upvote
> This is why we need regulation.

The Senate passed a bipartisan bill to speed up the approval process for data centers and power plants. The bill also makes data centers pay for the power they use.

This should accelerate the country the build more solar, wind, and battery projects.

https://www.npr.org/2026/11/20/g-s1-154579/senate-bipartisan...

reply
> But major environmental groups, including the Sierra Club and National Wildlife Federation, have opposed the bill, arguing it will weaken environmental accountability.

> Many Democrats have also opposed the bill. They say it will worsen pollution by making it easier to greenlight oil and gas projects and energy-hungry data centers, while weakening protections for clean air and water.

reply
Sierra Club is against building infrastructure to distribute clean energy as well. Their opposition to this doesn't say what you want it to say
reply
The Sierra Club is not honest or trustworthy.

In 2020, they sued to stop a transmission line from bringing clean hydropower from Canada to Maine. In 2024, they sued the Maine government for not doing enough to combat climate change.

reply
Oh yeah, how dare they sue to stop a private company from cutting a large corridor through pristine wilderness (maine's only really durable resource) to take hydropower from the people Maine buys it from to.... Not Maine.

Also Mainers get nothing out of it.

That transmission line was absurd and stupid. Maine needs new generation, not more demand to the same international markets we buy our power from.

Maine hasn't done enough to combat climate change, which is a serious problem for our fishing industry, which is already suffering from the impact of climate change and may eventually have no jobs. The power line made 0 improvement to that.

CMP has been refusing to connect already built solar installations. Our power is expensive because of that.

reply
Is climate change an existential threat or not? Because if it's an existential threat I don't really see myself caring about a small amount of maine's pristine wilderness.
reply
It's become necessary to destroy the environment in order to save it.
reply
> to take hydropower from the people Maine buys it from to.... Not Maine.

Interesting attitude. Why should anyone in North America care about the effects of climate change if the worst effects are felt in... Not North America?

reply
> making it easier to greenlight oil and gas projects

Orthogonal problem that ought to solved separately.

It would be weird for anyone to argue that we do not need more energy faster and at lower prices.

Energy is foundational to civilization.

reply
No one disagrees that energy is foundational to civilization, but we have been thoroughly informed of the dangers of oil and gas consumption. This comes down to short term financial gains over long term environmental impacts, and AI companies are slated to consume unprecedented amounts of energy.
reply
Gas turbines are not more economical than solar and wind. It's infuriating that we're allowing them to be built, but as time goes on and more solar and wind join the grid these plants will be relegated to peaker work instead of running full-tilt.
reply
> Gas turbines are not more economical than solar and wind.

I would expect that companies would build the most economical power source that they could. If gas turbines are less economical, it seems strange that they are being built; there must be something more nuanced to that story (or companies that are building them see the economics differently somehow).

reply
"Companies are efficient" is a lie. They will make decisions which make no sense all the time for short term gains
reply
deleted
reply
There are issues other than cost, like speed and expediency. Solar and wind are far cheaper than gas and coal, but they take much longer and are harder to permit. Basically oil, gas and coal are favored by regulation and subsidy.
reply
Ummmmmm...

"Economical" has different meanings depending on whether your time horizon is the next quarter or the next century. It also depends on whether you just consider your own pockets or those of the whole humanity. A lot of stuff, like the entire fossil fuel industry, is economical as long as Someone Else pays conveniently pays your debts! In any case, "economical", whatever it means, is not what we need. Sustainable, including economically sustainable, is.

reply
> I would expect that companies would build the most economical power source that they could.

Please stop expecting this, or at least take the time to figure out whether your priors are justified or not, because it sure seems like the facts aren’t supporting your world view these days.

reply
I bet that in the US that manufacturing and installing a gas turbine is in order of magnitude less expensive than manufacturing and installing the equivalent solar capacity.
reply
There is no equivalent solar without at least overnight hours of batteries -- which are, yes, very expensive.
reply
Not true at all. You can order huge amounts of solar panels for the cost of a gas turbine with delivery in a few weeks, while you can't get delivery of turbines for several years [], but getting land and a permit is a different issue. You missed the real issue which is regulation. Meanwhile the likes of xAI data centers pollute with gay abandon.

[] https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/03/climate/jet-engines-ai-da... https://www.wsj.com/business/energy-oil/how-jet-engines-are-...

reply
How are people still saying this? You can spin down the gas turbine when you have a lot of solar production.
reply
Why don’t they just build solar / wind / batteries if they’re so much more economical?
reply
Because current regulatory and administrative barriers prevent them from being built or connected to the grid.
reply
The point of life is to be healthy and happy. A substantial fraction of the energy we use actually has the opposite effect. We don't need more energy overall when we could use less with better life outcomes.
reply
More energy in the form of fossil fuel-based sources is not cheaper, no matter how low the immediate price. The long-term cost of continuing to increase greenhouse emissions are exponentially larger.
reply
It isn't lower on paper, either. BAAJA would unlock wind and solar projects moreso than any fossil fuel generation.
reply
It's pretty clear that across the board leadership at Google, Meta, Amazon, Anthropic, OpenAI, Microsoft and others don't believe this.
reply
Because the stock market does not incentivize longer term thinking.
reply
That's a strange complaint when two thirds of the companies on the list have share classes that make it so that the founders have absolute control over the company.
reply
Yeah, and it's pretty obvious the US is still quite primitive and has a lot of civilisation founding left to do.
reply
> Yeah, and it's pretty obvious the US is still quite primitive and has a lot of civilisation founding left to do.

Tell us more.

reply
It's important to point out that these Groups' claims are wrong.
reply
> The bill also makes data centers pay for the power they use

Data centers paid for power they use. It's amazing how far the data center conversation has drifted from reality.

Data centers, like all large scale grid-connected projects, are also assessed fees for the infrastructure costs they incur.

The debates have been around additional math beyond that where some people think that additional infrastructure buildouts should be billed even more to data centers, beyond what is assessed for their own connection. The argument was that utilities are sizing infrastructure projects based on projections of more data center growth and it's not popular to bill infrastructure growth to anyone but data centers right now.

reply
If datacenter demand drives up electricity, it is rational for citizens to want the costs put on the demand generators. Has someone drifted from reality for not wanting to champion economic suicide? Are they a crank if they're not out there with "Yes in my backyard" signs for datacenters?

Society has tools like taxes and laws to make sure those who can pay (datacenters and their backers) bear more of the burden.

https://fedscoop.com/democrats-letter-ai-data-centers-electr...

https://www.npr.org/2026/10/29/nx-s1-6022096/who-benefits-wh...

reply
They have to pay for the power they use? What a success. That bill must have teeth.
reply
do datacenters not pay for the power they use?

i'm not stupid, i know what you mean, but why say stuff this wrong way?

there are no new datacenters in San Francisco, yet my electricity rates have nearly doubled in six years. can we pass a law that says, my rates are frozen in 2019 too? it would benefit a lot more people.

the hard part isn't deciding, oh, use solar. the hard part is, reining in voters and tulipmanias. some voters like tulipmania, next week, we'll learn the hard way that "datacenter bad" isn't the win people think it is.

reply
Let's talk about solar.

Median days from application to permit issuance in San Diego is 0 days while it is 4 days in NYC. In San Francisco it takes 42 days!

Permitting is only part of the problem. Guess how long it takes from signing a contract to switching on your solar system? In Nevada it is just under 60 days while in California it is ~150 days. Texas isn't much better, at ~120 days.

Bureaucracy literally saps energy.

reply
there are a bajillion places around the world with no permitting. where are their big solar projects? i agree that permitting is a core issue, but how do you justify, "people can do whatever they want with their land" when you use it for solar, but not datacenters? everyone's income is someone else's expense, so it's not so simple, there's no objective or rationalist or effective whateverist or non-political answer to this problem. it's all political. the bureaucracy is a symptom of a popular political goal, and then when we look deeply into whatever technocratic, unenactable policies about energy, like "nuclear" or "solar" or whatever, we find it's still vibes at the bottom.
reply
The main goal of the permitting process seems to be raising costs and slowing projects down. If the permitting were focused around encouraging renewable energy projects and keeping things safe while hampering fossil fuels, I would be all about it.

Making it harder to build makes rent-seeking more profitable, so slowing things down is a goal unto itself. It's not just vibes - the vibes are how to obscure the goal.

reply
> there are a bajillion places around the world with no permitting. where are their big solar projects?

Here is a is map of the largest solar projects & locations: https://cleanview.co/power-projects/operating/solar-farms/us

reply
This is the US, the same place we just talked about
reply
China burns more coal than the US plus Europe plus the rest of the world combined.[1] No amount of regulation will make the slightest difference at the global scale. If you really care about pollution, what you should defend is severe sanctions on China and accept the cost this has. But of course, people don't really think it's worth the cost when it comes down to it.

[1] https://ourworldindata.org/data-insights/almost-all-the-grow...

reply
Most people do not believe things nearly as strongly as they portray they do online.

Ask people to put money and time on the line for the things they supposedly believe and you'll find out what they actually believe.

reply
China still emits about half of the CO2 per capita compared to the US and only just overtook the EU. Everyone needs to do their part proportionate to their population.

https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/consumption-co2-per-capit...

reply
I think your point and the point you are replying to are consistent.

Your link takes a lot of the coal power CO2 that is generated in China and assigns it to the US where the products are consumed. The prior post argued that the US needs to stop importing products from China.

reply
Here's emissions per capita without reallocation by consumption: https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/co-emissions-per-capita

It shows the same thing. US emits way more per capita than China.

reply
I stand corrected.
reply
Why cherry pick? Put Singapore in the check list.

If you care about CO2 per country, it's China. If you care about CO2 per person, there are many countries worse than the US.

https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/consumption-co2-per-capit...

reply
I picked those because those are what the original comment mentioned. I just don't think it's fair to point fingers at China just because they have a lot of people when other countries are more wasteful.
reply
>I just don't think it's fair to point fingers at China just because they have a lot of people

oh okay, why not?

population growth isn't just some random function.

brutal, maybe -- but unfair? Not sure.

reply
You could go by land area I suppose?
reply
US: ya but China pollutes more!

China: ya but the US are far more dirty per person they'll gain an advantage this way so we can't slow down (though they seem to be the ones building out the most renewable infrastructure)..

Canada: ya but both those guys are worse than us. We barely have any people!

India: well if nobody else even nice guy Canada is going to bother...

It's like nobody remembered the eye for an eye teaching.

reply
This isn't about punishment, it's about collective action to eliminate fossil fuel usage, and looking at individual consumption is the right way to look at it. You imagine the average Chinese person living in a cold climate can't heat their home, and wants to increase their heating usage by 200kg per year. Meanwhile the average person in the US uses 700kg for heating and also spends a few tons on flights and car travel every year.

It's not about "advantage" it's about asking the Chinese person to continue to freeze while the person in the US reduces their consumption by 200kg. So the Chinese person has 200kg worth of heating while the American has 500kg. But they should be equal assuming equal climate, is the thing.

reply
well American need more because they drive 2 ton ford car
reply
"The elves should take the ring" "No, the men should!" "No, the dwarfs should take it to Mordor"

The hobbit steps forward

"I won't. I won't take it. We hobbits are too small, we never got a ring of power. We have no involvement in this. It's simply not out responsibility!"

The men, elves and dwarfs, not humiliated, continued to argue.

reply
By that logic if you split China into ten countries with the same total emissions then they wouldn't matter any more right?
reply
deleted
reply
CO2 is not the worst effect from coal
reply
The climate doesn't care about per capita.
reply
Thought-terminating nonsense. All those people you call "capita", are real people with real lives and your suggestion in essence is to immiserate them. The climate does care about per capita when each of those people contributes to the development of green technology even in some indirect way.
reply
> All those people you call "capita", are real people with real lives and your suggestion in essence is to immiserate them.

You're putting a lot of bad faith words in my mouth I never said. If anything is "thought-terminating," it's that.

reply
You should know that the phrase you used implicates the beliefs I outlined, if you didn't already.

Also I offered a real counter-argument, that per-capita is in fact important. How is this thought-terminating?

reply
the climate does not care about per capita!
reply
Correct: the climate cares about absolute numbers. If we want to distribute an absolute reduction in carbon fairly across the world, we should equalize the per-capita emissions.
reply
Nobody cares about fairness; in order to convince larger nations to do anything , you need a large enough military and economic force backing the alternative.

I'd actually say that the US AND China have little-to-no responsibility to start a push towards cleaner energy because they benefit so strongly from the status quo. Those that don't have that benefit should be more incentivized to pushing their carbon output to zero, and pressuring both these entities with sanctions, trade wars, and military action wherever possible. Eco-terrorism should also be financed by these smaller entities targeting backers and companies of the larger ones.

reply
Fuck it. Let's just restart the game
reply
It also doesn't care about what countries people are arbitrarily grouped into. Per person emissions need to be reduced, and bigger countries have more people. You can't blame countries for having more people if their emissions for those people are lower than your own.
reply
sure i can. the important counts are the amount of plants and cars and so on.

the thing that needs to be turned off is coal and gas plants, not to mention gas and diesel cars and trucks

the people are irrelevant, and this is just excusing larger and growing populations to burn more.

i can blame them just fine for having more and replacing their coal plants with new coal plants

reply
This (climate) is a common problem. You of course can say "I want my yacht and my personal airplane and I do not care if 1M in another country use a coal plant only to have electricity to cook a meal". But I hope you can imagine how those 1M will consider you.

Solving a common problem can require finding a common solution, which would require some sort of agreement like "I will consume less, if you consume less and we can both survive decently".

Anyhow, at this point I find the discussion irrelevant as renewables are cheaper. Whoever wants to make it about "save the planet" or "they and not us are doing the damage" are indirectly helping the fossil fuel industry that wants this to be a "culture war" and not a discussion about "what is cheaper" (which they would loose).

reply
>the people are irrelevant

That’s where you lost the point. Earth doesn’t care if it gets hotter. The people do.

reply
Right. In that case China+US (which is strictly bigger than either) is the singular entity which needs to regulate.
reply
the climate doesn't care about china or europe or america either, so why are we apportioning blame to individual political entities in the first place? and why are you chiming in with this perspective after it's pointed out that, relative to its population, china is less polluting than america?
reply
> per capita

So? If I have a family 5 times the size of your family, my family is consuming more, negatively affecting those around me.

reply
Let's say there's your big family and five other families who all drive big trucks. The other families are all pointing at you saying you're the one who needs to fix things, not them, even though their collective emissions are higher.

It doesn't matter to the planet what arbitrary social construct you group people into, every family needs to put in the same work per person.

reply
> every family needs to put in the same work per person.

Why?

reply
Because the people are the ones who pollute, not abstract concepts like countries, states, families, etc.
reply
People's individual choices make zero dent in the overall environment, even if it affects local ecology.

Environmental issues have to be solved at a group-scale. Policy, market forces, technology innovation, etc.

To tell people they need to stop using plastic, not get something delivered next day, to not eat meat, and make it their personal responsibility simply does not solve things.

What's really off-putting (and likely hypocritical) is someone telling someone else they're failing morally on these matters.

reply
My point is that the groups are arbitrary. If you have a country with a billion people or ten countries with a hundred million people then the responsibility is exactly the same. Splitting a group into smaller ones doesn't make it not matter any more.

And of course personal choices matter, exactly for this reason. If a million people choose to be wasteful then it's not valid to claim "it's not MY massive car that's the problem".

reply
China chooses to manufacture disposable, low quality crap, and then ship it around the world. So casting them as better because of low emissions per capita is not holistic thinking.
reply
They manufacture it because people around the world buy it, it's not like they do it to hurt the environment like a Captain Planet villain.
reply
The ones to blame about the disposable crap are the ones that buy them anyhow. Which is mostly not China, so either way they seem to be "less to blame".

Or, by that logic, let's go to the source and blame only the fossil fuel producers ... wonder who produces more oil.

reply
If you are going to blame consumers as the ultimate drivers (e.g. in the case of goods manufactured by China) then you also have to blame them for the drive of other things like fossil fuels or AI data centers.

Otherwise it is just cherrypicking.

reply
Well obviously, if you burn the petrol in your car it's not the gas station's fault for selling it to you.
reply
The point I was trying to make is that it makes little sense to point to one type of link in the chain (material producer/energy user/product consumer), everybody gets something out of it.

Now, how essential for them is what do they get out of it - that's a different story. Buying one mobile phone per year is different to not having electricity to turn on the lights at night (exaggerated examples).

reply
And if you have a common last name, such as Smith or Johnson, people with your last name are consuming several orders of magnitude more than people whose last name is Zillman.

The environment doesn't care about arbitrary sorting of humans into sets. It just cares about totals, which is why unless you can make a good case that some people have some sort of natural or moral or divine right to consume or emit more than others the allocation has to start with per person.

reply
> It just cares about totals

Global greenhouse gas emissions have risen sharply over the past century, driven by industrial growth, expanding energy use, and population growth.

Select for US and China in this chart - https://ourworldindata.org/greenhouse-gas-emissions

What do you recommend?

reply
by doing nothing, most of western country birthrate is in decline anyway

would take a while for developing country but at the end of times, world population would decline and in translate to "reset"

reply
The problem of per capita has a very simple solution. Those with too high CO2 per capita need to have more children, and those with too low CO2 per capita need to have fewer children. That way it becomes more equal and thus more fair.

Should this be the new goal for COP32, or should it focus more on addressing global climate change and reducing the total global emissions? What is the metric that we actually care about?

It should be noted that older demographics have higher emissions rates than younger ones, so having more children is really an effective way to reduce per capita CO2 emissions. The emissions get spread out over larger population, and the new generation has less emissions than then the older generations.

reply
As soon as a metric becomes a target it ceases to be a good metric, obviously. The point of per capita emissions is looking at things like heating. If 1M people living in a cold climate in China use 1000 tons/year for heating, and 100k people living in a similar climate in the US also use 1000 tons/year for heating, expecting both countries to cut those emissions by 500 tons/year is likely suggesting that the Chinese should literally freeze to death.

Serious proposals need to take into account individual needs.

reply
Conversely China isnt setting up the sites and turbines/coal in almost residential areas. With the accompanying noise/dust pollution and other hazards , all in the pursuit of makinga quick turnaround instead of following the existing regs for greenfield projects.

China projects as far as i can tell are in remote , renewable heavy areas and mostly greenfield with the coal/gas contribution being mostly to stabilise the grid (when it not in industila/manufacturing processes).

And again this is a country of 1.4B people that also increasingly the manufacturing base for most of the planet, so throw in all the goods going to SouthAmerica/Africa/Europe into that energy consumption calculation. That lage parts of the developing and develpoed countires can accelearte their solar/wind buildouts comes directly from those coal/gas plants in Chna.

reply
IIRC China also generates more solar power than the rest of the world combined. It's just a really big place.

It's like saying the USA has the most inmates out of any country. True but not surprising because it's the 3rd biggest and has a crime problem. The USA has more inmates per capita, now that's the real problem.

reply
Not necessarily. Countries like China tend to execute entire classes of prisoners resulting in a lower per capita incarceration rate. Some countries are highly corrupt and laws are not enforced as they should be and would have similar rates if they were. How do you determine the 'correct' rate?
reply
“Mercy to the wolves is cruelty to the sheep.”
reply
Most estimates put China at ~1000-2000 executions per year.

The US incarcerates 1.2 million people.

reply
China has almost half the CO2 emissions per capita compared to the US, and only surpassed the EU as recently as 2019 – and that's even a biased analysis considering the worldwide industry is there.

https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/co-emissions-per-capita?c...

reply
the climate does not care about per capita!
reply
By this reasoning, if China split into a hundred tiny countries tomorrow, the problem would be fixed, since each individual micro-China wouldn't be a big contributor.
reply
that made me laugh
reply
Such a lazy argument, climate does not care about political boundaries.
reply
the climate doesn't care about anything, it doesn't have the capacity to do so. The capita though...they can do some caring.
reply
Shut up. You are expecting some koombaya shit where everyone in the world agrees you are right and decides on a maximum emission per person and implements it. That's not how anything works.

The largest entity that can agree and implement anything like this across its parts is a country, so you have to appeal to countries to implement regulations.

reply
Regulation obviously could approach this issue, look at China's record on the Paris agreement and their track record inside the WTO. Regulations will obviously be able to effect the incentives that shape their economic policy. Additionally, China's coal consumption of 3.4t/capita doesn't differ that much from the United State's coal consumption from 1985 to 2010, which was above 3.0t/capita for the entire duration of that period, and Australia's current consumption of 3.4t/capita. Are you going to sanction Australia also?
reply
Europe is implementing a tariff on imports that is scaled based on the carbon footprint of the item. In that way aluminum produced in Iceland by clean electricity would be more attractive on price than it is today than aluminum produced in China from a heavy coal grid.
reply
Degrowth mindset. China's trajectory is lower emissions per capita and diversification of power, and global exports of solar technology.
reply
I don't know about statistics for the entire country but the two most populous states in the country have been growing their percentage of solar power at high rates.

This surge of fossil fuel use is only possible because we have a glut of fossil fuel plants that were sitting idle because of solar.

reply
China's coal consumption is irrelevant to whether a US data centre should be required to control its local pollution.
reply
I don't see the point in bringing up China and only gauging by population alone for amount of energy used. That completely ignores factors like resources access, infrastructure, geography, and other factors I'm sure I'm missing in the energy equation.
reply
Green energy activists tend to present moral arguments which are easily dismissed on economic grounds. Even if the US were 100% green energy, it makes no meaningful difference since the rest of the world still generates most of the pollution. That fact is both inconvenient and inescapable—it has been very counterproductive for green activists to dance around it by citing unrelated data as a rhetorical device to change the frame.

This new wave of green activists have learned to simply make economic argument instead. To their surprise "it's cheaper and it's clean" sells a lot better than 'non-green energy is h!tler and we're cheaper." I also think markets needed time to get comfortable with green energy.

reply
> Even if the US were 100% green energy, it makes no meaningful difference since the rest of the world still generates most of the pollution.

For a rough calculation, if the US had emitted no CO2 this millenium, then if all else were equal that would be more than 100 gigatonnes less CO2; meaning we'd be closer to 420ppm than the current 432ppm.

(There are feedback loops like oceans and plants that would absorb less CO2 at lower concentrations which I don't know how to account for.)

Mass of CO2 and ppm: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_dioxide_in_the_atmosphe...

reply
Yes it will and to make global treaties on emissions rampdown politically realistic, people need to get the ducks lined up at home in each country.

It's a classic collective action problem, and the international community has done similar things before.

reply
How is severe sanctions on China supposed to solve anything? How would you convince a country you just sanctioned to do what you want (invest in green energy)? Did that work out with any other country we sanctioned??

China is also #1 when it comes to green energy research, and guess what, they got there by investing their dirty fossil fuel profits.

If we care about pollution we need a massive global Green New Deal. Yet all we get from Europe is lip service about it, in America we are actively kneecapping renewables, and only in places like Australia do we see some success.

The only superpower investing on a continent scale in electrification and renewables is China.

reply
Chinese coal and CO2 emissions are dropping https://www.carbonbrief.org/analysis-chinas-quarterly-co2-fa...

A carbon tariff on China is an excellent idea. As long as that same tariff applies to the United States.

reply
Likewise, the rest of the world combined pollutes far more than China, so no amount of sanctions against China will make the slightest difference.

We have all the excuses we need to do nothing.

reply
You need a global carbon tax and China has to implement it or sanctions. They'd probably go with the tax as the biggest producer of solar.
reply
China is not going to get sanctioned.
reply
Europe is implementing a carbon price on imports.
reply
It's that or eco-terrorism sponsored by smaller nations (or war). If we don't get any of those, then we're not going to solve the climate crises and we're all going to bake ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
reply
The world turns a blind eye to everything China does so they can manufacture trinkets for us that can be marked up by 90%.
reply
deleted
reply
We should do that too.
reply
You never have to look far to find the predictable "but China!!!!" comments. So:

1. China has 4 times the number of people as the US;

2. China is using coal in part because of the disruption to oil and natural gas supply caused by the US boondoggle and grand misadventure in Iran. As an aside, China essentially saved the world economy by cutting their oil imports by so much;

3. China has built in recent years and continues to build more renewable energy (particularly solar) than the rest of the world combined;

4. For pretty much anyone else building renewables, it's China supply the tech more often than not;

5. China has built the world's largest hydroelectric dam (ie the Three Gorges Dam) and in the coming years is building something three times as large;

6. China is actually building nuclear power plants, something HNers normally love;

7. Since the 2020 OPEC oil supply shock (which never gets blamed on the Trump admin for some reason), China has added roughly 80 million EVs to the road. It's estimated that this has reduced global oil consumption by approximately 2 million barrels per day, which again has greatly contributed to saving the world economy but also represents a ~2% reduction in global oil demand.

What else could China do? What is anyone else doing in comparison?

reply
Also Wikipedia claims that China plants lot of trees (reforestation project).
reply
china could not try to manufacture too much of absolutely everything, at which they wouldnt need to continue producing so much fossil fuel based energy.

theyre purposefully wrecking as much as they can for industrial independence and dominance. thats a bad choice for everyone, but especially the environment

reply
China is already having a manufacture flight as cost of living goes up and companies look into cheaper neighbors like Vietnam.

China could do more, but there comes a point when its time to stop pointing at the place making real inroads into alternative energy and turn to the ones screaming drill baby drill with a skitzo energy policy.

reply
I'm with you on the futility of trying to solve global carbon emissions with even more regulatory burden in first world countries (which have already had declining carbon emissions for decades, while the rest of the world's emissions skyrocket), but what leads you to believe a confrontational, sanctions-heavy approach to Chinese carbon emissions is the only viable approach to Chinese carbon emissions?
reply
Fixing these cost calculations is what a carbon tax does. I bet a carbon tax on data centers would be popular.
reply
> popular

First you'd have to explain to things to the populace:

a) how those taxes will affect their purse

b) what those tax dollars will be used for

I bet you that on (a) the cost will be passed on (because we are the ultimate consumers) and on (b) the tax dollars will be misspent to a meaningful degree. End result is not a meaningful improvement to reduced environmental impact and consumers pay more. Basically wealth evaporating.

reply
> (a) the cost will be passed on (because we are the ultimate consumers)

Tax Incidence is a lot more complicated than that

reply
It doesn't matter if the tax dollars are literally burned on receipt, a carbon tax would cause a meaningful improvement to environmental impact.
reply
> I bet a carbon tax on data centers would be popular.

Shouldn't a carbon tax apply everywhere, equally?

reply
Maybe but that would be unpopular.
reply
We could subsidize where necessary.

The important part is to get the accounting in place.

reply
I think we can start with the ones who have the money to pay
reply
A carbon tax will not get one republican vote in the Senate. And it needs a dozen to override the veto.
reply
The closure of the Straight of Hormuz and subsequent Democratic wave shows the opposite.
reply
How do you figure that either of those says that a carbon tax on data centers would not be popular?
reply
.. on data centers, not on the general public.
reply
This would be a perfect way to start a carbon tax in the US, considering how widely public opinion is against data centers.

Plus it would have the net effect of incentivizing renewable power to them, so all the assets aren't dark for years when the bubble pops and the economics turn against fueling them with gas.

reply
do you think concentrated feeding operations could survive a carbon tax?
reply
That's why we should force companies to report on SASB metrics from their inception. A lot of these "oh look how green we are" reporting is also heavily manipulated to make it look good only on the surface.
reply
I think this is better thought of as a failure of public utilities and regulation itself. I'd bet that these small scale power installs are more expensive per kw than a proper grid connection. We've been investing massively in data centers since 2022. The utilities didn't plan ahead for growth. They should have used the future revenues to finance cleaner power plants. But they are too slow and overly regulated in all the wrong ways.
reply
Maybe black holes are just the remnants of civilizations who discovered self improving agi...and then consumed all their energy into a singularity, while trying to prove their ultimate, most interesting, math problem.
reply
It's all paperclips in the end.
reply
Tears in the rain

Paperclips in the wind

Keep optimizing until GOTO END

reply
I would expect most of the compute to be dedicated to generating reports, reading emails, bots arguing online, and other non productive activities
reply
It's more likely they poured it into bitcoin mining.
reply
The math problem was: "what is 6 times 7" ?
reply
It's why we need smart regulation, like a carbon tax. Our currently regulatory structure massively favors fossil fuels.
reply
The problem isn't not knowing what to do, the will is simply not there. That's the saddest part.
reply
The will to do what? Regulate? I would disagree.
reply
Tax companies 1% of their revenue. Allow for deduction of batteries, renewables or charging stations only for the next 10 years.

Swap tarrifs for carbon tax on imports.

reply
Naively, taxing revenue at 1% would seemingly make it impossible to run any volume-based cashflow business with a <1% margin on COGS, e.g. many grocery stores.

That being said, as it happens, those businesses also happen to have heavy logistics involvement, so in theory, EV tax credits could save that business model. Though that "logistics involvement" is currently arm's-length (they contract with trucking companies) so in order to benefit from those credits by forcing EV fleet conversion, they would need to vertically consolidate, i.e. buy up all those trucking companies.

And of course, under your model, after 10 years, they'd lose these credits and become negative-margin and cashflow-starved anyway.

reply
> Naively, taxing revenue at 1% would seemingly make it impossible to run any volume-based cashflow business with a <1% margin on COGS, e.g. many grocery stores.

it will be factored into price for end consumers and back pressured to suppliers

reply
IOW, it will have 0 impact on Anthropic with its 80% profit margin, but will make groceries more expensive.
reply
I just explained clear error in your speculations: groceries won't go out of business.

Impact is separate topic of discussion.

reply
"back pressured to suppliers?" Just like "other countries" paid Trump's tariffs, not American consumers. LOL.
reply
> Just like "other countries" paid Trump's tariffs

You obviously don't have any numbers in your hands about this.

reply
pot. kettle. black.
reply
burden of proof
reply
On the person who made the first assertion. You, not me.
reply
I don't agree with "first" criteria. I would say "first easily challengeable assertion" or "assertion which is currently under discussion", and this part is on you.
reply
Naive, indeed. In reality all grocery stores raise prices by 1%, which is like 1 month of price inflation.

The argument against taxing revenue is usually framed in terms of "thin" businesses that perform some administrative function but not much of a physical one, not businesses with significant operations that still happen to be in a mostly-competitive market. Although perhaps you could argue that this competition is merely a skin over the real pricing power (eg egg cartel, PG vs Unilever), and grocery stores have become akin to thin businesses.

Then again, individuals are essentially taxed on revenue (can't deduct most things that would be straightforward business expenses, like "commuting" or food), and we still continue to exist (at least for now).

reply
No economic policy which can be explained in one line will ever work.
reply
We already tax at rates much higher than 1%, and already allow substantial credits and deductions for solar, renewables, and biofuels.
reply
The tax is on profit, not revenue and Anthropic runs at a loss.
reply
But taxes on loss is paid by someone else in the end. Nvidia or the company which provides power infrastructure(and the people who work on them) has to pay the tax.

Why not just tax the use of gas and coal directly, rather than going through all the loop.

reply
Everyone going on about Elon, Beniof, etc, shifting their tune when Republicans are in, when Dems are in

Until 5 years ago rank and file among IT were anti-union, regulations... now they're the frogs feeling the heat and it's all "regulate everything"

Not one mfer is socially reliable. Everyone really should just be minimized to a single individual, a single vote and left to their childhood neighborhood.

It's all such obvious copy-paste and empty platitude effort from top to bottom with humans.

Mirror neurons most def seem like the simplest answer; superficial monkey see-monkey do follow along without critical thought happy paths in the brain being lit.

Fingers crossed the AI bubble pops and ends it all one last gasp, our answer to the Fermi paradox. Or at least makes everyone obsolete and ignorable.

reply
A plain old wellhead tax solves this and every other problem in this category.
reply
is that a tax of all gas or a gas on the gas that Anthropic is using in this scenario?
reply
As the name suggests it is a tax on taking the stuff out of the ground in the first place.
reply