Doubly so when we consider companies with external security audits. Those external security firms sometimes have access to better models and larger budgets than the developers responsible for fixing the vulnerabilities they uncover.
You may also have fixed the issue but had a bug in some part of your deployment.
And the more core the bug is (issue in an os) I would wager the larger the set of services you’re likely to need to update is.
There is always an extra edge case you could have verified but didn’t, some interaction with reality unaccounted for in testing, complex systems are complex
I'd be more willing to believe the network in question here was under an attack load that either was probed or exploited far enough that shutting it down was worthwhile. It seems more reasonable to me than believing they've let AI run amok on their internals such that it's now failing.
Not because I'm deifying the NSA but because the system has to be decades old, at least, and I wouldn't expect significant changes to something that "just works".
Everyone sees the incompetence of the Trump admin. Everyone sees things like this highly classified network breaking and the Signal leaks -- it's not out of character or anything. But when it comes to "pre-programming" the population, the powers that be suddenly turn hyper-competent.
That said IMO our organizational structures, both private and governmental, are far less competent than anyone wants to believe and these kind of problems were only a matter of time. You don't get government contracts or billion dollar deals by giving realistic timelines or proper estimates of capabilities, you get them by blowing smoke up somebody else's ass and offering the impossible.
Masterlock for example isn't a leading lock manufacturer by producing good and secure locks, they are just good at pretending they are because most people don't actually test or know how to test them. And then people act surprised when some 15 year old gives one a swift kick and it pops right open. It wasn't secure by virtue of nobody kicking it until then, nobody just bothered to try before.
Eh, I don't buy it.
"Fast forward eight decades, and [US] government messaging efforts like FDR’s are basically nonexistent. At some point during those eight decades, Americans collectively concluded that this sort of message is propaganda — the kind of thing the Nazis and the Soviets did — and is therefore represents the kind of government thought control that a free society should desperately avoid. We decided it was best for the government to step back from the fray of public opinion, guarding the principles of free speech from an Olympian remove, and letting the best ideas prevail in a neutral Marketplace of Ideas. That approach seemed to do fairly well for us in the late Cold War."
From https://www.noahpinion.blog/p/liberalism-is-losing-the-infor...
See also https://www.noahpinion.blog/p/how-to-take-our-country-back
And https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48628832
The mysterious "pervasive US government propaganda" is sort of like the invisible dragon in Carl Sagan's garage.
Keeping telling yourself Trump has any say in how their organization functions at an operational level. I think Trump is incompetent but I dont think that incompetency travels down to the operational level in intelligence like you think, the politicans trust these guys to do their jobs with their expertise.
You can call people conspiracy theorists all you want as an insult (thats what it is), or you could just try have an analytical understanding of the past and how these institutions operate.
Trump's admin and Republicans own much more of any government failures because of DOGE, and they will for awhile. But, sadly, they are still trying to blame the previous admin, but seems like most people are no longer buying it.
"CIA Employees’ Names Risk Exposure After Trump Demands List in Unclassified Email"
https://www.newsweek.com/trump-unclassified-email-cia-agents...
What would falsify your theories?
The thing about them being "nonpartisan careerists", at least, appears to be false. See https://steadystate1.substack.com/
Same for "the politicans trust these guys to do their jobs with their expertise". See https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7UD6F4F-Bcw
So roughly speaking your claims seem to fall into two categories: (a) unfalsifiable, or (b) falsifiable, and additionally false. If your falsifiable claims are false, I expect the same is likely true of your unfalsifiable claims.
>You can call people conspiracy theorists all you want as an insult
How do you explain, for example, people who insist that the earth is flat despite all evidence to the contrary? There's clearly a cognitive trap around conspiracies which a lot of people fall into, and I'm supposed to avoid mentioning it when it comes up, in order to be polite? No thanks.
What does Occam's Razor say? https://substack.com/@kryptogal/note/c-390204515
Im talking about the NSA anyways, I can assure you the NSA is very scientific and an apolitical institution. Much closer to NASA than it is the CIA.
Why are you comparing me to a flat earther.. You're too irrational and judgemental to even have a discussion about this. You're one of those people who has to be the anti-skeptic, its kinda cringe rationalist speak where you think the world is black and white.
Im not going to argue with someone who resorts to these tactics to discredit someones argument just because they dont like their takes.
And yes, even the NSA isn’t immune to the political bullshit coming out of the Trump administration.
Personally, as someone who worked on these types of systems for 12 years, I don’t blame the Trump administration in this case as far as doing something directly to cause it like a budget cut….
However, this administration created an insanely toxic culture. I saw many many talented people leave due to the toxicity that grew purely due to the administrations choices.
There has absolutely been a brain drain in govt agencies.
They might as well do just that. I've heard the theory of a "soft false-flag". I.e. something that will not have casualties and will not inspire mass panic, things which could backfire. But it should be visible enough to DC circles, so it can be used by people that already have access to the administration to nudge Trump into making certain decisions.
Sounds a bit like 5-D chess, so I'm not buying into it for now. But an interesting theory, nonetheless.
> theres some sort of strategy of tension regarding cyber/fraility of systems being pushed.
> 'Manufacturing Consent', new Congress AI regulation for industry capture in the pipeline
both capture my inclinations, but the other thing is this can simply be symptoms/indicators. looking at the recent faa thing, this could be "move fast and break things" happening in real time.
new contractors, new programs, more outsourcing/privatizations etc, palantir type companies moving into new places.
this is right after midterms, so the admin is doing its final phase of plays
ie it could just be that this sort of thing happens all the time, but is just getting reported more on places like CNN et al due to heightened sensitivity to the issue.
I suspect it's a combination of all of the above:
- never been easier to hack
- people with agenda's pushing stories
- people with careers reporting the zeitgeist.
The one narrative I tend not to believe is the foreign adversary one - as if I was a foreign power and I knew, for example, how to bring down the US national security network - I'd be saving that till I really needed it.
The only thing that distinguishes this particular moment in time is the thousands of bots from companies preparing for an IPO.
Coincidence or is there some common explanation that I missed?
The site has pretty robust defenses, so nothing has broken through yet, but a penetration or an effective DDoS feels inevitable as the probing steadily escalates. I expect that juicier targets are seeing a lot more of this kind of activity, possibly leading to some of these outages.
I run rate limiting on my nginx config instead which helps a lot more to prevent site issues from too many requests.
Granted I am on the free cloudflare plan, maybe the paid ones do a better job.
I think the opportunity right now where we have powerful AI hacking systems but not enough protections is to establish long-term presence in all networks of interest. Not bring them down.
For example, we updated a GCP managed base image of Ubuntu that was released with 350 CVEs patched, some were as high as 9.8. In doing so, they (GCP) changed the DEFAULT setting for hardware GRO from off by default to on. That's a massive networking change packed into a security update.
We only caught it AFTER it started causing issues in production. We didn't have the OS pinned because (decently valid reasons) or catch it in non-prod (decent reason + human mistake).
This is on a modern highly automated tested resilient well architected platform.
I can only imagine these other platforms are dramatically more exposed that we are, hence these common large scale outages.
More plausible to me is that spy agencies had previously found and used some of these hundreds or thousands of vulnerabilities to hack into those networks just fine. But now other people like cyber criminals are using these vulnerabilities via AI. That is messing up both the attackers who had already gotten in quietly and do not want the attention and the defenders who now have to respond to a noisy intrusion they cannot ignore.
Outages could be grey-hat testers and emergency updates.
A temporary period like we are experiencing is to be expected when moving to a time where a single engineer can perform the equivalent work of a team of excellent engineers working for weeks. Security has always been a game of who has the capabilities, means, and requirement for any given attack surface.
Compare to that, most people in industry at this point are either business disguised as technologist or in some cases experts in one vertical.Aka bringing it up is flame bait circle jerking.
https://google.github.io/building-secure-and-reliable-system...
GSA's 18F played a major role in applying Site Reliability Engineering (SRE) and modern DevOps practices to federal government infrastructure.
Who decides when a DDOS of Trumpcare.gov that is traced back to Akamai servers was an attempt to extort government contracts or “those pesky Chinese state actors”?
https://www.gsaig.gov/sites/default/files/management-challen...
The only references to 18F are in a footnote citing two reports about 18F done in 2016 and 2017...so very much during Trump.
The problem is much more systemic than having 1 decent org.
That would mean nobody would face any personal responsibility for the damage they've caused. The main reason this hasn't been done on such a massive scale before is the political backlash. And Trump simply doesn't give a damn about that.
BTW: I actually am winning racer.
But give it another year, trust me bro.
It does? Can you share an objective metrics that can highlight this that doesn't focus on single, isolated events?
I know you'll provide this because of your strong anti-"trust me bro" stance and dedication to scientific fact.
That's just going off the top of my head in the past 5 days
if only hunger wasn't an issue
On a serious note, I see it as a paradox. Competency is built through struggles, and the non-competent do not want someone that seemed lesser at some point to outrank them, be the go to person.
* Keep conversations secret on Signal
* Make over the Reflecting Pool
* Avoid firing critical employees during DOGE
* Retain IT staff
* Calculate tariffs using a sane formula
* Label African countries correctly
* Etc., etc.
Yet we HN readers are also supposed to believe that there is a galaxy-brained plan involving the US government coordinating with Anthropic (Anthropic, the same company the DoW designated as a supply chain risk) in order to ban open-weight models (any domestic ban would only affect US corporations and do essentially nothing about the global cybersecurity environment).
What is motivating these mental gymnastics folks?
if they did have a brain they'd know this is terribly short sighted
Maybe because all the western AI leadership is saying and pushing for it fella. I tend to feel the mental gymnastics demonstration is coming from you currently.
Consider Occam's Razor. What is the simplest explanation? Some ideas:
* These are issues due to people updating software which hasn't been updated in ages, as a measure to guard against cyberattacks.
* These are cyberattacks, and the people attacked don't want to admit it: https://substack.com/@kryptogal/note/c-390204515
Imagine if you lived in New Orleans and a civil engineering firm is saying the levees need to be upgraded in order to deal with hurricanes. You see a hurricane on the horizon and think: "I bet this weather was orchestrated by our local civil engineering firm in order to drum up some business."
What I am saying is that these problems - be it intentional or not - are opportunistically being used by the administration to push for privatisation.
I would wager that the last two years of actions by the party have resulted in an unstable infrastructure situation which they knew would result from pulling funding/oversight bodies/etc. This is also supported fully by their own Project 2025 discussions.
This is also the very simplest possibility.
I suggest these failed projects are what are under direct control of the orange man (he wears a ~mask, has anyone noticed?) and that is why they are typical outcomes for him.
The model I suggest for you is Trump Administration as a sort of 'delivery mechanism' with an outer shell and an inner shell. Most of the garbage theatrics is designed to infuriate and denigrate and is 'environmental control'. But if the mission statement is "break government" and "affect a national divide" and "establish an oligarchy in US", they are batting a perfect record. Also note in my model, this "administration" (and its legacy) will do heavy lifting in shaping public opinion about all sorts of matters for at least a generation.
I imagine, for the paranoid spy, not being able to call home could also mean "the enemy has severed our comms, we've been compromised, burn everything and run!".
Of course, it might be a limited hangout to soften the blow of actually being compromised.
https://www.forcesnews.com/services/navy/nuclear-promise-let...
"Submarines on patrol were reported to have briefly gone on nuclear alert in 2004 when Radio 4 went off the air for 15 minutes due to a power cut."
It would be a bit like linking to Das Kapital in a discussion about class warfare, without expecting anyone to read the whole book at the link.
>
"Scott Sagan, a political science academic and anti-nuclear writer, postulated that if the HOBO 28 monitoring aircraft had crashed into the BMEWS early warning array instead of Baffin Bay, it would have presented NORAD with a scenario (radio link to "Hard Head" aircraft and BMEWS both dead, no nuclear detonation detected) that also matched that of a surprise conventional missile attack on Thule, leaving the unreliable submarine telecommunications cable between Thule and the US mainland as the only source of information to the contrary."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1968_Thule_Air_Base_B-52_crashSo much reporting about clandestine activities falls apart because the traditional 5 Ws of journalism cannot be attributed.
1. say nothing in an official capacity and let people speculate
2. make an official announcement to head-off any concerns and speculation
Anytime that's the case, always ask "Who wants this headline to be in the media and why?" Note that a credible media outlet won't run a story unless they can confirm the "people" leaking are in an official capacity to actually know the leaked info.
For example, per later reporting in NYT & WSJ, the "Jensen's sleeping with alleged Chinese asset" leak was from the China AI Hawk faction in the White House (Defense, State and Treasure Depts) trying to undermine the AI Trade Pragmatist faction (Commerce Dept, AI advisors and NVidia) just before this week's summit. That matters because the summit will determine whether Trump extends the H200 card waiver past January. Jensen was effective in swaying Trump at the last minute to get the waiver last year. The well-timed leak of the 6-month old Alice report ensured he wouldn't be on Air Force One going to this summit like he was last year. The reporters who wrote the original story certainly knew this was why it was being leaked but the 'rules of the game' are that the reporter doesn't include the obvious purpose behind a leak in the story (or they won't get the next leak).
Today's leak may be as mundane as NSA / Homeland Security budget squabbles. When you can't get your infrastructure budget approved, highlighting an infrastructure failure can change that.
You could use this logic about any topic that doesn't directly affect every single citizen in a way they recognize.
Not every person needs to know or cares to know about every news event. But that doesn't mean the news shouldn't be reported.
Also, those of us who lived through Sept 11 and the failure analysis + Patriot Act know that the federal government has a "secret network". The reason Sept 11 was successful is because our "secret network" knew about suspicious activities of the 19 hijackers but didn't have any way to message the domestic law enforcement (the non-secret comms networks of the US) to surveil them.
Phone lines were still operating. What exactly stopped them from just calling local law enforcement and saying "These guys look like they might be trouble, I can't get into a lot of details, but can you maybe keep an eye on them?"
Isn’t this more usually stated in bald terms like “no communication across silos”, just like in corporate America?
But the classified system is still a silo, so all of the changes didn't fix anything according to that analogy.
There were more complicated changes (FISA Court, unclassified tags on classified records, Fusion Centers, Suspicious Activity Reports, etc).
Likewise, nobody gives a shit about Juniper routers in Arkansas but they sure as hell care if the FAA can’t operate.
Am I missing something?
It feels more like downplaying of real issues (I won't say attacks...).
Now, there's been some kind of drama with the FAA, and they have already proposed laws to break it up and privatise it.
This is all project 2025 stuff. They want to disrupt trust in all public institutions as a justification to write up big contracts for their wealthy benefactors to save the day.
This felt sufficiently conspiratorial that I did some digging. In project 2025 pg(s) 632-633, it does discuss FAA and that certain missions of the org cannot modernize or innovate thanks to the nature of being so heavily regulated, and those portions are better off being removed from the FAA and letting the private sector pick those up, or allowing the FAA run like a business.
It does not however propose any sort of drama or imply any shenanigans to reach the result. It gives 3 potential COAs to solve the problem, all of which are regulatory in nature.
Yeah, there's no plan in the document for creating drama to justify privatization, but they're not shy about their feelings on the subject.
Any exercise in government-wide budgeting and reform should review the department with an eye toward consolidation, elimination, or privatization that examines the efficiency, effectiveness, and underlying philosophy of each individual component.
the only real solution is for the national government to do less: to decentralize and privatize as much as possible
edit: in reference to drama/shenanigans wrt faa.
Yes, this is a conspiracy, in the literal definition of the word. These people are conspiring to take control away from the government and place it in the hands of private enterprise.
Anybody that doesn't understand there is a classified plan to internally destabilize whether through legitimate exploits or planned accidents is woefully unaware of the history of the DoD and CIA.
the physical blockade is a brilliant use of presidential power and appropriate, in my book it doesn't constitute war.
Its either that systems are starting to decay because everyone is rapidly offshoring all the hard parts of their jobs to mediocre chat bots..
Or they're actually trying to cause some sort of public stress about the frailty of systems.. They dont go around publishing that their critical systems are going down. It is odd.
the us president is completely demented by now and half of his admin are fascists rotten to the core. domestic and foreign interests both want him to continue war with iran, while other domestic and foreign interests want him to stop that war at once. in less than two months, democrats will take back congress and likely go for cleaning up the us admin at day 1. geopolitical enemies of all kinds want to destabilize not just the us but everyone for their own gains (i.e. russia wants ukraine and china wants taiwan - both impossible as long as the major western countries roughly are on the same page). and ordinary cybercriminals plus for-the-lulz-skiddies now have access to cyberwarfare tooling with open-weight ai models and harnesses.
I don't think it's as simple as "russia wants ukraine" either. Ukraine was a red line for decades, existed alongside russia for decades, and washington got involved and started pouring in money into ukraine as early as 2014.
Times someone has brought up the midterms: None
I find it more likely that NSANet status is not classified than I do that 5 people committed a felony to tell CNN this information...
There's a reason Jeffrey Goldberg was in someone's Signal contacts from the Situation Room, even if he wasn't supposed to be on the big group chat.
> At least not before getting it back up, running and secure again.
You’re confused a bit: there is no correlation between being down and being secure. If a device is not operational (for various reasons) it does not mean it is not secure.
1. All flights grounded
2. Microsoft outage
3. Optimizely malware
4. Classified NSA network down
I don't know what, but something is clearly happening.
There are a couple of things to keep in mind with nsanet though:
- It can handle anywhere between confidential to TS//SCI information
- It is largely (completely?) an off-infra network, meaning that it doesn't run over the same infrastructure that the open internet uses. It uses an entirely(?) discrete backbone. SIPRNET uses similar architecture.
- You cannot easily cross pollinate data from unclassified networks to nsanet. Everything from removable media to EMSEC is considered prohibited without proper channels being informed and paperwork being performed.
- Lastly, we're unaware of the timing of this supposed source. This could have been over the last week or a month ago or <n>. Scant detail is given, so I'm unwilling to believe "lolz nsa pwnd" just yet.
I would not be surprised if something similar was involved here. It worked with stuxnet, too.
Beyond that it's also typically blocked by GPO prohibiting USB, so even if that were the case, the net result would be no real data transfer and a nice email to the DA mailgroup about the workstation and logged in user who triggered the alert.
Unspecified computer parts were interdicted by US intelligence while being shipped to Neda Industrial and infected with Stuxnet. Four other external vendors working on the enrichment plant were also compromised, likely by Israeli intelligence physically entering buildings.
Stuxnet then spread across each companies internal networks and onto USB drives that were then carried into the facility and plugged into the air gapped network.
https://gdmissionsystems.com/encryption/taclane-network-encr...
Aren't these being treated as "normal" outages by the media and powers that be?
We collectively are very much in arm-chair speculation at this point. If this is a coordinated cyber attack the US government right now wouldn't want to demonstrate weakness or fault. Iran would be the obvious culprit... but going full arm-chair on speculation... There was a major and disappointing result in our elections to the current powers that be...
If this was a staged set of attacks carefully done to minimize casualties... I bet it would be enough to declare a state of emergency and get additional executive powers "legitimately". If that was the case I would expect more propaganda and less bury it under the rug if that was going on.
Be careful out there the world is scary. Don't take any of this as fact, this is all personal speculation based on my own observations. Let me stand-up from my armchair and go for a walk...
- Epstein/SV network within the US flexing muscles in response to mid term losses
- Iran, obviously
- China, obviously
- Russia, obviously
- CIA attacking other parts of the deep state in some internecine struggle or other
Literally all of those are completely plausible scenarios where the actors are motivated and capable
Based on my personal experience and to a certain extent sitting back down in my arm chair. I don't believe this is either China or Russia, they both have priorities that don't immediately involve the US and (as a government) the US is actively supporting both right now in very desirable (to them) ways.
Internal US action and Iran both seem equally likely in my head right now, but this is purely speculation and attribution is the hardest part to actually nail down when a state actor is involved.
This and the continued outages, such as the new Apple services outage, all collectively feel to close together without some evidence of a shared infrastructure causing it or a coordinated attack.
I don't personally believe this is "AI agents hacking the planet". The companies involved (well at least half of the outages I've seen) have enough compliance and protection obligations they are regularly audited against that my Occam's Razor gut feeling tells me that this is either long established persistent and maintained access being detonated one-by-one OR its a focused attack by one or more teams under the same directive taking down significant US focused institutions for attack or reprisal.
Have you considered the possibility that this isn't even the detonation/attack? That this is testing and/or a modest demonstration of capability.
If these are attacks, they don't at all feel like they're at the hands of people who have shot their wad.
While all flights grounded is significant on it's own, and would have got press, even in a world where the fear of AI or foreign interference wasn't so strong, but there's been more than a few substantial local and regional groundings due to software over the past 4-5 years.
Microsoft outage is not new, Teams and Outlook have had more than a handful of outages way before the current doomer craze. While I had to search these for accurate recall, having worked closely with Microsoft for a decade plus, the recent outage is not isolated and to jump to conclusions is short sighted. For example, pre-doomsday summary of Microsoft's noteworthy outages: (1) Azure Outage -Sep 2018 South Central US (San Antonio DC); (2) Recurring multi-day Teams outage that effected users world wide February - April 2020 (3-4 outages in total); (3) December 2021 - Azure Active Directory outage locked people out of Azure and Outlook for several hours. (4) July 2022 - half-day outage for exchange, teams, sharepoint for most users. Same span outlook and exchange were down much like this last event for several hours. (5) Jan & Feb 2023 several outages for globoal Microsoft Outlook and network events.
That's not even all of the events in the last 5-6 years.
Optimizely, NSA network, and FAA mostly would have been under reported and or ignored by the general public.
I'm not saying this time couldn't be different this time, but what is the thesis? AI, foreign actors, incompetence?
"I don't know what, but something is clearly happening" is fear talking not rational thinking. Not all dots require connections. If you had full awareness of all the wild things that go on in one day, the amount of correlation you could draw from that if you're trying to tell a story would be pretty salacious.
But correlation != ____________
I agree that correlation doesn't imply causation. At the same time, I think an increase in uncommon events over a relatively short period of time does increase the chance that they are correlated.
Does it increase it enough to make it plausible or likely? No clue. But we've seen similar in Europe, and the consensus among intelligence/military analysts seems to be that Russia and Europe are in a non-military conflict of some sort.
It might be just bad luck here, or the start of something similar.
Because then you have to define the "major" and "short" in "major outages in a short timespan", in such a way that
A. Includes all four of those B. When applied to the past, would actually, meaningfully differ from the status quo (How often can something happen before it's alarming? Once a decade? Twice as often as that? Half as often?) C. Isn't a clear overfit, threading the needle to meet A and B, but is actually robust against perturbations.
You will likely be right that this is a meaningful period, simply from the flights being grounded and the Microsoft outage, both meaningfully unusual events, but it's very easy to make a fairly challenging assessment seem simple if you just arbitrarily choose things to count on your fingers.
I don't think it's a stretch to say that some number of services go down every day and we don't hear or care about them. Three or four services going down and/or being attacked over a few days is only a pattern if it's actually different from before vs. you're just more aware about them.
'Mr Bond, they have a saying in Chicago:
"Once is happenstance. Twice is coincidence. The third time it's enemy action."
[From the original Ian Fleming novel]'
After the very deadly crash in Spain a few weeks ago...
You don't need a spy if the target self-sabotages.
While this rule doesn't apply to the NSA, speculation that recent down time from these U.S. companies being caused by state-sponsored cyber warfare seems unlikely.
It's easy to spot patterns when paranoid.
If four politicians die on the same day of heart attacks, maybe they're unrelated. Maybe they're chemical assassinations.
Same here.
> Because we don't know they're unrelated.
They might be related! But the burden of proof is not on the null case.
AI-accelerated attacks, I think most of the cybersecurity ones are attributable to that exploiting previous incompetences. But the flight grounding and microsoft outages? Looks more like direct incompetence to me
Either way I think the takeaway is that we've been slacking for a long time and now we have something that doesn't need man-hours, caffeine, and obsessive human focus to take advantage of that fact. At least for those of us who have been in the field for a while there's lots of work cleaning up these messes for the foreseeable future but I been on calls with peers of mine in infosec who have definitely been losing valuable sleep and health over it
Of what?
What are you talking about?
The question I asked you is a specific one and it has a specific answer.
For instance, I have heard that Iranians have developed rather sophisticated cyber-warfare capabilities. I don't know if that is true, and if true, I don't know how likely it would be that they would have reached capabilities to cause the observed outages. But even if you assume that the probability (or rather degree of belief) is quite small but still realistic, say between 0.1 and 10 percents, than considering the current situation it might be absolutely rational to see it likely that they are behind these outages. The full analysis requires estimation of the probability that this is all just a coincidence, and of other major "non-coincidental" branches. But one can do this at various levels of precision and explicitly observe how the output depends on the priors and the estimated probabilities (and therefore, on the assumptions).
First of all, I have not said that just assigning arbitrary probabilities sheds much light on the matter. Rather, what I alluded to, is that even rough estimates might often shed a lot of light on the topic. The Bayesian formulation helps to separate the problem into relevant parts, make the relative importance and interdependence of various factors that enter the reasoning clearer, and makes the assumptions more explicit. But in my post I have not really explained anything; I have just pointed to a tool somebody interested might use to critically assess similar issues. So yes, if you took it away, the post would lack an important part of its message, namely a pointer to a framework that the OP (or anyone interested) might find useful. However, I do not plan to give a treatise on Bayesian analysis in a HN post.
As for the other angles of your post: 1. Yes, the usage of the framework absolutely can shed light on many matters of this kind. What is your background? How much experience do you have with statistics or inference in general? There are many good sources where you can learn about these methods. A somewhat controversial one, but freely accessible, is E.T. Jaynes' Probability Theory, which actually directly addresses some aspects of what I spoke about. 2."it just seems to make explicit what everyone already does implicitly" People apply very bad judgement to matters like these all the time, this forum included. And even if people all used those things implicitly (which often they don't) it would still be worthwhile since it allows one to inspect the argument and find flaws or observe what are the dependencies on various assumptions.
News professionals would never be granted "need to know", and therefore would never be granted any level of secure access at all.
What I however know is that somehow the human brain likes pattern matching. We look into the sky and see patterns made by the clouds. We see some random cloud formation, match it against 100000 patterns and say "This is a car". We look at ink blots on a paper, match it and say "This is a knife" (Rorschach test).
Nothing of this is true ... it's just that we matched a pattern. And that he hold something plausible.
But ... thinking something is plausible is far from being it true. To draw an actual conclusion, we need a rigorous thinking process. Based on logic, not assumption. With facts, not assumptions.
If I would have to describe the current times (e.g. the last 15 times) then it would be the sudden lack of all this virtues in people engaging with other people. We seem to be certainly back in the old times, where rumors are hold to be true ("This red haired lady with a dark cat is certainly a witch. Burn her!"). And, worse, often people base actions on this hearsay, so we are also a bit back in the Lynch justice mindset.
> I don't know what, but something is clearly happening.
And I know, something IS happening. That's an inherent truism. Example: You, dear reader, are breathing. Breathing is "something". It is happening. Clearly even. I mean, if we start to write extremely vague, then another human matching pattern can see anything in it. We shouldn't talk in horoscope language and we shouldn't assume that horoscope language contains anything of value.
AI cyberattacks, foreign interference, and Ghost in the Shell type stuff sounds cooler though.
It's a big change so hiccups are expected.
I saw some speculation here [1] that it might be the root cause.
That's basically what's happening to the US right now. It is corruption from the Oval Office all the way down. Pardons are being openly sold. The news was manipulated ("a ceasefire is imminent") to profit off the oil markets. Stock trades on insider information abound. All of this is an inevitable consequence from a Supreme Court who manufactured out of thin air substantial criminal immunity for the president. This built on other decisions where this Court in particular just could not see corruption (eg Snyder v. United States [1]).
In the private sector literally nobody is ever punished for cost-cutting on systems to the point that they break. In fact, they're rewarded for it. It's entshittification from the CEOs all the way down.
We'll probably find as more of these incidents happen that AI code was written and reviewed by another AI, never tested and deployed to production. Foreign actors will be blamed, Congress will be blamed, etc. As an aside, the DoT is asking for $50 billion after the FAA outage (the worst in 25 years). Then Representative Mullin voted against $25 billion for the FAA in the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act in 2021 [2].
Now the administration wants to sell this narrative that they've been hacked. No, they're just corrupt and everything sucks as an inevitable result. Everything is shit. Nobody is hacking us.
I honestly don't know how we get out of this but we need a hard reset of some sort. One such hard reset was the French Revolution. There are an awful lot of people who need to spend the rest of their lives in jail, penniless.
[1]: https://us.transparency.org/news/supreme-court-undercuts-fed...
[2]: https://heritageaction.com/scorecard/members/M001190/117
none of these systems are even vaguely similar
They don't. This administration thought they could Venezuela Iran from the air.
Even more importantly, when these pretextual actions occur, everyone interprets them the same way and agrees that the secretly-planned action is now the one we must take.
It has come to my attention that the political elites and the Epstein class simply do as they please with virtually no consequences.
But not the AOCs and Bernies. They have no counterparts in the completely corrupt and immoral GOP.
So, the real question, is: "why are they making this public?"
[0]: https://thehill.com/policy/defense/5286561-nsa-cut-up-to-200...
I'm pretty sure they were calling that network the NSANet back then; I assume it's gone through many generations of upgrade since then. I don't remember much about them as a customer, except that (a) we weren't supposed to mention their name, and (b) they were running a horribly old version of the switch firmware. My understanding was that they literally tested stuff for years before deploying it.
It was a long time ago, and I was just a summer hire, so I could have this wrong; in addition things may have changed in the intervening 40 years.
It’s ass backwards.
The entire process is about compliance, the actual security is totally ignored.
One vendor I spoke to was scouring eBay for old Juniper VPN appliances that still had some ancient firmware that could no longer be “downgraded to” on new ones.
Notably, this old firmware included the back door used by the Chinese government that was trivially exploitable! [1]
Why that version!?
“Because that specific point release was certified years ago, and they never updated the certification subsequently.” was the almost verbatim explanation!
It’s insane, but that’s how government drones think. You can’t snap them out of it, they’re unable to comprehend any other way of doing things.
Details like “security is a treadmill, you have to keep moving” just doesn’t compute.
AI is tuned to speak confidently and ship independently; it is rare that it will suggest that one go back to a broad survey of stakeholders to ensure no Chesterton's Fence is being torn down (https://fs.blog/chestertons-fence/). "I've read the documentation and logs, and nothing suggests this system needs these legacy capabilities/components/capacity" is something we hear all day, and it is a siren's song if there ever was one.
Couple that with a general (and valid!) consensus that modernization of legacy systems must be accelerated for a variety of reasons - to mitigate this new and continuing "Black October" of hyper-agile agent-driven cyberattacks (whether the network is public or private); to have more flexible infrastructure for new features to stay ahead; to allow human teams to show their efficacy in a world where technology jobs are increasingly at risk - and you have a perfect storm where change management is no longer what it once was.
Some weeks ago, our Claude subscription failed - most people stopped working and switched to tasks they had postponed.
I suspect the situation is that AI's caveats are just easier to ignore than a person's warnings. Plus all the other factors you list. Also, AI tends to give a person the kind of communication they ask for. I always ask for options but I suspect other people ask for just answer and so they get them.
Doesn't stop so many people from believing it wholesale, and doesn't prevent so many programmers from saying "I don't review code anymore"
Also the amount of code that is being produced (at least in some places) is almost unreviewable
Asking the coin-tossing machine if it's safe until it says it's safe. :)
I think you went off somewhere else.
Which is to say, a parent post here on HN doesn't narrow the topic to it's focus. That's what makes discussion here interesting.
There was this tv program in the 90's about a fully automated japanese warehouse. The staff was one maintenance guy. They ask him if it was a lot of work. He said, everything is new then he made the face like a puppy to fill an awkward silence.
I've often joked about the mechatronics fortune in our train yard, they need to study hard, get the diplomas, get experience. Then the only tool they get is a flashlight and they have to walk around indefinitely not finding anything. Hundreds of employees like that. A good day is when they all find nothing, there are many good days, they are not suppose to find anything. If anyone does find something it most probably wont be you. They apparently still find enough things to prevent the full switch to AI and those pretty line scan pictures.
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/7/74/Line_sca...
The new (modernized) trains have IT guys, they usually have red/purple faces and run up and down the train with their laptop. They plug it in all over and the color gets brighter. Bright enough that I don't make jokes about it.
The FAA's recent outage for example, at its core, seems like people trying to rush needed upgrades that were slow for a specific reason (e.g. reducing the testing window for 90 to 30-days).
The Microsoft outage seems like three different things linked together (and poor "full failure" recovery prep, lengthening the outage).
The bank "outage" may not have even existed, 2/3 of the banks claimed they didn't have an outage at all, and the other said it was a limited technical issue. The articles were based on DownDetector spikes.
This is just a media hype train. Zelle outages have happened many times before but the stories didn't blow up they way they are now.
This has reached a Witch-hunt levels of fever pitch.
You'll commonly get regional failures, when failure happens.
You're out here categorically saying none of these had an AI or cyber-attack angle with no verifiable proof and having a tantrum that other people are doing the same thing in reverse.
The list of unanswered questions is long. Maybe focus on pushing for more details instead of immediately saying "nothing to see here" regarding a series of important failures within a week's time.
BTW here's JPMorganChase's statement: > JPMorganChase has experienced a temporary issue related to a software bug in on-premise hardware systems – there is no evidence this is cyber-related. Where we were party to a transaction involving other banks, those banks may have been impacted, but this is not a systemic issue. Customers still have access to their accounts and funds.
If you were trying to send your rent payment via Zelle from your Citibank account to your landlord's Chase account and it continually failed yesterday with no clear reason immediately provided, of course any complaint is a "witch hunt" since your Citibank account "works."
it wouldve been easy for the faa to blame their new AI vendor or these companies to blame some new ai process set up by consultants etc...
So let me see if I understand what I should be:
- Be more skeptical of official explanations, including where it includes a technical breakdown of how it occurred (e.g. Microsoft/Outlook outage).
- Be less skeptical of random commenters claiming, without proof, that it is AI or Cyber Attacks.
Because that's the implied point you're making. Be more skeptical of A and less skeptical of B, even though A has someone placing their reputation behind it, and B is anonymous commenters throwing made up theories out into the ether.
The explanation for this one still doesn't ring true for me and that's exacerbated by how many times the story has changed after telling the public that they didn't need to know the reasons.
Agree, though, that the rest do have reasonable explanations
So this outage seems a bit overdue to me.
Is "Claude says it looks good so let's skip the usual testing window and push to prod on a Friday" really not a sentence you can imagine being said in this current environment?
My point is that people are taking a potential future problem and applying to actual things that have recently happened, that didn't fit that mold. Which is incorrect.
When AI or Cyber Attacks cause an outage, people are absolutely right to say so. But claiming - without proof, that every outage is related to the two is noise.
In my line of work I deal with a lot of banks. They have been absolutely panicked for the last few months as they have been using AI to find and exploit bugs in their own software (A huge number of banks are members of project glasswing and other AI cyber testing with less limits than the public ones we get). This has forced them to drop almost everything else and immediately address updates in their systems, especially to a lot of legacy software that's sat around forever.
Just this many updates is going to cause instability in itself. Old systems that aren't touched can run forever without many problems, but when you can RCE said app the normal 3+ months of testing goes out the window. Now imagine this with tons of bugs in hundreds or thousands of applications at a single bank and you can see why things are starting to get unstable.
It's not quite Baader-Meinhof because there is deliberate action involved, but it can also make a trend appear out of what is actually random noise.
Naturally, when you tell an entire occupation that they are no longer necessary employees and that AI writes all your code, when something breaks in a major way those people are probably going to ask the question.
(https://www.cnbc.com/2025/04/29/satya-nadella-says-as-much-a...)
Summer of 2019 was also a pretty good one [2].
I fully expect AI will cause insane disruptions at some point, but all evidence points to this just being a series of normal outages. Worst timing ever to have a patch Tuesday.
[1] https://www.csmonitor.com/USA/USA-Update/2015/0708/NYSE-Unit... [2] https://www.thousandeyes.com/blog/looking-back-biggest-inter...
As a developer, I know very well that systems break, sometimes frequently (AI or not). It has always been the case, and likely always will be the case.
But, I am not surprised that people are mentioning AI - feels like most posts on here for the last year have involved AI in some capacity.
https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/security/optimizely-su...
Is it possible that the false of productivity is leading to worse products and massive loss in valuable headcount? Instead of AIs directly writing bad buggy code? Or is "everything rage-bait, and AI is all sunshine"
There's a group of people who think AI is perfect and will solve all of humanity's problems. That's annoying. There's another group of people who think AI is the worst thing to ever happen to humanity and is the downfall of society. These people are more vocal in my experience and they're everywhere. If you ever use AI you're a bad person who they'll disown like you're racist. It's somehow become the most popular 'social justice' issue of our time even as ICE exists alongside it. These people see a problem and immediately try to figure out how AI is involved. That's far more annoying.
Best example I can give that came up in my circle recently is the video game "Big Walk". It was recently denied for a silly award nomination because the awards have a strict no-AI policy. Which to me is absolutely fine, go nuts. But the vitriol towards this game, that everybody absolutely ADORED before the developer disclosed that they fixed ~10 lines (!) of code with AI because they couldn't figure it out otherwise, is absolutely bonkers. People I respect treated it like they were mourning something that WAS great until this catastrophe happened.
Funny you mention Swartz. He was entirely on board with "information wants to be free". He explicitly condoned piracy in pretty much every form. Also there's many ongoing legal problems for these AI companies that address all this. Anthropic is already on the hook to pay 1.5 billion for pirated books alone.
But this is going to be the issue of our time. If we make it past this point in history (I'm skeptical) I have a feeling that the "stealing" of information in such a way will seem comical to future generations. We'll gape in awe at how everyone was in a rabid race to hoard THEIR information to get pieces of paper and that we basically destroyed the only planet we have to live on in service of having more of an imaginary "value" (whatever value means on a dead planet).
But I guess I'm of the opinion humanity is ultimately doomed because of our greed. We've been warned and are watching in real time as climate change does exactly what we were told it was going to do decades ago and our answer to it is to put out even more emissions (drill baby drill!). IF AI can cause a technological boom that can maybe fix some of that damage perhaps all the "theft" was worth it? If not oh well the theft probably won't matter for much longer. And yes I know AI is causing even more emissions, but compared to the overall problem that's built up over 200+ years it's basically negligible.
In regards to mass surveillance that was happening well before AI. We all have phones in our pocket that track what we do at all times. You haven't been able to buy a car that doesn't track you for a long while now. Unless you're using cash you purchase things with tracking devices. We ask all of our questions to Google, an international behavioral tracking company. Does AI make that worse? Yep. And people are finally paying attention and getting Flock the hell out of their cities. Hopefully that will go far and people like Facebook, Google, etc. will finally be prosecuted for their decades of crimes against humanity (doubt).
You can say all the things you just said about AI about the internet as well. I can go to anna's archive and steal all the books I want. I can get any movie, piece of software, whatever else that I please. It enabled all the crimes you mentioned and much more. The difference with AI is that it might just be the most important thing since the invention of fire.
When you steal a movie from archive.is and watch it what is the result? You stole .00012c from copyrightholders? Are you stopping them from making new movies or taking new revenue streams or setting up your own theatre to profit? no.
When an AI companies steals decades of information, uses it to produce copies, and sells those copies, it is monumentally different.
Aaron Schwartz was supremely aware of class issues in this country, and did not believe meritocracy was real. I sincerely doubt that he would be in support of the upper classes stealing the wealth of information from the lower, and using it to make themselves even more tremendously wealthy while skirting the law. The point of my illustration is that this is a class issue, corporations are viewed as ultra-persons capable of skirting the law all the way to profitability to serve their masters. Meanwhile we are all little peasants that get to watch it happen, but if one of us tries to do the same we will see the inside of a prison cell.
It would be interesting if someone could do a proper analysis, though!
It would hardly be shocking that hostile nations are able to cause some problems with Mythos level tools.
If anything, it is more interesting how we can invade another country and the idea that the country or a collection of hostile countries could hit us back in any way, shape or form is just an impossibility. An insane conspiracy theory.
Maybe it is not that but surely the probablity is not zero.
Though at the same time, the public isn't privy to even 10% of the incidents going on right now.
The information I have is consistent with general cybercrime and script kiddie patterns, just a much higher volume, and much larger diversity of targets.
I can't put my finger on it, but something sinister feels afoot.
https://beready.campaign.gov.uk/
It's nowhere near the kind of readiness and preparedness campaigns of the cold-war of course, but it's a step up in alertness that's higher than anything I can remember.
Frankly, for the past few days, my gut is pushing a hypothesis to explain why nothing happened yet: bad actors are holding off until the winter starts.
Too many people are addicted to their smartphones and don't feel the same level of pride they used to in their work. All systems are shared, instead of one person being the ruler of a certain part of the stack, it's a revolving door and it's rare that anyone stays somewhere for even 5-10yrs. It leaves a wake of modifications that nobody else can keep up with. Also, the tech industry is moving fast just to move fast, a lot of old infra is still C++ and COBOL but good luck hiring anyone to use that, so they have to convert the systems to use the Latest Tech of the Day. The old, stable people don't have any interest in learning the new thing, and would rather retire with their knowledge. The new people want to rebuild from scratch in the New Thing and are convinced they need to job hop immediately after.
There are now post mortems for both outages. The FAA outage was caused by a botched upgrade to an ancient system. The MSFT outage was caused by a latent concurrency bug that was surfaced by a later incident. My experience in this industry tells me that this is plausible because these are exactly the type of things that tend to cause outages. My industry experience also tells me that hundreds to thousands of people were involved in the responses to these incidents, so if the companies were lying about the cause it would be leaked to the press and posted about all over Blind.
The other outages all seem to be normal nothing burger outages that happen all the time and nobody ever hears about because they don't make the news or even the front page of HN. The reason they make the news now is most likely because we just had the MSFT / FAA outages and that's in the news cycle now, not because they are somehow linked.
I can put my finger on it, and nothing sinister is afoot.
[To be clear: I mean exactly what I said, which is "there could be" which is not the same as "I think there is" -- so call it a 5%-10% chance of real cyberwarfare -- which means I'm not dismissing those claims out of hand, and find the claims at least plausible, even if I don't currently believe them]
It’s not nothing
But my gut says incompetence and rushing upgrades out of fear of cyberwarfare, not an actual attack.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frequency_illusion
Combine this with news reflecting both supply and demand for stories, it's impossible to tell. There's certainly a constant supply of outages.
You have aides and resources and money. Not having enough information or understanding is a choice.
It's criminal negligence.
I also think generally that AI is probably both the cause and solution to these problems. We're certainly getting more code churn than otherwise, and in lots of cases that's really good! But you're going to have to deal with inevitable instability too.
(This of course is on top of whatever unusual things might actually be happening)
I'm sure most of us here have been on the receiving end of managers suddenly obsessed with a failure mode because it happened to occur twice in one month.
I guess this is what the run up to Y2K was like but with less time and orders of magnitude more systems?
But I'd note, these "named after a thing" phenomena (eponnyms) are kind of terrible for exact description since their definition tends to be fuzzy, there's a temptation to fudge their borders and they create an insider jargon (if only I could a device that could reach of the computer and slap everyone who says "steelman" when they mean strengthen an argument, etc).
I think the real ones were the Microsoft and FAA due to deploying the AI slop.
The other ones seem to be usual outages that normally no one reports on.
The combination is a cycle
1. AI finds bugs
2. Engineers us AI to try and fix
3. AI testing approves, minimal engineering review
4. Engineers push release rapidly, it's critical after all
5. Bugs introduced
6. Cycle starts again
So certainly there is a big social-psychological phenomenon. Or it's gonna be a cold winter! :)
With all the recent asshattery of leaking kernel exploits, I would presume trust is gone, and it's cover the big boys first.
(a linux kernel bug vulnerability could be patched without lkml involvement or distros even knowing)
Yeah, you can do fine with only one set of eyes on a problem. Yeah, it is more "efficient" in the short term. Culling lots of do-nothing people in your organization isn't going to produce many tears. Even so, devs and IT departments are now missing all sorts of backup and vital personnel that keep the gears oiled and running.
Then the board voted a $50b pay package for Elon Musk and she's like... "wait, why the hell are we trying to save $10m when we could save 50 times as much and not even be at 1% of his pay package?" I have no answer to that.
Also to your point, the value of someone's work isn't always tangible or directly correlated to the work they do day to day. I sometimes have some extra slack/bandwidth at my job but it allows me to jump on any incidents or anything that requires urgency faster than anyone else.
The owner can only extract and be a parasite, or can guide and reinvest and grow the business.
Musk clearly does all of that. Still, for there to be value to be extracted, the workers had to create it.
Hmm, it is murkier: Musk can create 'virtual' value by hype and stock inflation and then extract that value by selling his stock (essentially extracting from investors/stock holders).
But try to replace the actually vital people? Oh boy. SpaceX for example, if something were to happen to Musk the engineers would probably be quite happy of being rid of the constant noise. But if something were to happen to Gwynne Shotwell who is the one running SpaceX in practice? Whoops. No bueno.
first we extract gdp then we extract jobs then we extract technology
we're getting a good hard look at what 'deregulation' looks like currently.
The original package was approved in 2018. Note the $50B was if Tesla hit certain valuations, which at the time nobody believed.
A shareholder lawsuit and left wing judge decided to invalidate it in 2024, after Tesla hit those valuations.
So shareholders voted again to give Elon the pay package, and the judge rejected it.
Then the Delaware Supreme Court overruled and Elon got his $50B.
I’d say the situation is more like getting equity at a startup that is worth nothing, then it turns into billions but you lose it and the board gives it back.
Rejecting the pay package therefore wouldn't mean "saving" X amount of funds.
A $10m dollar saving would directly impact the company balance sheet.
It's funny how the smartest technical people keep falling for this "Management 101" trick. The reality distortion field is strong here
The answer is the very next paragraph of your comment!
>Also to your point, the value of someone's work isn't always tangible or directly correlated to the work they do day to day.
Elon is negative value and yet gets paid a stupid amount. Your friend is saving the business millions and doesn't see a dime of that.
Welcome to late-stage capitalism.
The friend can easily quit and find a better job paying more, why don't they? Likewise, Elon could step down for whatever reason and we'd see what happens to the stock price, maybe it goes down 50b, maybe up, who knows.
I do know that Elon leaving will have a much larger impact (one way or another) than 1 process engineer.
How can you assume that to be true? It depends where they worked and if there are similar open jobs nearby. Are those skills specific to Tesla production line or transferable? If they need to move to find a new job, do they have kids that also need to be moved? There are so many factors involved.
Also who says 1 process engineer? We're talking about a $50B pay package to a guy who already has nearly infinite money - that's enough money for hundreds of employees.
It’s an open secret his companies have to manage him so that they can get the actual work done while he is distracted.
A capitalist society's inevitable capitulation to the lure of capital over all else. The moment that the final nail is hammered into the coffin of what used to be known as the idea of the 'free market'.
None of this objective or fair.
Yeah it’s not objective or fair, that’s what we’re pointing out. That makes it objectively bad, inefficient, and dare I say fucking stupid
For a start, the opportunity cost of that sum is non zero
And all of this was also contingent on him dramatically increasing the value of the company. If he failed to do that, he would have gotten $0. It'd be akin to in this scenario where somebody's friend was working on a $10 million saving if her entire team received a salary of $0, and contingent upon the completion of the project, they'd each have received a fraction of the savings generated by it. If they failed, or it somehow did not achieve the desired savings, they'd receive $0.
And furthermore payment would also be in stock meaning that their compensation would be subject to the success of the company, and also would be worth less in "reality" than it was on paper since selling would reduce the price of said stock - probably negligibly for a relatively small amount, but it's still a nuance that's important. If Musk tried to convert his trillion (or whatever) to cash, it'd end up being worth much less than its nominal value.
It's all CEO bad tax the rich BS. I wish I got paid more sure, but I'm not pretend that I'm more valuable to the company I work at than the CEO.
If they made me CEO and I implemented a pay increase package and decreased my own, I'm pretty sure the stock would tank by more than the amount of the pay increase for everyone else.
I genuinely want to understand this position: don't you feel a little gross denigrating yourself like this? To purposefully undervalue yourself compared to another person?
> another person
Do you see how these aren’t the same thing?
One person is a highly skilled doctor - the only one in this particular commune in fact; the other is a janitor. It's not hard to guess who's getting kicked out. And this reality of some being 'more equal' than others would influence every single interaction in society. Even if everybody there genuinely believed everybody is equal, the reality is that some people would be worth much more to that society. So the equality is nothing but a fantasy.
I also find this whole concept trite. My value, as a human, is to my family. I couldn't care less what any company thinks of me so long as I am providing enough to support my family. And while I attach greater value to society as a whole, even that is again secondary to family. I think this obsession on extrinsic measures of value is probably a result of the decline of fertility and thus the decline of family.
Heh, you happened to have stumbled upon exactly what I wrote about last month, the overextension of the term "value": https://blog.calebjay.com/posts/meaningless-value/
To save you the click, people often conflate moral worth, personal attachment, instrumental value, and allocation priority, when those are all very different things. I admit that above I was playing around with the idea a bit, though I do find it a little, idk, self diminishing to purposefully place oneself under their boss even in instrumental value. Maybe because I'm co-op-brained now and have seen for myself how effective a worker ownership structure works.
> Imagine you have this commune of people, completely equal, and two people get into a critical dispute such that both insist they'll only stay if the other guy is kicked out.
I've seen this exact situation, actually, and the solution wasn't to keep the "doctor," but for the community to assert that both need to find a resolution because neither was getting kicked out without commiting some kind of harm to the group as a whole. That is to say, instrumental value doesn't get someone greater allocation priority (or authority). I understand that under capitalism, it's supposed to, but we risk getting into an unproductive conversation about who actually has more instrumental value to a corporation if we explore that.
I mean even if that's true and you believe that, are you like 250000x less valuable than your CEO ?
Books, videogames, travel, photography, civic engagement, coffee shops, and just being a bum is pretty awesome. I think the Chinese have been calling it lying down?
I wish I was rich enough to continue this lifestyle. Inverse FIRE, where I scrimp and live miserly, riding on just-okay savings?
I do great work remotely and I just wear my pajamas all day, and work sometimes at 7am, sometimes at 7pm, sometimes at 10pm (honestly depends on my token usage). I'm comfortable and I'm effective, what else could you ask for?
There are many folks way more talented than me who would never work a government job because of silly reasons like that. And it's like... Why?
Dressing up every day makes you feel great. I recommend it to everyone.
I had a job where dress clothes were expected and I miss it dearly.
My point is that the concept of work has changed so much yet we're still bound by the 9-5 rules. Core hours during which teammates must all be available makes sense, but absent that, it's all just arbitrary and cultural.
https://www.washingtonsun.com/technology/bank-ceos-nsa-tell-...
> Bank CEOs, NSA Tell Congress That AI-Driven Patches Are Behind Outages
> Artificial intelligence is not causing the disruptions but identifying gaps that are difficult to fix.
The base threat level has increased dramatically. Now everyone is racing to use Glasswing/Daybreak/whatever to fix the bugs before someone external finds them.
So yeah, maybe not a direct result of bots attacking, but still an indirect one.
These kinds of outages will just point out which idiots have no business managing these systems in the first place and they'll hopefully all be fired so they can be replaced by people who know better.
Twitter was so insanely resilient that in many places it was more reliable then any "official"/"emergency" communication channels for info about natural catastrophes and similar
so people did rely on it for "critical" thing
and that was gone with Musks changes
which is one of the things people tended to overlook there was a huge decrease in reliability/resilance after the huge cuts, it's just that the final outcome was still "just fine" for what most people in the US/EU used it for
Is there data/site to compare uptime before and after?
There's nothing natural about a billionaire with hints of racial supremacy coming in to cut costs on a complex system of a state.
State institutions aren't businesses.
The thing is, do people actually care enough to make the required changes to improve, or is this it ?
I see nothing passive aggressive in tru3_power's message, if that's what you're referring to. What's the alternative?
We shouldn't be surprised at where that's led.
That said, who knows how bad things have gotten in 2025+. The Trump political appointees seem to be largely incompetent and sycophants never improve the resiliency of systems.
This is doubly true at this time of year, when we're likely to see people pushing to get work delivered by the end of December so that they can include it in yearly reviews. I'll happily merge PRs I don't understand if that's what keeps my job.
Then it is a failure of software dev individualism. There is a long-proven, battle-tested solution to management making unreasonable demands from labor: Unionization.
That is because Twitter was and still is an incredibly well built system. It took a while and a lot of fail whales [1] until it got to that point, though.
But ever since that, there hasn't been that much innovation on the platform. Sure, we got native link shorteners, native photo hosting, native video hosting, private messages and circles. And now the CSAM generator also known as Grok. But... neither of these touches the "core" of Twitter, which is a system to fan out short pieces of text extremely fast across up to 250-ish million followers (Musk) while respecting stuff like account blocks, it's all bolted on top of that highly reliable infrastructure.
The danger is now that, say, you're Microsoft... you think you can cut costs by cutting off the greybeards. It worked at Twitter after all. But unfortunately, by all accounts I've come across, Azure is a brittle-as-fuck shitshow often requiring manual action by Microsoft employees, with cost-cutting already going as far as to offshore support for US Government Cloud customers to China up to 2025 [2].
Just because it worked on Twitter once, it doesn't mean it can even work at one other large company. But unfortunately, CEOs are vulnerable to herd mentality, sheeple following one leader mindlessly.
[1] https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/fail-whale
[2] https://www.cnbc.com/2025/07/18/microsoft-china-digital-esco...
No. You might be able to conjure some scenario up, but the answer is no. And that is the basis for classifying things.
And further, there's a public interest in knowing if one of the premier intelligence agencies is so dysfunctional that they cannot even keep their computers connected.
But to your point if somebody like North Korea did it, they wouldn't brag about it but they'd be talking quietly to their friends and maybe even taking orders for the next target.
If the network was one of those no-fail important ones (think NORAD stuff) then nobody would be talking about it as doing so would be treasonous. So, at most, this is a less-important internal network. It will probably be back up by end of business.
> The frequency illusion, also known as the Baader–Meinhof phenomenon, is a cognitive bias in which a person notices a specific concept, word, or product more frequently after recently becoming aware of it.
Or at least it is very similar.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gatwick_Airport_drone_incident
>> Flap, originally a military term to describe a "period of panic or chaos", is used by ufologists to describe surges of sightings in one geographical area. Longer surges spanning multiple countries may be called waves. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UFO_flap
Anything the catches the public's collective conscious, the media is there to stoke it into piles of ad dollars.
It's extremely profitable to write stories telling social media pitchfork mobs how correct they are. Influencers have been catching onto this game in the last decade too, and went from "here is what is actually going on" contrarians to "here is what is actually going on" agenda towing. It just pays so much more, and people trust you more (because people naturally trust those who tell them they are right).
Including NSA Net? How often does it fall down?
> We are probably only hearing about this because of the coincidence of the other recent network failures
This seems to be an explanation for why the press is covering it - this time. Which also hints that NSA Net failures happen with some kind of regularity and that that news orgs had been getting wind of it.
I suspect that the opposite is true. That it's rare to unheard of for NSA Net to fail like this and rare for a news org to get wind of something so deeply protected.
I rather doubt they have a public status page.
> This seems to be an explanation for why the press is covering it - this time.
That's one possibility. Another is it goes down sometimes, but that morale in the administration has sunk to where it gets leaked.
Like the United Airlines thing yesterday, the moment I got to the article it said "was down for a few hours" but the post was still just something about United Airlines network being offline
Or is it close to a large corporation network built on MSFT stack?
It'll be really boring MSFT. Older tech, because it's a massive PITA to upgrade and really all you need is Outlook and some document management. The outside world never sees the work you produce there so why make it nice.
The people who use it likely hate it. In short: nothing glamorous.
I understand the skepticism, and I certainly don’t think we should go down a rabbit hole of conspiracy theories. But shouldn’t we also be a little skeptical of dismissing these events so quickly? Is it unreasonable to at least consider the possibility that they’re not entirely coincidental, or to wonder why so many seem to be taking place in the US?
Companies have been wide open in all sorts of ways for decades, and basically just surviving by flying under the radar of script kiddies.
That changed. Now script kiddies or average criminal orgs feel more able to just pick their targets, and it's an extremely target rich environment.
That a lot of businesses are finally taking drastic action sort of tells you how much they were willingly ignoring the issue previously. Everything everywhere was very insecure. It was just surviving from a lack of attackers.
Top level management, like investor level, still thinks this is just something to be fixed by applying a new magic word too, like "buy another security scanner" or "just use AI to fix the problem"
However, AI works like a speedy intern who hasn't yet got to grips with the whole codebase, and sometimes makes assumptions. That's mostly because the codebase is usually bigger than the context window, so it is 'writing blind'.
"If you don't read the news you're uninformed, if you do read the news you're misinformed"
The sentiment is quite old, however. Thomas Jefferson wrote in 1807: ...the man who never looks into a newspaper is better informed than he who reads them; inasmuch as he who knows nothing is nearer to truth than he whose mind is filled with falsehoods & errors.
Where it gets interesting is the "Exclusive" part of the headline. Like somebody else said, any other source would either have to have access to people similar to CNN's "six people familiar with the matter" or else reference CNN.
The fact that Reuters amplified the story (and attributed it to CNN) gives it a little more weight.
Not unlike Bloomberg terminals…dos era UI but does the job well
Trump is headed to China for a meeting with Xi and Putin.
We have 3 carriers off the coast of Iran and (despite Trump's pleas) NATO is essentially pushing their boot into Putin's neck w/ continued Ukrainian strikes on Russian oil infra.
I've seen a few takes from L3 Harris / FAA employees calling the official line about the ATC issue bunk and there are 3 other major issues in the last week, now this NSA outage - curious if these incidents could be the BRICS axis flexing their own cybermuscles (independently in multiple separate attacks with carefully placed assets) ahead of their meeting with Trump in China?
An interesting geopolitical Mexican standoff, if true.
I'm not claiming this is true. I'm literally pulling it out of my rear with little context beyond a bunch of random news stories and X posts, it's pure pedestrian speculation / curiosity.
Would love someone steeped in national security / geopolitics (like: professionally as their job, not armchair analysts) to offer their take on this.
Is this a dumb, naive theory?
I know it's not the thrust of your post, but I see this or similar framing a lot, and I feel compelled to point out that Putin can end the strikes on his oil infrastructure at any time by ending the war he started by invading another country.
Historically he's chosen to go about things differently, which I guess is part of what is tickling the pattern matching part of my brain here.
If that were the case buddy, there would be Apaches stationed in Moscow now.
Wonder what happened in 2014 that might have led to this?
What is your point? Obama admitted to interfering in Ukraine 2014.
I'm not sure about naive or dumb but you might review your POV regarding this.
My complete POV, FWIW:
* From a purely moral / ethical standpoint: it is good that this is happening, Russia "deserves" this and brought it upon themselves.
* This nonetheless has geopolitical implications. The less oil Russia has to sell to China, the more buy pressure there is elsewhere, the higher the price of oil is generally and thus the higher competition for resources / tensions are between great powers.
* Ukraine is doing a lot of the heavy lifting in many areas themselves these days, NATO could honestly be doing more. However: what Ukraine is able to do themselves does owe something to the financial and material support they have enjoyed (historically from both the US and NATO, currently more from NATO only) in that they are able to allocate their own efforts with according relative "ease"
* It makes sense to me that, given the US' power within NATO, Russia and its BRICS partners would try to apply pressure to the US to encourage NATO to provide even LESS support to Ukraine (or outright become antagonistic against Ukraine, to the extent we aren't already) in whatever way they could.
What revisions to my POV can you suggest?
* Russia could end these strikes and this war tomorrow if they wanted to.
I don't know how it could be proven either, I'm just curious if it is plausible or even likely from the perspective of someone who knows more than me about NatSec / geopolitical issues.
I'm getting Feb 2020 vibes. I don't know what's going on, but this feels like more than just some routine outages going on.
So far this fall, none of my systems have gone haywire (yet!), so I forecast that we'll be OK.
Allowing our infrastructure to be manufactured elsewhere, maintained by companies who struggle to retain top talent, and overseen by folks out of touch with cutting edge threats, and funded on annual budget cycles by legislators even more out-of-touch ... is a seemingly insurmountable set of obstacles.
NSANet is one of the most locked down, observed and monitored networks on the planet
o MS cloud and enterprise outage
o Downed flights
o Numerous major U.S. bank and Zelle disruptions
o Charles Schwab website loading issues
o United Airlines systemwide glitch
o Apple services and iCloud glitches
o Emergency 911 service glitches
o NSA com issues
....did I miss anything?
* FAA
* Banks
* Optimizely malware
* nsanet
* Apple
Time to panic?
So timely, too.
It sure is fun living in a world of zero trust.
Did you try sending it via outlook.com?
Someone who wants to launch a Y2K-style hardening business (LLMS to look for problems, humans+LLMs to fix them) could really make bank right now. Maybe there will be a cuple in the next YC batch.
Just like good crypto must survive robust cryptanalysis, good network security needs to be robust even when adversaries know the network exists (and perhaps even where in physical space key nodes are located).
That being said: the network being down isn't something that immediately makes me worried in the near term. "Turn it off" is a better first response than "observe if anything seems weird" for communications channels that prioritize secrecy over availability.
And the cost to fix this is gonna be $12-billion. No wait, $30-billion. Fuuck it, make it $50-billion. And give it to me now or else!!!
Ultimately, yeah (with the help of GWB) https://www.nsa.gov/Press-Room/Press-Releases-Statements/Pre...
A couple of incidents, spin the media, let them be terrified
Put your cape on, come to save the world
Then tax it, regulate it, sprinkle some tariffs, nuclear winter, external enemies, china, don't forget about china
Then we police the world and our AI is the only one with the seal of "liberty"
From the black book of politiks, watch the sheeple, rejoice
Definitely just a big coincidence due to firing people, upgrades, and AI.
...maybe.
Seriously though at what point does this become justifiably suspicious?
The truth lies somewhere in the middle. My theory: someone figured out how to bring down each network. And is progressively breaking each system to help developers fix their security holes. Given enough breaks, we will figure out their modus operandi. And then figure out who they are.
Or something even more conspiratorial: us govt is halting each system to install back doors.
(I'm not saying the dems would do better, i'm saying we all need to stop voting for old men in primaries because they are more "electable")
Also consider that the media absolutely loves to run any story it can find about a network going down right now because it causes fear, and fear gets clicks. Now think about how many major networks have a problem in a given week. You just never hear about them until now.
No I don't. Why would you risk your career and potentially your freedom to leak a report about enemy action, in which doing so could potentially harm your country too?
[0] https://harvardlawreview.org/print/vol-127/the-leaky-leviath...
https://www.cnn.com/2026/11/16/politics/us-intelligence-iran...
No and that was the purpose of DOGE
(yes that quote was separated from its context with some malice)
I doubt this is the case, but since we're talking about conspiracy theories: this looks more like things breaking by accident as things are shimmed for control by a third party and less like a focused attack.
It's exactly like the media reporting every aviation notice after an airplane crash. Leading people to speculate "why is everything broken right now!" even though it's the normal course of business, they're only just noticing it now because they're being told to notice it.
We get stories about what went wrong filtered through journalism that doesn't have the technical knowledge to convey it accurately. So even if they get the real story straight from the source, we get an inconsistent version of the story that sounds somehow off.
Which leaves all kinds of room for conspiracy, preconceptions, or prejudices.
Circle of internet life.
[0] https://www.craigslist.org/view/d/dallas-dallas-redditors-ge...
Reddit is done. I'm so glad I got perma-banned by their AI mod. Though the meat-space mods lifted the ban on appeal, I had a long enough interval that I unwound all engagement. I found reddit right after they launched and have spent a lot of time over the last 20 years on various subs. That's all over now.
https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/11/laun...
Nice try, foreign hacker
If more people misspell than not, then what do the predictive statistics result in?
It peaked at early mature swype, and has been downhill since then.
> according to six people
Meanwhile, 24 hours later, we know the headline being questioned here was indeed accurate. Your heuristic will presumably now adjust somewhat, as to misinform people less in future.
https://www.nsa.gov/portals/75/documents/news-features/decla...