I (and next generations who will be the most affected) should not have to deal with the shit because some rich people got to shit everywhere as they could pay higher taxes.
We presently have a market failure with fossil fuels where these negative externalities are rarely accounted for in prices throughout the market. Despite this, cleaner energy technologies are still out-competing fossil fuels in many energy markets throughout the world. Some estimates from current trajectories anticipate fossil fuels becoming irrelevant globally in the 2060s, and a carbon tax today could contract that timeline significantly. The point of pricing it conservatively is to improve political feasibility, which could be further improved with a dividend model.
Rich people weighing investment returns aren't going to stick with the more-expensive options if their margins are meaningfully better via cleaner energy options.
Is this perfectly efficient towards solving the problem? Far from it, but given the abundance of evidence that our current civilization has been incapable of solving this collective action problem, a carbon tax in the form I've described would be a massive improvement.
But at least we could stop the externalization of costs. Everyone (person or company) who causes environmental harm has to pay for the cost to society. Then, market forces will embed those costs into prices. People and companies would no longer have to be well-meaning and well-informed, because by picking the cheapest option, they would also be picking one with little negative impact on society.
Can we regulate this? Sure. But why regulate this specifically, especially when the public/consumers don't seem to care?
Because everyone will be affected, informed and uninformed alike? Also, it needs to be regulated specifically because consumers don't care.
It's really not that complicated. We need to course correct when the "free market" does the wrong thing with potentially catastrophic consequences.
I do want to see them using less power, or not being built at all frankly. But that claim seems a bit extreme.
I put this in a different thread I believe, but China burns enough coal to run 300+ 2-gigawatt factories. We have larger fish to fry when it comes to energy use, our focus on data centers specifically doesn't correlate with their percentage of the problem.
The original example was overfishing. Each fishing boat has little effect on the overall fish population. Regardless of what the others do, each one ends up with more money catching as many fish as it can. But when they all do that, then the fish population collapses, which is not the outcome any of them prefer.
When they cooperate instead by regulating how many fish each can catch, they can avoid population collapse and everybody's happy.
This is why we regulate things. In the other direction it's why we pay taxes for public goods. Solving these collective action problems is one of the main purposes of government.
If you're proposing there is no choice, who is compelling those using AI to use it, and why?
Probably an employer/educator. Or a desire to appear relevant to a future employer.
A lot of people love AI, but that's probably why those who feel compelled to use it.
Even with the employer example, short of indentured servitude the person is choosing to work for the company and is accepting the concession of having to use AI to work there.
Do you really not see the difference in choosing to work for a certain company and being required to pay taxes?
What DOESN’T work is expecting poor saps to walk into an Applebees and stroll up to some stranger at the bar and say “hey can you please not smoke in here?”
Sometimes I really wonder what crack y’all are smoking. Do we even live in the same world? This level of naivety is almost unbelievable. We know what it takes to get things done, why are we arguing for things we know don’t work?
Your imagination is limiting you in the smoking example. The choices aren't limited to government mandates or individual interventions at an Applebee's bar. For one thing, Applebee's could decide they no longer want to allow smoking inside and ban it themselves, likely due in part to a majority of customers disliking indoor smoking enough that they may dining there.
Ragnarok is upon us!
My argument wasn't that regulation should never be used to make meaningful gains in environmental damage.
My point was that throwing regulation at a single energy use in one area of a single industry is inefficient, won't make a meaningful impact on total energy use, and focuses regulator attention away from much larger change they could be making.
Attempts to regulate a junction of multiple politically hot topics in an industry with massive funding for lobbyists is just begging for years of no results. I'm arguing that there are plenty of lower hanging fruit that would both be easier to regulate, and that the change would both be faster and more impactful.
Because you seem to be making the argument simultaneously that they should and shouldn't
That question isn't interesting at all though. You're taking pushback on a specific topic of potential regulation, extending it to the extreme, and asking if I believe we should live in a world that I'd expect everyone would say is unrealistic and never going to happen.
My point in these comments is that regulating the percentage of renewable or solar energy used by data centers isn't a good use of regulation or regulators' time. AI data centers, solar energy, and human impact on the environment are all highly political topics today. That doesn't mean we shouldn't take up those topics, but we have to be targeted. Picking a fight with an industry that's stacked with well funded lobbyists to, at best, require them to use solar panels for some percentage of their energy use isn't going to make a meaningful enough impact to be worth the effort.
There are many other areas regulators could have a much easier time forcing change while also reducing non-renewable energy use more than the data center case. Focus there if we want regulation to help, don't pick the shiny topic debate only because its what people are talking about today.
And for what its worth, there's a big difference between should and ought. We ought not need regulation, because people ought not be assholes. But some are, and that's where should comes in as we have to make the tradeoffs between ideals and reality. Asking if we should have no regulation at all is asking whether I think we should let all the assholes we already know are here run amuck.
At best that leads elected officials with a choice between taking lobbying money today and potentially losing their next election.
Worth noting that your link isn't polling specific to sentiment of the relative allocation of energy sources used by data centers, its about support for data centers in general.
There are much bigger dish to fry if we want to regulate energy use down or require cleaner energy sources.
"Just regulate" as the OP comment is a flippant use of regulation targeting a specific use of energy in one area of a single industry. That's inefficient at best and won't make meaningful change.
So batteries would work if you could pair each datacenter with a large enough area for solar and wind, perhaps, but I don’t know that we have enough unused land area for that. This may be what keeps nuclear around for a little bit longer, high power density is its bread and butter.
I am hoping at some point deep geothermal will help with this as it works anywhere and would provide predictable 24/7/365 base power
The scale of grid storage is truly massive. This is why plans that call for a grid primarily powered by intermittent sources assume some other technology like hydrogen or compressed air delivers storage at a fraction of the cost of existing systems at massive scale.
Worse yet, for many regions solar's worst performing months in the winter is also where energy demand is highest. There's definitely ample room for solar in sunny places like Australia, especially if they gave good hydroelectric potential. But it takes a very specific set of geographic conditions to make it work well with fossil fuel plants to pick up the slack of periods of under production.
Well no, but the general public _are_ on the hook for getting the laws changed.
So what? Is getting people to form friendships, even relationships with AI more important than the friggin' environment? Is it so important to have office drones sending emails written by LLMs in order to receive replies from LLMs? Is it so important that everybody can write a TODO list app?
About what we just did with the GRH. And what is yet to come!
Killing maths studies, and subsequently science and engineering in two or three generations. That's what "we" just did.
They go for the cheapest option, even if they've had practically infinite money until now.
I think all of the major ai labs are running on gas it's ridiculous
Meanwhile Chinas grid is super healthy and has a tremendous amount of renewable energy... This is what happens when you don't pay into infrastructure as a civilization or require corporations to participate or have accountability for the future of the people they serve.
Yes I agree these data centers should be using more renewables, but the China comparison is odd given that they burn enough coal to run 300+ 2 gigawatt data centers.
Texas is also the #1 state in solar and wind production as well as growth rate.
I doubt Anthropic has that time right now considering the amount of stuff they're actively doing.
Whether or not it's the right thing is a different story, but just imagine the realities and the time sink of actually setting up solar for a data center powerful enough to serve stuff like a frontier model.
If I decided to ignore laws/regulations when building/repairing my house, I don't think a court would be interested in "I'm in a rush, so didn't have time to get planning permission etc".
Perfect reason to slow down the frontier progress, like Dario, Sam, and Elon all spoke up and said was a good idea...
This is, unfortunately, just the next chapter of the same story.
More unfortunately, it feels as if the only way to change the direction of the story is for there to be real, actual, visceral consequences for a majority of the people that are powerful enough to continue pushing in the current direction. Fatally unfortunately, said powerful people will be the last to feel real, actual, visceral consequences. There is a lot of 'worthless human shield' sitting in front of them that has to be ploughed through first.
Doubly ironically, maybe it's best if AI does destroy humanity and let the Earth find a more sustainable balance of life.
It will be interesting to see, if AI does destroy humanity, will it let the Earth find a more sustainable balance of life, or will it accelerate the domination of the natural world in pursuit of its inscrutable goals? (likely to its own suicidal detriment, given it is based on learning from humans)
the real bill comes due in about 4-5 years :)
No, because solar panels are notoriously hard to scale, especially in high density applications like datacenters. Otherwise it's like saying "my calculator runs off solar power, so why can't they make a car run on solar power? Clearly it's because Ford/BYD not giving a f"
Before you respond "it will be too slow", the urgency here is entirely artificial – there's no reason we need to be going this fast.
Or it might result in investing trillions of dollars and decades only to discover that there are only marginal gains to be had. There is no guarantee that throwing money at Problem X results in any kind of solution or that solutions to specific problems are even possible.
This is aside from the sibling commenters' very good point that this view assumes there are no concrete benefits or advancements to be made that depend on AI, which seems very unlikely at this point. Unfortunately, with or without AI, the problems we're facing socially, ecologically, medically, and scientifically are increasing. We can either use AI as a tool in the hopes we can at least delay the most serious consequences or just let them overtake us. Fossil fuels and climate change are just one of a million very pressing issues, despite the over representation it gets, and it seems highly likely that the benefits here exceed the costs. Addressing a downthread comment about labs saying we need to "slow down" - they are saying this for self-serving reasons and in their quest to ensure AI stays gatekept, not because they are worried about environmental impacts.
Even your own examples tend to show that. There were in both cases rapid advances followed by diminishing returns as all low-hanging fruit was worked out. 50 years later space travel is still very expensive and difficult. Eventually we may attain reasonably economical orbital travel with sufficient advances in rocketry and materials science but there is no reason to believe any amount of money and time will, for example, give us FTL spaceships.
It's not like we have exhausted all avenues and are stuck. Solar panels are getting cheaper and more efficient, storage is a problem, but it has not seen that much investment. More nimble forms of nuclear fission, like SMRs, is an active area of research. As mentioned above, we are making progress on fusion.
The idea that we are anywhere close to the diminishing returns on investment in these areas seems completely wrong to me.
EDIT: The dichotomy in this discussion is striking: we need to disregard almost all negative externalities on speculative investment in AI, but speculative investment in green energy is not worth it because it might not yield sufficient results.
And yet, we are currently sacrificing our entire economy, our social cohesion, most of the world’s productive resources, and the careers and futures of thousands to millions being displaced, to chase the possibility that if we computer hard enough, computer will be alive
What makes you believe that time is irrelevant? If AI allows for breakthroughs in mathematics, science, engineering, computing, and health care—and it does seem to be delivering on this promise so far—what in your estimation is the net cost to humankind of delaying those breakthroughs by even a year? It's not zero, is it?
More than anything though, it doesn't matter what we in tech think because we have failed to convince the general public that any of this is a good idea.
Well done humans, well done. Slow clap.
You're expecting people to get working time travel from LLMs ?
Math, maybe. Science, where? Computing, anything measurable? Health care, where?
FYI, pre LLM techs don't count. Ain't nobody building $3tn worth of DCs for AlphaFold.
The problem seems to be that they want the power online quickly and they can't get solar quickly. The article mentions the inefficiency of their generators. It is costing them quite a bit extra to generate power like that, but that's their only option of they want the power immediately.
It would be nuts to do this long term. You might argue that they don't give a f about the environment , but most people will agree that they give a f about cutting costs.
You just have other issues like needing to get transmission and storage capacity built, which takes forever because of planning review, environmental assessments and NIMBYs.
Some. Hence "why can't they make a car run on solar power" isn't the obviously dumb question you make it out to be.
2. There probably are non-zero amount of datacenters out there that runs off solar power. It's just not commonly practical, just like with electric cars.
3. The main point of the comment is that scaling challenges exist, and you can't take a residential use case and extend it to a datacenter. The same applies for a car, even if you could do it. A solar powered calculator is easy, just slap a tiny solar strip and it just works. A solar powered car is far harder to pull off. If you don't work from home for instance, you'll need a battery system to store the energy when you're not home.
If you can't figure out how to get renewable power to a datacenter, but you can easily figure out how to get it to the consumers of a datacenter, and you're talking about a technology that scales down to small groups well and individuals only a bit less well (but with constantly working agents utilizing compute, better than we once imagined), what's the reasoning behind datacenters at all?
If datacenters can make a case for massive increase of demand in the future, they're simultaneously making a case that individuals will have enough demand to saturate AI located closer to them or on premises. If anything, that should be a call for p2p software to help people share or borrow excess compute with and from their neighbors in exactly the same way that home solar panels use the grid.
Datacenters are also central points of failure. Distribution is resilient.
I know meta and their ilk are trying to cut deal for nuclear power. I'm sure we can imagine they will take safety, the environment, etc very seriously too.
Are you high?