similar ownership rates to the US) don't have school shootings being a thing.

[1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/1463594/number-of-k-12-s...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_school_shootings_in_Eu...

[3] https://publichealth.jhu.edu/2024/guns-remain-leading-cause-...

reply
> We really don't hate the media enough

The media isn't shooting kids.

> An extremely rare occurrence

26 school shootings have occurred in 2026 alone as of Oct 16. [1] That's not extremely rare to me. Extremely rare are the typical things Republicans campaign on, like widespread voter fraud or schools performing sex change operations.

> has convinced every parent in America it's happening everywhere,

Schools have active shooter drills. This has, in fact, saved lives. It's not something that doesn't happen.

I mean, it's happening in most states. Just not all the time.

But no, blame the media instead of blaming the shooters and the government that doesn't do anything to prevent it even when it knows how.

1. https://www.usnews.com/news/best-states/articles/states-with...

reply
If you look at the actual underlying data [0] most of these school shootings are escalations of fights, especially at football games. These are not what most people think of when they think of 'school shootings', where someone is rampaging through the halls executing everyone they see.

[0]: https://www.edweek.org/leadership/school-shootings-this-year...

reply
Yeah from 2000-2025, there have been 35 "active shooter" type school shootings. There were roughly 30 "school shootings" per year between 1992 and 1999. They dropped to about 15 per year until 2020 when the number spiked back up to the 30 range where we are now
reply
So school shootings are school shooting. Gotcha.

The argument that you only want to count cases where someone is walking the hallways, shooting people at random, wearing a trench coat and using a rifle and not a pistol while wearing black shoes and they have to listen to heavy metal is silly. School shootings are shootings that happen at school. Hell, you couldn't even describe it without renaming it to "active shooters" in quotes.

reply
The point is again, relating to phones at school. If you look at most of the actual school shootings that happen, they are unrelated to the kind of anxieties that lead to suburban parents claiming their kids need phones in class in case of a school shooting. Many of them are not during school hours at all, and most are one-off incidents of interpersonal violence and highly correlated to areas of the U.S. that already have high levels of violence.

This is not a general thread about gun violence and whether it's bad and whether the U.S. has a lot of it.

reply
I've heard the rise of safety-ism and anxiety can be linked to the missing children photos on the back of milk jugs in the 70s. Also throw in media streaming national news instead of local news and you get a distorted idea of the dangers in your local community.

Maybe the terrorism and other turmoil in the 70s sunk into the generational subconscious and also contributes to the modern anxiety.

Anyway, parents (among others) are anxious and can be influenced/manipulated by playing into those fears

reply
Today's parents of school-aged kids largely weren't even born in the 70s, so milk jug thing probably isn't true. (I'm about to turn 50, born in '77, if I had a kid at 30, they'd be 20 and out of school).

But, the national media, with it's need to get views/clicks/engagement, pushes a steady stream of outrage-porn, doom-porn, anxiety-porn, whatever you want to call it. And I suspect that doesn't help anybody.

reply
In post-USSR of the late 90s and early 00s it was a safety measure because of all of the street crime.
reply
> parents texting their children at school, during classes, to check how they are doing on a daily basis.

That's the least surprising part, to me. The immediately severely addictive nature of The Devil's Whispering Obsidian Mirror of Everlasting Distraction is more of a "why didn't the teachers ban it sooner?" thing than a "why might parents who have the same addiction, prefer using their Endless Scroll Distraction Oblong to talk to their kids than spend another minute doing whatever boring job the economy forced upon them?"

15 years ago, when my then-girlfriend was phoning me in the middle of the work day, it was surprising; but then, I am a massive introvert*, and by the power of the Typical Mind Fallacy** the idea of people wanting to just hang out with me all day was a thing I had to learn rather than it just being my expectation the whole time.

We're a social species. Checking in on each other is the norm. Parents on their kids, moreso. I wish now my parents had been more like that than they were, though I finished school at basically the same year 84x48 black and white 2G phones got affordable: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nokia_8210

* an introvert? On a nerd website? Surely not! :P

** https://www.lesswrong.com/w/typical-mind-fallacy

reply
Completely understandable desire on the part of parents.

With that context, it seems like the core problem with having phones in schools might be the "smart" part, due to the amount of competing content that is brought into a student's presence when they should be focussed on socializing and academic work.

On the other hand, non-smart phones are decidedly boring. Has any school attempted allowing non-smart phones only? Really curious what the outcomes might be.

reply
So they did not consider school a safe space for their children, basically? There's probably a lot to unpack there.
reply
> Parents insisted that they needed to be in contact with their kids. Not being able to text the kids was a safety issue and strong inconvenience.

Because in the rare event of a mass shooting, you want to be able to text your kid so their phone beeps, potentially revealing their location.

It's not a safety issue, it's an anxiety/annoyance issue.

reply
"safety issue" of moms who need more valium.
reply
Our school gets them to hand them in and pick them up at the end of the day. We appreciate contact later on as plans change, buses are late, its kind of rural.

(these are secondary+ kids though).

What is the main problem, is the schools depending on access to phones (and computers in part) to do their homework. I don't mind a PC/Laptop if they provide the account - but what we're hitting on is the requirement for MFA, and with MS this means you're stuck with their "Authenticator", which hard requires GSF, which requires a google account to download (I know I can get around some of these). Google accounts require a phone number... etc etc. Terrible, ive refused - we get homework on paper, and books to actually read.

reply
Meanwhile, most places are objectively safer than when those parents were kids. I feel bad for kids who are expected to always be at their parents' beck and call.
reply
When I was a kid my parents just called the school
reply
I'm both confused and not terribly surprised that people don't seem to recall that's an option.
reply
Today's parents are the kids who were raised to never talk to strangers (for "safety") and so are largely also extremely adverse to that sort of "call a stranger" option.
reply
Don't call a stranger. Call the school.
reply
And those parents always kind of pissed me off. My kids are 5 and 10 and have never had a phone at school. In fact, the youngest kids never had phones at school. Of people can send their 5 and 6 year olds to school with no phones and easy contact, I don't want to hear crap from the parents of teenagers.

The entire argument they made was complete nonsense.

reply
perceived safety issue
reply
Not being able to text the kids was a safety issue and strong inconvenience.

It's just feeding the Stranger Danger™ industry.

Ignore the fact that crime rates in America are at 100-year lows, as long as we can make people paranoid so they buy our tech gadgets and alarms and doorbell cameras, which do nothing other than allow someone 50 miles away watch a thief walk away with his Amazon box.

reply
But what's the root cause analysis? Big tech infesting our society with social media addiction so that they can personally profit from it.

Everyone who builds these products and profits from doing so is responsible for this.

So what is the solution? It seems to me that we should look at what was done to the tobacco companies in the previous century. Regulate these companies and fine them for the damage that they've intentionally caused to society.

reply
Study shows average US teenager gets >200 app notifications per day: https://www.michiganmedicine.org/health-lab/study-average-te... These young people are supposed to be preparing for life years down the line. The half-life of usefulness of these notifications is about 15 seconds.
reply
Imagine how much better off we’d be, with capacity to nimbly and efficiently both establish new regulations and repeal existing ones. We do the opposite, make it difficult to regulate and difficult to deregulate. Much commerce, especially tech, depends upon the lack of regulatory agility, especially since it often allows the industry to supply the agility when needed by writing the regulations themselves, or guiding via lobby.
reply
It was never a safety issue. That was bullshit people made up to justify their anger over a meaningless invoncenience.
reply
an inconvenience we had lived with for all of humanity.
reply
IMO one cause of this and many other problems in the public education system is that parents have too much influence in the education system.

Nowadays, if they give a kid a failing grade, there's a good chance the parents show up to try and intimidate their way into a pass... Instead of figuring out why their kid is failing. Same goes if their kid gets into trouble - their angel can do no wrong, why are you being mean?

This kind of stuff was happening 20 years ago, I am not surprised it's gotten worse. Parents by and large are unqualified to make decisions about education, but have outsized influence in it. It's probably a huge reason why the US public educational system has been getting smoked by Europe and east Asia, where parents have less insurance.

reply
>Parents by and large are unqualified to make decisions about education

This attitude will drive people away from public schools (and already has). Parents are major stakeholders in their children's education and public schools must be accountable to the public. For the benefit of everyone, there should be a better process for handling the input from parents.

I think we would agree there needs to be a balance. Arguing about changing an F to some passing grade is wrong. But it's also incentivized by the schools and states to meet metrics, so it's unfair to just cast this blame on the parents. But absolutely parents who do this are in the wrong and schools should not enable it.

Some things experts should have broad leeway on are methods. How they structure a reading curriculum or teach long division. Not so much on enforcing certain goals or values.

And the more results that the schools deliver, the more deference from parents they will be able to expect. But the more contention there is between parents and schools, the worse public school support will become.

reply
> This attitude will drive people away from public schools (and already has)

This is a net positive because it will mostly be the people harming the education system through unqualified micromanagement.

> Not so much on enforcing certain goals or values.

Yes, schools shouldn't go beyond the basic virtues society is built on (don't steal, don't bully, etc). But telling them they can't have an addictive device, designed to monetize their attention, is not about virtue. You can't learn how to multiply if you're watching tiktok instead of paying attention.

> the more contention there is between parents and schools, the worse public school support will become.

This is a hard cultural problem. The US seems to have been doing better when parents trusted schools and pushed their kids to succeed. European and East Asian schools similarly trust educators in a way Americans don't. But yes, things would be better if parents trusted schools more.

reply
>This is a net positive because it will mostly be the people harming the education system through unqualified micromanagement.

Well not really, since it pulls support from the public schools. Which are struggling.

>But telling them they can't have an addictive device, designed to monetize their attention, is not about virtue. You can't learn how to multiply if you're watching tiktok instead of paying attention.

Totally agree on that. Phones shouldn't be in schools.

>> the more contention there is between parents and schools, the worse public school support will become.

>This is a hard cultural problem. The US seems to have been doing better when parents trusted schools and pushed their kids to succeed. European and East Asian schools similarly trust educators in a way Americans don't. But yes, things would be better if parents trusted schools more.

How would this be a problem, and not a solution, if unsupportive parents pulled out, as you stated above? It's a two way street. Both parents and schools need to feel the relationship is beneficial for the relationship to sustain itself.

reply
Completely agree. Early education is the time to be protective of social dynamics formation without overeager parents blowing up every PTA meeting and skewing things for everyone. Definitely empathize with educators that have to deal with this balancing act.
reply
> Parents by and large are unqualified to make decisions about education

Especially in the sense of grading and assessment, but I wouldn't generalize this. Both in the sense of do they actually make good decisions on things they can (sometimes) control, such as school (district) selection — barring interesting exceptions like Nikole Hannah-Jones I think they do — and whether they are legally or morally thus qualified. Not that you're implying this, but I bristle a little at the use of the term, since it connotes the removal of parent agency by state action. Caution is advisable there.

reply
They are experts, but they are providing a service. There needs to be a balance. Your doctor is another primary example.

I think one guiding principle is methods vs. values. An expert has more authority on methods, but values need broad alignment between the service provider and the the people they serve. And neither party is entitled to the other - both parties need to feel the relationship is mutually beneficial for the relationship to be sustainable.

So there is some truth in needing to defer to educators, but not absolutely.

reply
I think you are giving too much credit to us!

The problem was already entrenched before anyone noticed and cared.

Not just a school issue: my 8 yr old daughter asked me to install a TikTok alternative on her iPad. She’s not allowed to use it much - long care rides mostly.

But she found out from a friend who lives in a home with a more liberal policy. Happened on a playdate after school. And so I am negotiating from behind the curve.

reply
>But she found out from a friend who lives in a home with a more liberal policy. Happened on a playdate after school. And so I am negotiating from behind the curve.

This is precisely why it can't be solved without collective action.

And what's crazy is that studies have found that while kids don't want to be left out of social media, they do want everyone to be off it. Which is more or less corroborated by the top level comment:

>My kids (16 and 13) both attend schools that recently implemented phone bans and they love it, somewhat surprisingly.

reply
Parenting is hard. I don’t for a second downplay that (dad of 2). But I think a lot of people operate in a near-overwhelmed state and end up more likely to bend. As you said, it takes just a small number of parent-kid rule-bender combos to screw it up for a larger group.

Phones feel so obvious in that context. And phones are so easy to hide / disguise. So it’s not that they were allowed, but instead they were never banned because who understood the full extent of the issue.

I am frankly less worried about phones and more concerned about the use of Chromebooks instead of other tools. Example in my daughter’s school: kids can read books on Chromebook’s. Instead of just reading physical books. Just seems like a bad priviledge imo.

reply
> but instead they were never banned

that's patently untrue - they were banned in many schools districts across many states for much of the early part of the century...

reply
Not saying I am right and you are wrong because my statement was more about a perception of what’s handled.

But where do you see “many” in public info? How many states?

reply
Knew a set of parents that didn't allow their kid to have a phone or use a computer and he was socially isolated/bullied at school bc he couldn't participate in the shared culture at all (memes) they recently loosed to let him play Minecraft and use discord VC and it's genuinely helped a lot.

I think these anecdotes speak to the problem of individual action. If your kid is the only one not using their phone, they don't feel much benefit from not having it and are also actively punished for not being able to participate with their peers.

reply
Similar for me - but I don’t think that answers the question you’re responding to.

There were parents that let their kids drink in 7th grade when I was in school - but still kids today are not allowed to bring Jim Beam to class, just like then.

Something definitely shifted with the phones, it’d be interesting to see a documentary or read a book about how it ended up being allowed in the classrooms..

reply
> Something definitely shifted with the phones, it’d be interesting to see a documentary or read a book about how it ended up being allowed in the classrooms..

The children in schools aged out of being Gen Z (raised by Gen X) and into Gen Alpha (raised by Millennials). I think that goes pretty far to explain the shift.

I've never personally met a strict millennial parent, while my parents (and those of my peers) when I was in school seemingly still held more 'old-school' values like refusing to give their children smartphones until highschool (or until they got their own job and could buy it with their own money), being willing to ground (and punish) their kids, and restricting screen time.

reply
It's definitely a tough situation. Our kids aren't phone-aged yet but even toddlers are getting iPads as default for outings and even home life in some situations. I've heard people say that when they are more strict about phone access for older kids, the kids will just end up with secret accts on their friends devices. Yet again tech goes faster than we can figure it out
reply
Long car rides for my kids. That’s about it (from me specifically).

To your point - I think you help by sitting with, playing/understanding when your kid is using a device and you can make a point to join and not deny the activity.

reply
How do you define “strict”
reply
What period of time are you referencing?

I understand your example but am trying to align the example to phones

reply
Like - I think I got my first phone in.. 7th grade? A Sony Ericson of some kind, around 1999-2001 or so?

And like.. I cannot imagine what would have happened if I had taken that out in the classroom, in Sweden. Then I did high school in the US, and same thing there, zero chance they would allow phones out in the classroom? That was in Missouri in like 2004-2007 or so.

But I hear phones are being allowed in the classrooms, so clearly the policy changed between 2008 or so until now, right? Something shifted the classroom stance on phones between when I left the US and Swedish school systems until now that my kid is going through them

reply
It was because only the bourgeois kids had them at first, and these weren’t just average kids — their parents were were in the know techies and early adopters, Steve Jobs stans, yuppies. “If the ‘in the know’ families have cell phones”, thought normie America, “my kids should too.” Iow, blame hn here, and the early adoption crowd whose lack of wisdom and lust for the shiny got us.
reply
The tech elite famously didn't give their children devices.
reply
bourgeois=!elite

I’m talking about the precedent set by the first 10% of kids in public schools who brought in cell phones. The children of tech elite do not make up 10% of our public schools so I’m not talking about them, obviously. In any case, I don’t think the early adopters were a random sample and it was the early adopters who set precedent and determined the politics and cultural norms around cell phones at school.

reply
Anecdotal evidence here, but a number of my family members working in public education have recounted similar stories of parents threatening (or attempting) legal action when a student’s phone or iPad is taken away.

The common rationales from the parents are:

- “What if a school shooting happens? You are making them unsafe!”

- “Their IEP says they need it!” (It almost never does, or calls for device access for a very specific, limited reason tied to a communication tool or educational outcome. Not unlimited video scrolling)

reply
I feel like all the posts claiming “parents” are giving too much power to, well, parents.

I graduated circa 2010 in an incredibly wealthy district - and the district was constantly pushing technology oriented mandates in the name of modernization and progress that no one asked for. Smart boards, laptops for note taking(?), and on and on.

The teachers hated them, the students, at least us high schoolers that grew up without this ineffective junk, we mocked it, the parents were at best ambivalent.

But always some careerist district employee with no allegiance to school nor county nor state would push policies for a promotion then jump ship a few years later.

reply
So basically same logic as most hierarchies involving money and power: greedy self serving fucks get into power and self serve because decent people want to do some actual work.
reply
> don't understand when it become allowed honestly

A lot of folks subscribe to the view that early constant exposure to technology gives on advantages with said tech.

I sort of see it with e.g. Bill Gates and computers. But for a mass technology, the idea that incumbency will dominate is broken by asking a simple question: is every kid born for the next decades fucked because someone alive has more years using this particular tech? The answer is always no—fundamental cognitive skills beat familiarity every time.

reply
Related; my teachers used much this argument:

> A lot of folks subscribe to the view that early constant exposure to technology gives on advantages with said tech.

In the late 90s to justify Windows over MacOS, "because Apple will be bankrupt soon".

Even though Apple's still around, MacOS classic isn't. But Classic MacOS's UX paradigms are only as outdated as Windows 98's, and even for iOS almost none of the UI/UX I've been paid to implement has totally adhered to Apple's standards, which themselves have shifted significantly since phones replaced desktops and laptops for most people most of the time.

reply
I graduated high school in 2016 and most of us had smartphones by then. I remember many teachers bought these little phone pocket things to hang on the whiteboard which had numbers 1-30 on them. We were each assigned a number at the beginning of the year, and they would count attendance by whether we had a phone in the pocket. Teachers would confiscate phones when they were out in class, too.

One friend of mine really foreshadowed the trends that happened in the next decade. He has ADHD and terrible handwriting and got an accommodation to have a laptop in class. He brought his gaming laptop and just played games all day but would back out to a notes page and tell his teachers that he had an IEP and was taking notes every time they called him on it. They gave up pretty quickly and he just played games all day every day.

reply
>> Bonkers to me that we ever allowed this.

It was never allowed, I get the impression Meta and other social media platforms pushed stories that told parents they were doing the right thing insisting their kids had a phone for safety/emergency contact and the parents succumbed to the pressure as no parent wants to be seen as "irresponsible".

Which is ridiculous as the school is a fundamentally a safe zone for kids. I could of course be wildly of the mark as this is pure speculation but these companies have a track record of this sort of thing.

reply
The problem isn't just phones in class, but in school outside of class. We had phones in school, but no use for them - almost all my contacts were my classmates, who would I text?
reply
A whole bunch more school shootings scared parents into wanting connectivity, plus ability to track kids through safety/surveillance tools like Life360
reply
With no thought to what being constantly surveilled does to kids psychologically. As a parent, I know it’s hard, but parents really need to get a handle on their anxiety, helicoptering harms children. Developing independence is a core drive for them.
reply
I was in high school when the iPod touch was huge. They were definitely banned by the letter of the law, but so many kids had them that some teachers just gave up on enforcing the rule. There will always be some number of kids not paying attention or goofing off, and they don't have the energy to enforce the rule 100% of the time. Then, as smartphones became ubiquitous, the soft acceptance just snowballed.
reply
When I was in high school (elder millennial) if I needed to get in touch with my parents because plans had changed, I could use the pay phone by the front doors to call home, and indeed I carried some change for that purpose and did it maybe once a month or so. But pay phones aren't a thing any more, because of cell phones.
reply
I still remember when digital watches became affordable - if your hourly chime went off, your watch was confiscated.
reply
Probably due to tablets becoming standard use at school. It was around the same time, and I imagine it felt silly to tell kids they couldn’t use one extremely distracting device while requiring them to use another that is the same thing in a different form factor.

Phone bans are a start. Getting tablets out of the curriculum is next.

reply
I remember advocating to a teacher that an iPod touch is not a phone and therefore it should not be banned.

In general I think we were only allowed to use phones during math lessons (as calculators). This was at a time when none of us had mobile data and there was like one wifi router in the whole building.

reply
They were even dicey about calculator watches. There was a brief fad of watches with a game built in, like Pac-Man. I can’t speak to the quality of the game because we didn’t have that kind of money, but they got banned in about 72 hours which I’m sure tanked sales. One wonders why market analysis didn’t anticipate that happening. Phones at least have utility for other demographics.
reply
In my own life it was after 9/11. Despite cell service being extremely unreliable in New York that day, they wanted to be able to get a hold of me in an emergency.

I didn't get an attention-sucking smartphone until ~5 years later. Back in MY day we played snake and tetris on our TI-89s!

reply
Lots of folks here profited from and advocated for those policies.

It’s always important to consider the impact of your work and whether the dollar earned is worth the damage done.

Also, the “move fast and break things” shouldn’t be allowed anywhere near children.

reply
Not everything is a conspiracy
reply
My guess: because of those addictive dark patterns, the kids were trying it so much that teachers were exhausted with trying to enforce policy, and gave up completely.
reply
When I was a kid, we were allowed using phones during breaks. But they were "dumb phones", ie mostly used for messaging with friends.
reply
I think flip phones were allowed in a lot of schools and then I guess they gradually evolved into smartphones with social media apps?
reply
You didn't use a flip phone in class as all your could do with them was talk which was obvious. Though kids playing snake did get them taken away. For the most part a flip phone was used to call for a ride after school. (much better than waiting in line for 20 minutes for the student phone)
reply
> Which means that someone looked at the world after that point and said "yeah actually, phones are ok now" which baffles me

more like someone looked at the world after that point and said "yeah actually that makes us a lot more money"

reply
> I don't understand when it become allowed honestly. Like when I was at school, phones were never allowed. If a teacher saw one they'd confiscate it and your parents would have to come and collect it.

When and where was this? Before smartphones, teachers (at my school, Sweden, 90s/early 00s sometime) didn't give a crap about phones as long as you didn't play music out loud on it, not until society got infected with social media that teachers started telling kids to put away the phones it seems to me.

I think it was a gradual thing that's why there wasn't a "allow or forbid" moment, it just was, until it was everywhere and literally poisoning people's mind.

reply
In the US in the early mainstream-cell-phone era (95-05ish), playing with any sort of device in class would get called out if spotted by teachers.

Some of the larger-handed athletes amusingly thought their tiny Nokias were small enough to make it not obvious they were texting/playing Snake on them, but it was pretty easy to spot.

Having it in your backpack if it's not making noise? Sure. Using it? Nah.

reply
In the 1980s it was Sony walkman radios and cassette players kids where getting taken away at school. Though it didn't happen much, I think most kids knew it was a distraction.
reply
UK, around 2000-2015
reply
US, graduated 2008, we were never allowed phones either.
reply
when I was at school, phones were never allowed.

Heck, when I went to school radios weren't allowed. I got detention when the radio I had in my gym bag got jostled and turned itself on.

We also weren't allowed to have calculators until high school. We were specifically told that it was so our brains would learn to think when we were young, and then be able to use the calculator as an assistant instead of a crutch when we were older.

reply
We pushed as long as we could against "smart phones" as parents with my two sons.

Eventually gave in when the flip phone my son had as a freshman in high school couldn't run the app the marching band was using to communicate.

A very sad memory with my younger son: I was a chaperone for one of his soccer camps when he was in middle school. I remember down time between games, and thinking this is nice he can spend some time socializing with his teammates. But he was the only one without a phone, and the teammates immediately took out their phones and started scrolling, leaving my son to sit there alone in silence.

(Yeah, maybe I should have tried to convince the other kids to put down their phones, but it was an awkward moment that took me by surprise.)

reply
Thats how it was in middle school for me, and then in high school phones were basically always allowed. Its probably not a coincidence that my grades were better in middle school than they were in high school.
reply
> That was before the absolute worst addictive dark patterns etc. Which means that someone looked at the world after that point and said "yeah actually, phones are ok now" which baffles me

Zeitgeist went too deep into phone normalization. Kids are being raised by parents who were mad their phones were taken away when they were in school. Kids complain, parents then complain to admin or teachers, and teachers' authority to take away a phone slips bit by bit by bit.

The cheeky thing about a teacher's authority is, like all authority, it isn't actually real, it just exists by the consent of those over whom the authority is exerted. "Consent" being used loosely - if you can convince people via rhetoric, tricking them, intimidation or whatever, then that counts too. Anyway point is, when all the students decide together that the teacher can't actually make them put their phones away, then that becomes reality. Teachers also learn not to waste their social capital / authority on demanding something they can't get.

The teacher's job has always been hard, but I've a lot of friends and family that have been teachers up to the last 20 years, and it is absolutely getting harder. Glad to hear some school districts are getting the right idea and banning phones, kids just aren't equipped with the tools to protect their attention from those that would leech it to sell to advertisers. Maybe none of us are.

reply
Phonification of the world is right. Remember this xkcd?

https://xkcd.com/1802/

It used to be a funny premise that somebody would carry their phone just because they were leaving the house.

When I was in high school, there was a payphone in the atrium. Then everyone started carrying their own phones and they took the payphones out, so now if you don't have a phone you really are stuck.

Happened in real life, too. A few years ago I was out of town when my phone died and needed to get from one hotel to another. No problem, I thought, get a cab. Oops, hotels don't have a cab stand any more. Call one? No payphone in the lobby. The front desk doesn't have a phone, either. Lowest friction path was buying a charger. Good thing businesses just let you plug in anywhere these days.

reply
What about that one?

https://www.xkcd.com/1348/

reply
Blows my kids' minds the fact that sometimes, you couldn't watch cartoons, because there were no cartoons "on."
reply
Or waiting till a certain time, because only then you could watch your favourite show.
reply
You didn't have Cartoon Network at your house, eh
reply
in 2023 my eldest went to high school and was told that sometimes they would have to use their phone in class to do classwork.
reply
How old? What about kids without phones? Or are there none?
reply
11/12. Everyone in the class except one person had a smartphone of some sort, that person had to borrow a parent's phone to do homework, or use one of a very limited number of tablets in class. Lasted about 3 months before they got a smartphone.

In terms of phones in general, when I was at high school in the 90s I had cash and I could use a payphone to contact home when there was a problem on the bus or train or I was staying at a friends. I knew my home number, and my parent's work numbers. And the school number, and had friends numbers either memorised or written down. Those were expected paths of communication.

That world doesn't exist any more -- there aren't payphones for one thing, there aren't house phones.

reply
It doesn’t really baffle me and you seem to have the general understanding to put it together to, i.e., your awareness of dark patterns. Something related that you may not be aware of is how there was a large shift of the slot machine industry conceptually centered around Las Vegas that moved into developing mobile games and social media. It was roughly also the same time that this generational transitional phase was entered into where the older generations i.e. Gen X and older started discovering smartphones. They had resisted prior to that point, largely related to the technology, refresh cycles and adoption, lag of older generations.

The affected hat on them was essentially like the introduction of crack in urban communities. Without going into too much collaboration, it essentially was gasoline on facilitating, the pervasiveness of smart phones and social media even among children because no longer was there an actual parent left to put up guard rails and limits for children. It’s also that time period when the term iPad baby emerged. From then, on as a society, we basically had to go through the addiction arc as the predatory forces of society prayed on us and our children, being social media, mobile games, unfettered access to the Internet by ISPs facilitated by the whole ad industry and predominantly, Google, of course, lobbying for that purpose, with probably the most egregious offender, the fuel the whole addiction complex being Facebook. It may seem innocuous to some, but because I was aware of this from the very onset for reason I won’t go into right now, it was seared into my mind that day when I saw the video of Mark Zuckerberg having an impromptu unplanned little chat with a group of Facebook team employees that we’re having a outdoor get together where he said, clearly off the cuff and ad hoc, that he would like for Facebook to replace the Internet.

Now, of course, the alien known as Zuckerberg did not seemingly achieve that, but actually attempting to achieve that would have required extreme strategic maneuvering and manipulation of the kind that Facebook has been repeatedly found to engage in over the years; whether it be his approach to politics that seems to dovetail in with current transactional and corrupt values in politics or the illegal, psychological manipulation and research being performed on users, including children that Facebook was found to have engaged in.

reply
Phones in class seemed to be the result of the inability to deal with school shootings.
reply
That doesn’t make sense, phones are common in EU classrooms as well and they don’t have the school shooting problem.
reply
and in the UK, and lots of other countries too.
reply
How so? I'm not following your logic here.
reply
My recollection was the vocal complaints about banning phones in classes was from people who were concerned that their kid needed a phone to call for help if Columbine happened. This was 20 years ago before smartphones.
reply
Hard to believe; in 1999 only 29% of college students had cell phones.

https://archive.nytimes.com/www.nytimes.com/packages/html/bu...

reply
The proliferation of phones happened after 1999. A few years later it was double or triple that figure.

So you have more people getting phones, and you have parents concerned about school shootings that recently happened and were still part of the spirt of the time.

https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1999-apr-27-mn-31533...

I literally remember this on the news, my mom wouldn't let me get a phone.

reply
This isn't directly related to a school ban, but I can share another anecdote that reinforces your kids' thoughts. I'm a parent of 17 & 15 year olds and regularly (3-4x/yr) chaperone my 15yo daughter's soccer team to regional and national events. It's typically two vanloads of girls -- 18-24 kids -- and up until about three events back we let them have phones until lights out. As expected, if they weren't competing, they were on their phones. We instituted a revised policy last year where we take phones at 9pm (lights out at 10pm) and give them back after breakfast. It's made a world of difference in the camaraderie that's developed, since the girls now have to actually talk with each other. It's also led to improved travel maturity overall, and much more pleasant van rides [with only silent phone use allowed -- typically locked in with their personal pre-match music]. 10/10 do recommend.
reply
> they love it, somewhat surprisingly

The problem with phones, as well as social media, or anything else with a network effect, is that it becomes a prisoner's dilemma. You can recognise the harms, but feel the need to take part anyway, because opting out puts you at a social disadvantage. If everyone opts out, the disadvantage is neutralised

reply
deleted
reply
s/social media/AI/g
reply
I don't entirely disagree, but it would be nice if we could go one comment section without somebody making it about AI
reply
Unfortunately, given the likelihood that the world is becoming "about AI", this is only going to become more common.
reply
Someone downstream brought up an idea of a screen-less AI. HN is not the place to escape from AI discourse.

That is one thing I sort of miss about Reddit. While the offshoot is small, you can in fact take your ball and move to another court if you want a different feed that bans topics that other feeds embrace. Many subs banned politics for that reason; not because it wasn't important, but that it becomes all encompassing if allowed in more than small doses.

reply
No, there are plenty of strong reddit-wide biases that you can't escape without leaving the platform.

They might just happen to be biases that you agree with.

reply
Sure. That's built onto any given community. Escaping a sub-community is still easier to do than escaping a main community. People will migrate worhing reddit, but not many will add another social media innadition to reddit (let alone leave it entirely)
reply
s/social media/drugs and alcohol/g as well.

Actually, that works for many things that aren't exactly healthy.

reply
Turns out addiction is a problem however you slice it.
reply
That's great. I sat at dinner with my teenage nephews after the phone ban had been announced in my state but before it had gone into effect. They were all opposed to the idea and gave several reasons about why they weren't comfortable with giving up their phones. I told them some of the arguments for it and they remained skeptical until I pointed out that _noone_ would have phones and their eyes lit up as they considered the implications of that and they suddenly became excited about the upcoming ban.

I think there are more parents that want their kids reachable at all times and the kids just want to hang with their friends.

reply
Pedantic aside, _no one_ is two words.
reply
Shouldn't that be a colon rather than a comma?
reply
> they love it, somewhat surprisingly

I recommend reading The Anxious Generation by Jonathan Haidt. It's a great read on the effects of social media, phones, and general modern society on our youth.

One of the interesting bits in the book was about phone access in school. There are 3 tiers for any kid:

1) everyone has phones, including you 2) everyone has phones, except you 3) no one has phones

Option 2 has been tried by many parents over the years, to lackluster results. Kids basically feel weird and isolated if they're the only one without a phone. Turns out, as you discovered, that if no one has a phone, everyone is happier. It's something no single parent can do, but we're starting to discover that if we implement it across the whole school, it really does work.

reply
My older son (12) has his phone on my desk, and I unlock it for him when he wants it. Tried many times to give him full access, only to find out the phone usage skyrocketed to several hours a day.

When they go on a school trip, he's usually the only one without a phone and watches others glued to their screens, even when they have free time to run in a park.

Now, finally, the school purchased a box where kids lock their phones in at the start of the day and recover them at the end. They seem to enjoy it as well.

reply
We just don't give our daughter (11) a phone. She has a smart watch that can text us and a few other whitelisted phone numbers (or call them). I don't think middle school kids need an actual phone.
reply
> She has a smart watch that can text us and a few other whitelisted phone numbers (or call them)

i didn't realize there were watches with that capability, that's a really good idea.

reply
We use the Gabb smartwatch, but there are others, and our research suggested that all of them have some issues with battery life (though our daughters' has been good so far), without a clear standout of one brand being better than the other.

Obviously you need to pay a monthly subscription for the cell connectivity.

reply
Standard feature of apple watch with cellular support.
reply
Interesting. How does he handle it? I mean, does he ever get angry about it or feel excluded by the other kids? Kids can be mean.
reply
Of course, he would want to have a phone like other kids. On the train, he usually finds someone else to talk to or reads a book. Last trip he's talked to some girls which he otherwise wouldn't if he'd have a phone. At times, he gets frustrated, sometimes angry, but I try to talk him out of it, which sometimes works, sometimes it doesn't.
reply
> Before the ban, at lunch or study halls or recess, kids would just be on their phones and now they're laughing and goofing off, as kids should be doing.

> Bonkers to me that we ever allowed this.

Mm. You've just reminded me of middle school, where if the kids got too loud during lunch, a teacher might order us to all eat in silence and anyone braking the rule would have to stand alone looking at a wall until the end of the lunch period as punishment.

In retrospect, I have absolutely no idea why that guy even wanted to be a teacher if he wasn't OK with kids socialising while they ate.

reply
Controversial opinion: I think a screen-less (or small screen/watch) AI assistant here would be perfect. Carry out all the functions of a regular phone, including directions, nearest restaurant/pharmacy type functionality, without the constant need to be "online" looking at newsfeeds.

Could also pull off running a local model for regular ops, because you don't need frontier intelligence on the go.

reply
I’m so happy for your children, I didn’t think phone bans were really a thing that would even work.
reply
> Before the ban, at lunch or study halls or recess, kids would just be on their phones and now they're laughing and goofing off, as kids should be doing.

During my personal experience working with schools, I've always saw kids off their phones when physically next to each other. Phones were always banned in class, but lunch usually permitted them. I guess social dynamics change from place to place.

reply
I wouldn't even expect phones to decrease test scores, just make kids antisocial and unhappy. Could even make them more studious in a messed up way. That's what happened when I was in middle school too, cause the iPhone 3G got released.
reply
When I was in middle school, there would always be kids with a GameBoy or Walkman with a small group gathered around them. Even someone with a Nokia phone and snake was enough to break the boredom we all felt.
reply
More anecdata: one of my kids struggled for years with making friends, getting heavily depressed. This year her school implemented phone pouches (which get locked in the morning and self-unlock only at the end of the day), and suddenly she's found a best friend and is happy as she can be - even her math grades skyrocketed, which was surprising because they were historically so bad that we even considered discalculia.

It might be a total coincidence, of course.

reply
Coming to a workplace near you soon (already here in places).
reply
A little off-topic for schools, but honestly, I was always shocked by the amount of lost productivity to phones in the white-collar workplace. I worked in a cube farm, and walking around nearly everyone at their desk was looking at their phone at any given time. I can guarantee you that, most of the time, what they were looking at wasn't work related, or at best maybe it was related in a peripheral way (stock prices, industry gossip, etc.)

The "attention tax" that is paid to a handful of firms in Silicon Valley is really unbelievable.

reply
It's not just productivity. It alters the workplace socially, typically in negative ways. Rather than getting to know one's colleagues and accept them for who they are, animosity flourishes over trivial things. (I'm not claiming that workplaces were anywhere near perfect before cell phones, you still had jerks and gossiping cliques. But a lot of the time I'm like, "pull your nose away from the phone and get to know them, you may actually like them.)

Granted, I have worked in places where the only convenient social contact you have is with people within a 1 km radius. So you either got to know the people you worked with, isolated yourself, were paying hefty long-distance bills, or were burning your paycheques to fly to the nearest city every weekend.

reply
Yep phones can make it worse, although amusingly even email communications can cause this. I once had to break up an "email fight" from two people who were literally sitting on opposite sides of a cube partition (my first tip-off was the angry typing sounds.) One of those people reported to me, so I pulled him aside and forced him to go actually talk the other person in real time. Solved the problem immediately. One of the few times I felt like I taught a valuable lesson as a manager...
reply
That's wild. In my workplace, I rarely see that. If it's that visible, how come they aren't reprimanded for it? I'd think excessive phone-use would affect how much they get done too (in a visible way).
reply
I think there was a level of "trust", that as long as people got their work done, then no one was going to police their screen time. If you want to make your day longer go ahead, as long as things got done on time. It was salaried work, not hourly, so longer days didn't directly cost the company any more.

But there was definitely a cost to the employee, in terms of time at work.

reply
Oh, right, that makes sense.
reply
Have you never worked a job outside of an office? Many, many workplaces ban phones, and have for decades.
reply
my boys ( ~17 and 14 and a Junior and Freshman US HS respectively) mostly feel the same. Or at least they don't complain about it and are in the routine. Both of them meet up with their friends before school and sometimes after school for clubs. However, the kids still refer to their Yondr Pouches as a "i-can't-call-my-parents-and-tell-them-i-love-them-in-an-emergency pouch" heh.
reply
Funny as phone bans this September in France is what may have pushed to the youth uprising (and allowing them back was in their demands).
reply
The reason why is simple. It's due to extreme liberalism in the past years. That's why we need both liberalism and conservatism in a balance. The same can be seen in many other areas of life. Many of them not yet socially accepted to be talked about.
reply
i dont remember when phones became allowed in schools, like I don't remember how we started letting children operate electric motorcycles on city roads. A wave of technology takes over before you realize it
reply
Your kids have non-class periods? Lucky them!
reply
> as kids should be doing

They probably should, but also I'd be weary of what obsolete generation thinks about next generation

reply
I honestly wouldn't mind if phones (or at least, non essential apps on phones) were banned for adults, either.

I am forced to use one in the modern world, but I really would rather not. It doesn't bring me any joy, and all the apps and mobile websites are built with toxic dark patterns in attempt to either sell more, or show more ads.

It really has ruined a lot of our brains, or at least that's what it feels like to me.

reply
I don't even think the phone is the problem. It's the algorithmic feeds of modern social media. Regulate that and you remove a good 70% of why modern society sucks in one fell swoop.

Of course, that feed is a multi-trillion dollar business with an army of addicts. So good luck with that initiative. I think long term it will win, but we're talking some 20+ years after those who grew up with it are in policy and can attest to how it ruined their generation.

reply
> Bonkers to me that we ever allowed this.

I think it was the boil-a-frog thing going on.

phones were for calls.

then for text messages.

then for music.

then for apps.

and games.

and finally attention.

reply
> Bonkers to me that we ever allowed this.

The craziest part is that some people watched it happen and would genuinely argue that "maybe this is leading to better outcomes, we cannot know until we try"

I guess I'm just blown away by how easily many people can ignore the evidence of their eyes

reply
> Bonkers to me that we ever allowed this.

It’s not bonkers at all. The reason why phone usage became so prevalent is precisely because of how much we didn’t know. It doesn’t even make logical sense why it’s bad.

That’s how insidious it is because it seems so benign.

reply
how much we (royal) don't know.

The architects of such feeds had centuries of "mind hacking" that go all the way back to Pavlonian training and gambling psychology. We've known for centuries that the human mind wasn't that hard to appease. Now the tech caught up with the last constraint that kept these ideas at bay: latency.

reply
Zuck and the founders of MySpace had no idea about the consequences of social media. They were just trying to make an online business.
reply
In 2004, certainly. I don't think this was some 20 year mastermind at work.

It's very clear they understood the power and leaned into it by the time of Cambridge Analytica, though. Likely much earlier than that, but that's the objectively clear point to the public. So we're at least 10 years into choosing not to put the corrupting genie back in the lamp.

reply
You don't know what you have until you don't have it. This generation knows what it's like with phones because they experienced school with phones. The next generation who grows up with the phone ban will probably think it's pretty stupid, because they don't know what it was like without it. Then they'll repeal it again and go through the same cycle.
reply
> Bonkers to me that we ever allowed this.

Bonkers, but what about lobbying by big tech?

reply