upvote
Its sad though - the hiring system is essentially running on nepotism. Its not very meritocratic.

And i suppose if you are shy, well then i guess you are just screwed.

reply
It's not really nepotism, it's looking for trust.

You have two options:

A) Display you are trustworthy by having a consistent employment history and a degree (what it really proves is you showed up at a university for 4 years and crossed your Ts and dotted your Is).

B) Rely on personal connections that already know you are trustworthy or are willing to take a chance of you.

The third case is having a random person deciding to take a chance at you. Which feels the riskiest one of all for the person doing the hiring.

reply
Strong agree. Whatever information you can learn in a few hours of interviews with someone pales in comparison to what you learn by having worked with someone for years. If hiring is restricted and you get very few reqs, of course you are going to lean to hiring a known quantity over taking a risk on a stranger.

I don't think of it as nepotism - if I know someone sucks from working with them, you better believe I'm making sure I warn everyone if I see them in the pipeline. It's not about pulling friends, it's about pulling people you know are good.

reply
That's it. Employing someone is a risk for a company. At the really bad tail end you can hire someone who contributes negative value, is good at hiding that, poisons the culture, and in the end sues you for whatever.

If you've worked for a few months on a team with a competent, decent and reliable person, you'll give this person a huge preference over someone unknown, even if on paper the unknown looks better.

reply
It's technically not nepotism because they aren't specifically favoring family, but it is cronyism because they are favoring friends, peers, and close associates.
reply
Option A is no longer sufficient on its own.
reply
> It's not really nepotism, it's looking for trust.

Well yes, "trust" is the entire point of nepotism and why its a thing.

reply
I have to disagree here, the main point of nepotism is self-service and the corruption of institutions.

The idea is we place our guy in that spot so that a) our guy gets to reap the benefits of the cushy job we lined up for him. b) when conflict arises between our interests and the organizations we can count on our guy to do the thing we want.

The thing I am describing above is much more benign. It's literally HR asking people in the company if they know anyone they would like to refer and then taking the referrals seriously.

reply
Has this ever not been the case? Every job I've ever received in my entire life (including even fast food as a kid) was because I knew someone. I have no chance without it.
reply
People cry nepotism more often than they should as a way to deal with rejection. In some cases, it truly is nepotism where someone who is lacking the skills is hired. But, those cases I believe are not that common. What really happens is having skills is the baseline now. There are talented people everywhere. Hiring managers must look for signals beyond the skills to break the tie, and having some type of recommendation is exactly that.
reply
I think it depends highly on the region or country you live in and how the market is doing for your specific field. There have been times I have been able to get interviews and job offers without connections, but nowadays in the Swedish tech/IT sector, knowing the right people is extremely important for most people to even get interviews.

I feel especially sorry for a lot of the English speakers in Sweden right now. The job market is tough even for locals who speak Swedish, but Sweden has a lot of immigrants who only speak English and work in the tech sector, and the market is absolutely brutal for them from what I have seen on my LinkedIn feed. Lots of people I have worked with over the years have been unemployed for over a year and are really struggling to get hired.

reply
It is far more so the case now. To the point that relationships become a necessity.

It wasn't long ago anyone could follow the route of acquiring competences, get a job after a few applications and 2 rounds interview.

reply
I wholeheartedly agree. The problem is that the "standard" process that was followed before is broken:

An HR sourcer will receive 1000s of resumes for a position. All very similar, all completely qualified for the position . How would she select one? How would she make that scale?

Then, an HR would get 100 of those candidates for an interview. If only just to ensure it's a human, it's who they say it is and can actually work in the position [people lie on ATS about having Visa/permit]

Then the hiring manager gets 10 people to get to the technical interview process.

It just doesn't scale. And everybody is using AI in both sides. And nothing guarantees you are hiring a lemon or a diamond.

So the referral route jumps all that. When someone you trust refers a person, it IS a shortcut to the technical interview stage, and sometimes even more. Sometimes you even can take for granted what they put in their resume.

reply
And it wasn't long before that when relationships were a necessity.
reply
As a counter example, every job/contract I’ve ever received in my entire life, minus part time jobs at college I applied to and TA positions in grad school, was because I did work voluntarily out on the open Internet, and other people found my work and skill valuable and reached out.

I’ve stopped doing that (except a couple projects in the few k stars range just chugging along with minimal maintenance) because any idiot can now drawn me out with a few instructions at a slop machine. That door is officially closed for all but a few extremely lucky people whose projects really blow up.

reply
Early explosion of the tech field in security. So at least 00s-10s for me. Certification and degrees met little if your resume spoke to whatever keywords the SWE department passed on to HR. From there it was just matter of getting in front of a job interviewer and not staring at someone's chest or being a psycho.
reply
Leaning on people you have worked with before and who have a favorable impression of you based on that experience is not nepotism.
reply
Shyness has been the death of many people. Lots of people basically die from embarrassment.
reply
Yeah, tell me about it. I'm learning to get out of it. Or fake extroversion. At least until I can get what I want. It just fucking sucks.
reply
> the hiring system is essentially running on nepotism

The hiring system has always run smoother on personal connections. Nepotism denotes taking unfair advantage of a particular subset of connections, the familial. Note the difference.

Re meritocracy, I'm not sure that it ever existed in its idealised pure state. (Not unlike "free market" and a couple of others.) This very forum is chock-full of laments about the pathologies of supposedly meritocratic hiring practices of times past.

reply
> Nepotism denotes taking unfair advantage of a particular subset of connections, the familial. Note the difference.

Typically the term nepotism also denotes close social connections. I meant it more broadly to mean getting a job based on who you know instead of your abilities.

Wikipedia defines nepotism as: "Nepotism is the act of granting an advantage, privilege, or position to close friends or relatives in an occupation or field"

reply
> Typically the term nepotism also denotes close social connections.

I have never encountered it used to mean anything other than familial connection where someone who is objectively unqualified or inexperienced gets a job/role.

Hiring someone one has worked with in the past over randos where both meet the minimum qualifications for the job is not that.

reply
There is this distinction that bawolff might not understand.

If I get a friend of mine to work for the company he still has to put in CV, still has to prove he can do the job.

Only bonus he gets is that I know the person and can back him up on the fact he is good to work with and since I work there that candidate will fit in the team more likely than a random person.

Meritocracy is there and people like to blame their failures on “nepotism” or “meritocracy” or anything else that is beyond their control to feel better.

reply
OK, but suppose there is another candidate who would be a much better hire, but they don't have a connection. They have a CV or resume that is comparable or even a little bit better than your friends. But your friend is the one who gets hired, because they had the advantage of being your friend. A big part of the problem is that actually evaluating the merit of candidates is very difficult. The job market is effectively a lemon market where the employer doesn't have enough information to know the quality of a candidate, and a referral or connection is a way to establish more trust in an applicants credentials. But it's still an unfair system.
reply
I understand, i just disagree.
reply
Exactly.

The hiring manager gets the weight of your opinion that this person is good.

Without that then the hiring manager is basically hiring the person that is best at pretending they would be good at the job. The best actor in the interview. That is hardly a meritocracy.

reply
Anyone who thinks meritocracy has ever been the primary hiring vehicle is deluding themselves. It has always been much more valuable to lean on your network in both directions. And I say this as a fellow shy person, you're only getting screwed if you allow that to happen.

And as an on again, off again hiring manager: hiring is such a crap shoot that I'd weight what someone I trust is telling me about a candidate much higher than any signal gleaned from the interview process. There are a million things day to day more important than how a candidate performs in contrived interview situations. The only way to really suss that out is if someone you trust has already seen them perform in those situations. That's not nepotism.

reply
Its more an indication of how hard the jobmmarket is rather than a shift to nepotism.

Hiring people today in tech is just as bad as trying to be hired. The last role my team had open was getting hundreds of applications for every one application worth considering. We were trying to fill the role through our personal networks at that point mainly to get out if the death loop of reviewing LLM slop resumes.

reply
Networking is meritocratic.

Are you going to get your idiot friend a software engineering job that they have no ability to succeed at and damage your own reputation?

Of course not.

This is Goffman's front stage / back stage. If everyone is putting on the same front stage performance, what matters is knowing what is back stage. Knowing what is back stage with a person is what it means to "know" a person.

Meritocracy doesn't mean some kind of fine grained MCAT exam and then you are just hired based on a sorted list. The system isn't broken because it is not that.

reply
No disagreement there. I do tend to see networking still hold to merit, people just know who they've seen do well and keep connections open there.

And personally I tend to put less weight behind standardized tests like MCAT vs personal experience working with a person. Standardized testing fights against the challenge of control, creating something so structured and controlled it can be gamed and the results are only as good as the assumptions used designing the system.

reply
Well said. I commented above that having the right skills is table stakes now. Tons of candidates have technical skills.
reply
>And i suppose if you are shy, well then i guess you are just screwed.

If you feel sorry for yourself, yes you are screwed. Even introverted people need to learn to fake being social.

reply
> nepotism

Do words still mean anything?

Using personal connections to get hired isn't nepotism.

reply
wikipedia defines it as: "Nepotism is the act of granting an advantage, privilege, or position to close friends or relatives in an occupation or field"

I guess you could argue about how close a friend qualifies, but it seems inherently about using personal connections.

reply
That's...exactly what nepotism is.

> The favoring of relatives or personal friends because of their relationship rather than because of their abilities

But that specific professional vouching is good for the employer. It's adding trust to the process.

I see this same kind of exchange constantly about "eugenics". People get really really upset when there's something that's very obviously eugenics but also very obviously a good thing.

reply
Nepotism isn't a problem unless they're hired when they don't have the skills to perform. I'd go so far as not calling it nepotism in that case but a "smart hire"
reply
That's exactly my point though, nepotism and smart hiring are a Venn diagram.

Now personally I think it would be great if we could also get OTHER forms of trust to work, but it's harder and not free.

reply
There is a clear advantage of hiring people you have worked with before.
reply
Isn’t your ability to network based on your reputation a function of merit, statistically speaking? I fully agree that introverts as well as gap time will make networking harder, but not sure the extreme cynicism on hiring is warranted… at least not for this reason. :P

Side note - the word “meritocracy” was popularized as a humorous pejorative intended to point out that what people call “merit” generally originates from social advantages, especially rich parents. Merit is a system that feeds itself, not one that is particularly good at finding raw talent or potential. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meritocracy#Criticism

reply
Nepotism? Not at all. Hiring is a big risk. Relying on your network is the best way to ensure you’re hiring competent people that others want to work with. It’s why companies offer huge recruiting bonuses to employees to refer their network.
reply
Meritocracy works (at best) in small groups. Any larger group is too complex to consistently float the best people to the top. It quickly becomes network theory, rather than merit.
reply
I think I'd agree, though its worth considering that the larger the group is the more valuable the skill of networking itself may become.
reply
We've essentially outlawed all of the good ways to assess merit, and many of the ways to verify if people are lying.
reply
That's an interesting assertion. Can you be more specific?
reply
> not very meritocratic

You must be new here.

reply
Your experience and solution sounds basically what blue collar and manufacturing went through the with the flight to China. Where the whole knock on the door and give them a firm handshake meme grew from.

It is going to get ugly and fast for many when the people skills many in SWE have neglected for technical skills suddenly becomes invaluable for even obtaining basic jobs that 10 years ago would have gotten a new phone call every day. The real shit show is going to be that we've essentially murdered the physical aspect of any of it so you are starting at negative if you aren't a tweet star or forcing yourself into some quality job hiring events.

reply
People skills mean a lot less than social signaling. The best predictor of your being considered for a job is the prestige of where else you have worked, and the prestige of your university. If we were intending to make a system that hires only of the upper social classes we couldn’t have done any better.
reply
Meet ups still happen, they are a cheap and local way to be face to face.

Also, maybe local small business? In the same way that you found the pizzeria, is there maybe a local chain of dentist offices or veterinarians or something? Corporate hiring is totally broken, but "finding good people" is still a top problem, especially for medium sized business (50-100 employees, 5-10 locations, across 2-3 states).

Can you get a shitty IT ops job that can beat the pizzeria salary? And help repair your resume hole?

Best wishes.

reply
Or consulting. SMBs can’t always afford a full-time software engineer, but you could come in and help 5-20 companies with monthly rates for project work and support. It is a great time to be a generalist and know people.
reply
How does one actually get into SWE/Tech consulting? I’ve got what I would assume are the makings (an education degree and 10 years of experience in software dev), it just seems like such an opaque and crowded space
reply
I don't have experience in that niche per se, but rather as a civil engineering consultant.

There's always a chicken/egg problem trying to break into a space like that. Once you have clients, you usually end up with TOO much work. But until then, you're starving. It's very much feast or famine.

My advice is this:

1. Pound pavement! Knock on the doors, talk to people. Do all the networking. You will likely be laughably ineffective at this at first, but it's still useful to get the practice reps in so that when you get in front of the right person, you'll be polished. I got my first big client after taking a lawyer out to lunch, buying him a couple of scotches and straight up asking if he had any clients who needed engineering work.

2. Embrace the Pareto principle and Focus on the whales. Small jobs/clients are almost a complete waste of time. They're the one who will give you trouble over your rate, payment issues, manipulative scope changes, etc. And... they just don't have the pile of money to throw your way.

3. Don't actually chase the whales directly, figure out who are the people who will refer clients to you. These are the people who are INSANELY valuable and often don't even realize it. Treat them well, NEVER make them look bad, and keep the relationship fresh.

Once you're in the space, there's other skills you need to learn in the vein of that "fuck you pay me" article. However, I would never recommend someone trying to break in to the space to not eat a shit sandwich with a smile to get their foot in the door.

Oh, and one more thing: you'd be surprised how long it takes for a lead to develop into a job. In my world that was often 6+ months. So patience is key.

reply
This also matches my experience.

Me and two of my colleagues left our relatively cushy jobs to start a tech and business consulting company, focusing mostly on mid market and enterprise sales. It is a kinda niche service (building internal knowledge graphs, ai integration etc).

I think our biggest shock was realizing that every single client would take several months of talks if we wanted to get reasonably paid and ensure a successful project.

Assessments, discovery, getting the buy in of every relevant stakeholder takes a lot of time, dinners and compromising.

Price negotiation is its own challenge, and until you have a few clients you also have a weaker negotiating position. This means you are probably getting squeezed in your first contracts. 3-4 long deals fell due to prospects trying to buy us out as employees in the end of the sales process, wasting hundreds of hours of work.

If everything goes well then you are going to have some back and forth with legal teams before it gets signed.

Companies also go on their own time, and you are not going to be top priority for any of the people involved in the process.

Took us about 6 months of talks to close our first client. This also means we need to have sales running all the time, and capacity planning is incredibly challenging. Failed deals hurt a lot, since there was a large time and money commitment involved.

Honestly, i would not be able to do this alone, even as a reasonably well connected person. My main advice is to not start a business alone if you can. The only reason we survived is because my co-founders are great at their jobs.

Now that we are at least close to breaking even it feels good, but the first months were AWFUL.

reply
> Embrace the Pareto principle and Focus on the whales. Small jobs/clients are almost a complete waste of time. They're the one who will give you trouble over your rate, payment issues, manipulative scope changes, etc. And... they just don't have the pile of money to throw your way.

One nitpick is that you should be open to some small guys for your first few gigs. Yeah they suck and will probably pester you for the next few years after you're done, but they will give you experience and legitimacy. Just take the hit as the cost of getting off the ground

reply
it seems like a crowded space till you realize its not.

I just got started as well after floundering for 2/3 years. learn sales. learn sales. learn sales.

which means learning who to target, your messaging. if you target the wrong person - after all its people that buy not companies.

reply
That’s having the same problems caused by AI that regular work has done.

My last 4 months of paid work was consulting and all the clients decided to go with AI based results because they were “good enough” and getting by on a 20 dollar subscription.

It’s also experiencing a glut of out of work engineers competing for everything now.

reply
deleted
reply
I agree. I worked for 14 years (2005–2019) at a large corporation in India before moving to Canada in 2019. Since moving to Toronto, I have not received a single offer through the local job market. The only opportunities I have managed to secure interviews for, or employment through, all remote with companies based outside of Canada, have come via referrals from my former colleagues. And honestly, I expect it to be much the same even if I move back to India.
reply
Eh the impression that Canadians / Americans have of many from India is you don't really know what to believe. I recall one time my college hired someone from India - unlike all the Americans her resume was literally 40 pages. Insane appeal to authority by American standards. But it worked for her. Then it's often a gamble if the person speaks natural English. Because I've had experiences where they say they do but they don't. Finally, aren't you aware that Canada has a pretty bleak situation currently? Not only does a Canadian have to compete with other Canadians, but also with the whole world, especially India. It's the same way at our universities. Local people won't be able to afford it there but affluent foreigners still are. It's just not ideal.
reply
Does your definition of Canadians include new Canadians like me? Somehow, I get the feeling it might not. Even though my American employers pay me ~2x to what I would expect to earn in a comparable Toronto-based role, I would actually prefer working onsite rather than remotely. I guess I am a bit old-school in that regard.

And yes, my English is not the best, but for whatever reason, my teammates - mostly from midwest US and Californians - have never complained!

reply
Essential workers during COVID, unwanted competition now, eh? So much for Canadian politeness! Just double standards and glass ceilings everywhere here in Canada. USA for all its negativities is the only place an immigrant ...an Indian... can dare to succeed.
reply
[dead]
reply
[dead]
reply
> But the problem is the front door in hiring is broken.

Is it really broken? I haven't heard about companies having trouble with filling positions with people they are largely happy with, so hiring seems to work as intented.

If by "broken" you mean "frustrating for cadidates", then it's a different matter. But, it could be argued that the job itself (cushy, high-paying, low stress office SWE job) is more than enough compensation for the frustrations required to get it. Similarly (but much more extreme), Navy Seal candidates go through recruitment process that is actively built for breaking their will. But, those who perservere, get rewarded with an elite and prestigious posting.

reply
I applied for a role involving Linux kernel development, TPMs, and corporate security. I got rejected immediately. I was able to follow up with a friend in a senior engineering position who was able to get my resume in front of the hiring manager, and I was interviewed the next day and made an offer less than a week later. An anecdote rather than data, but on the other side you're rarely going to see the people you're missing out on - they may be filling positions with people they're happy with, but that doesn't mean they're filling positions with the applicant who'd do the best job.
reply
I'd counter this with two realities;

Firstly, most employers don't specifically target "best". Partly because "best" is hard to define, and includes measurements across multiple axles. And partly because it's impossible to know you have just seen the "best" so leading to paralysis.

Typically companies thus target "good enough" and for lots of positions there are several candidates that fit that bill. Sure they'll choose the one they think will be the best, but there's no way to know for sure.

Secondly, and speaking generally here, for most of us, this is probably a good thing since it's very likely there is a better candidate than me out there somewhere. If companies only hire "the best" then all us "second best, still good enough " folk would struggle a lot more.

Of course we all think we are the best possible option. Because we value our strengths and devalue our weaknesses. But objectively what are the odds that out of hundreds of applicants we're the actual "best"?

This doubly so when so many high quality people are looking for jobs?

reply
I can't say I'm absolutely the best possible candidate for the role, or even that such a thing is objectively measurable, but in this case the fact that the process went so quickly the moment I got in front of them is a pretty strong indication that something went wrong in terms of the initial rejection. Anecdotally I've heard other people in similar positions, and on this occasion I was just fortunate enough to have a side channel.
reply
From a purely utilitarian perspective, good enough is often better than best, as the good enough employee is likely to be cheaper and have a longer tenure than the best.
reply
Yep, that’s why companies generally don’t hire people who are overqualified for the position.
reply
> And partly because it's impossible to know you have just seen the "best" so leading to paralysis.

This is the (unfortunately named) "secretary problem": how do you decide when to stop interviewing and make a hiring decision? It's possible that the first person you interview is the best candidate you're ever going to find, but you don't know that. At the same time, you can't just keep interviewing forever, hoping that you find someone better than everyone you've seen so far. But you can never be 100% confident that you've found "the best" - you just have to get to the point where you're happy that someone is better than the others.

The unfortunate reality is that the first candidates to be interviewed won't ever get an offer, because there aren't enough data points to make a decision yet. Which can be comforting if you've ever interviewed somewhere and thought you did well but they went with someone else - you might have just been too early in the process.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Secretary_problem

reply
> The unfortunate reality is that the first candidates to be interviewed won't ever get an offer, because there aren't enough data points to make a decision yet.

This doesn't follow in any way. Sure, the offer the first candidate might receive will be delayed, but if you're looking to fill a position in 1 month and the first candidate you've seen was still the best you saw in that month, you'll of course make him an offer.

And I am saying this from experience - we've often hired our first candidate for an interview in my team. Though I will admit that we don't follow much of the practices I read about and have heard from other friends, so maybe we are not typical in this either.

reply
That assumes that candidates are ok with waiting a month to hear the results of their interview, which in my experience isn't realistic. Also, the best candidates have plenty of options. So there's a significant chance that if they are actively looking then they'll receive another offer in that month. Even if that's just because the other company interviewed them further along in their process and is comfortable making an offer quickly, because they have enough data points to know how good they are!
reply
Mag 7 companies typically take months to finish an interview/hiring cycle. It took over three and a half months to join Google for me. Similar but shorter for other Mag 7 companies I have worked for.
reply
No, it’s broken. On the hiring side, most resumes are fraudulent, most phone screens will be with foreign spies, and the sheer quantity nearly drowns out the plentiful number of good candidates. Also our old way of doing code challenges doesn’t make sense in the age of AI.
reply
Last year I helped a friend’s startup hire for multiple SWE positions and it was easily 75% North Koreans.

It got so bad I opened every interview with “You will be required to travel to San Francisco to meet with the founders, they will pay your travel expenses, is that an issue?” - and click hung up. Once had this happen 4 consecutive interviews.

I did approximately 32 interviews and maybe 8 were not NK.

reply
> "You will be required to travel to San Francisco to meet with the founders, they will pay your travel expenses"

There were times when that actually was the case, can you imagine?

reply
Arguably it didn't make sense before either.
reply
I agree, but it’s definitely worse today. The only positive as a hiring manager is that there is better talent out there than normal. As a candidate, it’s clearly terrible.
reply
This is the way.
reply