One key difference between each company's implementation had to do with the shifting solenoids and the electronics. But as far as I know the actual clutch pads and gearing were the same.
[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GM%E2%80%93Ford_6-speed_automa...
All the manufacturers have been doing it since even before that, with major items like engines and transmissions.
What they haven't been doing is standardising all those other parts that need replacing. For example, standardising on the wheel hub+knuckle for 15-inch, 16-inch, 17-inch and 18-inch wheels will let wheels of the specific size use the same disks, calipers, pads, balljoint, wheel bearing, CV joint and all the sensors (wheel speed, brake, etc).
I see no reason why two different SUVs on 17-inch wheels need completely different brake pads shapes, when both sets have the same surface area, require the same performance profile, etc, but that's what we have now.
You can do the same with almost every mechanical and electrical subsystem in a car, and still have a large variety in cars produced. After all, car manufacturers don't manufacture their own tyres and batteries, do they? They don't manufacture they own wheels.
Even the things that are specific to them, they outsource anyway - they don't each have their own windscreen manufacturer, they outsource that. The already outsource all the glass, all the oils and fluids, all the pipes, etc, it's jus that they produce incompatible designs so that the actual parts manufacturer has to charge a jig setup fee for each of them. Standardising on parts brings in economies of scale.
They’re a Right to Repair aligned business model.
Because an SUV that has 17" wheels can weigh two tons or three tons or more. It can do 120 mph maximum speed or it can go to 160 mph or more.
The math changes really fast when it comes to stopping that SUV down based on those two parameters alone. You can see why different calipers, how many, brake disk size, type (ventilated or not), different sized brake pads.
> Because an SUV that has 17" wheels can weigh two tons or three tons or more. It can do 120 mph maximum speed or it can go to 160 mph or more.
Didn't I address this objection in advance with the words "performance profile"?
Right now, 95% of SUVs have the same brake performance requirements: under 4 ton, under 160mph, etc. There is no cost saving in making an entirely different wheel assembly for SUVs that require under 3.99 tons and under 159mph, which is what the current manufacturers are doing.
I did not understood your statement like that.
I don’t know about cost savings, but most likely it is about design decisions regarding how a wheel should look like (brake calipers in front of the wheel, in the back).
It's irrelevant in 95% of cars. All of the things I specified are irrelevant in 95% of cars.
A big honking cast iron caliper grabbing 12" rotor that mounts from the back of the hub (to reduce the hat diameter letting you have swept area right up to the wheel bolt circle) can really take some heat and the whole thing will package in a 16" rim. But it ain't gonna be light. I get that we're gonna have different "classes" of performance and you won't put that brake assembly on a new land rover even if it has comparable demands to the old van but there is a whole lot of room to consolidate here.
That will eliminate like, technically different washers and nuts used for screws to mount the truck calipers that goes this way versus van calipers that comes through this here using slightly longer screws, and that kinds of things add up.
A lot of comment heree seem to be fixated on metal parts, but I think it's more about plastics and wires and electronics. If you could use a common harneess for compacts and sedans and trucks going forward and backward and across... saves a lot of inventory cost.
Depending on the car, some estimates say that only the windows and tires are the only pieces that come from outside suppliers.
[1] https://www.electrichybridvehicletechnology.com/features/fea...
So JAMA (Japanese automakers’ industrial association) asked what they could do. Their answer was to standardize basic components so that they could reduce bottlenecks.
e.g. if you know you use 20/day and it takes 2 days to get the new parts then you order parts when your inventory hits 40.
If the error bars on the delivery dates suddenly grow, you have to start ordering parts earlier.
So in a sense, yes, needing to hold inventory is against part of JIT but if your goal is to maximize resilience to inventory shortages or supply shocks then no, it's not against their core principles.
The entire point of JIT is to identify those widening error bars early and treat. In this case, by moving more work onshore.
The error bars inherently have a big of a lag due to it taking some time for the average time to catch up to the real world conditions.
Much like trading, you could use exponential and/or weighted moving averages to give you signal as things change.
Stockpiling parts was one method routinely used to mask instances of waste, so they had deliberately worked to reduce inventory held in stock to force waste to become visible, so they could then address the causes of the waste.
But as long as the inventory doesn’t go stale on the shelf, it is a relatively minor waste compared to the other types, and certainly much better than the major waste of having no finished goods to sell into the market.
It requires some deep introspection, and is often error prone.
This is a great example of initiative and resilience, but a pretty textbook example of a fragile system. A single major but predictable event overwhelmed all primary and backup systems leading to a global scale nuclear catastrophe.
Note that the scope of standardization is fairly limited at least for now. JAMA’s initial targets are steel, resins and wires.
Toyota did that for years with their window switch assembly. You saw the same design on a Corolla and a Lexus, but the Lexus would have a nicer finish.
I suspect the second scenario is the more likely, as the car makers have had long personal relationships with their suppliers and will prefer to work with them.
US manufacturing in the 1940s was very in tune with the multiple supplier method. Jeeps and Liberty ships still come up as examples for their broad production and interchangeable parts.
This happened because the economy was on war footing and the government commanded it. Same reason Packard was making Rolls-Royce Merlin engines.
That's a non sequitur. At least unless the whole world switches to the same standard or they all only had one customer to begin with. If those suppliers have to change, adapt or extend their production to accommodate a standard while still shipping their original product to other customers, the end result will be more expensive. And it would have done nothing to relieve the geopolitical issues brought up by the parent comment.
If you build things for A and B but they have both their own requirements and do their own tests, you might use similiar / same machines for steel etc. just switching recipes. Or your windshiledwhiper motor is the same but the casing for it is slightly different or the rating.
Can I introduce you to peaks, troughs and shoulders?
You're likely to respond that the market stays the same, because its now split up by the wiper manufacturers that were creating specialised systems - fair.
Except nobody is ordering in an even cadence across the year, most orders will be higher at some points, and lower at others. And, the success of a given wiper manufacturer would be coupled hard to the success of the car (model[s]) they build for.
Now, the wiper manufacturers will be able to plan their output, coupled not to a given model(s) success, instead to the Japanese car industries success overall (less variable, still not deterministic though, to be fair)
That brings us to the peaks and troughs section - they dont have to have capacity for the peaks, which goes to waste (idle plant/staff) during the troughs, instead the other customers will fill the shoulders (more even output)
That's significant cost savings for the homogenised (wiper) manufacturers, with the one off cost of refitting their lines (which will be cheaper to do than normal because... multiple of them will be doing it...
Why would it jump? Overall demand doesn't increase under the given assumptions. They'd be selling the same thing in a different form. Producing more forms costs more money.
And also:
> You're likely to respond that the market stays the same, because its now split up by the wiper manufacturers that were creating specialised systems - fair.
> Except nobody is ordering in an even cadence across the year, most orders will be higher at some points, and lower at others. And, the success of a given wiper manufacturer would be coupled hard to the success of the car (model[s]) they build for.
Please try to have an honest read before misrepresenting posts.
(so, an EV without powertrain may have up to 30% less parts, or as many as 70% as an ICE. not like 10x less, at all. And this is before adding back in 7000 battery cells each made of few parts and the motor itself so... the parts count is actually the same? Interesting)
And you can also just standardize on the battery pack itself.
Chances are, the esoteric crap comes from one plant and has one major customer, so every bit is gonna be the same.
With USB-C cables, Who the fkkk knows what you'll get? The only bit guaranteed identical between two USB-C cables is the connector shape. Everything else is lottery.
At this point I think EU should introduce a mandatory labeling scheme for USB-C cables, so that each cable is stamped both on packaging and on the cable itself, with the very same stuff USB-C cable tester shows it. And since the "better" cables have chips on board, we could enroll them in the same "Battery Passport" / "Digital Product Passport" thing, with steep fines to all the importers or resellers who waste people's time selling fake cables.
Just mandate a resistor-style colored band for the modes / versions.
The failure was not realizing that physical indication of electrical spec would be necessary in a do-everything cable/connector spec.
Conversely - in the esoteric world, if the manufacturer is disinclined to produce "quality" - what exactly are you going to do about it?
The first generation Prius was technically amazing but not much to look at (a coworker had one - "bland" is how I would describe it). It sold in low numbers, allowing Toyota to build expertise with the technology before the second gen became a smash hit.
They're following the same plan for their BEVs. The Toyota bZ was nothing special in terms of electric vehicles, but they just finished building a battery factory in the US to scale production up for their next generation.
https://pressroom.toyota.com/toyota-supercharges-north-carol...
The question is whether they're acting fast enough. BYD and other Chinese makers are screaming fast when it comes to introducing new models. While the Chinese haven't entered the US market directly - they're already here in terms of Waymo's Ojai vans, which are made by Zeekr, a subsidiary of Geely.
The new generation tundras with an “innovative” ICE and hybrid motor, both based on the same 6 cylinder design, are having widespread and catastrophic engine failure.
In Japan I have no idea what will happen. Yes they've shown they can innovate. And Toyota can last a long time on their reputation for quality. But I have no idea how much they need to sell a ton of cars to survive. The transition will take a long time[1] (saving grace for them). I'm sure the global sales volume of ICE cars will start declining very soon, if not already.
[1] Or not. If battery costs drop suddenly, it's game over.
With the US/Israel/Iran war, this year's sales seem likely to be less again.
https://ourworldindata.org/data-insights/global-sales-of-com...
The problem there is you're comparing a Corolla to a Tesla and not e.g. a Chevy Bolt, which has a lower TCO than both.
> At the high end, electric trucks are insanely expensive and less practical than gas trucks.
There is a reason companies like Amazon use electric delivery trucks and it's not because they're impractical.
The main issue with trucks is that to give an electric truck a reasonable range when hauling a load, it needs a much bigger battery, and then to justify that you have to be actually using it as a truck full-time rather than as a truck-shaped car. Which is fully justified when you are, because then the fuel savings are enormous.
Whereas the people not really using it as a truck don't really need the bigger battery and then it doesn't have to cost that much. And even that isn't going to matter if the battery prices keep going down.
The other option which the US companies seem to be leaning into is to use the smaller battery and offer a range extender that runs on gas, which is a hybrid in a sense but it's more like an EV with a slot to put a gas generator.
The industry is kinda moving in that direction anyway, even for personal vehicles.
We’re seeing a number of new “hybrids” (that are really tiny EREVs, EV vehicles with no charging port and cheap tiny batteries, tied to a gas generator). Reduces complexity drastically while keeping most of the fuel efficiency
(See the new 2027 Nissan Rogue Hybrid, or the 2027 Hyundai Santa Fe Hybrid. Both going EREV, and assembled in plants in the USA)
If the industry continues down that route, every car will be an EV and your just picking how large a battery you want vs how large of a gas generator you attach to it.
The average new car buyer is not very good at math or they wouldn’t be there in the first place.
Remember when everyone was going wild over the fact that Elon was promising a sub-$25K EV? That was in 2018. Today, a Model 3 goes for $22K (in 2018 dollars). People aren't paying attention.
(Edit: Sorry I typo'd the amount in the CPI inflation calculator. Should be $27K, not $22K. Still, in the $25K ballpark).
I am not sure that median U.S. driver really thinks that. After all, both are about the same size and serve a similar purpose. The Tesla is a lot faster, but for city driving and commuting the difference hardly matters.
Things like "tech" and "ongoing updates" are a negative for some people. Inevitably, this means more things that can fail and more opportunities for manufacturers and third parties to mistreat the driver. I, for one, require my car to be offline, with its cellular modem physically powered off.
For city deliveries an EV is a no-brainer. Short distances with lost of start-stops, lots of idling, perfect for an electric motor. An electric F150 will have very different usage pattern and TCO.
Right. It's subsidies/incentives. And, of course, operating within the legal/governance structure, you can 'fine' the vehicles you don't like - have special clean air zones with fees for entry, high tax for oil/petrol, etc.
I hope you didn't mean this was something to do with costs. It's just the government using licensing, laws, taxes, etc to direct proceedings as they want - nothing to do with the underlying costs.
The main issue is that the US effectively bans imports of electric cars from the most efficient suppliers on the planet.
His interference in elections and the war in Ukraine hasn’t gone unnoticed in many markets. Tesla comes with weaker residual value because of the brand damage.
Now that other manufacturers are moving away from soft-screens towards tactile controls software UX is much less important too.
Personally, I’d much rather have “knob per function” than have to go menu diving through a GUI at 80mph.
There’s many great alternatives now that really are great value. i.e. Renault, Nissan, Skoda, VW, BMW, Dacha.
Self-driving cars, the kind that doesn’t put a human on the hook would be amazing. I can read a book, work on my laptop or even take a nap in the backseat. I want a driver without having to pay a human for it.
For instance, Renault use cells manufactured in France, Poland and Hungary with AESC in Douai, France as the main supplier.
Nissan have major EV manufacturing for the new Leaf at Sunderland, UK and AESC has a gigafactory for that near by too.
If you ignore the ongoing nazi car brand aspect, which is pretty hard to I agree, I am not convinced the traditional car brands you mentioned are better value. And they have a nazi past too. But that’s a while ago so it’s okay.
Both have reasonably priced, well engineered EVs in their range now.
Both use Android Auto and IMHO that works very smoothly and without jank. Plus they have physical controls.
Personally it’s a company ’s present and future behaviour that I care most about rather than stuff that happened in the 1930s and 40s no matter how horrific.
You do you, the Nissan Ariya or the Renault Scenic aren't that bad indeed.
I've got no love for the cringe machine that is Elon, but c'mon. Would people really buy from a Chinese maker over Tesla based on some kind of political stance?
The Chinese haven't been spending a lot of money to support right wing authoritarian governments in my country.
Buying Tesla does. So you don't have to be "clean as a whistle" to be a massive improvement.
Worse than Musk? Probably not. Better than Musk? Also probably no.
If they can't get something else, they settle for a Tesla.
Tesla had a 0.8% share of EV sales in October 2026 in Denmark.
Is this figure really for EVs only? I don't find this article[0] absolutely clear, but in context it seems to be referring to Tesla's share of all passenger car sales:
> Norway remained a bright spot for Tesla. The carmaker recorded its best October on record and was the country's top-selling car brand with a 9.8% market share, according to OFV. Chinese brands continued to expand their footprint, accounting for 22.5% of new passenger car registrations, their highest monthly share on record.
> [irrelevant quote]
> By contrast, Tesla's market share in Denmark was only 0.73%, behind BYD (002594.SZ), Leapmotor (9863.HK), Xpeng (9868.HK), and SAIC-owned MG (600104.SS), which captured between 1.6% and 5.5% of the market each.
[0] https://www.reuters.com/business/tesla-registrations-surge-a...
Not listed are all the European, Japanese and Korean cars. I see lots of new VW, Kia and BMW EVs in Copenhagen, far more than Tesla or Chinese, but I haven't searched for statistics.
In September 2026 (the end of Q3), Tesla registered 2,299 cars in Denmark.
This is just because of Tesla’s ”delivery waves”. Also October 2025 Tesla’s sales in Denmark were low.
Cherry picking the weak months is very deceptive.
"Yet Tesla’s Danish registrations are up 47% to 10,126 for January through October, a 5.9% share, according to Mobility Denmark, showing why one month is not a good description of the yearly registrations."
https://evxl.co/2026/11/03/tesla-nordic-sales-jump-denmark-s...
I wouldn't have a Cybertruck because they look absolutely ridiculous but a regular Tesla looks like a pretty normal car.
There are probably a fair number of Danes who more or less agree with Elon's politics too.
better quality car is higher priced.
I mean, for most people, you put Spotify/Audible on, switch to the map, go. There's a hard limit on how much things can change.
Unfortunately, that footage does not stay on your computer/car.
https://www.drive.com.au/news/tesla-shared-private-camera-re...
I've sat in my friend's 600 HP Zeekr few months ago and saw all you mention in some form or another plus much, much more than in my colleague's tesla 3.
Ideally that should work to your preference, for example a restaurant vs fast food nearby.
The capital cost of an EV charging station is absurdly low (compared to say building a gas station) and returns are high value with zero effort.
In other words they're a high return profit center, which means that pretty much every place which is aimed at "passing long distance traffic" will get one at some point. We're already seeing this play out a bit, but in 10 years they'll literally be everywhere.
I don't see what having a huge dash screen gains you unless you have eyesight problems.
Aren't Americans constantly harping on about liberty and convenience?
Plus tesla is poisoned by nazi owner who is extremely hostile towards Europe for whatever reasons and feels like he needs to interfere in global politics, that brand is burned for good regardless of products. Something about having actual morals and spine and voting with wallet and not supporting evil actors if you don't have to.
It's a luxury *price*. It is not luxury *quality*.
They're pretty crappy cars for the price, lots of flimsy plastic and bling.
It absolutely is NOT a luxury car. There are a lot of people, especially early adopters, who have tried to act like it is in order to increase its cachet. I think that this point that game is up because they're no longer rare or limited, a Tesla is the most normal thing an Uber driver will pick you up in the airport in. Nearly everyone has been inside one, and it only takes one experience to realize its a plastic econoshitbox. There's nothing wrong with that, some of my most beloved vehicles have been my shitboxes I've taken on adventures. But let's just be real here, Tesla owners are no longer fooling anyone.
They cost a lot more in manufacturing but save money on the road. They can recuperate energy what an ICE can't do and for companies the investment into solar is just basic math.
They are also more practical than gas trucks in plenty of scenarios: they are more quiter and they can break quiter. They are more agile and its easier to have more power as a bigger engine is nearly free. As usual with EV and recupreation, you need bigger engine anyway to do this efficient.
At least in germany btw. you can only drive for 4 hours and have to take a break and there is a huge difference between short and long haul. Not everyone needs to switch yesterday.
I'm guessing maybe your problem was that you live in an apartment which doesn't provide a parking space with electricity, so fast charge was only option? Definintely an issue, especially in some countries where the usual home isn't a standalone single story like Australia where I live.
The price difference between home charging vs a fast charger can be extreme, 6-7p/unit vs 80-90p/unit.
Usually I charge when I go grocery shopping. I can't remember the last time I drove to a charging station just to charge.
In the long run I think electricity wins out. The grid is available nearly most places people will have their cars in the first place (along roads), barring the wilderness. The production and distribution chain for gas vs electricity is a funny one to think about. And the fact that it's non-renwable. Solar and wind are very clean and limitless sources of energy.
Typical Dutch driving pattern is strongly bimodal - a lot of everyday short trips (think commuting), plus several holiday trips per year - Austria, south of France, Italy, you name it. That would be the trips where "too many hours at fast chargers" would be a problem for me personally.
Over here in the USA, there is one such train that goes from Washington DC to Florida - 1400km, the same driving distance as Amsterdam to Nice. Your car gets loaded onto special train cars and then you get into a normal passenger coach; they are coupled together and go. Passengers get all the amenities of a comfortable long-distance train.
This is what we need more of :)
It's a true statement, they don't. Yet everyone, not just people with jobs and hobbies that cause fires, still needs smoke alarms and fire extinguishers and building codes that demand multiple exits from bedrooms etc.
This "outlier" argument that a lot of people think makes sense, doesn't. It's completely invalid. Most people could actually get by with a golf cart most of the time. Except no they can't, because most of the time isn't good enough.
In my house there are no smoke alarms, or fire extinguishers, and all the bedrooms have a single exit. And I'd say we're pretty typical in this area.
Which is not to say those things wouldn't be a good idea, it's just that the attitude towards house fires may be more local than you assume.
BMW just launched an i3 with a 567 mile range. Is that enough?
Personally I think I’d be pretty happy with 300 to 400 miles.
Range will increase over time.
There’s still lots of efficiency improvements to be made like replacing the motor, differential and breaking systems with in-wheel combined brake/motor units.
We will get to a point where EV range is greater than on ICE cars.
There are a lot of drawbacks to this strategy btw. Unsprung weight gets a lot worse, and expensive high voltage parts become much more exposed to elements and shock loads. The benefits seem unlikely to outweigh the drawbacks for most applications.
Not necessarily. Where it gets interesting are the prototypes with lower unsprung weight than the equivalent braking system.
They’re not there yet but it shows there’s definitely new avenues to explore.
The average in the US is 27 mins: https://www.census.gov/topics/employment/commuting/guidance/...
Longer commutes aren't uncommon, I wouldnt call them typical.
I wanted a median/quartile breakdown, but that seems harder to find.
> In the 2022 National Household Travel Survey, home-based work trips by car, van, SUV or pickup average 14.4 miles one way, with a median of 8.9 miles.
https://truedrivingcost.com/articles/average-commute-distanc...
Only 10% travel one hour one way or more.
Ehh that's complicated. They're much _much_ longer once you get out into the sticks. In the suburbs I imagine it varies. But in urban areas AFAIK they're fairly similar and as it happens those are the areas where you benefit from EVs the most while also being where people with highly paid jobs tend to be located.
Dunno about Europe, but EV chargers are not that common yet. You could drive a few hours and end up street parking or lot parking and there's no charger.
This gets tricky if you drive a long while and your destination doesn't have a charger, and then you have to return, and you haven't been able to have your car charging while you were at your destination. If that isn't reliably done, ICE cars make more sense unless you're rich enough to just have as many cars as you need, which a bunch of people aren't.
The big difference is that public charging is more than 3x home charging in the US and (on average), less than 2x home charging in the EU. As the number of chargers goes up in the US eventually that will change. Why the US lags in charging infrastructure is a different question, but is probably because so many early adopters were able to charge at home.
It doesn’t mean this, but you do want to at least have your own driveway.
If you work near-ish to a city (so that your typical daily roundtrip is ~30mi or less) you can even get away with exclusively Level 1 charging. I did that for the first 40k miles on one of my EVs before we finally bought our own home where we could install a Level 2 charger. But the new home doesn’t have a garage either, just a driveway.
Just bought a PHEV (Peugeot), and if you can charge at home it runs rounds around ICE cost-wise, eves with it being relatively power-hungry compared to some alternatives (but so comfortable and sleek). With public charging it is marginally cheaper than ICE, pricing of public charge points swallowed the price advantage, but I guess it is not free to build that infrastructure, so its okay I guess.
Atlas Policy has the 2024 models within a few grand of each other at 7 years. It's not significant and the Tesla is a much nicer car. Hybrids are expensive to maintain.
Only 16-20% of cars on the road in the "u"s are trucks, so not really relevant anyway.
https://finance.yahoo.com/sectors/technology/articles/didn-t...
But the rules may differ for those of us who are not major automotive CEO's.
The trick China and Tesla is using is to recur parts by integrating multiple parts. This impacts repairability massively.
Consumers REALLY hate this.
I realize that in some places the momentum behind EVs is not obvious since so few are sold. But the change is inevitable. Even if you think China is a weird case, the fact that Western Europe is now all-in in EVs should make it obvious that there is no turning back. It's not ideology but capitalism that's pushing this. Costs have come down and will continue to do so. All the European makers have many EV models now and the only thing holding them back a bit is the massive workforce that needs to reskill.
A digital camera is more convenient and cheaper to operate. An EV is less convenient for me and more expensive. If you live in Europe maybe it’s more convenient, but also appealing to those consumers views.
I actually can’t believe your still saying this when it’s clear the EV narrative is down after all the US companies tried it and Tesla interest is waning.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_automotive_manufacture...
This includes China afaik. Japan is winning so much its not even funny. Besides, every car review of a Chinese car I've watched goes like this: great interior quality, low price, tons of extras (some of them weird), but the car is generally weak on 'core' specifics - ride quality, real-world efficiency/charge speed for EVs, interior space efficiency, ergonomics.
I think that exposes a couple things - I can get a door handle at a hardware store for like 8€ - it'll be made from metal, finished quite well etc etc. So putting in the widgets into cars that make an interior feel great doesn't cost that much, and people care about it a lot. Existing manufacturers have engaged in market segmentation based on this, but the Chinese saw this as an easy win and took it. That's one of the reasons why Chinese cars seem a lot better than what they cost.
This is the most out of touch take I’ve seen.
People simply don’t give a shit about that. China is taking over literally every car market they’re allowed to compete in. People want a good car that is not expensive. China has those in spades.
https://www.fenabrave.org.br/Portal/conteudo/emplacamentos
Here what you can see for Oct 26, is out of the named brands 15% goes to BYD+GWM, which is less than 17.5% that VW does alone.
Chinese brands are not dominant in Europe, they're obviously absent in US (which are the most profitable markets).
For Asian markets I picked Thailand, Japanese cars account for like half the sales.
Toyota has lost 40% of sales in leader like Corolla.
And I'd think the Brazilian everyman. like most people, cares for reliability, and resale value . Even if the Chinese cars prove reliable (considering most manufacturers have existed for less time than the median age of a car, I'd think we have some surprises ahead), we still have the question of resale value. If tariffs are gone, you'd be looking at an instant 35% drop in the value of the car, which is bound to piss off a lot of people who have already bought.
A lot of jobs. Brazil has a big native car industry. One of the biggest car exporters in the world. They’re foreign companies but native industries. By letting in imports it gets hollowed out.
BYD is building factories here though which means they’re native and in a few years they’ll take even more of the market. Chinese companies are already 25% of the new car market and it’s growing.
I understand the reasoning for the tariffs. But Chinese cars here are just plain better. Traditional companies sell shitty cars at high prices, like 90s level quality, literally the most profitable market for those companies. Chinese companies sell at better prices for actually nice cars.
I keep reading about new breakthroughs they make in charging speed including 1MW networks. Do they not translate to real world models or just not to the cheaper ones that people tend to buy?
Don't quote me on that, but the only vendor that does well on all 3 is Tesla with their superchargers.
Even when a Chinese EV is rolling from the factory parts for it are hard to come by since they'd rather make new vehicles with those parts.
When your Chinese EV incurs damage and there aren't any parts available for it you'll end up with a gigantic financial and economic loss. The car is basically scrap.
The base story from China is just until people understand what overcapacity is, all everyone else can do is protect themselves economically. Ideally you find a way to work with China, but there's a certain point where you just can't - it's their "manufacture everything" worldview and poverty at home, or degrees of gatekeeping.
China appears to believe it's OK for them to be everyone's manufacturer and views Japan's bubble popping as a mistake by the Japanese. What that actually is, is economic under capacity elsewhere while China continues to absorb both investment and capital. Japan can help with their margins this way a little bit, but while investment in China is sky high, companies aren't failing because of policy, etc., no one can compete cleanly with China.
When you hear things like deindustrialization of the West being a good thing, you sort of see what the end-game is. For the non-industrial countries its fine for them to think that, but it really is one of those "if this is what you get, why would any country invest in any other" mindset. And that makes everyone much poorer. And for industrial countries - BMW/Toyota/GM, etc., etc., going out of business would be a massive social drain/flashpoint.
In Europe every car I've had has had roughly interchangeable batteries. There might be two or three different sizes for family petrol cars. That seems like a reasonable amount of useful variation for manufacturers to choose between when playing Tetris with all the components they need to fit alongside the engine.
Do we really need a new car to look cosmetically different every few years to spur sales and say “new?” At the same time this means they can still customize the sheet metal, for different trims and types but the motor is the same, transmission is the same, seat is the same, etc
And for those parts, do we really need new part numbers every year? Heterogeneous is great? But something something Henry ford you can have any color as long as it’s black is also ok.
Plus it isn’t really new, brand engineering is this. Toyota grabs the bmw z4 and makes it a Supra, Mazda grabs the rav4 and makes it the cx50, etc
And personally I think most cars have been getting uglier. I would’ve been happy if they stuck with what they had 10 years ago.
So yeah, if you wanna save money, stop wasting it on a new redesign every few years. Don’t waste the money retooling to change random things every year.
They might do a cosmetic facelift every couple of years but the platform will typically stay in production for a decade or so.
GM in particular are famous for using the same chassis, drivetrain, floorpan etc on half a dozen or more models across their marques.
Still, however, as great as cheap available parts would be.. the major car brands desperately need to find ways to significantly lower the price of their cars. New cars and trucks are reaching the prices of like a big down payment you could put on a house. Standardized parts would definitely reduce costs but would that be enough? Even many 2 income households struggle to get ahead. In my opinion the number one priority of these companies should be how can they make an inexpensive car that the average person can afford.
The problem that I have with cars in general is that they use pretty old technology and you want something new that actually works OK and it does not have that much lag. While I understand the myth about manufacturers using old components because they are proven, they should get over it and use circuits made in the 21st century. Reliability has grown a lot, we don't need vacuum tubes in the cars anymore (I am being sarcastic about the vacuum tubes).
Another thing is the subtle but annoying differences in cars in different geographies: in one country you have a 360-degree camera system, but in others they don't even offer it as an add-on. For the same car. And other little things.
What I would like to see though would be to have the ability to upgrade the hardware in the car every 2-3 years. Like replace 2-3 "boxes" full of components and have "an almost new car" with improved technology.
This is a rather unenlightened take. The electronics used in cars aren't typical consumer gear - the parts are much more rugged. This is for good reason. The same car could start life parked on the side of the road in the nevada desert (wild temperature fluctuations), go on a roadtrip through death valley in the summer, and a few years later be parked on the street in florida (ridiculously humid) or somewhere in north dakota (extreme cold). Meanwhile we expect not to have any major electrical issues over a 20+ year product life. It's actually fairly absurd when you stop and think about it.
Do you think they make regular and -Q1 parts on different photolithography machines from different silicon? Nope, the only difference is post production testing and price.
PCB's, wired, solder, resistors, capacitors, connectors, cases
yes, testing is more. But there is a lot more in the manufacturing side for a qualified part.
A junk pile in residential storage, sure.
> An iPhone can also visit ...
Try leaving it out in the backyard in north dakota for a full year and see how long it lasts.
A Tesla does not use 5-10 years old chips and works in all environments.
All of the things you mentioned are telated to the metallic components of a car. If I take the battery out of my phone, and connect it only when needed, it will work just the same.
Again, this myth of old electronics are better for a car needs to be put to rest.
They might as well merge now and save the drama.
If all the parts are the same, everything will perform the same. Every brand will wear out at the same time. The cars will corner the same, accelerate the same.
Thus, no brand differentiation in the market.
if only one size 12v battery ‘exists’, then no one can have a bigger engine (requires a bigger starter and battery) or more electronics (requires a bigger battery, etc.).
also no ability to be more efficent, as they all have the same battery anyway and the same electronics and engine, eh?
either way, no meaningful differentiation.
if so, just merge into one company already eh?
Hasn't this ship already sailed?
What makes you think they'd look identical? You think the only parts in a car are cosmetic parts?
how else do you think this all works?
Nope
> how else do you think this all works?
As someone who actually has built-up cars in the past, and currently hand-building a lotus replica, I can assure you that I know how all this works, and speak from a position of authority on parts, compatibility and dimensions.
Oh, your experience is expressly when nothing is standard, and you pick and place from a entire catalog of non standard parts? Weird.
Especially since you don’t have to actually meet regulatory or emissions standards which they do?
So not actually applicable at all?
Built-up cars (as in, building up from a wreck), do have to meet standards.
Since the rest of your argument relies on me not knowing what I am doing, there's really no point in continuing this thread.
The reason is because Cybersecurity is a priority for us and the Chinese are spying on us blah blah. I know for sure that cybercrime was no where as frequent as today, and with that not only is it from china anymore along with a much larger scale of intrusion and theft.
I was actually hit by a DongFeng almost a year ago. I'd love to know where they got the new grill and bumper cover from, and how long it took.
So Japanese car manufacturers need to figure out some way to stay competitive. Standardizing parts is one way to do that.
Every other auto manufacturer has no path forward other than hiding behind government tariffs to protect them.
But yes I guess building everything yourself cuts out the middle man but obviously if the Japanese government spent $10bn (probably in Japan more like $20bn purchasing parity) into subsidising electric vehicles parts, robotics and supply chains I'm pretty sure it would have helped. Instead the Japanese government invested about 1/10th the amount of the Chinese.
My point is saying sure the end result could be vertical integration, however it's a million different things they did and number one was getting the right person into a position of power rather than a corrupt politician.
I’m very concerned about ceding auto manufacturing to China as we are doing, but as you say there have been a lot of factors involved and some of them very much self inflicted.
Elon Musk himself claims, "you are free to clone our satellite and car manufacturing; we only file defensive patents"
Really what I took from his statements was an emphasis that good execution is harder than you think at the same time as his personal philosophy is shifting to like, machines will make everything so people's personal stakes in their own investment will be discardable. I don't know, he is both very wrong sometimes and a force of nature, so it's anyone's guess.
So good effort and they got some influence, but they're still left with the cons of this approach which unfortunately also means the rest of the world has to deal with it too. Regardless of their strategic aims, COVID gave people advance warning of the fragile way things have been restructured and also accentuated how insane China is in an undeniable way.
We could see Japanese automakers standardizing as primarily a cost savings, but in a way Japan is also trying to get industry ready to pivot to military manufacturing if needed the same way we have seen in some cases in the US to better prepare for World War 3. Japan is a critical component of that, because the US needs flexibility in how it interacts with China right now and Japan is helping us extend deterrence. Japan really is amazing and what they're doing is thankless.
That may or may not be one component to what the automakers are doing, but it would probably not be a popular thing to promote publicly in Japan, because of their culture. It will also be riskier in World War 3 than in World War 2, because these plants are big targets that aren't hard to hit in today's world so I think it would largely be a temporary strategy up until any conflict escalates to the point where plants are being attacked if so.
In terms of hiring, the CCP isn't unique in having engineers/technically literate people in charge of companies, you could argue it's pretty much the norm across the auto industry with some exceptions so I don't understand the point you're making there.
Pointing out Tesla feels overstated.
[0] Agreement it was when supply chains were being developed
[1]https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/exclus...
Japanese company and Japan at large had been consistently and extremely challenged with recognizing existence of foreign markets or lands or just functioning beyond its borders.
Still, its products sell like free lunch, as if, sometimes lunches might be not so great but can't beat free. But it's not free, and Japan rakes in cash like it's a pile of gravel. That's a modern mystery, frankly.
So yes, but the drag is downstream of highly conservative product positioning not incompetence.
Even worst, if you're in California, the per mile price to charge an EV at home, without solar, is greater than filling up a hybrid Prius on today's gas prices.
Oddly though some types of energy as massively taxed. Taxation on solar in the US means that it costs 3-4 times the price in Europe and Australia. This is a political choice the US population made to have more expensive energy.
Do you have a source for that? So all sources I find say that the energy cost per mile on electic is around 1/3rd than that of gas.
Most other hybrid architectures are built around a conventional transmission and retain all of the mechanical complexity of an ICE drivetrain while adding substantial electrical complexity on top.
Ford licensed Toyota’s design for a while too.
Europeans and Koreans are still using traditional transmissions.
Which is why I now own a BYD.
Until they grow big enough to make their own glass.
For tires it does not make sense to integrate that too. Unless someone has the bright ideea to sell unconventional sizes, like 18.2" or something crazy like that.
I feel like the title is misleading on the impact, it's actually all of the big players
> The push to simplify and lower costs comes as Japan’s seven automakers, including Toyota, Nissan, Honda, Mazda, Subaru, Mitsubishi, and Suzuki, work to fend off the increasingly competitive list of Chinese automaker
Nissan is losing money, closing factories, ending model lines, and tried to merge with Honda last year.
Honda had its first annual loss since 1955 and they have no EV lineup.
Leaf was ugly af and prone to mocking by Tesla fanboys. Nissan exec couldn't understand that such a thing can steer customers away from a car and kill a brand. That was partically fixed that by ZE1 Leaf but it was too late. Meanwhile Toyota's Lamborghini-styled ZVW60 Prius that followed it was soon enough and good enough that it solved the same issue for Prius.
The most obvious is that it was ugly as hell. Before Tesla showed that a normal looking EV could sell well, manufacturers seemed to think they needed an EV to look like an EV, which somehow meant looking weird. This was wrong but it took Nissan a very long time to figure that out.
They had terrible range. This was understandable, maybe unavoidable, in the early days, but they didn’t keep up. Their longer range trim had barely 200 miles of range in 2024!
And then they had terrible technology around the battery. They were still using air cooling until 2025. This severely limited charging speeds (if charging efficiency is 95%, then 100kW charging has to reject 5kW of heat which does not come easily!) and, worse, made the battery degrade much faster. This actually damaged not just the Leaf but the entire industry. It was the most common EV for years and a whole lot of people learned that an EV battery is only good for a few years before the range tanks and you need an expensive replacement. This is not generally true, but it was often true of the Leaf.
Folks who can afford to shell out a lot of money for a car every decade at most can't take risks with unproven tech just because it may seem cool.
EVs have been proven tech for a while now. You’re not taking a leap into the unknown with them anymore.
Tesla is simply too expensive to buy, which is a blocker and it doesn't matter thats its a bit cheaper to maintain (and its not like tesla is #1 in long term reliability charts, is it). Even ignoring nazi owner - if you are actually a moral person you shouldn't but thats another topic. If used teslas with say 95% of the battery would cost around 15k that would be more interesting, but then we go back to nazi topic.
Grey/White/Black cars made of plastics, EVs nonetheless are cool...
They are largely and mostly big money losers with mild demand.
Volkswagen is one of the rare exceptions as it should sell more than 1M EVs in 2026.
They waited so long. They finally did it, with a rebadged GM because they don’t have the time to make one themselves, and it was popular. So they canceled it?
You’re way too late to start making your own, and they don’t even want to do it.
It’s like they think choosing to have a corporate Viking funeral and just burn the place down is the best way to honor their legacy. It’s nuts.
Just a thoroughly unnecessary foot-gun.
Honda almost got forced into acquiring them by the government and then managed to get out of it. There was a very funny press conference where press asked the CEO of Honda why they would buy Nissan and the guy said something like "That is a difficult question".
Businesses must be competitive. If they all use the same AI model, then they’ve lost all competitive advantage by using it. The only advantage left is the inputs that go into the AI model. Who supplies those?
Since you’re asking for examples, let’s talk about marketing. You cannot fully automate this. It’s a zero sum game. It’s like if all business owners decided to pick a really good marketer named Steve. Steve could probably come up with some bangers for a few clients, but once every business is asking Steve for marketing, it all looks the same.
High end fashion brands like Gucci, Prada, Louis Vuitton, are perfect examples of this. Why would I buy such an expensive bag from them? AI is never going to be the reason because fashion is not rational, even if it’s the one constructing the bag
In the next 3-5 years, sure, but that's not the long term vision I see. I think it's more likely we'll see the Anthropics/OAI/Google/Meta/XAIs of the world stop selling tokens. Instead they are the ones offering wider ranges of SaaS products, starting quant trading operations, taking over media (even more than today), developing new pharmaceuticals, etc. GPT 12 or Gemini Francium can and will tighten the RL loop by improving robotics, and have billions of dollars to offer armies of humans to fill the gaps where needed, until it no longer needs humans.
> let’s talk about marketing. You cannot fully automate this
Marketing is one of the most easily automatable jobs there is. AI is already capable of designing commercials, making cold calls, buying ads. Sure, they suck right now and are weird, but in 20-30 years when all of society has been so permeated with AI, AI will be more capable and also people will be way more accepting of AI.
I even find contradicting claims within software companies: that agents will boost productivity 10x, so they don't need to hire so many people. But if it made people 10x as productive, the maths say they could hire 10x the people to become 100x as productive! Shouldn't they do this and do circles around their competition?
(a counter argument is the productivity claims mean it's multiplied in general but not exactly per head... But I don't see many nuanced arguments, just "accept or leave").
This isn't going to happen. You're in the middle of a hype cycle.
1) Your claim is false. At least at my company, we are still doing the "intern to full-time hire after graduation if we like you" pipeline that we've always been doing. Does my one anecdote defeat your zero anecdotes? I don't know.
2) The companies are caught up in the hype. They're trying to find out what it's good at and what it's not. As reality comes back online and prices go up, they'll find reasons to hire humans again.
3) Money is no longer free (ZIRP is over) so there is less experimenting and less hiring and less mobility between employers, meaning fewer openings completely independently of the AI stuff.
There's many explanations that don't require falling for the AI hype cycle.
Predictions about the medium term future on HN are ridiculous. 95% of them are mindless drek, 4% are weak claims, and 1% have anything close to reality baked in and might be reasonable.
Younger generation had an edge previously because they could absorb how to use new tools, machines etc compared to someone older.
That's not the case here anymore.
Older people don't have any problem using AI. It's just AI don't need that many people. I don't think you can blindly apply what happened in the past to this case.
AI is no different, it's just people are swallowing the hype and getting hysterical. Certain things will be made more economical via AI which will create new opportunities which will in turn create other opportunities and new work.
The idea that AI will put everyone out of work is asinine.
For some reason, people in this thread keep making this statement without providing any reason why they believe it
So higher today than in 2015?
https://www.newyorkfed.org/research/college-labor-market?utm...
Doesn’t select to back your claims up in America
If you don’t think using AI is a skill, then you haven’t used it enough
If people didn't get fired, like they weren't with introduction of regular IT, then... the whole narrative will have to change.
Everything requires some amount of skill, but if you think using AI requires some great skill, like a degree, then you're using it wrong.
More to the point different people will have different levels of productivity using AI, but that has more to do with their existing or different skills. For instance more experienced developers tend to be more productive with AI (but not always).
If you think it is a skill, then you haven't used it enough.
FWIW, I use it plenty, and you're talking to a group of highly technical people who have probably also used it plenty.
Saying its painful but things will be fine, comes across very... Farquaad.
Like what are you insinuating this even means? Painful as in people starving to death painful or just painful as in no family vacations for a few years or a blend of both?
Are you saying that we just have to accept that as it is and nothing can be done about it?
Most people, especially with kids, don't share this attitude to keep things polite.
Not for a generation or two, there weren't. Unless you have an example, I'm not buying this argument.
In a fully mechanized/automated world, we won't work. It will make no sense to work. Im this scenario we have a wealth distribution problem. How do you decide who gets how much of what? Capitalism as we know it relies on cost of labour to distribute wealth.
Now, will AI be doing this? I don't think so. So I agree with you, it's going to increase productivity of a lot of jobs, but it will also create jobs. But we don't really know.
Your entire argument rests of this statement. Why wouldn't it make sense to work? How would one company differentiate its products from another if they're all using the same AI?
Let's take a contrived example. Let's say automation can produce yachts for all of us at affordable prices someday. We're just going to all own yachts then. What will be the reason for one person to choose one yacht over another? Branding, marketing, positioning, patents, regulations, etc. Who does that work? Humans. Because ultimately you're selling to humans in a human-controlled world, not machines.
Why are humans needed for that?
Patents, regulations are decided by humans because we’re ruled by humans
What I'm saying isn't anything new. It was a hot topic during abd after imdustrial revolution. Even Karl Marx joined the discussion and wrote about it. The key thing is, what is money and what determines the prices. If there's abundance, the problems you talked about start to occur and market cannot price the goods. This is, to some, abundance communism.
I suppose, at that point, the key inputs to a company become creativity and ambition (rather than, say, overall effort). Humans are still better at those than AI.
Humans would still direct branding/marketing/positioning while we control the overall creativity and ambition of a project/company.
If the only intent is to make money, then I suppose you could build machines that tweak the creativity & ambition in different ways to create different products & services, in which case you can argue no humans need to be in the loop.
But there is no pure capitalism and the government also redistributes wealth.
In an extreme(-ly unlikely) case of everything being automated the government would just redistribute the generated wealth to the populace (assuming a democracy). Apparently the end state of capitalism is socialism.
This is usually where people insist that the corporate overlords will take over and enslave everyone.
The thing that these sentences miss are the time spans.
It took more than 80 years for the British workers to recover salary and occupation wise from the first industrial revolution.
It took 70 years for European economies (deep into the 1950s) to recover from machines entering agricultural fields. In the meantime tens of millions emigrated to the americas because there were simply no jobs.
And previous revolutions only arrived in specific sectors (industries or fields). Now workers are being attacked in every single sector at the same time.
Do you have several life times till the job markets correct? I don't.
Yes they do. Constantly.
If AI is coming for all our jobs why are more progressive politicians not screaming for a standard 4 day workweek?
In fact, we should be on a 3 day workweek by now.
Why are "they" only speaking about people having normal 5 day week jobs, or being completely replaced by AI - no middle ground? Surely this is the time to transition to working fewer days? Fucking bizarre.
I choose to work only 4 days (for less pay obviously) and consume less (until automation makes more things cheaper), but it looks I'm alone with that choice.
Also remember that to Ford, "good american" usually also meant things like "not jewish".
The reason Ford increased wages was because he had to retain labor. The work was hard and mind numbing and awful, so turnover was massive, so he raised wages to get workers to stay and actually benefit from them learning on the job. An assembly line actually works fairly poorly with green labor.
Ford raised wages because the system didn't work well with bottom tier labor. You couldn't treat your employees as super replaceable.
This of course has largely been forgotten by everyone to instead be replaced with stupid myths about his legacy.
Of old age or something else?
My point was basically that I only see us going the exact opposite direction of using more human labour. I don't see how that changes with more automation, I'm probably too pessimistic.
I like to imagine a new form of wealth distribution needed to ensure happy life for everyone- healthcare can become cheaper with AI for example. Could we fund healthcare for all?
imagine the increased demand in animal husbandry, tool and die making, metalworking, woodworking, logistics and transportation, storage & food processing itself.
The secondary effects of any big jump like that rarely touch one portion of life.
The objective and effect of the plow (and practically every tool humanity has ever made) was to improve the efficiency and efficacy of a single task. The objective of the AI hyperscalers is to create a tool that is capable of doing any arbitrary work. They want to abolish human effort as the last possible economic problem to solve - similarly to how cryptobros proselytized about the monetization of everything forever, hyperscalers are sticking their tech everywhere they possibly can to try and find places where it extracts money.
The argument this time around is stronger as the fundamentals are simpler and more practical and not a pipe dream. Cryptobros argued that you could "own" anything, as long as you and every other person alive agreed to jump through the stupidest hoops ever concieved and were fine with not actually owning things in any conventional sense and also you connect everything in the world to the internet because its Really Important™ that proof you bought a pack of gum is duplicated on millions of computers simultaneously. There are endless critiques of Web3 and crypto, but they all generally boil down to infeasibilty. The AI argument lacks this issue; real tangible work is being done profitably right now by machines. The uses of these machines can potentially be cheaper than paying a person to do this work. The work done may be done faster or better or cheaper (or some set of these) than if a human does it. Economic players recognize its potential value and are frothing at the mouth at the idea of never having to pay a person to do any work ever again. Employers don't want to pay people because people are generally their highest cost, and eliminating them for a cheaper alternative is their goal, and an economic inevitability.
- https://www.automotive-fleet.com/news/gm-ford-officially-sig...
it'd be interesting to see if they try something like NUMMI between Japan/China beyond the fairly simple bz3 operation they had going
Think about it like this, 15~20 years ago, each company was building an operating system: Simbian, Windows Phone, Windows Mobile, various Linux based phones, Android, iOS, Blackberry OS, Palm OS, Firefox OS, Ubuntu's Unity Mobile... But then with the rise of iOS/Android, the cost of building something for each platform sky rocketed, you could have ten people each making the same tool for a different OS, or each making a different tool for the same OS. On the other hand it was easier to write one software for Android, and install Android everywhere, instead of having ten different apps for ten different OSes, and a company could install Android on their phones and have a smart phone, the other could make a whole operating system and only when all of the Anroid apps were available to their os it would have become feasible.
So efficiency and optimization always means the death of variety. You can have many programming languages with no good libraries, or a crappy JavaScript and C that have everything available to them... We all chose the latter.
The OS as far as I'm concerned is the same Android with its Material Design and UI rules. Sure, that makes using it easy and that is all that matters, but hey if you go one step more radical you'll see the difference between Windows Phone's Metro, and iOS, if you go even further you end up with forms like Smalltalk and even more so with things like Ivan Sutherland's Sketchpad. Things can be way, way more different but we get the same navigation bars, carts, boxes, icons, ideas... across all our software.
Was chatting with the local hardware store owner a few weeks back about bulbs and solenoids - there are standards, but the breadth of different types in cars on the road means it isn't worth the shelf space to stock them - individual types move slowly while stocking enough variety to cover what the local market needs takes space away from more profitable things (like metric-thread fasteners).
Even nearby auto parts store end up ordering common parts from regional warehouses, putting them on roughly equal footing with RockAuto in terms of time to delivery (and of course at a disadvantage on price).
And this doesn't even get into truly unique parts like door latch motors or the various ICs that control various subsystems.
Frankly, it's a mess. Having a spare "parts car" sitting around is best if you have the space for it.
I can't count on both hands the number of different types of battery, spark plug, fuse, or indicator lamp I've encountered.
And I've never worked on a car that was produced prior to 1979.
There were "step changes", like when headlights went from sealed beams to halogen bulbs in reflectors, You either had 6" or 8" sealed beams, or most likely H4 halogen bulbs (or a single filament bulb I've forgotten if you had separate low/high beam lights). If you had a headlight out, it mostly didn't matter what model car you had, or of it was a Ford or a VW or a Leyland, they all used one of 4 types of bulbs and they were all interchangeable.
In my head, and this is more motorcycle specific than car specific, but likely indicative across the entire automotive industry, it was the early 2000s when that started to change. My 1991 and 1998 Hondas and my 1999 Ducati and my 2004 Cagiva all used H4 headlight globes and the same 10/25W tail/brake light globes. My 2009 Yamaha was the first bike I owned where I had to buy headlight globes from Yamaha.
I've had cars with 9006/9007 headlight bulbs. Those were OK, I guess, other than the polycarbonate housings that turn into a clouded quagmire of shit when exposed to sunlight.
My 2012 Honda uses D2S headlight bulbs. That's a metal-halide part and it does not interchange with any other format, including other metal-halide parts. Each also requires both ballast and igniter assemblies. (Once lit, the bulb itself runs on [IIRC] 35V. But it takes a few kiloVolts to get it to initially arc over, vaporize some metallic salts, and start making light. And none of those volts are the ~12V that the car's electrical system produces.)
But at least it can use ~any regular D2S bulb. More-modern cars often use LED assemblies that aren't interchangeable between models at all.
But, yes: For decades in sealed-beam automobile world, we had a couple of sizes for round, and a couple of sizes for rectangular, and these sizes included the whole light-producing assembly, with focusing elements and the whole shebang. Some included a high-beam filament and some kept that separate, but: Any of these were very normal (standardized) things that anyone could pick up at ~any place selling auto parts and swap out with a screwdriver and whatever it takes to remove some trim.
(I've lived long enough to have seen sealed-beam headlight assemblies on shelves at small-town grocery stores. I have every confidence that if I rolled into the parking lot of such a store with a burnt-out halogen headlight in nineteen-eighty-something, then I'd be able to buy one and borrow enough basic hand tools to replace it in their parking lot in fairly short order. I'd probably also have paid Way Too Much for the headlight assembly itself, but I'd have been very grateful anyway. Convenience has a cost, even in matters of safety.)
I can screw in any of a whole galaxy of spark plugs into my Honda's engine, but that doesn't mean that the pistons won't collide with them before reaching TDC. (Does it matter if the screw threads are compatible when the parts crash before they can be used?)
Do we really have to talk about the light bulbs and the fuses, too? It's pretty boring, but I'll be bored later if anyone really wants to get into that.
(I'd like some popcorn, first, if anyone feels like contributing something.)
I'm not sure what general purpose robotics even is because the point of robotics is to not be general purpose, a general purpose robot is hardly faster than a general purpose human, the speed of the assembly line comes from recombining standardized parts, that's true for human or robotic artisanal vs assembly production
the bespoke sandwich shop is always going to be more expensive than the sandwich factory even if the former is operated by a bot
This was Dell’s big selling point when they started. Your PC built to order.
Yes, assembly line stuff will always be cheaper, and we'll continue to use a lot of mass manufactured stuff. But we don't always pick the cheapest option for everything. As custom options become cheaper we'll pick them more often even if they don't reach parity with mass manufactured options.
Worth mentioning - evolution generally favors robustness over efficiency.
Standardization of parts is good for the consumers, cheaper to build and cheaper to maintain.
I've been hearing statements like "cars all look the same, they're not like they used to be" for way, way more than 30 years.
It fits right in with "new music all sounds the same" and other easily-identified crotchety shit that some people seem to become prone to saying.
(For my own part: I can identify cars at a glance from many different eras, but I pay attention to that. I'm having a difficult time finding new music that I like, but I also don't try very hard on that front. I think that passenger planes have all looked the same for way more than 30 or 40 years, but I've never given them much attention at all -- flying has never been a regular feature of my lifestyle.)
To be blunt, this is part of the claim of a centralized command economy. This is part of why everyone wants to hate a centralized command economy. People like options.
But nothing in capitalism forces a diverse market, so it will find it's way to a centralized command economy if it can. Because it improves profit margins in exactly the same way it reduces "waste"
Semi Related to the topic.
Nissan and Honda are not the biggest Japanese car makers anymore. [0]
In Last Japanese financial year (April 25 to Mar 26), the total sales of Nissan and Honda were so bad that Suzuki has now leapfrogged them both to become the second biggest Japanese car seller internationally after Toyota.
The sales drop for Nissan and Honda is mainly due to steep declines in China. Suzuki already left Chinese market in 2018 so it was not affected.
[0] : https://www.carexpert.com.au/car-news/suzuki-overtakes-honda...
Suzuki doesn't even sell cars in North America.
They have good small cars but North America's market has evolved to stupidly big cars and pickups. Soccer moms that started the SUV revolution with the Ford Explorer are now driving F150 or VW Atlas
I see tons of large vehicles from Suzuki around here on the streets, more common countryside of course, but maybe "stupid big" is a step above that?
Bunch of SUVs, pickups and what not from here for example: https://www.autoscout24.com/lst/suzuki?body=4%2C5&cy=D%2CA%2...
None of these vehicles are considered "large" in the US. I've seen Vitaras, they're a mid-size crossover by American standards.
Also, this whole idea that "every American drives a cartoonishly large vehicle" is bullshit, and it was especially bullshit in 2012 when Suzuki entered the US market. The recession was driving sales of smaller, more affordable cars. Ford brought back the Fiesta, GM introduced the Volt and Cruze, and all of those sold really well for a time.
Suzuki just did zero marketing. Almost no non-nerd knew they were even here, and dealerships were hard to come by. And why would you buy a Kisashi or an SX4 when a Fiesta cost the same and came from a brand that isn't better known domestically for snowmobiles and motorcycles?
I actually test drove both a Fiesta and a Suzuki Swift in 2013. They were comparably priced but the Fiesta was better equipped and a nicer drive, and I (rightly) figured that part and maintenance would be easier for the Ford over my ownership.
Its not magic to use a different voltage system. Electrical engineerse capable of building a car can just do that.
It seems also that 48v + 12v was used already in the industry since 2010 and the real difference of tesla is 48v only and only in cybertruck which failed hard.
So its not a tehcnology genuies thing its again the old car makers not taking china serious enough to align faster and quicker. Probably because its just a lot easier to do it the old way until it either really hurts or until they are gone (see nokia and co).
I think these big car makers get run over by chinese companies because they don't see the car market as a commodity which it now becomes.
Companies like BMW can easily go to their suppliers and demand what they want. And BMW showed with the Neue Serie that they are very capable of building very good EVs.
Whatever the problem is, it snot a technical problem and if you look how many big car companies already use the same base etc.
I know you need to hate Musk, but calling the cyber truck a failure is a complete misunderstanding of “halo vehicles”. The cyber truck is immediately recognizable over any vehicle in the world, it was a resounding success in marketing and engineering around regulations that make every other vehicle extremely similar. Yes, I know how much it is disliked by some people.
GP is correct. If you want innovation it needs to be a multiple laboratory approach because other you are going to get only what Bosch or Vector or ZF or ContinentalTevis will give you drawn exactly by SAE one time and nothing more.
$40k vs. $60-70k 500 miles vs 300 miles 3.5k lbs vs 2.5k lbs payload
Clear failure.
Next their demonstration of the glas live: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=udxR5rBq_Vg and don't tell me they were happy with the result. This wasn't a win it was overpromised and not a success.
Then the sales were not what they wanted and "U.S. Tesla Cybertruck sales have fallen sharply—dropping to 20,237 units in 2025 (down 48% from 38,965 in 2024"
Its not even allowed in Europe and it can't be driven in Europe with a normal license because its too heavy.
The cybertruck also had plenty of bad engineering decisions. The huge whiper makes it hard to get replacement. The stainless steel doesn't hold up and has to be glued on instead of being the chase itself which was one of the core ideas of it.
The Fiat Multipla is also easily recognizable.
But don't get me wrong, im european the cybertruck is way to big for were i live anyway and i care very little for this car. But for sure its a failure in every core metric relevant to having a sucessfull pick-up and iwas for sure not meant to just being a marketing stunt or a halo vehicle. It cost Tesla a lot of money to make and they are winding it down because the endproduct didn't fit the market.
Im for sure not in automotive, i only live in munich and have worked on projects with BMW and Mercedes.
If you work for BMW, BMW tells you what you can use and how it has to loo like. I don't think BMW gets told from Bosch or co but i can be wrong.
The Cybertruck was an engineering marvel, introducing several groundbreaking features. It captured a ton of media and pop culture attention. This does not change the fact that production lines were vastly over provisioned for the eventual amount of units sold.
I don't doubt that the Cybertruck project pushed Tesla engineering forward substantially. So far I don't see any evidence it has translated to additional sales of its already popular models 3 and Y.
As a "halo vehicle," it was an embarrassment to the Tesla brand.
It's interesting that you've decided that their critique of the Cybertruck must be motivated by Musk hatred.
If you're trying to say that Tesla did this, you'd be wrong. European and Korean car makers were already switching in models were it makes sense long before Tesla released its first 48v (the cyberyruck).
Tesla did release their whitepaper last year to accelerate the transition mainly in other American makers, we'll see if it helps.
Some of the models, are completely built by one brand while , another sells it under different name with some cosmetic changes. The brands keep their unique/marquee models to their own, while outsource the other ones (which are not marquee).
And we need something similar for e-bikes and e-scooters, where manufacturers are still rolling their own everything, just like we had with mobile phone chargers before the EU mandated USB connectors. As a society we need interchangeable parts available through freely available standards.
Seems like there's plenty of headroom here.
This is not about OEM markups.
If you look at the "one 15min stop" range, the first Chinese car to appear is the Geely-owned Volvo and only on the second page:
https://ev-database.org/#group=vehicle-group&rs-pr=10000_100...
The AUTO industry is a lesson that value with firms only lasts while technologies are still standardizing.
In the future, consolidations will occur, and one or two firms will supply Cars for AV firms, which in turn will run their own D2C shops while also being available on Uber.
First, a driver was about to turn as I was catching the end of a greenlight... Let's just say I'm grateful to be in one piece.
Then, the navigation got me stuck in traffic for a train crossing. The train must have been 200 cars. I lost count. As I'm sitting there missing reading my ebook on the subway, I look around at the cars. A blue Kia hatchback with the new logo, a Mitsubishi, a few Toyotas, Hyundais.
I can't help but think these brands are already relics.
A trend under everyone's nose is public transportation, and non-car travel modes, have only gotten better. For the rest, you'll have public and private vehicles that drive you, there's car share, and what remains is a much smaller rural market.
What does each of these companies have, to respond to that? Shortages and cost overruns it seems, and not much else. Nokia was a household brand until it wasn't.
It's hard to imagine Toyota having that faith. The rest, I reckon many will fall. Don't you think?
No, I think your comment comes off as a bit out of touch if you believe that public transport is replacing the tens of millions of cars that hit the roads on a daily basis any time soon.
Non car travel modes are fine unless they’re not. I can ride a bike when it’s nice outside, but when it’s cold or raining I’d really rather get into a car. Public transportation can be better if the whole city is in a gridlock, but usually it’s not, and you’re locked into preset routes. When I’m going somewhere with friends I’d rather be able to talk to them freely without third patries giving me a side eye because it’s too early or too late or omg there are little children here you need to keep this pegi 8.
Let people own things, damn it. There’s enough rent seeking everywhere.
This, 100%. Besides, car rentals are so expensive that if you need a car more than a couple of days a month, you are much better off keeping a cheap car. Uber and the like have also become insanely expensive.
We have pretty decent public transportation in Qatar but people mostly go by car and we use a shit ton of fuel while at it. Around 3 cars average per household here and closer to 5 if you only include citizens. It's all car culture with plenty of infrastructure to support loads of cars.
A day pass on the metro costs just $2 but our fuel is also quite cheap.
I've lived in places where my cars stayed parked for weeks at a time... and in places where I drove essentially every single day.
Not about to be taking it anytime soon.
Remarkably they seem to be a British industrial success, and I’m impressed.
The part about keeping consistent color coding in the wires relives a mental load for repair.
On the bright side, maintenance and repairs should become much simpler.
We certainly did fine back when all cars had sealed beam headlights and the choices were circle or the more exciting rectangle and two lamps with two filaments each or four lamps with one filament.
I could easily see standardization to a small menu of less exciting parts. Surely, every model still needs different wheels, but wheel hubs could be pretty standardized with several sizes.
Without that, you often end up with one final batch of parts made and when it runs out, you're stuck with harvesting parts from other broken machines.
If 90% of the infotainment system is identical between 15 brands and the only differences are the bezel around it, the exact shape of the knob, and the coat of paint on the UI is that really so bad?
Costs just keep going up and up. People complain about it constantly. Anything to help make cars cheaper so they’re more competitive is a plus for everyone. Even if it’s only by a tiny bit.
You might have been worried about stifeling innovation. , but this does not seem to be it.
But seriously… this is impressive and smart. It’s following the Theory of Constraints way of reducing costs. It’s “the hard way” that will have long term benefits.
At least Toyota have a range of more sensible EVs now in the UK, but they seem to be squarely aiming at the large (i.e. expensive ... Tesla Y, BMW x1 prices for example) SUV market where you're never going to compete to more premium brands in a Toyota (this is why they invented Lexus after all). Where is the 250 mile range EV Corolla or Prius for example?
Curious how it plays out for nissan given they're already just reading Renaults.
I used to only buy Hondas and Toyotas in the old days but now I've switched to other brands because they sell EVs that are usable.
No one who cares about engine noise and gear shifts are going to buy a slow kei car with bolt-on wheel arches anyway, young drivers who this might be a first car don't know any different (no nostalgia), soccer mums or pensioners won't care, people who want/like/prefer an EV will be alienated by the fake-ICE stuff ... Who is it for?!
It feels like a "fun" concept thing, not a production vehicle. Pure novelty stuff to try and grab some column/screen inches.
100% agree that 110 miles yes is enough for everyday getting around and commuting etc but it does mean you need to charge basically every day/every other day (I have a ~220 mile car and I personally don't like to leave it much below 50% to cover the "opps - need to do an unexpected trip" which happens from time to time, so it charges maybe once a week etc). And longer weekend trips are out of the question. So you need a second car people say - sure but now you need two chargers too since you need to charge this 100 mile range thing daily AND your bigger family car etc. madness - it's almost like they deliberately want to make it so their EVs aren't competitive for some reason.
Now they are shocked that they can assemble the components and slap a different logo ?
This is not the kind of standardization they are considering. But why stop at fuel pumps and O2 sensors? Oh wait, they aren't even starting there. They are going to standardize the color scheme for wiring harnesses?
Part standardization is obviously much more complex and difficult than just thinking it is a good idea. I remember reading about Prusa using x-ray and other detection mechanisms for quality control of parts from outside vendors. It sounded like a bit of a headache for something as simple as a 3D printer part, let alone a car part.
Hoshin Kanri vs TPS
If for some reason it's super important to have the thing constantly leeching power to listen for a digital signal, I'm sure that companies standardizing parts can also manage to standardize a few signals.
As to incentives, well, yes, that's the source of all kinds of enshittification, not just this specific example.
Toyota, Nissan and Honda are different companies.
- Hyundai Motor Company
- Kia Motors
They are also quite behind on car software, like the Germans.
So many moving parts that can break in the cars today
I hope so
From the article (yes)
I guess it applies to car as well.
That’s why there’s 100 different toothpastes that all effectively are the same.
I’ve also had good feedback from my dentist re: manual brushing and “essential” toothpaste (of which I have a national stockpile) so I will use that up before venturing into something exotic.
all these brands spend so much money in advertising just to convince people that their product (which is probably 95% the same as any other one) is the best.
what a waste of resource and money.
Soap isn't quite soap, though. Like with a certain brand of soap I was using, once I had used like maybe two thirds or three quarters of it, the remaining bit would somehow always sort of dry out or something and no longer foam up properly when washing hands. Whereas a different brand of soap remains perfectly useable all the way to the end.
More seriously, I suppose it's because you want competitive markets and products can vary along multiple dimensions like price, size, ingredients / composition, ethical claims, consumer targeting, etc.
I'm reminded of one of my favourite historical Onion articles: https://theonion.com/consumer-product-diversity-now-exceeds-...
“As more and more species fall victim to extinction, we face a grave crisis of decreased diversity, not only in America but across the globe,” Hargrove said. “But the good news is, these losses in biodiversity are more than offset by a corresponding rise in consumer-product diversity. Though flora and fauna are dwindling, the spectrum of goods available to consumers is wider than at any time in planetary history. And that’s something we can all be happy about.”
Need canned beans? Fine, no worries: Baked beans, black beans, pintos, red beans, refried, whatever -- they're all on the shelf... and they're all labeled with one of Aldi's in-house brands.
It was generally the same with the meat and the cheese and the produce and ~everything else, too. Ribs? Ribeyes? Fresh salmon? They probably had it, and there was definitely only one brand to pick from -- whichever one of Aldi's house brands fit that broader category.
(It's softened somewhat in recent years. Nowadays, I can select a block of [fucking-outstanding for-the-price] aged cheddar cheese with an Aldi house label, or a competitive product at a somewhat higher price with a Cabot label. They're stocked next to eachother.)
E.g. even cornflakes – first of all, if you really want to standardise on one single "cornflakes" product, does that mean sweetened or unsweetened cornflakes? If it's the former, I already loose out, because I prefer the latter. (I sweeten them myself if necessary.) And even among the latter category, I've observed some definite variation in both taste and shape/size distribution of the cornflakes, leading to me preferring a certain brand over others.
I want you to be able to get as many different kinds of corn flakes as you desire, with as many strange animal, flower, or Dali paintings as you wish for box art -- or very plain. Some GMO, some not. There should be a variety of manufacturing techniques for you to select betwixt, with stable variations in things like shape/size distribution. They can be sweetened with HFCS, cane sugar, stevia, real honey, or as plain and drab as that puritanical Kellogg himself intended.
Maybe you can't get them all at the same place, but whatever: You should then be able to walk somewhere else, or get back in your car, or on the train, hail someone else's flying EV while it's in Revenue Mode, or maybe just have the bot drop it off on the porch later this afternoon, or whatever: You should be able to get that done.
I like variety, myself. And there was definitely a time when I had a lot more mouths to feed when I'd go into an Aldi (in the US), and pick up only the selection of meat, cheese, produce, and canned goods that I preferred -- for whatever reason I preferred that.
It was also like a scavenger hunt -- maybe Aldi didn't have any fresh mushrooms this month at all, or maybe they'd have them at such a fantastic price that I'd have been a fool to buy them anywhere else.
That visit could account for maybe 60% of my grocery shopping for a week, say. The rest would be purchased from Somewhere Else. That worked fine for me, although it did motivate me to accomplish a lot of meal planning based around whatever the Aldi flyer said was cheap this week.
But again, I'm not thinking that a given store should be forced to cater to every whim. Or any particular whim at all, really.
If you or someone else wants to build a grocery store that sells only corn flakes of some preferred kind and quality, with some preferred packaging, then: You should be able to do that, and you should have all of the freedom to sink or swim in that venture that the combination of the marketplace and your coffers allows for. If you want instead to build a grocery store that carries as many varieties of corn flakes as possible, from every corner of the globe, then: Knock yourself out.
I might not shop there at all, ever. Or I might work hard to buy whatever it is you have to offer. (That part is up to me.)
eg. Breakfast cereal boxes should be small, medium, and large, regardless of brand (and "large" and "medium" should differ only in width). Then shelves and cabinets can be sized to fit the ISO standard cereal box with no wasted space. Same with dish soap. Etc.
General principle you bring up I agree with, but the example is interesting for this issue/reason
I’m curious your lifestyle and usecase!