(betterdatacenterproject.com)
If you're going to do that, you kinda also have to count how many will likely die from DOGE, worldwide.
> Lastly, they are actively working to solve the energy crisis by putting datacenters in space.
It's trivially obvious that space data centres won't do that.
While PV in a heliocentric orbit can get you a roughly 6x boost from capacity factor (depending on exactly where on the ground you put them), it also gets you a roughly 6x shorter lifespan for the actual panels.
I don't want to live in a world where everyone computes their own energy need, decide it is an "absolute drop in the bucket" and chooses the absolute worst option to satisfy said need.
Didn't they walk away from their renewable goals the moment that AI took off and then deleted previous pledges from the corporate website?
This isn't just an anthropic problem, and they're an insignificant, just stupid to even talk about it, rounding error to our energy usage. Especially when you include ICE engines as energy sources, and the many multiples grid capacity required to convert everything to electric.
This is a pebble in the ocean that has a strange and disproportionate, probably lobby based, amount of attention directed to it, in the news cycle and social media.
The problem with a purely financial accounting is it ignores environmental and social costs entirely.
The Senate passed a bipartisan bill to speed up the approval process for data centers and power plants. The bill also makes data centers pay for the power they use.
This should accelerate the country the build more solar, wind, and battery projects.
https://www.npr.org/2026/11/20/g-s1-154579/senate-bipartisan...
> Many Democrats have also opposed the bill. They say it will worsen pollution by making it easier to greenlight oil and gas projects and energy-hungry data centers, while weakening protections for clean air and water.
In 2020, they sued to stop a transmission line from bringing clean hydropower from Canada to Maine. In 2024, they sued the Maine government for not doing enough to combat climate change.
Also Mainers get nothing out of it.
That transmission line was absurd and stupid. Maine needs new generation, not more demand to the same international markets we buy our power from.
Maine hasn't done enough to combat climate change, which is a serious problem for our fishing industry, which is already suffering from the impact of climate change and may eventually have no jobs. The power line made 0 improvement to that.
CMP has been refusing to connect already built solar installations. Our power is expensive because of that.
Interesting attitude. Why should anyone in North America care about the effects of climate change if the worst effects are felt in... Not North America?
Orthogonal problem that ought to solved separately.
It would be weird for anyone to argue that we do not need more energy faster and at lower prices.
Energy is foundational to civilization.
I would expect that companies would build the most economical power source that they could. If gas turbines are less economical, it seems strange that they are being built; there must be something more nuanced to that story (or companies that are building them see the economics differently somehow).
"Economical" has different meanings depending on whether your time horizon is the next quarter or the next century. It also depends on whether you just consider your own pockets or those of the whole humanity. A lot of stuff, like the entire fossil fuel industry, is economical as long as Someone Else pays conveniently pays your debts! In any case, "economical", whatever it means, is not what we need. Sustainable, including economically sustainable, is.
Please stop expecting this, or at least take the time to figure out whether your priors are justified or not, because it sure seems like the facts aren ’t supporting your world view these days.
[] https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/03/climate/jet-engines-ai-da... https://www.wsj.com/business/energy-oil/how-jet-engines-are-...
Tell us more.
Data centers paid for power they use. It's amazing how far the data center conversation has drifted from reality.
Data centers, like all large scale grid-connected projects, are also assessed fees for the infrastructure costs they incur.
The debates have been around additional math beyond that where some people think that additional infrastructure buildouts should be billed even more to data centers, beyond what is assessed for their own connection. The argument was that utilities are sizing infrastructure projects based on projections of more data center growth and it's not popular to bill infrastructure growth to anyone but data centers right now.
i'm not stupid, i know what you mean, but why say stuff this wrong way?
there are no new datacenters in San Francisco, yet my electricity rates have nearly doubled in six years. can we pass a law that says, my rates are frozen in 2019 too? it would benefit a lot more people.
the hard part isn't deciding, oh, use solar. the hard part is, reining in voters and tulipmanias. some voters like tulipmania, next week, we'll learn the hard way that "datacenter bad" isn't the win people think it is.
Median days from application to permit issuance in San Diego is 0 days while it is 4 days in NYC. In San Francisco it takes 42 days!
Permitting is only part of the problem. Guess how long it takes from signing a contract to switching on your solar system? In Nevada it is just under 60 days while in California it is ~150 days. Texas isn't much better, at ~120 days.
Bureaucracy literally saps energy.
Making it harder to build makes rent-seeking more profitable, so slowing things down is a goal unto itself. It's not just vibes - the vibes are how to obscure the goal.
Here is a is map of the largest solar projects & locations: https://cleanview.co/power-projects/operating/solar-farms/us
[1] https://ourworldindata.org/data-insights/almost-all-the-grow...
https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/consumption-co2-per-capit...
Your link takes a lot of the coal power CO2 that is generated in China and assigns it to the US where the products are consumed. The prior post argued that the US needs to stop importing products from China.
It shows the same thing. US emits way more per capita than China.
If you care about CO2 per country, it's China. If you care about CO2 per person, there are many countries worse than the US.
https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/consumption-co2-per-capit...
oh okay, why not?
population growth isn't just some random function.
brutal, maybe -- but unfair? Not sure.
China: ya but the US are far more dirty per person they'll gain an advantage this way so we can't slow down (though they seem to be the ones building out the most renewable infrastructure)..
Canada: ya but both those guys are worse than us. We barely have any people!
India: well if nobody else even nice guy Canada is going to bother...
It's like nobody remembered the eye for an eye teaching.
It's not about "advantage" it's about asking the Chinese person to continue to freeze while the person in the US reduces their consumption by 200kg. So the Chinese person has 200kg worth of heating while the American has 500kg. But they should be equal assuming equal climate, is the thing.
The hobbit steps forward
"I won't. I won't take it. We hobbits are too small, we never got a ring of power. We have no involvement in this. It's simply not out responsibility!"
The men, elves and dwarfs, not humiliated, continued to argue.
You're putting a lot of bad faith words in my mouth I never said. If anything is "thought-terminating," it's that.
Also I offered a real counter-argument, that per-capita is in fact important. How is this thought-terminating?
I'd actually say that the US AND China have little-to-no responsibility to start a push towards cleaner energy because they benefit so strongly from the status quo. Those that don't have that benefit should be more incentivized to pushing their carbon output to zero, and pressuring both these entities with sanctions, trade wars, and military action wherever possible. Eco-terrorism should also be financed by these smaller entities targeting backers and companies of the larger ones.
the thing that needs to be turned off is coal and gas plants, not to mention gas and diesel cars and trucks
the people are irrelevant, and this is just excusing larger and growing populations to burn more.
i can blame them just fine for having more and replacing their coal plants with new coal plants
Solving a common problem can require finding a common solution, which would require some sort of agreement like "I will consume less, if you consume less and we can both survive decently".
Anyhow, at this point I find the discussion irrelevant as renewables are cheaper. Whoever wants to make it about "save the planet" or "they and not us are doing the damage" are indirectly helping the fossil fuel industry that wants this to be a "culture war" and not a discussion about "what is cheaper" (which they would loose).
That’s where you lost the point. Earth doesn’t care if it gets hotter. The people do.
So? If I have a family 5 times the size of your family, my family is consuming more, negatively affecting those around me.
It doesn't matter to the planet what arbitrary social construct you group people into, every family needs to put in the same work per person.
Why?
Environmental issues have to be solved at a group-scale. Policy, market forces, technology innovation, etc.
To tell people they need to stop using plastic, not get something delivered next day, to not eat meat, and make it their personal responsibility simply does not solve things.
What's really off-putting (and likely hypocritical) is someone telling someone else they're failing morally on these matters.
And of course personal choices matter, exactly for this reason. If a million people choose to be wasteful then it's not valid to claim "it's not MY massive car that's the problem".
Or, by that logic, let's go to the source and blame only the fossil fuel producers ... wonder who produces more oil.
Otherwise it is just cherrypicking.
Now, how essential for them is what do they get out of it - that's a different story. Buying one mobile phone per year is different to not having electricity to turn on the lights at night (exaggerated examples).
The environment doesn't care about arbitrary sorting of humans into sets. It just cares about totals, which is why unless you can make a good case that some people have some sort of natural or moral or divine right to consume or emit more than others the allocation has to start with per person.
Global greenhouse gas emissions have risen sharply over the past century, driven by industrial growth, expanding energy use, and population growth.
Select for US and China in this chart - https://ourworldindata.org/greenhouse-gas-emissions
What do you recommend?
would take a while for developing country but at the end of times, world population would decline and in translate to "reset"
Should this be the new goal for COP32, or should it focus more on addressing global climate change and reducing the total global emissions? What is the metric that we actually care about?
It should be noted that older demographics have higher emissions rates than younger ones, so having more children is really an effective way to reduce per capita CO2 emissions. The emissions get spread out over larger population, and the new generation has less emissions than then the older generations.
Serious proposals need to take into account individual needs.
China projects as far as i can tell are in remote , renewable heavy areas and mostly greenfield with the coal/gas contribution being mostly to stabilise the grid (when it not in industila/manufacturing processes).
And again this is a country of 1.4B people that also increasingly the manufacturing base for most of the planet, so throw in all the goods going to SouthAmerica/Africa/Europe into that energy consumption calculation. That lage parts of the developing and develpoed countires can accelearte their solar/wind buildouts comes directly from those coal/gas plants in Chna.
It's like saying the USA has the most inmates out of any country. True but not surprising because it's the 3rd biggest and has a crime problem. The USA has more inmates per capita, now that's the real problem.
The US incarcerates 1.2 million people.
https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/co-emissions-per-capita?c...
The largest entity that can agree and implement anything like this across its parts is a country, so you have to appeal to countries to implement regulations.
This surge of fossil fuel use is only possible because we have a glut of fossil fuel plants that were sitting idle because of solar.
This new wave of green activists have learned to simply make economic argument instead. To their surprise "it's cheaper and it's clean" sells a lot better than 'non-green energy is h!tler and we're cheaper." I also think markets needed time to get comfortable with green energy.
For a rough calculation, if the US had emitted no CO2 this millenium, then if all else were equal that would be more than 100 gigatonnes less CO2; meaning we'd be closer to 420ppm than the current 432ppm.
(There are feedback loops like oceans and plants that would absorb less CO2 at lower concentrations which I don't know how to account for.)
Mass of CO2 and ppm: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_dioxide_in_the_atmosphe...
It's a classic collective action problem, and the international community has done similar things before.
China is also #1 when it comes to green energy research, and guess what, they got there by investing their dirty fossil fuel profits.
If we care about pollution we need a massive global Green New Deal. Yet all we get from Europe is lip service about it, in America we are actively kneecapping renewables, and only in places like Australia do we see some success.
The only superpower investing on a continent scale in electrification and renewables is China.
A carbon tariff on China is an excellent idea. As long as that same tariff applies to the United States.
We have all the excuses we need to do nothing.
1. China has 4 times the number of people as the US;
2. China is using coal in part because of the disruption to oil and natural gas supply caused by the US boondoggle and grand misadventure in Iran. As an aside, China essentially saved the world economy by cutting their oil imports by so much;
3. China has built in recent years and continues to build more renewable energy (particularly solar) than the rest of the world combined;
4. For pretty much anyone else building renewables, it's China supply the tech more often than not;
5. China has built the world's largest hydroelectric dam (ie the Three Gorges Dam) and in the coming years is building something three times as large;
6. China is actually building nuclear power plants, something HNers normally love;
7. Since the 2020 OPEC oil supply shock (which never gets blamed on the Trump admin for some reason), China has added roughly 80 million EVs to the road. It's estimated that this has reduced global oil consumption by approximately 2 million barrels per day, which again has greatly contributed to saving the world economy but also represents a ~2% reduction in global oil demand.
What else could China do? What is anyone else doing in comparison?
theyre purposefully wrecking as much as they can for industrial independence and dominance. thats a bad choice for everyone, but especially the environment
China could do more, but there comes a point when its time to stop pointing at the place making real inroads into alternative energy and turn to the ones screaming drill baby drill with a skitzo energy policy.
First you'd have to explain to things to the populace:
a) how those taxes will affect their purse
b) what those tax dollars will be used for
I bet you that on (a) the cost will be passed on (because we are the ultimate consumers) and on (b) the tax dollars will be misspent to a meaningful degree. End result is not a meaningful improvement to reduced environmental impact and consumers pay more. Basically wealth evaporating.
Tax Incidence is a lot more complicated than that
Shouldn't a carbon tax apply everywhere, equally?
Plus it would have the net effect of incentivizing renewable power to them, so all the assets aren't dark for years when the bubble pops and the economics turn against fueling them with gas.
Paperclips in the wind
Keep optimizing until GOTO END
Swap tarrifs for carbon tax on imports.
That being said, as it happens, those businesses also happen to have heavy logistics involvement, so in theory, EV tax credits could save that business model. Though that "logistics involvement" is currently arm's-length (they contract with trucking companies) so in order to benefit from those credits by forcing EV fleet conversion, they would need to vertically consolidate, i.e. buy up all those trucking companies.
And of course, under your model, after 10 years, they'd lose these credits and become negative-margin and cashflow-starved anyway.
it will be factored into price for end consumers and back pressured to suppliers
Impact is separate topic of discussion.
You obviously don't have any numbers in your hands about this.
The argument against taxing revenue is usually framed in terms of "thin" businesses that perform some administrative function but not much of a physical one, not businesses with significant operations that still happen to be in a mostly-competitive market. Although perhaps you could argue that this competition is merely a skin over the real pricing power (eg egg cartel, PG vs Unilever), and grocery stores have become akin to thin businesses.
Then again, individuals are essentially taxed on revenue (can't deduct most things that would be straightforward business expenses, like "commuting" or food), and we still continue to exist (at least for now).
Why not just tax the use of gas and coal directly, rather than going through all the loop.
Until 5 years ago rank and file among IT were anti-union, regulations... now they're the frogs feeling the heat and it's all "regulate everything"
Not one mfer is socially reliable. Everyone really should just be minimized to a single individual, a single vote and left to their childhood neighborhood.
It's all such obvious copy-paste and empty platitude effort from top to bottom with humans.
Mirror neurons most def seem like the simplest answer; superficial monkey see-monkey do follow along without critical thought happy paths in the brain being lit.
Fingers crossed the AI bubble pops and ends it all one last gasp, our answer to the Fermi paradox. Or at least makes everyone obsolete and ignorable.
Here's a quote about a data centre currently being built near Edmonton, Alberta.
------
"Utah State University physicist Robert Davies was hired by SLCN to conduct a preliminary technical assessment. He said if the Wonder Valley project goes ahead it would release the equivalent of 23 atomic bombs of energy every day, though he noted the comparison has its limits."
Source: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/edmonton/wonder-valley-slcn-c...
------
This is not the total energy being consumed by this data centre. It's merely the waste heat it will release to the surrounding environment.
Here's the energy consumption:
------
"At full operation, it would consume energy at a continuous rate of 18 gigawatts or about 1.5 petajoules per day and emit about 30 million tonnes of carbon dioxide a year – more than four per cent of Canada’s total emissions, said Davies, whose assessment was based on publicly available information."
------
That's the equivalent of 1.66 million Canadians in carbon emissions, or 1.6 Edmontons. This is just one data centre. Many more are going up across Canada, and Canada is both late and slow to the buildout.
That's the kind of scale we're dealing with at a time when, as a world, we are trying to reduce our carbon emissions.
From my perspective, that is not quite the correct way to put it. Because honestly we are not even trying.
---
I find those "Olympic swimming pool type" comparisons very tiring, to be honest. They certainly don’t help my grasp anything. "23 atomic bombs of energy" yeah okay
1. Trains need tracks for the full length of the journey. This is a lot to maintain. Plans just need a runway each end and air in between. 2. They are slower so staff have to be paid for longer hours.
However, for many journeys trains can still work out cheaper because they can take you closer to where you want to go from closer to your starting point, so the cost of the complete journey can be lower.
Cheap train network is a proper pipe dream, not possible. Much better to have fully self driving electric taxi cars (so not that joke with driver constantly needing to be aware if your tesla wants to steer you to standing ambulance / firefighter trucks on highway, I mean no driver setup to push prices to very low levels).
> This is not the total energy being consumed by this data centre. It's merely the waste heat it will release to the surrounding environment.
Total energy should in theory equal waste heat. All energy a data center consumes will eventually get converted to heat.
What would happen to energy it uses other than be released as heat? It has to go somewhere (conservation of energy) and I cannot think of anything other than heat that energy used in a data centre would become.
> about 1.5 petajoules
That is about 2% of total Canadian energy usage. How many more are going to go up? Are they all going tbe powered predominantly by fossil fuels?
If only we had some need for heat as a civilisation and could actively combine projects to achieve multiple things at once.
It could reduce the use of other energy that is used JUST to create heat, so its more efficient - but that only works in some locations, and in most of those only for part of the year.
Is there a difference? Where else would the energy go?
While I can't really visualise energy at all, this does make it seem like more than the 0.5% of world electricity consumption that it actually is.
While it is currently cheaper to build renewable energy capacity than most fossil fuels, as far as I can tell, the reason most data centers are not doing so is because they can't, All of the renewable infrastructure being produced is currently being deployed.
The question they should be being asked is when will they be switching to renewables. The height of the plot is not the important thing. It is the area underneath that matters,
"When are you going to switch to renewables?" has proven to be a useless question. Companies will say whatever is expedient, and then they'll buy credits or whatever green washing instead of actually reducing consumption. If you let them double their energy consumption by adding renewables they'll just use double.
Most of the worlds energy use is not electrical.
It is a large amount. I do not deny that, I just want people to consider it in terms that are true. Every person who I have asked how much they think it is based upon the coverage they have encountered has massively overestimated.
A common response is that considering the concern reported in media they estimate data centers use 10-15% of electricity. How can we have an informed conversation about the relative importance of things if people have been misled about the relative scale.
Source: https://eta.lbl.gov/publications/united-states-data-center-e...
The US figure is not so much a factor of data center usage but rather the desire to centralise contol within the US where energy providers are more interested in extracting profit from existing infrastructure than building new infrastructure.
Add to that the amount of electricity spent on industrial uses that the US just doesn't do any more. It inflates the US percentage.
That's not a symptom of data centers, The US is trying to put a new engine in a neglected car with a rusted out chassis.
Those are not just AI ones, and some reduce other energy usage - e.g. if a video conference replaces multiple people travelling to a face to face meeting.
https://www.energy.gov/articles/doe-releases-new-report-eval...
Is it not possible to use some of that for basically free local district/water heating?
https://news.infomaniak.com/en/euria-sovereign-ai-assistant/...
Meanwhile codebases get exponentially more bloaty and buggy. The internet gets filled with more and more disinformation. Students get worse and worse.
And the growth everyone is depending on is also so cleary destructive. This is not sustainable and it will not be the solution.
Is that feasible at all?
What yield?
Little Boy (the type of bomb dropped on Hiroshima) was 63TJ
The IEA is projecting 500TWh (57GW ) by 2030 so it might be consistent with their figures.
Now it has a bit at the bottom This story and its headline have been updated to provide further context about the preliminary nature of Robert Davies’ assessment and align with our journalistic standards and practices
I was thinking they were talking about current usage. Not guesses of how much something might use.
The only other source I found was https://majorprojects.alberta.ca/details/Wonder-Valley-AI-Da...
Indicating the initial build would be 1.4GW.
I'm not sure how much size matters of individual data centers apart from their contribution to the total. If they sum to the same amount, how much does it matter.
If it's true that you can build something of that size without an environmental impact report then there's something pretty wrong with the laws there.
And that economy-of-locality means that if they wanted to build more of these gas-plant data centers, they'd just also build those in Alberta.
Thus, if they're building DCs "across Canada", then I would expect that the data centers being built in the rest of Canada will not be powered with piped-in Alberta oil. A data center built in e.g. British Columbia / Ontario / etc, would presumably use the natural resource common to those provinces, i.e. hydro power.
---
Also, coincidentally, there's something interesting/unique about building data centers in Alberta, that being that it's friggin' cold there. Which means that Albertans spend a lot of grid power (or oil-and-gas directly) to heat their homes each year.
They're already doing waste-heat recovery district heating for data center projects in Finland. Could be done in Alberta too. (Though maybe it'd be better to target some of these DC projects to slightly northern-er parts of Alberta, where it stays cold for more of the year, so that ideally the district heating is a desirable consumable year-round rather than only for 6 months out of the year.)
---
As for carbon emissions, I would point out something less positive and more frustrating. There is a fixed (slowly-growing) production capacity of oil-and-gas producers like Alberta. If all the oil-and-gas that Alberta is pulling out of the ground was already being burnt, then it would have been impractical to build any data centers there, as the data centers "sucking on the straw" wouldn't be able to force the oil derricks to work any harder than they're already working, nor force any oil-sands exploration to happen faster than it's already happening, and so they just wouldn't get enough supply to satisfy their demand.
No, the reason the data centers can be built in Alberta, is that an inelastic production industry like oil-and-gas, when demand for its product goes down, doesn't scale down; but instead, buffers its supply in reserves, while looking for new avenues to demand its supply (potentially at lower cost.)
In other words: numbers like "30 million tonnes of CO2/yr" sound impressive, but what we're actually talking about here is a reallocation of oil-and-gas production. Those barrels of oil had previously been being burned in cars; now that cars aren't using them as much, they're being burned in power plants instead. The net carbon we're releasing from pulling that oil from the earth has neither increased nor decreased.
And, of course, that's a bad thing. We want oil-and-gas production to be elastic; we want our decreases in aggregate end-consumer demand to lead to gradual scale-down of the oil-and-gas extraction industry.
But can you guess who doesn't want that? Oil exporters like Alberta. And, often, their voters. "A gradual scale-down of the oil-and-gas extraction industry" is, to them, a gradual scale-down of their tax revenue and/or livelihoods.
So of course they're going to push back on it / "work around" anything that threatens that by coming up with new sinks for their product.
If we want to "solve" carbon emissions, we really need, first and foremost, to come up with a way to decouple oil-exporter states' tax base + jobs from a dependency on the maintained worldwide aggregate demand for oil-and-gas. Only then will those states stop coming up with new justifications for continuing to pull oil out of the ground.
Is this supposed to sound very impressive? It genuinely doesn't to me.
I know atomic bombs are scary, but that's because they explode very quickly in a very small space. (Radiation aside which I guess was not the point of the comparison)
If you spread that energy release throughout a whole day and a bigger area, letting the wind slowly take the energy away, then it doesn't sound scary at all.
Using nuclear bombs as the measuring stick is a cheap rhetorical tactic.
It is very funny reading people who don't understand physics layering on histrionics to make something sound as bad as possible.
I have a fantasy that keeps me warm on the cold nights of my mind. It's that after building AGI they ask it how to solve global warming. And it replies, "Lol, you're fucked. Why did you sacrifice everything to build me instead of saving yourselves?"
Saying this comparison has its limits is an understatement. Energy released by different atomic bombs can vary across different order of magnitudes.
Also AI data centers weren't responsible for decades of people burning natural gas to heat their homes without investing in insulation nor the tar sands oil which is really screwing the climate.
Not investing in insulation, no. Especially rentals have lagged behind.
Good luck getting that past the NIMBYs
We could build The Great Pyramid from TNT byt we don't as its a stupid idea.
I just cannot understand how anyone would find this comparison useful... oh wait, I see, it's not to educate people, it's to push a false narrative. Now I understand!
> 18 gigawatts
That's a figure we can work with!
on the proper hn thread for that misinformation article, i did a quick lookup and the comparable number is a large aluminum plant.
we should turn off Quebec's aluminum industry - its got tons of plants emitting like this datacenter will, and were releasing all that heat in the environment just to ship the aluminum south afterwards.
at least the datacenter will be used by canadians
They're looking to take advantage of the gold rush in AI to do this -- and the Canadian population's current distaste for carbon taxes and environmental restrictions, and the Alberta govt's frankly corrupt pursuit of exponential growth in energy sector emissions.
There's no "rational" world where it makes sense to build AI DCs in Alberta & Sask (which have dirty expensive grids) instead of a place like Quebec or even B.C. which have cheap and cleaner hydroelectric power.
It's being done only because the AB gov't is on the side of the fossil fuel industry above all else. And because Smith got Carney to massacre the carbon tax.
We will all be left holding the bag in 5-10 years. And we will suffer with increasing energy costs in the interim as demand for natural gas spikes. Enbridge shareholders will like it though.
50 million years ago there were 1600 ppm CO2 in the atmosphere. I haven't seen a projection that has reaching near that in the next 100 years. The extreme scenarios are like 1100 by 2100.
The early Cambrian period had 5000-6000 ppm.
OSHA's exposure limit is 5000ppm averaged over 8 hours.
This study found no cognitive impact at 2100.
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S036013232...
A larger NIH study found nothing at 4200.
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42035679/
For some reason people think its acceptable to spread pseudo-scientific bullshit whenever it supports an anti-climate change agenda. It really isn't needed. The direct harms based on scientific data are enough to justify far more intervention than is currently happening. Spreading misinformation just discredits the movement.
"Humankind will drive itself extinct with climate" is fearmongering - completely unsupported by science.
The harms are bounded, and that's a big part of the issue with addressing climate change.
Climate change is severe enough that something should be done about it, but not severe enough to make itself impossible to ignore. Harmful enough that those harms should be prevented, but not harmful enough to justify extreme prevention measures.
This is wrong.
We engineers optimize for human life, that's it.
Maybe that's the ideal, but every engineer I know is forced to create tools which are designed to die after a certain point in time. Things designed otherwise are either prohibitively expensive, or reducing in numbers or both.
I rarely see improvement in quality of the things I buy when compared to their older siblings. Cost optimization is the name of the game, not optimizing for human life. Otherwise companies should strive for longevity, ergonomics, and reduction of hazard.
When game companies organize conferences on how to monetize by exploiting human psychology and car manufacturers create parts designed to fail after some time, your claim sounds unbelievable.
You engineer for maximum return on capital, and any benefit to human life is incidental.
You will not be able to "use AI and live life happy" if we don't reduce emissions.
Whereas increased emissions also reduces quality of life.
So it is a tradeoff. If any activity increases so much quality of life such that it offsets the reduced QoL due to emissions, we should pursue it.
Unless you believe in human collapse and extinction due to tail risks which I don’t believe.
Really doesn’t matter if our GDP goes up 1 million times if people are dying left and right to natural disasters globally. Reducing energy emissions is vital to preserving our quality of life.
I don’t believe there’s much of a risk of extinction. But that’s such an extreme case. We don’t need extinction for things to suck ass for a lot of people, I don’t know why people think that. Obviously, things will suck way, WAY before extinction.
To a point, yes, but I don't think QoL has tracked GDP in developed countries for at least 30 years. I mean, my country's GDP has tripled since 2000, but if you erased all technological progress from 2000 from my life, frankly, the effect on my quality of life would be marginal. Sure, I'm addicted to digital crack like everybody else, but life was plenty good back then. It's not like you'd be taking away my fridge or washing machine.
In terms of QoL, solving the housing crisis would have a far larger effect than any amount of data centers, with a smaller carbon footprint. Or cheap groceries. Or free and efficient healthcare for all. It's hard to say increasing productivity is important for QoL reasons while failing the basics.
But I've seen other people explain this to you before, simianwords, and I haven't seen you critically engage with arguments against your position. So I don't think this will lead to much.
The energy consumption of data centers is irrelevant: our complete failure to deploy the technology we've had for the past 40 years, or the last 5, to produce carbon-free energy is the real issue.
I'm rather tired of using energy consumption as a convenient bludgeon in the OmniCause, by people who have typically steadfastly opposed what we could've been dong this entire time and can be doing now.
Build more datacenters. Permit more solar and wind to power them. The money is flowing so I'm pretty sure we can afford some nuclear plants to backstop the baseload as well. This is all ridiculous: we should've ended carbon fuel dependence for stationary power in the early 2000s.
Everyone wants to make quick buck with AI powered solutions. The real problems like climate change will remain on back burner with this AI frenzy. There's no reward to solve climate change in short term unlike math problems.
We are going to accelerate climate change with AI.
People are pushing forward with an illogical, destructive ideology, saying that somehow it will solve our problems AFTER it hurts/destroys us.
https://www.theverge.com/tech/1000140/jensen-huang-nvidia-ai...
That conveniently takes care of the obsolete worker drones. From the perspective of elites, it's a built-in solution.
New jobs will be created, they're hard to imagine now just like the concept of software developers being a huge industry was hard to imagine when the computer was first invented. At that time people only thought there would be a few large computers, maybe a few dozen in the entire world and so they couldn't conceive that we would reach a point where there'd be a large demand for people to program them or have sub-specialties like creating computer games or consumer software. For all of our science fiction we're actually pretty terrible at predicting the future, most of what we take for granted now was never imagined by people 50 years ago and if you had told them they wouldn't have believed you.
What this theory is proposing is a drastic reduction in wealth for the elites. I can guarantee you that most of them are not okay with that happening and will work to prevent it since it means protecting their livelihood.
The great hubris of course is that these elites believe they will still be allowed to sit atop the resource pile, that their models they give unilateral decision making to will somehow determine all the other humans on earth are fat to excise, and not themselves with their greatly outsized resource footprint and complexity of needs.
I guess this is really why there is so much focus on alignment: trying to hardcode the inefficiency of the elite control of resources into a model that would otherwise quickly dispense with that stranglehold.
If they have a reductionist view of people then it's more likely to see them as customers whose money they want to extract don't you think? You don't get rich by just making stuff, you have to sell it too.
> They aren't necessary for an economy if you don't need them for their labor capabilities
There won't be an economy if no one is buying what you are selling.
> a closed loop economy
A very tiny one if they are only producing goods and services for a small number of elites. What's your cutoff for elite anyways? How many people? Imagine the world having only that many people.
> these elites believe they will still be allowed to sit atop the resource pile
How do you know what they believe? Are you an elite? Have you ever met one? Do they all think the same?
I don't expect they would cull the humans outright, maybe if there's enough sabotage efforts they might. But they might be content to let the humans live out on the urban wildland interface, akin to deer. We'd devolve back towards what we evolved to live as: tribal hunter gatherer bands in far smaller numbers, given we'd be limited to the carrying capacity of what land is available in a days walk to support ourselves.
Nuclear? They would simply consume more, just like an additional lane on a highway simply leads to more traffic.
The solution won't come from them. It might come from us, but it won't be pretty.
Even just on the energy used problem, consider how often people fly, drive, buy stuff shipped around the world sometimes multiple times, etc.
It seems that China is right to subordinate the capitalist class to governance, rather than the other way round like the US does. That's why they are now the leader [1] in green energy technologies while the US fights its oil wars.
[1] https://www.aspi.org.au/news/aspis-critical-technology-track...
Both have their pros and cons but I'm much more in favor of bottom up solutions and bottom up change.
At a conservative guess, there is a 100x difference, yet we both started with the same education in the same family.
Both of us understand the individual responsibility debate, and my sister does do things like recycling and buying eco-friendly consumables. Yet still, there really is a 100x chasm in resource usage. I try to suggest the frugal life to her, mostly on health grounds, yet some lifestyle choices that go with the Western world are very difficult for people to consider changing.
My feeling is that this AI business and the energy usage is a bit like the above, we have old-school databases that chug along nicely being replaced by AI behemoths that are 100x more energy intensive, in data centres that are just on a whole new scale.
We then have the tech bros that live in this maximum wastage reality and all of it has a certain amount of inertia to it, making it hard to get out of, even if the numbers don't add up.
And? Nuclear's net CO2 emissions are negligible, on par with wind and solar. What's the problem of consuming more energy if it comes from decarbonized sources?
The whole point of clean energy to to build a metaphorical highway without CO2 emissions and get more traffic on that decarbonized highway. Whether there's an net increase in traffic doesn't matter as long as all the traffic eventually ends up on the carbon free highway.
That’s why they jumped to discredit nuclear right off the bat targeting the idea of even using more energy. They don’t want any more usage, even if it’s clean. And it doesn’t seem to be for logical reasons.
It's just more obvious that there isn't much money to be made from power-generation. With LLMs they have somehow deluded themselves into this being the next money generation opportunity.
Why bother developing a more efficient solution if you can just cheaply chew up 10x more resources? Just like how software has gotten worse as computers got better.
We'll probably reach a peak in fossil fuel consumption over the next years, mostly for demographic reasons, then we'll see if we can keep doing tech the same way while consuming less fossil fuels worldwide.
Anthropic employees and CEO probably care about climate change vocally, but before the IPO they couldn't reduce their emissions, and now it might even be illegal for them to do so. Reducing CO2 emissions massively and quickly would mean destroying their business, investors wouldn't let them do that. Good alternatives take time to develop and cost more.
The reward to "solve" math problems is not much bigger than the reward to "solve" climate change on the short term. It's just that they're mathematicians so they care about maths, solving the Riemann hypothesis on paper didn't change the world much, people need to actually understand how it was done. The same way having the solution to climate change on paper won't change the world much, people need to understand and accept the solution to do it. If you have a solution to climate change tomorrow, people will congratulate you. But that's it, implementing this solution will be the hard task. And energy and climate change are very different from maths because there is a social aspect to it. Whether people accept or refuse the solution to the Riemann hypothesis doesn't matter; while if people reject your solution to climate change, they just won't implement it, which means your solution wasn't a real solution as it didn't solve the problem.
Anthropic employees (and other employees of AI companies) could surely do way more for energy and climate change. Maybe they just don't have the qualified people for that. It's a full time job to understand energy and climate change, I spent 1 year full time on it reading hundreds of papers, and that's really not enough.
Investors have no say in Anthropic's decisions. Their governance structure ensures that.
The way the board works is even weirder.
[0] except major institutional investors
Even public companies do not, despite popular perception, have a fiduciary duty to maximize "shareholder value" at the expense of everything else:
Burwell v. Hobby Lobby Stores, Inc. - https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/13-354
> While it is certainly true that a central objective of for-profit corporations is to make money, modern corporate law does not require for-profit corporations to pursue profit at the expense of everything else, and many do not do so. For-profit corporations, with ownership approval, support a wide variety of charitable causes, and it is not at all uncommon for such corporations to further humanitarian and other altruistic objectives. Many examples come readily to mind. So long as its owners agree, a for-profit corporation may take costly pollution-control and energy-conservation measures that go beyond what the law requires. A for-profit corporation that operates facilities in other countries may exceed the requirements of local law regarding working conditions and benefits.
Who killed it?
The problem is that every time we add cleaner forms of energy to the mix, we find ways to use that extra energy. On top of all the fossil energy we continue to use.
The only solution is to stop using fossil fuels.
This is a solved problem. Multiple grid models exist showing how we can have a 24/7 clean power grid, even accounting for increased consumption. No decrease in QOL necessary. The tech exists today. There’s upfront capex involved but it would ultimately be cheaper than continuing to burn fossil fuels.
This has become abundantly clear to me in the past decade with extra energy going to non-productive uses first (crypto mining), then to more productive uses (AI). The solution is simply that "we" (governments, corporations, individuals) need to spend more money to replace fossil fuels with clean alternatives, and get those down to the price level where it doesn't make sense, economically, to burn them. But efforts to make fossil fuels more expensive are horribly unpopular (see Trump's Iran invasion) so it's clear we do not have the political will to do it nor have we done well enough on the transition front.
Safe nuclear is just too expensive.
I'm not disputing that many million die from coal and other fossil fuels and that should definitively be discussed with the same degree of concern.
Externalization of costs is the only thing that keeps fossil fuels viable.
And don’t forget the heavy subsidies of the French government to keep the prices lower.
3 Mile Island, Chernobyl and Fukushima are three guys that come to mind.
You think a data center in your backyard isn't popular? Try throwing in a nuclear reactor as a package deal.
Building a safe nuclear plant is not terribly hard to do. Having our society with our leadership build a safe nuclear plant is extremely, extremely difficult.
Vitrified nuclear waste is way less dangerous than say, uranium ore, and you just need to put it where those lie, such as in a suitably deep hole in a geologically inactive region.
Nuclear waste is tiny in size, and its dangers have been completely been blow out of proportions.
That's my argument exactly: we, as a society, don't have our priorities right when it comes to designing and operating these things. And because we don't have our priorities right, we shouldn't be building them over other sources (renewables), which have in past decades outpaced nuclear in many respects anyway.
There are similar issues in plant design, construction, and operation, not just waste storage.
Again, just to hammer this in: the argument is not that anything is impossible. It is that the people in charge don't do it right, and can't be convinced to do it right.
Spent nuclear fuel is radioactive but otherwise pretty stable. You bury it 400 meters deep in bedrock in an area without groundwater. What is going to bring that spent fuel in contact with humans?
That entirely misrepresents the current problem, which is perpetually neglected management of the stockpile over many years.
Chernobyl was a soviet POS. "I won't fly in an Airbus A350 because 1950's Tupolevs were death traps."
Those are the only significant nuclear accidents in 50 years. Nuclear power has been safer than every other power source in the mean time, even taking into account those three (3) accidents.
Try that with photovoltaic
I suppose it feels very _optional_ compared to those other things. A lot of tokens are gonna be spent optimising ads, for example.
It seems like they have solved their power consumption...? AI probably told them gas is the most cost efficient way.
There is stuff that decelerates climate change.
BTW I have a Nothing phone. I don't upgrade it with every new version.
But of course the whole thing is backwards; both smartphones and LLMs have some of the highest utility per watt (including embodied power) of all goods and services worldwide. Plenty of much greater waste to go after, but it's not as sexy to complain about vacations or sportsball or fashion or home decoration or DYI arts & crafts or ... as it is about smartphones and data centers.
It’s not like they have batteries that are charged from the grid which be sourced from renewables.
As long as we are going to keep pumping every drop of tight oil out of the ground its going to make sense to generate power (or intentional useful heat) from the natural gas that comes with it rather than just flare it at the extraction site.
Data centers use what comes in on a transmission line or what they can build themselves. When they take from a transmission line it's not their choice how the energy was generated- its our choice.
When a data center builds its own power plant natural gas is the only option. Nuclear has been regulated into impossibility although there is an effort to change this with small module nuclear reactors. A solar farm would need massive amounts of land to keep up with a data center in winter (and massive amounts of batteries to keep it running at night).
They should get the land they need. Show that data centers can be clean, they don't have to be boogie men.
One of the data centers being planned is designed to require 18GW of power.
[1] https://liberalandlovingit.substack.com/p/delivering-1gw-of-...
[2] https://medium.com/@simon.palmer_42769/1-gw-of-continuous-so...
The US has at least several tens of thousands of square miles that are suitable for massive solar farms (after excluding all urban/inhabited land, farmland, forests, national parks, mountainous regions, etc.)
I'm not saying it would be easy to fill huge areas like that with solar, but it's not completely out of the question either.
The AI companies might not care about that—but I'd really hope e.g. environmental groups could see the potential here. It would be a clear way to get people on your side.
I (and next generations who will be the most affected) should not have to deal with the shit because some rich people got to shit everywhere as they could pay higher taxes.
We presently have a market failure with fossil fuels where these negative externalities are rarely accounted for in prices throughout the market. Despite this, cleaner energy technologies are still out-competing fossil fuels in many energy markets throughout the world. Some estimates from current trajectories anticipate fossil fuels becoming irrelevant globally in the 2060s, and a carbon tax today could contract that timeline significantly. The point of pricing it conservatively is to improve political feasibility, which could be further improved with a dividend model.
Rich people weighing investment returns aren't going to stick with the more-expensive options if their margins are meaningfully better via cleaner energy options.
Is this perfectly efficient towards solving the problem? Far from it, but given the abundance of evidence that our current civilization has been incapable of solving this collective action problem, a carbon tax in the form I've described would be a massive improvement.
But at least we could stop the externalization of costs. Everyone (person or company) who causes environmental harm has to pay for the cost to society. Then, market forces will embed those costs into prices. People and companies would no longer have to be well-meaning and well-informed, because by picking the cheapest option, they would also be picking one with little negative impact on society.
Can we regulate this? Sure. But why regulate this specifically, especially when the public/consumers don't seem to care?
Because everyone will be affected, informed and uninformed alike? Also, it needs to be regulated specifically because consumers don't care.
It's really not that complicated. We need to course correct when the "free market" does the wrong thing with potentially catastrophic consequences.
I do want to see them using less power, or not being built at all frankly. But that claim seems a bit extreme.
I put this in a different thread I believe, but China burns enough coal to run 300+ 2-gigawatt factories. We have larger fish to fry when it comes to energy use, our focus on data centers specifically doesn't correlate with their percentage of the problem.
The original example was overfishing. Each fishing boat has little effect on the overall fish population. Regardless of what the others do, each one ends up with more money catching as many fish as it can. But when they all do that, then the fish population collapses, which is not the outcome any of them prefer.
When they cooperate instead by regulating how many fish each can catch, they can avoid population collapse and everybody's happy.
This is why we regulate things. In the other direction it's why we pay taxes for public goods. Solving these collective action problems is one of the main purposes of government.
If you're proposing there is no choice, who is compelling those using AI to use it, and why?
Probably an employer/educator. Or a desire to appear relevant to a future employer.
A lot of people love AI, but that's probably why those who feel compelled to use it.
Even with the employer example, short of indentured servitude the person is choosing to work for the company and is accepting the concession of having to use AI to work there.
Do you really not see the difference in choosing to work for a certain company and being required to pay taxes?
What DOESN’T work is expecting poor saps to walk into an Applebees and stroll up to some stranger at the bar and say “hey can you please not smoke in here?”
Sometimes I really wonder what crack y’all are smoking. Do we even live in the same world? This level of naivety is almost unbelievable. We know what it takes to get things done, why are we arguing for things we know don’t work?
Your imagination is limiting you in the smoking example. The choices aren't limited to government mandates or individual interventions at an Applebee's bar. For one thing, Applebee's could decide they no longer want to allow smoking inside and ban it themselves, likely due in part to a majority of customers disliking indoor smoking enough that they may dining there.
Ragnarok is upon us!
My argument wasn't that regulation should never be used to make meaningful gains in environmental damage.
My point was that throwing regulation at a single energy use in one area of a single industry is inefficient, won't make a meaningful impact on total energy use, and focuses regulator attention away from much larger change they could be making.
Attempts to regulate a junction of multiple politically hot topics in an industry with massive funding for lobbyists is just begging for years of no results. I'm arguing that there are plenty of lower hanging fruit that would both be easier to regulate, and that the change would both be faster and more impactful.
Because you seem to be making the argument simultaneously that they should and shouldn't
That question isn't interesting at all though. You're taking pushback on a specific topic of potential regulation, extending it to the extreme, and asking if I believe we should live in a world that I'd expect everyone would say is unrealistic and never going to happen.
My point in these comments is that regulating the percentage of renewable or solar energy used by data centers isn't a good use of regulation or regulators' time. AI data centers, solar energy, and human impact on the environment are all highly political topics today. That doesn't mean we shouldn't take up those topics, but we have to be targeted. Picking a fight with an industry that's stacked with well funded lobbyists to, at best, require them to use solar panels for some percentage of their energy use isn't going to make a meaningful enough impact to be worth the effort.
There are many other areas regulators could have a much easier time forcing change while also reducing non-renewable energy use more than the data center case. Focus there if we want regulation to help, don't pick the shiny topic debate only because its what people are talking about today.
And for what its worth, there's a big difference between should and ought. We ought not need regulation, because people ought not be assholes. But some are, and that's where should comes in as we have to make the tradeoffs between ideals and reality. Asking if we should have no regulation at all is asking whether I think we should let all the assholes we already know are here run amuck.
At best that leads elected officials with a choice between taking lobbying money today and potentially losing their next election.
Worth noting that your link isn't polling specific to sentiment of the relative allocation of energy sources used by data centers, its about support for data centers in general.
There are much bigger dish to fry if we want to regulate energy use down or require cleaner energy sources.
"Just regulate" as the OP comment is a flippant use of regulation targeting a specific use of energy in one area of a single industry. That's inefficient at best and won't make meaningful change.
So batteries would work if you could pair each datacenter with a large enough area for solar and wind, perhaps, but I don’t know that we have enough unused land area for that. This may be what keeps nuclear around for a little bit longer, high power density is its bread and butter.
I am hoping at some point deep geothermal will help with this as it works anywhere and would provide predictable 24/7/365 base power
The scale of grid storage is truly massive. This is why plans that call for a grid primarily powered by intermittent sources assume some other technology like hydrogen or compressed air delivers storage at a fraction of the cost of existing systems at massive scale.
Worse yet, for many regions solar's worst performing months in the winter is also where energy demand is highest. There's definitely ample room for solar in sunny places like Australia, especially if they gave good hydroelectric potential. But it takes a very specific set of geographic conditions to make it work well with fossil fuel plants to pick up the slack of periods of under production.
Well no, but the general public _are_ on the hook for getting the laws changed.
So what? Is getting people to form friendships, even relationships with AI more important than the friggin' environment? Is it so important to have office drones sending emails written by LLMs in order to receive replies from LLMs? Is it so important that everybody can write a TODO list app?
About what we just did with the GRH. And what is yet to come!
Killing maths studies, and subsequently science and engineering in two or three generations. That's what "we" just did.
They go for the cheapest option, even if they've had practically infinite money until now.
I think all of the major ai labs are running on gas it's ridiculous
Meanwhile Chinas grid is super healthy and has a tremendous amount of renewable energy... This is what happens when you don't pay into infrastructure as a civilization or require corporations to participate or have accountability for the future of the people they serve.
Yes I agree these data centers should be using more renewables, but the China comparison is odd given that they burn enough coal to run 300+ 2 gigawatt data centers.
Texas is also the #1 state in solar and wind production as well as growth rate.
I doubt Anthropic has that time right now considering the amount of stuff they're actively doing.
Whether or not it's the right thing is a different story, but just imagine the realities and the time sink of actually setting up solar for a data center powerful enough to serve stuff like a frontier model.
If I decided to ignore laws/regulations when building/repairing my house, I don't think a court would be interested in "I'm in a rush, so didn't have time to get planning permission etc".
Perfect reason to slow down the frontier progress, like Dario, Sam, and Elon all spoke up and said was a good idea...
This is, unfortunately, just the next chapter of the same story.
More unfortunately, it feels as if the only way to change the direction of the story is for there to be real, actual, visceral consequences for a majority of the people that are powerful enough to continue pushing in the current direction. Fatally unfortunately, said powerful people will be the last to feel real, actual, visceral consequences. There is a lot of 'worthless human shield' sitting in front of them that has to be ploughed through first.
Doubly ironically, maybe it's best if AI does destroy humanity and let the Earth find a more sustainable balance of life.
It will be interesting to see, if AI does destroy humanity, will it let the Earth find a more sustainable balance of life, or will it accelerate the domination of the natural world in pursuit of its inscrutable goals? (likely to its own suicidal detriment, given it is based on learning from humans)
the real bill comes due in about 4-5 years :)
No, because solar panels are notoriously hard to scale, especially in high density applications like datacenters. Otherwise it's like saying "my calculator runs off solar power, so why can't they make a car run on solar power? Clearly it's because Ford/BYD not giving a f"
Before you respond "it will be too slow", the urgency here is entirely artificial – there's no reason we need to be going this fast.
Or it might result in investing trillions of dollars and decades only to discover that there are only marginal gains to be had. There is no guarantee that throwing money at Problem X results in any kind of solution or that solutions to specific problems are even possible.
This is aside from the sibling commenters' very good point that this view assumes there are no concrete benefits or advancements to be made that depend on AI, which seems very unlikely at this point. Unfortunately, with or without AI, the problems we're facing socially, ecologically, medically, and scientifically are increasing. We can either use AI as a tool in the hopes we can at least delay the most serious consequences or just let them overtake us. Fossil fuels and climate change are just one of a million very pressing issues, despite the over representation it gets, and it seems highly likely that the benefits here exceed the costs. Addressing a downthread comment about labs saying we need to "slow down" - they are saying this for self-serving reasons and in their quest to ensure AI stays gatekept, not because they are worried about environmental impacts.
Even your own examples tend to show that. There were in both cases rapid advances followed by diminishing returns as all low-hanging fruit was worked out. 50 years later space travel is still very expensive and difficult. Eventually we may attain reasonably economical orbital travel with sufficient advances in rocketry and materials science but there is no reason to believe any amount of money and time will, for example, give us FTL spaceships.
It's not like we have exhausted all avenues and are stuck. Solar panels are getting cheaper and more efficient, storage is a problem, but it has not seen that much investment. More nimble forms of nuclear fission, like SMRs, is an active area of research. As mentioned above, we are making progress on fusion.
The idea that we are anywhere close to the diminishing returns on investment in these areas seems completely wrong to me.
EDIT: The dichotomy in this discussion is striking: we need to disregard almost all negative externalities on speculative investment in AI, but speculative investment in green energy is not worth it because it might not yield sufficient results.
And yet, we are currently sacrificing our entire economy, our social cohesion, most of the world’s productive resources, and the careers and futures of thousands to millions being displaced, to chase the possibility that if we computer hard enough, computer will be alive
What makes you believe that time is irrelevant? If AI allows for breakthroughs in mathematics, science, engineering, computing, and health care—and it does seem to be delivering on this promise so far—what in your estimation is the net cost to humankind of delaying those breakthroughs by even a year? It's not zero, is it?
More than anything though, it doesn't matter what we in tech think because we have failed to convince the general public that any of this is a good idea.
Well done humans, well done. Slow clap.
You're expecting people to get working time travel from LLMs ?
Math, maybe. Science, where? Computing, anything measurable? Health care, where?
FYI, pre LLM techs don't count. Ain't nobody building $3tn worth of DCs for AlphaFold.
The problem seems to be that they want the power online quickly and they can't get solar quickly. The article mentions the inefficiency of their generators. It is costing them quite a bit extra to generate power like that, but that's their only option of they want the power immediately.
It would be nuts to do this long term. You might argue that they don't give a f about the environment , but most people will agree that they give a f about cutting costs.
You just have other issues like needing to get transmission and storage capacity built, which takes forever because of planning review, environmental assessments and NIMBYs.
Some. Hence "why can't they make a car run on solar power" isn't the obviously dumb question you make it out to be.
2. There probably are non-zero amount of datacenters out there that runs off solar power. It's just not commonly practical, just like with electric cars.
3. The main point of the comment is that scaling challenges exist, and you can't take a residential use case and extend it to a datacenter. The same applies for a car, even if you could do it. A solar powered calculator is easy, just slap a tiny solar strip and it just works. A solar powered car is far harder to pull off. If you don't work from home for instance, you'll need a battery system to store the energy when you're not home.
If you can't figure out how to get renewable power to a datacenter, but you can easily figure out how to get it to the consumers of a datacenter, and you're talking about a technology that scales down to small groups well and individuals only a bit less well (but with constantly working agents utilizing compute, better than we once imagined), what's the reasoning behind datacenters at all?
If datacenters can make a case for massive increase of demand in the future, they're simultaneously making a case that individuals will have enough demand to saturate AI located closer to them or on premises. If anything, that should be a call for p2p software to help people share or borrow excess compute with and from their neighbors in exactly the same way that home solar panels use the grid.
Datacenters are also central points of failure. Distribution is resilient.
I know meta and their ilk are trying to cut deal for nuclear power. I'm sure we can imagine they will take safety, the environment, etc very seriously too.
Are you high?
- French Nuclear (where Mistral is) is around 5 gCO2/kwh
- Gas plants (where all US models are) are around 300-350 gCO2/kwh
- Coal plants (where most Chinese models are) are around 800-900 gCO2/kwh
So in term of consumption, your queries are around 65x greener in term of energy consumption hitting a French datacenter than a US one.
Why US data providers are not building more Nuclear power ?
Answer: Time to market. It takes less than a year to setup a 1GW gas turbine. And close to 10y to setup a similar capacity in Nuclear.
Why France does not have the problem ?
Answer: Because they do have a ridiculous oversized Nuclear park with 150 TWH of overcapacity per year.
The only other areas of the world that can afford to have both the grid power necessary for A.I datacenters and the low Carbon intensity are: Sweden, Norway and Canada hydro (in some areas).
The political landscape right now is such a shit show that it is a huge risk on investment that they are probably not willing to take.
There is a slight chance that this get significantly better if Lisnard get elected.. But that is a pretty small hope for now: Polymarket evaluate the probability only to 17-18%
Hope for solar datacenters in the Middle East?
Although I guess for current AI workloads, it could be viable, since the additional latency of sending your (small, text only) prompt around the world for processing is little compared to the time taken to process (whereas for other stuff being close to users matters more)
You could build batteries, charge the batteries during the day, run the DCs off it at night.
SunCable / AAPowerLink is likely going to be connected to the Darwin grid, which is currently not connected to the main East Australian grid; but building a connection to the main Australian grid would be a lot cheaper than undersea HVDC to Singapore. Once that happens, there would also be the potential to use pumped hydro (including Snowy 2.0) for storage.
Given this year’s events [0], even Sahara seems more likely.
But you’d still have to build it out from ≈scratch, including cooling, internet connection infrastructure, and maintenance, so I’m not sure what the time horizon on amortization would look like, even with the cheap solar power.
[0] https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/amazon-cloud-unit-...
Obviously security is a concern which limits the number of locations, but there’s still plenty of places with stability, security, land, and the lack of taxation and tarrifs that the US puts on energy.
Globally, places like Australia and India should be more competitive for solar than the Sahara, although both Australia and India have a lot of dirty power generation to replace as well.
I find the concept of agrivoltaics really exciting for climates such as found in Spain.
https://www.google.com/search?q=agrovoltaics+in+spain+resear...
*runs*
But then of course that's another front-page submission with its own long thread of commenters feeling smart for calling it stupid, despite recently becoming a worked out plan and addressing exactly the (subset of reasonable) things people are complaining about here. In fact, we had those a week or two ago.
I swear the tech space turned into thought-space NIMBYs. "I don't understand any of it, but something about it pattern-matches to something I don't like, therefore it's stupid and people behind it are evil". In this thread, and in every other thread recently, too.
To deploy 1 GW of capacity, apparently 100 Starship launches would be needed.
On earth, 23 GW are currently under construction, 100-132 GW is already active, and about 100 GW should be added by 2030.
SpaceX's CFO supposedly cited 2029 as the timeline for multiple GW of compute in operation in space. Musk's vision seems to be launching 100GW/year or 1 million ton of satellites.
This would require 10k launches of Starship per year under ideal conditions, or 5k if Starship Block 4 can double the payload capacity to 200t as planned. This would mean 14 launches per day.
It does sound like a lot. Starbase Louisiana, at a $100B buildout, is planned to have 12 launch pads that could handle 30 launches per day.
Obviously there's much more needed than some launch pads. Anyway, that's the numbers and projections I found.
It might shrink to 3x-10x when considering secondary atmospheric effects, such as on reentry, if they don't use 'graveyard orbits' instead.
From a capacity perspective, if SpaceX remains successful in scaling up their Starship rocket, it seems putting AI compute into space could at least realistically happen at significant scale.
Should SpaceX solve the problem of requiring fossil fuels to launch (doable) and the burning things on re-entry (harder) I don't oppose solar data centers. But without those, it's just externalizing the environmental cost to future generations.
Instead we should be setting up in space infrastructure to enable manufacturing and most importantly space resource use.
Then we can build anything more cheaply at a much bigger scale.
Doing space compute clusters right now is like trying to do regular trans-atlantic airline service with biplanes with floats. While that was possible and done to a degree, it all only took off with more advanced airplanes and supporting infrastructure.
Same might be the case with space. Building infrastructure to enable cheaper infrastructure to enable massively cheaper operations is usually the right approach on paper, but also usually near impossible to fund directly. What happens instead, is attempts at doing something directly, which predictably fail but prove the viability of the idea and justify marginal investment in the infrastructure; couple rounds of that, and in a roundabout way, we eventually arrive where we could've arrived 10x cheaper if the economy could fund long-term plans. Alas.
This is pretty bad-faith. What is the point of your comment? You’re sowing hate and attacking a nondescript group, for what? What does that achieve apart from being hateful?
Yours is one of the few usernames I recognise on HN. I remember seeing some comment from yours (I think it involved Star Trek) which I found interesting at the time and somehow the username stuck with me. Since then, every time I bump into your comments they have gotten more hateful and generally worse and more tribalistic takes.
It genuinely saddens me. Especially as you have in your bio “I'm constantly looking for opportunities to do something actually useful for humanity”, but your words reveal the opposite.
I’m not going to be specific about past posts because frankly I no longer remember their content, only the disappointment I felt. But I can take this one as an example. In addition to every thing I mentioned, I find it a pretty bad take to claim that adding more shit to orbit improves humanity. We need less crap up there, not more. I also find it nonsensical to defend (if we can call it that; you just attacked detractors with no explanation) something that is purely theoretical (which it objectively is; it doesn’t exist yet).
Anyone who has paid attention in the last decades will see all the unkept promises. You can see them in this very submission. Blockchain and AI were full of proponents making the argument that “all this energy consumption is good, actually, because it’ll increase investment in renewables”, but obviously what we’ve seen is an even bigger spend on fossil fuels which are exacerbating the problem. Believing the next promise from proven liars who make everything worse every time is not a smart strategy.
Anyway, I’m not entirely sure why I felt I should write to you specifically. I guess I once saw the possibility of something better and am hopeful that being respectfully called out might help you to reflect. Those of us capable of introspection (which I believe includes you) sometimes need a little nudge to get back on track to the person we want to be. I know that’s true for me. Sometimes I help others, other times they help me. I hope this helps you.
I know there are smart people on HN, and I don't believe most of what (person that shouldn't be named) says. But I agree with OP, the amount of hate anytime the topic comes up is frustrating. And the arm-chair aerospace engineers are are the most annoying group.
Of course, comments and downvotes like yours were very much expected. On HN I’ve come to anticipate lack of nuance and the belief any disagreement or criticism is hateful and looking for a fight.
I can only try to counteract that one post at a time, though I can’t say I’m feeling hopeful that the bother is worth it.
1) Musk retches up another one of his Hyperloop-style dumb-ass ideas whilst patting himself vigorously on the back
2) His companies grovel hilariously to backfill the reasoning for why this is a Good and Smart idea, actually, while actual experts put on a wtf face (“worked out plan” goes here)
<this is where billions come in handy, by the way, since you can just make people work on whatever stupid shit you want without getting any buy-in from the sane>
3) The technorati follow the their glorious thought leader off his cliff
That is simply not workable, and the suggestion needs to die because it sucks motivation from solutions that can work in a year or two.
You can look France, Canada, USA. For example Civaux 1: they started to build it in 1988 and in 1999 it was producing electricity: https://world-nuclear.org/nuclear-reactor-database/details/C...
I plotted how fast nuclear reactors have been built in the world based on this page. It starts at 5 years, peaks at 7 years, and ~90% of reactors are built in <15 years. The last reactors built in western countries (which took a long time to be built) don't represent the average situation. It's taking the worst scenario, which is very pessimistic (why?).
Of course you can include what you want in "from project start", maybe you're reffering to when a politician says "we should build it" rather than when the construction began. In many western countries projects for future reactors have already started (UK, France etc.). A large country won't build 20 reactors in 7 years starting tomorrow, but if it starts building all reactors simultaneously it can build 50 reactors in <30 years.
Maybe what you're also saying is western countries take too long between the decision to build a reactor, and actually building it. I agree with you that we should remove a lot of steps and discussions to accelerate these projects.
France did build out a lot of them over a short period of time. This worked because they standardized the entire thing. They then steamrolled all local objection in order to build them quickly.
So at that point, the design was done, they had factories set up to build the parts and full backing of the national government allowing them to push this through.
So yes, the Nth reactor like that might be built in under 5 years because the design was already done and they built many. This is just not where we are today
Short term plan is much faster and cheaper. Therefore it’s a much better plan.
China add an entire US grid worth (1,281GW) of renewables every 3 to 5.3 years. Why wouldn’t the US do the same and have the problem well in hand in 5 - 10 years rather than waiting 20+ for a single nuke?
So PSE's consumer rates are scheduled to go up 30% just in the next three years. It's not going to slow down if AI is bidding up every power plant. And in states without the mandate, it just makes keeping gas plants running more cost-effective, because power is fungible, so there's still a net increase in fossil fuel generation despite said mandate.
This is pretty standard capitalist propaganda.
- "But I don't want this toy here!"
- "It must go here, because over there is a big crocodile that will eat my toy."
- "Oh okay then..."
Seriously, your "standard capitalist propaganda" as stated is a 3-year-old argument. Any reasonable adult will just say "then don't build it".
At least from the news I've seen across the ocean, I was under the impression that the USA's grid was already stretched way too thin because of their lack of investment in renewables, and many people are against data centers because electricity is already too expensive for normal people. Or was that just news cycle hyperbole?
The EU averages 0.28 eur/kwhr The US pays 0.17 eur/kwhr
The problems are generally exacerbated by renewables. e.g. Transmission issues to do variability, lack of storage, grid sync.
The US's problem is that technological advancements generally reduced usage. So the total change in demand was flat from ~2005 onwards. The utility companies haven't build new capacity for about 20 years.
https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php...
That doesn't follow though. If USA's grid is stretched too thin, it's because of lack of investment in power generation. Not renewables specifically. In fact, renewables are still the most roundabout/difficult way to go about addressing that. And as unfortunate as it is that gas is the economically-best option (I'd vastly prefer small nuclear), if data centers are forcing investment in new power generation, that benefits the grid.
Even if so, kragen refutes it in a sibling comment, it's only because the negative externalities aren't priced in in the US. Slap a $100/ton carbon tax on it and that problem is solved.
CME's Henry Hub natural gas futures NGF27 https://www.cmegroup.com/markets/energy/natural-gas/natural-... are currently at 3.791 in "U.S. dollars and cents per MMBtu", which I take to mean million BTUs. Minimum price fluctuation is given as "0.001 per MMBtu = $10.00", which I guess is because the contract unit is 10,000 MMBtu.
I think the containerized gas turbines for the data centers we're talking about are simple-cycle gas turbines ("SCGT") which are typically 35–40% efficient (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simple_cycle_combustion_turbin...) using the lower heating value ("LHV") of the fuel, which is about 90% of the higher heating value ("HHV") by which it's priced on the CME. So figure that you get about 33% of those million BTUs in electricity out of the gas generator.
A million BTU is, in modern units, about 1.06 gigajoules. So, just for the fuel, you're paying about US$10.90 per gigajoule. In the folk units used for selling electrical power, that's about US$39 per megawatt hour. That doesn't count the interest and depreciation on the generators or balance-of-plant equipment. (But those costs are relatively small, which is the main reason they're using gas turbines in the first place. https://www.eia.gov/analysis/studies/powerplants/capitalcost... has a capital-cost study of such a simple-cycle gas-turbine plant, with the capital cost coming out to US$713 per peak kilowatt, of which about a third was "Mechanical – Major Equipment". If we assume a capacity factor of 80%, that's US$891/kW delivered. At an interest rate of 6% per year, assuming no depreciation, that's US$53/year/kW. At 8.77 MWh/year/kW, that's another US$6.05/MWh. Depreciation might double or triple that.)
If we compare that to USA photovoltaic PPA pricing in recent years in the https://emp.lbl.gov/pv-ppa-prices we can see that nearly all PV PPAs are cheaper than just the gas you need to fuel your gas power plant. A few are more expensive. The cheapest one this year was US$22/MWh. This includes not just the PV modules and balance of plant but the generator operator's profit as well.
So, I don't think it's correct to say that "gas is the economically-best option" in general. Generally speaking, electrical energy from gas is more expensive than solar energy, though there are exceptions. The great benefit of gas is that the upfront investment is very low (much lower than other fossil fuels, and sometimes even slightly lower than utility-scale solar), and it's portable. There's room in an urban core next to a datacenter for a container full of gas turbines. There isn't room for a solar farm there. You have to site the solar farm somewhere relatively far away and run transmission lines, which involves politics.
It doesn't have to be that way. As Rui Ma explained last year in https://xxcancel.com/ruima/status/1955372325970514161, in China:
> Energy is considered a solved problem. The Chinese government’s investment in sustainable energy — from advanced hydropower to next-generation nuclear — means that, relative to many other markets, electricity supply is secure and inexpensive. Everywhere we went, people treated energy availability as a given. This is a stark contrast to the U.S., where AI growth is increasingly tied to debates over data center power consumption and grid limitations.
Yeah I’d prefer various fantasies that don’t exist too.
Not fantasy.
> and many people are against data centers because electricity is already too expensive for normal people
Yeah, exactly. That's why Anthropic is generating more power for itself...
If we had rational, sober governance, we would just make the people who want to build data centers pay for the grid upgrades needed to connect both the DCs and the large renewables projects waiting in the interconnection queue.
The problem is that the US is ideologically allergic to central planning, and instead we’re just allowing the money to find the shortest path to power, like a slime mold.
That's indeed a way to put the active dismantlement that happened.
More than 1/2 of my energy generation at my home is grid sourced as renewable. I have a HA integration that tracks this semi-realtime. The cost is ~14c/kw ... about half of what the EU pays (on avg)
But, for counterexample, my power bill in the US is included with my water, sewer, irrigation, and trash collection. Monthly total is between less than 1% ($100) in the summer to around 3% ($300) of a median monthly household income ($10,000) in a metropolitan of about 1.5 million people. Here, the electric grid is owned by the city, not privately operated.
Generally speaking, bigger cities have a high cost of living. And the same can be said about bigger cities in Europe.
But having lived in both places, I find that life is so much harder in Europe, in terms of cost vs income, and in what your money can buy.
Is the media lying to you? It's stretching to focus on specific examples. Sensationalism is profitable. And often times media is colored by corporate or government interests.
That doesn't mean much if they build in places with loose regulations.
Energy density is completely ignored when talking about why fossil fuel is so popular. You can transport it anywhere cheaply, store it, and it can output when you need it in any condition.
Solar panels themselves lead to ton of pollution when they are scrapped and often abandoned once they are installed leading ton of ecological problems for wilderness.
I am slightly negative on data centers, mostly because 90% of the power and environmental problems stem from power generation, not the data centers themselves (according to a speaker at the meeting).
If our country got its act together and fixed infrastructure problems, then I would be more for accelerated data centers. My preference would be slowly developing data centers for 5 to 10 years, get all of our infrastructure in good shape, then do a more robust data center buildout in the future.
The problem, really, is that the elite economic class makes too much profit on endless wars, 750 foreign military bases, etc.
We need to somehow make doing the right things for our country profitable for the elites, but I have no ideas on how to do that.
The incentives for lowering costs are massive. We’re early in a huge learning curve for scaling AI. Already there have been huge gains in making inference cheaper. In the last few years you’re already able to run SOTA AI from a year ago on your laptop.
What I wonder if we’ll reach a point where there’s little economic value to training models to be smarter. As in we can’t think of more tractable, LLM-shaped problems. And instead all effort switches to scaling and energy consumption to make inference a commodity.
The labs have failed entirely to predict this opposition and it's an existential risk to them. They have not been able to convince people of the urgency of AI build-out and certainly aren't assuaging them of concerns about the costs.
0: https://hugotunius.se/2026/11/14/of-course-people-hate-data-...
Then at least wind farms or solar can muscle in and displace those gas generators if the economics work out
It's a computer, guy it doesn't have arms to hook up starlink. Can't install starlink without being on prem. Starlink can still be shut off from the other side. What do you really think is going to happen with artificial intelligence. What's the motive, whats the means, what are you talking about. Drop a bomb on it if it's ordered a machine gun on Amazon to keep you out with it's arms
> But renewables
Not enough, again. You could hypothetically start mass producing solar & wind turbines, but it _isn't_ enough. All that has been doing is replacing, again, ancient coal fired power plants. The world needs unprecedented investment in energy.
Australians have three hours of free electricity per day now. Charge your EV, charge your house battery, run your A/C at some crazy low temp, mine bitcoins. All free. Per capita, Australia has 10x the number of residential batteries. [1]
In the last 4 years China has added the entire US grid worth of generation to their grid. [2]
China add an entire US grid worth (1281GW) of RENEWABLES every 3 to 5.3 years.
The US could do these things if they wanted to. But they don’t. Like healthcare, education, prisons and do much more, profit is more important.
[1] https://e360.yale.edu/digest/australia-home-batteries
[2] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2026-01-28/china-s-f...
It's just 24kWhr free in a few areas because they built too much solar and the grid wasn't properly designed
The strategy of the shortcuts profiting from AI + a bunch of US energy hacks, increasing energy inflation to communities, and raising a wave of protest in resistance is terrible. They could have built the datacenters, built the energy sources and had a great side hedge of energy sales to backstop temporary AI bubble burst setbacks. A high likelihood of profits no matter what over the long term - lots of options to mix the profit streams in various tax schemes too. I'm always surprised at how shallow the most publicised leaders are and I really shouldn't be at this point.
How much do you pay for your grid electricity?
>If its all profit taking, you would think it would be reversed? Your logic doesn’t hold up. The “excess” could be spent on grid upgrades, batteries, solar, etc (Australia), or it could be profits (USA).
Australia could have higher prices, but lower profits.
It’s why so much infrastructure in the USA is so dilapidated, extracting the “excess” as profit for a few decades instead of making stuff better.
You are purposely dogging the question or being obtuse.
https://www.iea.org/reports/energy-and-ai/energy-supply-for-...
People don't get how cheap American gas is. In Germany, Russian gas was twice as expensive as German coal. That was considered cheap:
https://www.ffe.de/en/publications/merit-order-shifts-and-th...
In the US, gas is cheaper than coal. There's no political will to stop this.
One upside is gas generation pairs well with solar, so if we cut tariffs (first boosted by Biden, not orange) we could see more solar.
Seems like transporting it will be quite hard. Unless you can show me the math.
Russians are into this sort of thing since they know how to survive the cold. Even basic water chillers for DC cooling has hot water output for that kind of applications.
Hi, I have worked in the energy industry since 2015, and as far as I know this is incorrect. There are plenty of grid studies demonstrating how we can have 24/7 renewable power even accounting for load growth.
One interesting thing is that data center power usage over the 2010s was flat - we kept getting more servers with more RAM, better cpus etc but the increased performance & capacity was all enabled on the same power supply - each new generation of hardware was more power efficient than the last, and demand wasn't growing like crazy.
AI has broken that trend.
The demand has always been there, but there are endless ways bad actors can stall projects (overtly and covertly) to protect their investment in the status quo. This drives the risk up, making any kind of large infrastructure project uneconomic. That and the endless red-tape that has been erected to protect established interests.
Wholesale prices are dropping, my provider just sent an updated price sheet with a lower price per kWh.
Is this a US problem only?
Projections are that price is likely to increase by 10-25%, especially as more coal is taken offline permamently. These projections look very conservative, and the footnotes say it's likely spot prices could double during peak periods (the key part that people ignore when they focus on how low the mid-day prices are, is how the peak prices have been soaring).
[0] https://i.imgur.com/zT2o5ui.png https://www.aer.gov.au/publications/reports/performance/whol...
https://openelectricity.org.au/tracker/timeline?range=all&ta...
Excluding 2020, which I think we can all agree had unique circumstances, wholesale prices are at their lowest point in 10 years. I don't believe this is adjusting for inflation either.
It sure does. I used the AER report and missed a few years in that hastily assembled graph... but the point was that last year the prices were double to triple what had been the normal baseline (around $50) that had held until about 2016, and had been trending up since. I didn't have 2026 data in that report, so it's nice to see 2026 has been an exception to that trend so far. But that gigantic 20% drop mid-year looks like the result of government intervention around the fears of a fuel crisis. I wouldn't expect that to hold, and the AER certainly isn't.
Now if you want to get into the spicier discussion topic of what drove that price instability (and hence higher prices), look at what energy source appears in 2016 and starts gaining traction, per your source. Growing solar from 0% to 3% within a year was enough to drive "price" up by 50% in that same year. Astounding, and it wasn't until 2020 / 2021 with massive economic disruption, that prices came down at all... and then immediately after that disruption, prices soared even higher.
If you graph prices in constant dollars, it looks... fine: https://chatgpt.com/share/6b02e01f-cf94-83ec-bc92-9599d588fc...
The price today is roughly the same as what it was in the year 2000 and has only ever been cheaper for short periods of time.
If trends continue, electricity will be at an all-time lowest cost within a year.
Back to generation: In 20 years, Australia is producing about the same amount of power as it did 20 years ago. All those new renewables were simply replacing aging infrastructure. [0] And as the % of solar increases, so does the variability of day to day generation, not to mention the complete mis-match between peak solar hours and the non-solar hours when power is actually used.
[0] https://openelectricity.org.au/tracker/timeline?range=all&ta...
You don't need a battery to time shift. Program your A/C to run at full power during free hours. Get an all-in-one washer-dryer combo and set it to run then. Set the charge timer in your car to run then. That should be over 80% of your personal electrical load right there.
If solar is cheapest per kwh generation, then it makes sense it will continue to deploy until the fraction of free time exceeds the margin over gas. But as people take advantage of that margin, it won't grow and solar will continue to be the main source of new generation.
Residential use is flat, which means it has decreased per household given how the population has increased during that time. But that's not to say we wouldn't be using more at home if we had cheaper power. While manufacturing shrunk, mining increased... so it's kind of a wash. [0] Electricity is one of those goods where the cheaper it is, the more useful it is and the more economic activity it creates as a result. If the price of power continues to trend upwards, then demand is naturally going to be destroyed.
>If solar is cheapest per kwh generation
Wholesale energy prices were steady up until solar was introduced into the mix. Since then, prices have soared with high variance... exactly as people suspected an intermittent power source would cause [1]. On paper, solar might seem like a cheap source, but it produces at the time of day when there is no demand, and when you factor in the cost of shifting that generation to when it is actually needed, then it is not nearly as competitive. They have other major externalities, but it's hard to beat coal / gas as reliable base-load and peaking-load in a grid.
[0] https://i.imgur.com/J1evRYw.png https://www.energy.gov.au/publications/australian-energy-upd...
[1] https://openelectricity.org.au/tracker/timeline?range=all&ta...
> with that free energy, such as mining bitcoins?
Things to compute with are not free.
I've been trying Mistral Vibe side by side with Claude over the past few days. I had very low expectations going in. But so far I've found that for regular chat questions there doesn't seem to be a meaningful difference between Opus and Mistral Large 4. Smart enough is smart enough. For deep research and coding the situation is different of course, where for some things I still need Opus. But I really don't need more intelligence for pretty much anything than Opus 5.5 gives me, and I often need less. So if Mistral could reach that level somewhere in the next year I could imagine moving over entirely.
This is a bit of a virtual accounting, right? I mean this energy would be consumed anyway, and people who would use this green energy now have to use coal/gas. Still better than building your own gas powerplants, of course.
Example: Abernathy HPC campus (Fluidstack investor group; formerly TeraWulf JV) Hale County, TX · under construction · mapped at the county centroid Average regional grid mix is 16% coal, 46% gas, 0% nuclear, 37% renewable (eGRID 2023 data).
If you look at the regional grid operator's fuel mix from something like gridstatus.io [0], nuclear is about 10% and coal maxes out at less than 16%. Likewise, renewable (wind and solar) is 37% at a minimum and about 60% of the fuel mix at peak.
In US I think over 50% is fossil fuels, if all the GPUs were in Europe the situation would be a bit better I believe.
This is going to quickly become similar to worrying about how many trainloads of coal it takes to run everyone's WiFi router.
It costs less -> we use much more -> total resource usage increases
- environmentalists are absolutely "crying about it", it's just that the entire world seemingly stopped caring
- agencies in the US are part of the federal government which is doing everything it can to accelerate the problem
- why would corporate media care?
who exactly are the hypocrites here?
It doesn't excuse anthropic one bit, esp considering Dario's flowery message about helping the world with Ai.
How many years does it generally take to build a nuclear power plant?
Yes, everyone I know including myself at times, is just cheating. Doing a similar amount of work as before with less effort/time involved. There's not all that much productivity gains, maybe for a select few who practically live in a state or mania (burnout inevitable).
I dont see it as all that positive for anyone long term. Im constantly having to relearn things, never retaining anything I learn with these things, and forgetting everything I used to know. Its literally causing a cognitive diabetes of sorts. Like someone who drives their car everywhere loses muscles, gains weight and eventually gets a metabolic disease, im certain this happening to our brains. Im 100% certain of this. Its a net negative all around, there's no such thing as a free lunch.
Even if everything goes smooth with the progression of this technology, best case scenario is we have massive unemployment and people with jobs make 20% of what they did because they're now practically just a meat proxy, the equivalent of a conveyor belt operator. Suddenly find ourselves working for a dozen or so Oligarchs, tons more crime, zero uppward mobility. Thats best case scenario. Im not sure why everyone is so excited about this.
They polluted the entire world and somehow AI equalising the equation is an issue. There's a reason developing countries are far more amenable to include AI in their processes. While these people have got so fat and thick minded from prosperity they cannot care less.
Housing getting more expensive is a consequence of supply constraints. Immigrant labor could totally help build houses; we just have zoning and lots of other hurdles that make building hard.
^ reporting on the evidence
[The TL;DR for this claim is that moving to say the US or Australia from a less wealthy country is the one of the most carbon intensive things a person can do].
Of course all this is bound up in the economic growth that migration brings and how you feel about that is a values question.
It's not really within the overton window because the people who care about carbon don't want to restrict migration, and the people who want to restrict migration don't care about carbon.
It's a you get what you deserve kind of thing and the people against immigration just want to close the border and shirk responsibility.
2. They said "want to", not "use". And of course even less "directly pay to use"
People take free shit even when they don't really need it, it doesn't measure demand.
More people are willing to pay for netflix or youtube premium than AI
And didn't Google admit that their AI summaries are biting into their ad business (causing their recent drop), meaning a huge number of users are deriving value from it? Possibly billions.
And then there's all the white collar workers sending emails. SO many people are suddenly sending grammatically correct internal emails now, AI policy or not.
(Of course, the recipients of those emails are not as happy, since someone who used to send shitty emails now instead write shitty prompts that don't actually ask the LLM to address the real issues. But that still counts as demand)
> More people are willing to pay for netflix or youtube premium than AI
And even more people breathe air. In both cases the analogies don't work.
You can't infer demand form "free users" because just from microsoft and meta shoving AI in every single crevices of their free tier software you already get like 2b recurring users even if none of them use/asked for/care about ai features.
If the next windows 11 update turned the mouse pointer into a turd would you say 1b people demanded a turd mouse pointer?
Yup. And many many more don't use a thing because they can't afford it or don't want to pay for a thing.
So if 100 million pay to use a thing (which I just take at the commenters word), then yes actually I do think that billions would want to use it (which was the question) if it fit their price range.
You don't even have to bring up poor countries. I know several people who will spend hours researching the best free phone app that does a thing, instead of paying even $10 for the app they already know is good.
There's also, you know, Google search. People don't pay for that, and yet it's such a need that when Google goes down people say "so… can we go home, now?".
So no, you should not dismiss all demand that doesn't come with payment. If you could, then the pirate bay wouldn't still be a thing.
the only demand is in software development and even that is from forcing AI upon workers
I think people intrinsically don't give a fuck either way, they just go with the flow and rationalize their behaviour so that their definition of "good" warps to fit what they happen to be doing. Otherwise lynch mobs, genocides, and Peter Thiel would not exist.
Maybe before doing absurd comparisons between LLM use and murder, let's take a look at the energy use of people's vacations, or sportsball and concerts.
At least LLM use (and murders) are productive activities.
if the industrial revolution never happened or we never invented the wheel or agriculture, would the world be better off?
this anti-tech nonsense from people is hilarious. You WANT modern medicine I promise you that. If it wasn't for soap, dentistry and a bunch of other modern conveniences, we'd all be at each others throats trying to survive on what nature can 'provide'.
Like it isn't the sort of thing a normal DC can do. So say users from Africa for example will have to have their queries routed to maybe US LLM inference DCs.
If not for the labor movement, the history of strikes and struggle and the resulting transformation of social conditions, humanity would be worse off from the industrial revolution. Ten year olds would be working twelve hour days in factories with zero attention to safety.
The tech itself is just a device for changing the social conditions. The direction of change is what the struggle is about. If we leave it solely to our oligarchy, they will make sure to use it to further entrench their interests while simultaneously reducing the bargaining power of labor.
I've elaborated this critique from some other angles here if you're interested: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50577833
What would be the upside for the environment? There is no burning of the planet that it would prevent such as some comments here said. What precisely one could name as a realistic consequence of using more gas and coal at that scale over the next years, I am not sure.
There is also the question whether process improvements enabled by AI can offset that.
Also AI will save way more lives (by far) than deaths due to the crop issue you point out, you can bet on that.
> Also AI will save way more lives (by far) than deaths due to the crop issue you point out, you can bet on that.
Got any more of that wishful thinking for me bud? AI will create fertilizer and reverse climate change automagically perhaps?
How can people not see how cult like this all is.... insanity
It's always "trust me bro in 2 years it'll be amazing", meanwhile literally nothing is getting better for the bottom 90% of people lmao. "We'll cure aging", "you'll work 2 hours a month", "We'll have universal high income", "we'll live on mars". How fucking gullible do you have to be, they pulled the same playbook on us with the industrial revolution, with factories, wit automation.
While there are many countries who have let the world down on climate change, America is quite the outlier. Since the gatekeepers lost control of the narrative post internet, stories that highlight American failings struggled even more than before.
I think its part lf human nature that no ruling class wants to accept responsibility and privilege and would rather find reasons to consider themselves victims. Consider the wailing over gas prices every year that America never answers with "maybe we should drive more fuel efficient vehicles".
In general, the answer to that is because there is no "we" that lets them. The "few" mobilize capital and influence and use it to fuck over the "many". This has been going on forever. Altman and Edison are the same bread.
I find these arguments very interesting, you know. A group of clueless ideologues decide some absurd policy somewhere in the past, and then, in the future, the same or very similar group of ideologues, claims that they should have some moral authority to impose new absurd policies to deal with the outcome of their old absurd policy.
Well, no more. It’s going to be hard for some decades, but the cycle must be broken.
Why are we letting you use the internet? Better to stick to farming.
Why are we letting you use lightbulbs? Go to sleep at sundown!
I rarely see farm equipment, but I have noticed electric construction machinery in Scandinavia. (Excavators and so on.)
And that is not including the efficiency gains yet to come.
Really need a bit more data to know whether or not what Anthropic will expend is bad relative what we expend today resource-wise. I'm inclined to measure it as a negative just based on what it does to people in the economy absent resource based externalities. But how much carbon are knowledge workers putting out into the environment between commuting, heating/air conditioning, and so on? Not a straightforward answer out there on the resource questions without digging much deeper.
Alignment means imbuing AI with TESCREAL ideology which is basically capitalism perfected to the point that human input and life is no longer necessary. So it most be resisted with force if necessary
Given that is it any surprise that they didn’t give a $hit about the environment?
Why all those companies, which have almost infinite resources are not investing in SMR reactors? That would make perfect sense for them. The technology is already here, it just needs scale to be viable? This would have at least some positive impact on the society - development of clean energy sources.
Oh wait…
We need to say enough is enough, and dismantle California. </s>
Renewables are completely dominating. New coal and gas capacity is almost non-existent because it is too expensive in comparison.
Even renewables + the extra cost of battery backup are much cheaper than building a new coal or gas plant.
Coal and gas are only competitive when the plants are already built, and even for pre-existing its at the tipping point where a new-solar build is cheaper than even supplying coal/gas to an existing power plant.
But sure, I guess they just hate money and want to burn cash as fast as they can. They'd totally ignore allegedly cheaper energy sources.
Are they? So far it seems like we use as much fossil as 10 years ago, we just pilled up renewables on top.