> A shared, standardised communication protocol: it may sound technically complicated, but it is as simple as it is brilliant, and the technical blueprint has long been familiar to all of us: email.
The only visible text on the first screen is even less informative:
> A better internet for everyone is possible. Today. How do we build social media that strengthens democratic discourse and is both resilient and appealing? The Open Social Web Alliance aims to provide the answers.
If this wasn't #1 on HN right now I wouldn't even have scrolled past the first screen.
The doc was written by the Heinrich Böll foundation, Germany's Green party think tank (my preferred party). I first thought it might be LLM writing, but it might just be German habits leaking into English.
It’s the only approach that has ever made sense to me. We all have them. We all have ample storage for them. It’s the only option that will “just work.”
Also, specificity is important, though brevity and specificity have tradeoffs with each other.
I, too, am immediately skeptical of a "shared, standardized communication protocol" that is "as simple as it is brilliant", especially when they're trying to say email would be the basis. As it stands, the email protocol suite is already a hot mess of brilliant, well-engineered complexity.
I'm also, as a protocols-over-platforms FLOSS misanthrope, wondering what actual value they're adding here. My absolutely off-the-cuff guess is that OSW will try to be the new Web3.
Skimming through leads to nothing except "this should be done, therefore we will win, give us ten [p29], no thirty [p31] million dollars" without even stuff like "why we are a good choice for this money". It's impressively content-free text.
I'm confused, they will provide it? But then why does it say "a total of €36 million would be sufficient to provide for the ecosystem over the long term". Would be or will be?
I see, then on page 11 it says " The public financing for infrastructure as well as the first round of seed funding from public and private capital for innovations and applications (see 2.3 Funding) are scheduled for spring 2027."
It seems to mostly be an optimistic plan, assuming/pretending that other actors behave exactly as wished for. Strange document.
> A shared, standardised communication protocol
Over the last decade I've been left so cold by these attempts to 'fix' democracy via cleverly engineered tools. I think the problem is not one that we can engineer ourselves out of. Furthermore we've known the solution for longer than we've had digital technology: talk to people, build a coalition, wield power to make a (positive) material impact in peoples' lives. Trying to make the solution more complicated than that is not only a waste of time, but I think it's actively harmful as it pulls resources away from the things that we know work.
A populace with critical thinking skills and the ability to regulate their emotions is immune to all the bullshit we jump through hoops placing bandaids on.
But even if I try to consider this scenario for the aake of the argument, the biggest issue I see with it is that it puts incredible individual responsibility on everyone.
E.g. where I live we make cigarettes extra expensive, put explicit pictures of cancer patients on the box and prohibit all tobacco product advertising. We could simply educate people and expect them not to smoke, but we know it doesn't work as well. It puts every single person in a fight against corporations spending millions on psychological research and targeted advertising.
IMO government regulation isn't bullshit and bandaids, it's citizens focusing power in a bigger entity that can then fight a slightly fairer fight against those odds.
A new way of thinking is required to find peace and kindness.
From my perspective, better education would help enormously. As long as you don't use the narrow definition of education that only contains subjects like maths/physics/chemistry.
Education is important, sure. But what is even more important is basic decency, kindness and willingness to live and let live. I don't need a PhD to feel empathy for a kid in Ukraine caught in the stupid war or for a woman living under the religious fanatics in Afghanistan etc.
There are videos on YouTube of seemingly normal people making fun of the Palestinian misery in Gaza, for example. These people aren't uneducated, no amount of education will make them care. They just don't give a shit.
But people have been miseducated about the Nazis. They are made out to be a special kind of evil people that you can't accidentally be. In truth, most of the actual Nazis actually didn't know they were Nazis, they just thought Germany had a Jewish immigration problem that the government was dealing with, etc. because that's what the media (mostly newspapers) told them
Or do you think OP was suggesting that education is the sole issue and that evil people would suddenly cease to exist if they went to college? Do you also argue that laws are dumb because criminals still do crime, or do you understand that sometimes there are just evil people and "nu-uh"ing a suggestion because you thought of one, single, counter-example is non-additive and childish?
As long as you believe that's a symptom of a disease and not the human condition, you're not forward facing. The triumph of critical thinking over emotions is only a thing in sci-fi.
This is why righteous nerds never win, they don't want to. Deep down they know what they're saying is impossible, but they'd rather be "right" than make a difference.
NB: From what Wikipedia says, apparently OpenAI and Anthropic also had Pol.is on their radar since they apparently used it to build/study consensus.
> talk to people, build a coalition, wield power to make a (positive) material impact in peoples' lives
but allow such to scale in a useful manner, like vTaiwan / pol.is has shown is possible.
Same, the solution to most of our woes (govt inefficacy, social media, partisan politics, corruption) is to talk to each other again IRL. The many outweigh to money.
To this end I now make paper mini zines and give them to people, usually resulting in conversations with strangers.
> The Open Social Web Alliance aims to provide the answers.
The short answer is that it isn't as profitable as creating discord. People's fears and anger are monetizable. The internet of the 1990s is gone. People don't share information just out of altruistic kindness anymore. Now it is all about selling a product.
This is opposite the experience I have. I know there are places where people sell things, HN has always been one, so I spend more time socializing elsewhere. It's sort of like hanging out at the mall and complaining people keep trying to sell you things. The web is massive and there are tons of people seeking connection, being creative, and sharing kindness.
If we are on HN we are also the old guard at this point. We know of enough places and clubs that the loss isn’t as felt. Wikipedia is seeing a drop in traffic, and people are increasingly moving to Discord over forums and subreddits. Discord being outright inimical to search and finding historic information is a feature for users at this point.
Google AI summaries are busy hacking at the roots of the old web, reducing traffic to communities and intermediating the content they create.
I might be too early to call this out, but a contrary data point is audiences developing an intolerance for AI generated text.
Given the rise of AI chatbots, this is surely expected and unremarkable. Wikipedia's traffic was never an interesting metric anyway. What's important is that the information on Wikipedia is correct.
We need to have these companies pay for the downsides of their monetization practices and then itll be a competitive playing feild with these open standards
> Now it is all about selling a product.
The point the OP seems to be making is that it doesn't have to be this way if we organize.
We're brainwashed into thinking that everything must turn a profit, but this simply isn't the case.
This just screams "we want to censor the views that X stopped censoring"
Yeah no thanks
We need less censorship / "moderation", not more
I tend to agree. It's further a bit insane that "businesses" are getting a say in the governance at all.
> We need less censorship / "moderation", not more
Yeah, the main thing we actually need is the elimination of bots and paid commenters. What makes HN nice is it's mostly devoid of bots. What makes twitter hell is the fact that it seems like 90% of the tweets come from bots.
If that's even true (I agree there are no _obvious_ bots), I think this is mostly a function of HN being niche enough. Any social network that addresses a large enough part of society is a target for ads/manipulation. It just comes with the territory. IMO the right approach involves adding a cost to spam.
Of course VPNs exist but this would instantly solve so much of the bot problem.
There’s 3 topics that are the horsemen of the apocalypse for online communities: Politics, Religion and meta commentary. Any community that allows these topics will have a higher moderation burden.
Conversely, communities for topics where posers find it hard to survive, have lower moderation burdens. Technical topics create higher barriers to entry, and end up with experience community members who can call out errors and referee discussions on merits and domain knowledge.
Required Community moderation level is primarily a function of barriers to entry.
On a separate note, I’ve found that putting this information out there, always riles someone or the other up. I have no idea why.
The greatest trick the devil ever pulled was convincing everyone he didn’t exist. Professional influence campaigns are so effective because no one targeted by those campaigns believes they’re being influenced.
That’s not what X is. It’s a clash of ideas pushed by folks with bigger bot armies. The calm down after Yandex’s datacenters were hit should give anyone arguing for the cacophony a pause.
Like, what was the last original idea of consequence that developed on X through discourse? Compare that with blogs or pamphlets or newspapers.
This was fake / deceptive btw. There was no dip
Not happy being exposed to weaponised bot farms - note: not real people - cynically trying to engineer my beliefs by manipulating my emotions.
We've had more than a decade of experience of wannabe social engineers who claim to be for free speech, but are bitterly opposed in practice to truly organic political sentiment when it conflicts with their financial interests. (And their personal narcissism.)
Nor is Humanity a garbage fire.
Humanity had many better tools to manage discourse, and better discourse in the past.
Twitter did a pretty good job of creating a meeting place. I’ve been on Reddit during its hey day and I’ve seen national movements that coordinated untold millions, to achieve narrow technical policy goals.
I’ve lived and breathed the idea that free speech is the best tool for ideas to win, until the difference between idealism and the actual behavior of users landed on my doorstep.
I strongly recommend people volunteer to moderate wherever they can. It is easy to hold an opinion when you have no skin in the game and things are theoretical.
It’s a constant shame that trust and safety teams rarely engage on HN.
Letting corporations milk dry anything good remaining in society is also less than desirable. And we know they do it simply because profit, and they will walk much further well into criminal behavior simply because profit.
Kids shouldn't read alone Mein kampf for example or racist xenophobic antisemitic etc things. Don't you agree? And that's regulation too.
But that falls apart if you are one of those and actually want to hang out there as part of a community. If you were sitting at a park with your friends while random strangers yell the most offensive thing they can think of at you or going to a bar while a klan meeting is the next table over you probably wouldn't be like, "it's so good that I'm part of a diverse marketplace of ideas."
So in the same way you curate your friend group to be people who don't talk about jews controlling the media or aren't painfully insufferable about the Avengers perpetuating patriarchal attitudes after going to see a movie it's nice to have social media where you can have that too.
1. Those who don't have enough of a moral sense to want to avoid it like the plague.
2. Those whose desire for money outweighs their moral sense - their desire for exposure to an audience makes X hard to resist. This includes corporations. The New York Times would have to give up nearly 60 million followers to leave X, for example.
3. Those whose values are aligned with the far right, up to and including MAGA, neo-Nazis, and the final boss of that mindset, Musk.
Arguably the first category includes the other two.
Besides, the ideas in question are difficult to avoid. No-one is starving for the latest rationalization for those ideas - and you won't find any good ones on X, anyway. If you want the intellectual background, read a book on the history or philosophies in question.
I got absolutely lambasted by that user as a DINO and by a couple of other accounts that smelled of bot farms.
That said, I fully support moderation of these tools. They theoretically exist to form communities. The fact grifters and trolls can ruin that is not freedom.
Moderation should be something you yourself opt-in on the client side. The server should have no say in it and deliver the data as raw as possible.
The whole problem with modern social media is that you can't, since there is no unfiltered way to access them, most don't even allow you to see a plain old timeline, all you get is algorithmic click bait. Having account requirements that make the content inaccessible to read via the public Web is another huge issue.
https://www.404media.co/republicans-learn-x-is-an-echo-chamb...
Are you an actual X user? Because people from both sides were instantly clowning on this, it was far from a consensus and the most popular posts were being meta / ironic
The article is very much giving this meme: https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/jessica-chastain-at-the-compu...
> We need less censorship / "moderation", not more
As if X isn't full of its own dark patterns.
Based on what? The self-styled free speechers took the reins of American social media and made a mess with it.
Why would we need more censorship? Let them say anything they want.
I mean we’ve seen a global program of attempted (and failed) political mounted by these folks, using their social media power, that has cost lives and liberties.
> Let them say anything they want
I still believe in this. I don’t in them privately and selectively amplifying.
In the meantime, it's mostly group chats, and me having to assume everyone else is either a bot or selling something (no worse than traditional media, but no better either)
I care less about the hosting provider, and more about trust and the impact on users.
And it's also full of bots. I posted one thing yesterday, and I got one human reply and 4 bot replies.
I think I've gotten too used to having "custom" feeds like "For You" in my Bluesky.
Twitter used to be that. Still is to some extent, but not as resistant as before.
Much of that activity has moved to group chats, but those aren't a good replacement for the experience Facebook used to provide.
That has the same shape as spam. People don't want to participate when what they're sharing gets drowned out in a sea of noise. Of course the old experience required maybe 10 minutes a day to see everything, which is not a recipe for a profitable advertising business.
The profit-centric platforms are engineered to be addictive, but it need not be profit-centric if we organize, which is the point of the OP.
Let’s take two different social networks today: Strava and Threads. They serve wildly different purposes and have no need to talk with each other. By virtue of hyperlinks, one can enable cross-posting between networks if that is somehow desirable.
The only way a shared protocol makes sense is if the purpose of the network is either very general (looking at you, e-mail) or the semantics involved are very homogeneous.
This proposal wants federation but also doesn’t say how existing federation technologies fail much less how their own will work.
E-mail will be hard to unseat and social networks are still a dime a dozen with wildly different expectations for messages passed between them.
That part is TBD, but others have elaborated on the problems and solutions:
i really believe that this is a bad goal. 100 million people don't need to connect, and any system that tries to enable this will end up having all the same problems as facebook does. open-source or not.
the best online social spaces are small, focused, and have barriers. build a healthier world by connecting tens of people, not millions.
It's a cute attempt at fixing some of the things with social networks but they almost always something that people don't want fixed at all. For someone who has very little followers on X and leaving replies or engaging in the comment section of Youtube or HN are probably living in a completely different reality for those of us who have gone viral or have experienced an insane amount of engagement. There's almost no reason to try anything other than what the big mainstream networks offer.
Same for when someone tries to start an HN alternative, people simply flock to it for a while and then it trickles down. Or reddit alternative. Digg is a great example where people get interested for a while and then they are back on reddit.
The topology of addiction- and influencer-based social networks is bizarre, and I think there is plenty of room for alternatives. There are potential users that value quality over quantity; they want, and would probably prefer, far less of a network effect.
The ones that are addicted are guys in the reply section, youtube, HN, reddit racking up an insane amount of posts and interactions that ultimately can't be momentized or lead to any sort of economic uplift.
Reducing social interaction to its profitability is definitely a different approach than the article is proposing.
I don't see this OSWA ensuring that kind of scenario (more centralized moderation probably won't encourage that soft self-moderation), but there are better patterns that can be recreated.
This reads to me a little bit like saying the person addicted to a drug doesn't want to get off the drug so why even try. These are people that are extrapolating into the future and being worried about what they see. This is an attempt to, as a community, steer us into a more resilient but still enjoyable behavior I would imagine. How can we support them because the alternative could lead to a decline in overall species health and we'd regret having gone down that road too far.
You have confused being online permanently solely as the fault of social networks but the perma-online crowd has existed even before the arrival of mass social networks like Facebook. They've hung out in IRC chats, php forums, mailing lists.
bsky is a protocol, so the protocol ought to work for both the left and the right. Some people are annoyed with how broken on a technical level x has gotten
Network effects really do matter which is the problem with "Facebook sucks. But Facebook popular, therefore Facebook good". Because nobody wants to move off the bad product because you lose access to everyone else on the bad product
The internet's still relatively young. It takes time to move, and establish
I do think we do have some amount of decentralized social media, but if everyone moved to the bsky.app tomorrow, I would say there was no real decentralized social media despite the fact that it's a service based on AT Proto.
Yes there is a twitter-like Nostr. But there are plenty of other apps that just built on the relativeley simple nostr protocol (it is just JSON over websockets with some conventions and crypto - basic server is probably done in less than 500 lines of code). The heavy lifting is in the clients. I do not use it for twitter-like social media, but only for messaging via white noise (a MLS based messenger, [0]) and in some hobby projects where I use trystero [1] where is piggy-backs on nostr relays so I do not have to have an event broker in my deployment.
But yes, the protocol and its possibilities are plenty of fun :)
[0]: https://www.whitenoise.chat/ [1]: https://trystero.dev/
We get rid of the adverts.
It's that simple. Advertising has perverted every platform it is introduced on (search, twitter, instagram, even email with gmail). So how do you fund such a platform without ads? Perhaps we need governments to step in with funding for a social good, as they do for roads etc.
Communication networks should not be solely in the hands of private companies and moulded for their benefit, encouraging 'engaging content' to sit between their ads, content that is by design indistinguishable from ads.
They propose a publicly funded central Secretariat deciding on "interventions" (Section 2.2.2, p. 24–25 & 2.2.3, p. 27).
The Secretariat connects with state authorities and broadcasting councils.
One its duties is "to discuss new and critical cases and decide on interventions at the infrastructure or application level."
It also calls for mandatory reporting systems (of things people find offensive?).
Then you can allow your friends to make accounts on your website and then they can get access to certain posts and pictures. Your friends can also subscribe to your newsletter to keep up with you without doomscrolling.
Making your algorithmic feed would be easy since you just choose the people you want and it shows their posts. People could also curate their own feeds and charge a fee for users to see their feed if their curating skills are elite.
Most attempts to solve this focus on only one of the above.
If anything, Twitter was always left leaning. The microblog architecture requires you to be visibly proficient, interesting, and cognizant of reputation to be able to gain ANY attention whatsoever, and that is not easily achievable while holding right wing biases. Microblog is just structurally very discriminatory against skill issues.
that's certainly an interesting comment to make under a post about "strengthening democratic discourse"
And the policy paper nails the important motives, although I miss some notes about why Nostr is not perfectly aligned with these values already.
Another critique: "We have identified five key challenges: infrastructure, governance, funding, attractiveness and public mandate." - I wonder why network effect has not brought up.
Of course these are not very important questions, if a lot of money is already available as funding to keep the devs busy for the next 3 years.
Seems a broken idea. No idea if it can be solved so simply. Or if the solution is dedicated forums as of the past. Shared interest away from degenerative musings on things people will not properly engage nor meaningfully attempt to solve.
What has kept AP and AT from replacing social media - and how is this going to be different to address those issues? Those are the questions I want to see answered
With regards to establish companies, I would advocate for regulating algorithms, data harvesting, and targetted advertising. I think if we go after the last one, the others will lose their value and natural incentive (more ads, more money)
Doomed to fail already.
The true solution to open social media is decentralization without any governance, and there are already protocols and developments in that direction (nostr).
Since reading The Murderbot Diaries, I've wanted something like The Feed. The ubiquitous common comms network that everything travels over. ATProto feels like the closest thing we have to it right now, or at least a distant ancestor of the feed.
ATProto also allowed Blacksky to flourish and grow, providing its users with a far more equitable place than any other social network.
ATProto is still in its infancy really. Private spaces launch next month, and I'm excited to be able to use that for my own Keybase style encrypted storage. There's an absolute fuckton of possibilities for user-owned user-portable data, even in this brave new agentic world.
I decided some time ago that I'm not going to waste my time and energy anymore on convincing other people to 'join' the open web. The open web is still open for everybody. People that want to join already did. People that see the benefits of the open web above closed walled gardens already see these benefits.
Trying to convince the masses? That's flogging a dead horse.
I'm subscribed to around 2000 RSS feeds from - mostly - the HN community. That's my own social media, without thirdparty algorithms. So keep on posting guys/gals!
> How do we build social media that strengthens democratic discourse and is both resilient and appealing?
Not everything is politics. Why build social media to strengthen democracy? Sounds ff*ing boring even to me, as someone who actively built alternatives. Why not build social media for fun, without algorithms? Why see social media as a democratic battle ground only because others apparently see it as a battle ground?
Nah, it's all still permission-begging protocols. I'll stick with nostr.
That said, it's a great idea. I just don't think it will go anywhere, as there's just too damn much money to be made, by being bad.
It’s not the protocol, it’s not the platform. Sure, it’d be great to have this stuff out of the hands of the assholes. But the actual act of social media makes people narcissistic and silo’d.
We could just stop doing it.
There's no content here. What are the intended uses of such a thing? I didn't see any descriptions of what this infrastructure would enable people to do.
Anything Mastodon based has the problem with instance admins holding their users hostage in defederation issues, and everyone has to deal with spam and abusive behavior (which partially is why the behemoths are closed down so hard).
Your post advocates a
(X) technical (X) legislative (X) market-based ( ) vigilante
approach to fighting platform centralization.
Your idea will not work. Here is why it won't work. (One or more of the following may apply to your particular idea, and it may have other flaws.)
( ) Spammers can easily use it to harvest email addresses
( ) Mailing lists and other legitimate email uses would be affected
( ) No one will be able to find the guy or collect the money
( ) It is defenseless against brute force attacks
( ) It will stop spam for two weeks and then we'll be stuck with it
(X) Users of existing platforms will not put up with the inconvenience of switching
(X) META, RDDT, and DJT will not put up with it
(X) Requires too much cooperation from incumbent platforms and service providers
(X) Requires immediate critical mass and widespread ecosystem adoption
(X) Many users and businesses cannot afford to abandon established audiences and commercial relationships
( ) Spammers don't care about invalid addresses in their lists
Specifically, your plan fails to account for
( ) Laws expressly prohibiting it
(X) Lack of a centrally enforceable authority for cross-network governance and moderation disputes
( ) Open relays in foreign countries
( ) Ease of searching tiny alphanumeric address space of all email addresses
( ) Asshats
(X) Jurisdictional problems
( ) Unpopularity of weird new taxes
( ) Public reluctance to accept weird new forms of money
(X) Huge existing software, infrastructure and commercial investment in incumbent platforms
( ) Susceptibility of protocols other than SMTP to attack
( ) Willingness of users to install OS patches received by email
( ) Armies of worm riddled broadband-connected Windows boxes
( ) Eternal arms race involved in all filtering approaches
(X) Extreme profitability of incumbent platform business models
( ) Joe jobs and/or identity theft
(X) Technically illiterate politicians
( ) Extreme stupidity on the part of people who do business with spammers
( ) Dishonesty on the part of spammers themselves
( ) Bandwidth costs that are unaffected by client filtering
( ) Outlook
and the following philosophical objections may also apply:
(X) Ideas similar to yours are easy to come up with, yet none have demonstrated the ability to displace established platforms at meaningful scale
( ) Any scheme based on opt-out is unacceptable
( ) SMTP headers should not be the subject of legislation
( ) Blacklists suck
( ) Whitelists suck
( ) We should be able to talk about Viagra without being censored
( ) Countermeasures should not involve wire fraud or credit card fraud
( ) Countermeasures should not involve sabotage of public networks
( ) Countermeasures must work if phased in gradually
( ) Sending email should be free
(X) Why should we have to trust your alliance, governance structures and publicly funded infrastructure?
( ) Incompatibility with open source or open source licenses
(X) Feel-good measures do nothing to solve the problem of platform concentration unless users actually migrate
( ) Temporary/one-time email addresses are cumbersome
(X) I don't want governments determining the design or governance of my social communications infrastructure
( ) Killing them that way is not slow and painful enough
Furthermore, this is what I think about you:
(X) Sorry dude, but I don't think it would work.
( ) This is a stupid idea, and you're a stupid person for suggesting it.
( ) Nice try, assh0le! I'm going to find out where you live and burn your house down!https://plaintext.world/#BEEHF1unzJlSD2ZHzK0HqD5CaOmIsTs0jHa...
Ref: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38365892
Claude recently proved that the NIST curves are safe too.